Buck stop?!!!!!!!

it would be interesting to find out the rough percentage of MR's buckstopper success rate...do Recommended Associates keep any records?

According to Monty R in his book From My Hands To Yours ''I have acheived success with these techniques in an extremely high percentage of cases". He is also adamant that even the most persistent buckers suffered no lasting harm from using the device. I'm sure RA's do keep records and I would be surprised if any of them that did actually use it would continue to do so if it didn't work or injured the horses they worked with. The ones I've met take the ethics of their work very seriously.

This thread seems to be getting a bit circular - nobody is disagreeing that time and patience are the best way to deal with a problem, or that a buckstop is anything but a tool of last resort. Whether to use it or not will be the choice of a person in a very difficult situation with their horse, and that decision is theirs alone.
 
According to Monty R in his book From My Hands To Yours ''I have acheived success with these techniques in an extremely high percentage of cases". He is also adamant that even the most persistent buckers suffered no lasting harm from using the device.
That's a statement MR's bound to make about his own branded product....who can blame him, he's hardly likely to criticise his own training methods. On hindsight though, I guess in reality, there's no way of ever finding out the true success/failure percentage rate, so I think it best if we leave it at that. :)

This thread seems to be getting a bit circular - nobody is disagreeing that time and patience are the best way to deal with a problem, or that a buckstop is anything but a tool of last resort. Whether to use it or not will be the choice of a person in a very difficult situation with their horse, and that decision is theirs alone.
I totally agree Yann, this thread seems to be going round in circles, the only thing I disagree with here is the buckstopper needn't be 'a last resort'...there's many other trainers out there who can help the most traumatised horse overcome their problems without the need of these type of gadgets......but as you say - it's the individuals choice at the end of the day.;)
 
Pretty common bit of advice given about riding buckers it so 'keep the head up', generally meant hands high and use the bit to keep the head up. Do those of you that think the buckstopper is evil think that keeping hands up to try to stop 'head down and bronc' is nasty as well? That uses a metal bit to put pressure on the sensitive mouth.. almost nastier than a bit of soft rope. And a buckstop doesn't depend on the rider's timing and balance as a bit does..
 
Pretty common bit of advice given about riding buckers it so 'keep the head up', generally meant hands high and use the bit to keep the head up. Do those of you that think the buckstopper is evil think that keeping hands up to try to stop 'head down and bronc' is nasty as well? That uses a metal bit to put pressure on the sensitive mouth.. almost nastier than a bit of soft rope. And a buckstop doesn't depend on the rider's timing and balance as a bit does..

Your right, in general people are taught to ride through a buck in this way - but that's all it does, it helps keep the rider in the saddle so they can push the horse forward....... it doesn't actually address the problem of why the horse is bucking in the first place. I agree, in that situation, the bit would put pressure on the horses mouth – but if the arms where braced but relaxed while keeping contact with the horse, that's all it should produce...pressure, not pain.

In contrast, the buckstopper, which is made of quite narrow rope is placed between the top lip and gumline, this only comes into effect when the horse tries to buck. Now this may sound kinder on the horse than keeping contact with the mouth, but when you consider the weight behind a buck and that weight jolting against the piece of rope that's between the horses top lip and gumline......I hardly think there's any comparison.

The buckstopper is a severe gadget and for that reason why MR probably states it should only be used as a last resort and why they're not readily available for sale.

:)
 
would you be prepared to use that one?(in the appropraite circumstances, not suggesting it's appropriate in any but the most difficult case where pain etc has been ruled out)
i'm sorry , i thought this post was about that not the MR one :o
 
Last edited:
Your right, in general people are taught to ride through a buck in this way - but that's all it does, it helps keep the rider in the saddle so they can push the horse forward....... it doesn't actually address the problem of why the horse is bucking in the first place. I agree, in that situation, the bit would put pressure on the horses mouth – but if the arms where braced but relaxed while keeping contact with the horse, that's all it should produce...pressure, not pain.

Assuming the horse isn't bucking because of current pain where the advice should be 'get off and sort it out'.

Ok, what if you hold your hands up and horse still tries to throw head down and gets a sock in the mouth with the bit? I've never met a rider yet that can keep a perfect soft contact while ponio is trying to bronc them off..

I've seen a bucking horse with the rider's hands held high to keep head up look a h*ll of a lot more bothered by it than the horse I've seen in a MR buckstop...

I do think the buckstop should only be used in circumstances where the more normal methods have failed but it has its place and don't think its quite as much of a big evil as some are making out.
 
Assuming the horse isn't bucking because of current pain where the advice should be 'get off and sort it out'.

Ok, what if you hold your hands up and horse still tries to throw head down and gets a sock in the mouth with the bit? I've never met a rider yet that can keep a perfect soft contact while ponio is trying to bronc them off..

I've seen a bucking horse with the rider's hands held high to keep head up look a h*ll of a lot more bothered by it than the horse I've seen in a MR buckstop...

I do think the buckstop should only be used in circumstances where the more normal methods have failed but it has its place and don't think its quite as much of a big evil as some are making out.

The horse would only get a sock in the mouth if the rider lost contact – if this happened (for whatever reason) it would result in him getting a painful jolt against the bit each time he threw his head down. However, if contact was maintained (I don't think anyone would expect a perfectly soft contact in this situation);) all that should result is an increase in pressure... under normal circumstances, this should be enough to give the rider time to push the horse forward through the buck.

I've already expressed my views on MR's buckstopper quite clearly and also my thoughts on the 'last resort' reason for using one....so I'll not go over them again. The only reason I replied to your previous post was to give my views on the comparisons you made between a bit and the MR buckstopper.

Personally, I think everything else has been covered in great detail from both sides now.

:)
 
The horse would only get a sock in the mouth if the rider lost contact – if this happened (for whatever reason) it would result in him getting a painful jolt against the bit each time he threw his head down. However, if contact was maintained (I don't think anyone would expect a perfectly soft contact in this situation) all that should result is an increase in pressure... under normal circumstances, this should be enough to give the rider time to push the horse forward through the buck

Really!? I used to ride a bucker. He used to buck when he was told do something he didn't like, like walking away from his friends. Sometimes he would be fine, others he would have a stroppy bugger moment and have a right old paddy. Horses are capable of just being stupid sods;). Some horses nap or head shake - he bucked. WE as humans think of bucking as a major expression of stress - -most horses don't unless they've been taught it's very wrong.

And he certainly would not just get a 'steady increase in pressure' - he got him head yanked back up as hard as I could!! - if i didn't he would have me off. If you've ever ridden a proper, experienced bucker you'll know 'pushing them through it' isn't a gentle process:eek: They get their mouths yanked pretty damn hard, not to mention being booted in the ribs and probably getting thier bum smacked too. I think I'd prefer the MR buck stop to that!
 
.And he certainly would not just get a 'steady increase in pressure' - he got him head yanked back up as hard as I could!! - if i didn't he would have me off. If you've ever ridden a proper, experienced bucker you'll know 'pushing them through it' isn't a gentle process:eek: They get their mouths yanked pretty damn hard, not to mention being booted in the ribs and probably getting thier bum smacked too. I think I'd prefer the MR buck stop to that!
If you read my post, I did state under NORMAL circumstances....a normal buck, I wasn't refering to seasoned buckers....these should be dealt with from the ground...not by constantly being yanked in their mouths and having their heads yanked back...this is no doubt the reason why some horses become habitual buckers in the first place and end up as a 'last resort' horses.!!!!

Just for the record...I have ridden (and owned) an habitual bucker, read through the posts on this thread!!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So india ...................why don't you tell us how mr parelli deals with habitual buckers..............that may take us in another direction.
 
So india ...................why don't you tell us how mr parelli deals with habitual buckers..............that may take us in another direction.

I wondered how long it would be before someone made a remark like this. :rolleyes:

Let's not turn this into a them against us thread, there's enough of them around as it is. ;)
 
that's a shame india, was genuinely looking forward to further discussion

i don't know how PP would deal with a bucker

pretty please carry on :)
 
If you read my post, I did state under NORMAL circumstances....a normal buck, I wasn't refering to seasoned buckers....these should be dealt with from the ground...not by constantly being yanked in their mouths and having their heads yanked back...this is no doubt the reason why some horses become habitual buckers in the first place and end up as a 'last resort' horses.!!!!

I don't think anyone would suggest using a MR buckstopper on a normal bucker that just has the occasional 'wheee!' buck or opinionated buck.

'Seasoned' buckers can't always be dealt with from the ground. At some point you have to get on the horse and deal with it.

The last one I dealt with was perfect on the ground, lunged well, long reined, wore a saddle no problem but would freak and bronc until you were off. Original cause was a badly fitting saddle but it took a lot of work after that was sorted to get her past bucking and keeping a soft contact was not top of the list when she started bucking! I didn't use any gadget because she didn't immediately go off bucking so there was opportunity to get on and persuade her people up there weren't so bad. She was incredibly good at bucking and didn't stop once she'd started until you were off. If she had been a tiny bit worse and bucked as soon as someone was up there instead of there being a small opportunity to persuade her it was ok then maybe she would have been one that needed something to persuade her not to buck. Everything I did with her was about being nice and persuading her that people up there weren't so bad, but if she threw her head down I wasn't about to sit there and give with the rein 'of course you can dump me dear, let me make it even easier for you' so she did yank against the bit a couple of times.

Another bucker I rode did it because she was an opinionated madam who had learnt it was a very good way to get rid of the inconvenience up there and get back to her friends. Her other lovely trick was emergency stop and head down while cantering. She was eventually sorted out by head up and a smacked a*se after a lot of ignoring it and just trying to stay on and gentle persuasion had failed.

If anyone has managed to fully cure a 'seasoned bucker' from the ground or without any discomfort at all I'd love to hear about it.. :)
 
I would genuinely be interested to know about the Parelli approach too, and promise to be on my best behaviour:D
 
that's a shame india, was genuinely looking forward to further discussion

i don't know how PP would deal with a bucker

pretty please carry on :)

I think I've already ran through the basics on this thread anyway teabicuit.:)

I didn't mention what training method I used to help Beau overcome his problem, purposely to avoid the thread going of track......it's just a shame someone else felt the need to mention it.

:rolleyes:
 
I still dont think that bucking is all to do with pain.

Kia bucked twice yesterday and his ears were pricked as he was excited and raring to go.

He always does this and I have had everything checked twice ;):D

I wouldnt use a buckstopper as a quick pull on the reins reminds him of his manners and he stops. He does bronc occasionally but only when very annoyed and really throwing the toy out of the pram.:rolleyes:

So is one method worse than another??? I mean gadgets as opposed to working through it??? This I mean after all the checks???

Nikki xxxx
 
If anyone has managed to fully cure a 'seasoned bucker' from the ground or without any discomfort at all I'd love to hear about it.. :)
I can truthfully say my Beau overcame his behaviour problem without experiecing any discomfort or pain...he'd already been through enough of that as it was.

The retraining initially started from the ground and progressed to ridden work over a period of around eighteen months. That was a few years back now but he's never once attempted to revert back into his old ways.

I call him my 'wonder horse'...because in the early days, I very often used to wonder what possessed me to buy him.

:)
 
newrider.com