Buddy seat

That’s before we even get to how much more likely you are to be involved in a car accident etc, hardly anyone dies in a horse related incident in comparison to RTA’s yet no one makes a fuss of getting in a car or walking down the street.

Mechanical failure, driver error, deisel on the road, drunks etc those car's are more unreliable ;)

The poor horse is victimised in this country.

A lot of truth here. In the US I believe it's illegal to operate a "car" while wearing a helmet. I find this amazing since the "PC" usually seem so attentive to "making others safe" regardless of personal rights. I'm usually told that it's because "helmets" restrict peoples vision, as well as other senses. It would still seem to me that folks who really care about their children would have them wear a helmet when being transported in a motor vehicle. "Common Sense" seem's to say so. :)

Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
OK, it seems there are 2 issues here: safety of child and wellbeing of horse.

Safety of child: It seems to me that a child holding on behind a parent at walk on a steady 14.2 criollo is as safe as any I've seen jumping their ponies at pony club, led out on ponies on roads, or galloping over the fields... Not as safe as if you kept them off horses altogether of course. The emergency dismount (which I've never done from a criollo yet) would involve chucking the child off first, then dismounting as normal. By chuck I mean slide, but that would be practised first.
Wellbeing of horse: This is my big concern. My son is skinny and light - about 35lb, but the horse has a shortish back, and he'd be sitting on the croup. I don't envisage long rides - but I don't want to cause any damage or strain. I'd really like to hear from people with experience rather than speculation. These are on all the US tack sites, so there must be loads in use...:confused::confused::confused:
 
jack what the bloody hell does helmets and driving a car have to do with the topic??

loads of things are used commonly, doesnt mean it is right.

the point of the buddy seat, from where i am sat, is for little toddlers to stay with mummy and daddy while they go play ponies.
the difference with lead rein ponies, jumping, hacking whatever else on their own pony, is that they are in control (or you are) and its only them to worry about.

and you can see them at all times which is a definite plus point ;)
 
Xloopylozzax what the bloody hell have you got between your ears? Not a very pleasant way to address someone is it?

I think you’ll find the point is quite obviously that riding a horse poses less risk that travelling in a car if you consider how many people die or are seriously injured and that people who make a fuss over how dangerous horses are don’t seem to care that they put their child in a car without any safety equipment they consider essential in a less risky activity.

Perhaps he was hoping people would come to the conclusion that risks are not cut and dried and that they need to be addresses on a case by case basis not hysteria.

But i guess he only has half a brain cell like myself as he can’t measure forces within the exo-muscular system by sight alone ;)
 
i dont think i am the only one increasingly frustrated with some of levi1739's posts. they seem to get at everything and say nothing. i never seem to 'get' what he is getting at, which is a shame cos he obviously has something worthwhile to add.
 
I have no experience of these saddles and have read this thread with interest. I have to say that there is no way that I would put my child in one of these seats. It is just too dangerous.

Apart from anything else, you do not have eyes in the back of your head and how would you know that they were sitting straight in the saddle and not leaning over to one side so they can see where they are going? My son is 2 and a half and is no where near sensible enough to sit on a horse without being watched like a hawk. I would think that the child would need to be at least 5 years old to be able to trust to sit still, and by that age surely they are big enough for their own pony anyway.

I agree with the point that you cannot do an emergency dismount and if the horse bucks or spooks you are both in trouble. My saint of a horse who is used for all the beginners in the riding school threw me off last week. It goes to show that even the safest horses can buck and a responsible adult needs to ensure that the child gets the assistance they need as quickly as possible if the worst does happen. You cannot do that if you are sitting on the same horse.
 
Buddy Saddle V's Car crash :confused:

Whats that got to do with the price of bread!

I was wondering that too!

It's hard to compare the 2 really. I think that there are a lot more vehicles being driven than horses and ponies being ridden?
Also, horse riding is for the majority of people a leisure pursuit whilst driving is not. There are not many people who can survive in this day and age without using some form of motorised vehicle - I know I couldn't with my job.
Have we not gotten a little off topic here anyway?

I think Old Woman gave the best advice - everyone on here has given their opinion but if you ask on American forums you may find more people who use them or people who choose not to use them and who can tell you why. Good luck! :)
 
exactly, all it could take is a sudden spook... even a small jerk to the left could chuck a child out the side door. How can you monitor they are holding on tight, they could be pointing at something, picking there nose... anything!

I know over seas also, hat wearing is not always so hot as it is in the UK, I would dread to think of the injurys caused by a child falling out the side door, of a large horse onto there head. Saying that again, even with a hat on extensive injurys 'could' happen.

Yes Horse riding is a dangerous sport, we all take risks everytime we mount a horse, however how does a small child know the risks? The what ifs? they just see it as a fun horsey ride! It is up to us as adults to ensure we can only cover every aspect of safety we can.

A child falling of a small lead rein shetland pony, is not going to cause as much damage as falling of a larger mount. With a leader at the side you have half a chance of catching them!

makes me shudder the thought of it!

for the subject of 'off topicness' ! in a car I would ensure the same ( car safety seat properley installed)

You cannot compare horse riding accidents to car accidents, first of all look at the ratio of cars to horses !!! :rolleyes:
 
I don't like the look of this for another horse discomfort reason other than the very real and valid point about weight bearing past the last rib (may have been mentioned but only skimmed through the responses).




I can imagine this 'saddle' causing a twisting motion on the back of the saddle.
 
It’s very simple to statistically derive a risk for horse riding / RTA’s it’s simple mathematics.

It is not simple to say the same risk applies to riding in a ménage as on a 5 star event in the same way cycling or walking in the highlands has the same risk as doing either in central London.

The point is horses are not 100%, neither are many things people are oblivious to, cars for example for the reasons mentioned but people consider it essential to wear protective equipment for horses they don’t deem necessary for riskier pursuits.

There is a risk to almost everything we do and giving the horse a blanket dangerous is as stupid as giving cars a blanket safe.

If you look at A&E there are more drink related injury’s than all of those sports related of which horse riding is only one yet who wears protective gear on a night out?

People say it’s dangerous to use the buddy seat and it will be for some people, horses, activities, but to say it is for every use is leap to far as is the suggestion that just because the device may place pressure on the weakest part of the horses back automatically means the weakest part cant take any pressure at all, it will clearly vary on breed, confirmation, load etc. There was a European Cavalry that rode with saddle and fully grown man in this area a couple of hundred years ago, not that it was good idea.

If people don’t want to think I guess it’s up to them as long as they don’t start preaching there ill-informed biases to those who choose to.

(Yes I’ve been speaking to some halfwits on the phone this morning and my be a bit harsh as a result.:o)
 
If people don’t want to think I guess it’s up to them as long as they don’t start preaching there ill-informed biases to those who choose to.

I personally do not feel that I am preaching an 'ill-informed' bias at anyone. As both a mother and a horse woman I have made a decision for the safety of my child that there is no way that I would use one.

Yes life is dangerous but that is why we need to minimise the risks as much as we can. Keeping on the subject of car crashes, the whole reason that seatbelts were made compulsory for children (and then adults) is that it made the risky business of driving a car safer. Therefore, we need to ensure that the equipment that we use on with our horses and children is safe as well. Just because this buddy seat has been used historically, it doesn't mean that we shouldn't move with the times and update to more suitable equipment today.
 
as is the suggestion that just because the device may place pressure on the weakest part of the horses back automatically means the weakest part cant take any pressure at all, it will clearly vary on breed, confirmation, load etc. There was a European Cavalry that rode with saddle and fully grown man in this area a couple of hundred years ago, not that it was good idea.

If people don’t want to think I guess it’s up to them as long as they don’t start preaching there ill-informed biases to those who choose to.


The basic anatomy of the horse dictates that the lumbar region of the horses back is an extremely weak area. There is extensive veterinary information that supports this information and which recommends that this area is not weight bearing at all. I.E. Not suitable to bare any weight.

I suppose there is a chance that you can place weight on this area of a horses back and not cause him pain and disomfort, or impede the movement of the pelvis and put undue strain upon the hind ligaments. But there is also a very real, and very well researched and supported risk, that you can and will harm the horse.

Yes there are risks in everything we do in life, but I take calculated risks. I work on the theory that the risk has to be worth the gain. I guess I just value my horses welfare more than I do the gain from taking a risk with saddle-fitting.

If people want to turn a blind eye to blatant factual evidence when it doesn't support their own opinions and theories on a matter, I guess it's up to them. As long as they don't start preaching their ill-informed ignorance to those who have actually taken the time to educate themselves on a matter before making a decision.
 
Last edited:
It’s very simple to statistically derive a risk for horse riding / RTA’s it’s simple mathematics.

Sorry I disagree with comparing equestrian 'sport' to anything to do with driving a car as simple mathmatics. I personally do not connect them atall.. thats just my personal view. :)

There is a risk to almost everything we do and giving the horse a blanket dangerous is as stupid as giving cars a blanket safe.

I dont think anyone has or would class a car as safe. There are 'different' risks with a car, under a risk assessment scenario I would have a completely different set of rules. ( price of bread !)

There was a European Cavalry that rode with saddle and fully grown man in this area a couple of hundred years ago, not that it was good idea

sorry I dont get the point why this has been included? what a European Calvary did a few hundred years ago would in no way be included on my risk assessment to horse or rider!
If people don’t want to think I guess it’s up to them as long as they don’t start preaching there ill-informed biases to those who choose to.

Ill informed?? Biased?? when you quote me something different on how great the saddle is to both horse and rider, then and only then would I look at it differently. I personally cannot see how this ludicrous design is anything but potentially harmful to horse/rider on top of the risk of even being on a horse in the first place. Trying to drag A&E, a Calvary from hundreds of years ago and a motor car into the equation still has not worked for me! and seems rather price of bread :confused:
 
I personally do not feel that I am preaching an 'ill-informed' bias at anyone. As both a mother and a horse woman I have made a decision for the safety of my child that there is no way that I would use one.

That is the way it should be and I wouldn’t use one either with my child but he has ridden in front, but a sweeping generalisation is without fail wrong for some.

Yes life is dangerous but that is why we need to minimise the risks as much as we can. Keeping on the subject of car crashes, the whole reason that seatbelts were made compulsory for children (and then adults) is that it made the risky business of driving a car safer. Therefore, we need to ensure that the equipment that we use on with our horses and children is safe as well. Just because this buddy seat has been used historically, it doesn't mean that we shouldn't move with the times and update to more suitable equipment today.

Even with seat belts, air bags and child seats etc you’re still more likely to die or be seriously injured in a RTA than on a horse, so if for example a person rides with a hat because of the risk and they don’t drive with a hat a person is laying themselves open to accusations of being ill-informed or hypocritical if they talk of horses being risky and things not being safe.

If the buddy seat is safe and suitable for horse, rider, child, activity then there is no reason to not use it, if it’s not then it shouldn’t be used.

The basic anatomy of the horse dictates that the lumbar region of the horses back is an extremely weak area. There is extensive veterinary information that supports this information and which recommends that this area is not weight bearing at all. I.E. Not suitable to bare any weight.

I suppose there is a chance that you can place weight on this area of a horses back and not cause him pain and discomfort, or impede the movement of the pelvis and put undue strain upon the hind ligaments. But there is also a very real, and very well researched and supported risk, that you can and will harm the horse.

Yes there are risks in everything we do in life, but I take calculated risks. I work on the theory that the risk has to be worth the gain. I guess I just value my horses welfare more than I do the gain from taking a risk with saddle-fitting.

If people want to turn a blind eye to blatant factual evidence when it doesn't support their own opinions and theories on a matter, I guess it's up to them. As long as they don't start preaching their ill-informed ignorance to those who have actually taken the time to educate themselves on a matter before making a decision.

I don’t disagree with you except a child/weight in this area is not going to have same effect on a shire horse, Lipzzana etc as it would on a fine long backed TB and that is the issue there is not a definitive answer, what has not been mentioned is the current theory within certain exo-muscular system experts at one of the big college’s in the US that the last rib and even iirc the second last are not weight bearing and the implication on loads and force distribution throughout the exo-muscular system when ridden, current saddle fit thinking etc, perhaps they are not as educated in the field as they believe or perhaps they are I wouldn’t make the assumption either way.

At the end the day risks, possible harmful forces within the exo muscular system above those that are placed in any horse with a person it's back and the way they ride, by this device are what they are, what i belive or others do does not change that.
 
Last edited:
Even with seat belts, air bags and child seats etc you’re still more likely to die or be seriously injured in a RTA than on a horse, so if for example a person rides with a hat because of the risk and they don’t drive with a hat a person is laying themselves open to accusations of being ill-informed or hypocritical if they talk of horses being risky and things not being safe.

I think that the risk of anything that you do has to be proportionate. Yes, more people do die from head injuries as a result of car accidents compared to those who fall off horses.But this doesn't mean that I am going to start riding my horse without a hat and strapping my child to a buddy seat. I don't understand your arguement.
 
Gosh, this thread is becoming very obtuse.

Even with seat belts, air bags and child seats etc you’re still more likely to die or be seriously injured in a RTA than on a horse,
If you are a horse rider and you also drive a car, that statement is factually incorrect.
If however you don't ride, but drive a car, then yes you are correct :D.

I'll read the rest of this thread later.
 
Gosh, this thread is becoming very obtuse.


If you are a horse rider and you also drive a car, that statement is factually incorrect.
If however you don't ride, but drive a car, then yes you are correct :D.

I'll read the rest of this thread later.

2008 just under 3000 RTA deaths, 10 Riding related according to government figures.

4.2 million Riders/carriage drivers according to BEF, be generous and say 60 million car drivers.

21 more times likely to die from a RTA.

Serious injury? I don’t have the exact figures to hand, perhaps you do?
 
2008 just under 3000 RTA deaths, 10 Riding related according to government figures.

4.2 million Riders/carriage drivers according to BEF, be generous and say 60 million car drivers.

21 more times likely to die from a RTA.

Serious injury? I don’t have the exact figures to hand, perhaps you do?

Chilli, I expect the horse related injuries would go of the scale if there were a boom in sales of the Buddy saddles :p

The name makes me laugh 'Buddy saddle' I wouldnt put my worst enemey on it! :D
 
newrider.com