Buck stop?!!!!!!!

That helps me a bit thanks India.

I just got the feeling that everyhting was being slammed in this thread instead of the original item.

I totally agree each to their own and what works for some may not work for all!!!

Thanks!!!!

Nikki xxxx
 
There was nothing over the nose, so no drop noseband effect

Doris, your description of MR's buckstopper is correct as far as I'm aware - the other one that is being referred to is the one that was linked to in the very first post on this thread, more of a daisy rein type arrangement.
 
However, I also found that in post number 62 of this discussion, when asked by lizzzy how you cured your bucker, you stated that you 'initially established what the probable cause was for him bucking'....

Then, when I made the point that it's not always pain which causes a horse to buck, and that that seemed to be the general assumption, you made the above quote in reply.

Did you not, by establishing the 'probable cause', make an assumption yourself; an assumption which you then based your retraining of the horse upon; an assumption which was just that, and by its nature, may not have been the real reason for the cause of your horse bucking at all!.

True, I did state to Lizzy that we first established the probable cause of Beau's problem and that's exactly what we did.....we determined through examination what the most probable (likely) cause was and based his retraining on that theory. If he hadn't shown any signs of improvement within the first few weeks, we would have assumed (accepted) the problem didn't stem from pain and then looked towards other possibilities for the cause of his bucking.

Any type of problem solving involves finding the most probable cause and working down from there until you hit the jackpot....process of elimination. I don't think it's wise for anyone to immediately assume anything especially when they're working with or around horses.

Although I can't categorically state or prove that his problem did actually stem from pain, by working on that probability in the first few weeks and noticing the improvement in his behaviour, confirmed without a doubt in our minds this was the true cause of the problem...besides the fact that 18 months later he was classed as a safe and sensible ride.

All this happened a few years back now, but he's never once reverted back into his old ways........
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I just agree totally with India and itis nice to see there are other people in the world on the same wavelength and oppinion as myself.
I too am not dismissing "gadgets" completely, I just do not use them myself as I do not need to. All I was trying to get across is that people do use them as a first option as a quick fix for things when IMO they should be used as a last resort. Even then, is it absolutely necessary.
All of this is IMO, I am not trying to offend anyone before people start insulting me - MY OPPINION AND IN MY EXPERIENCE, NOTHING MORE, NOTHING LESS :D
 
sometimes, hosses can buck just cos they have high spirits and they know can, and it feels good. it's not always caused by pain :confused:
 
Last edited:
sometimes, hosses can buck just cos they have high spirits and they know can, and it feels good. it's not always caused by pain

That's fair enough then, no need for anything to fix it! Unless it's causing the rider problems in which case the first point of call would surely be a look at the management of the horse? But habitual bucking isnt just high spirits, the horse is trying to tell you something.
Re; the bucking simply because they know they can and want to unseat the rider - in that case rather than using something to stop the bucking I would be asking myself why the horse didnt want to be ridden SO badly.

In the case of my horse - his bucking was out of physical issues at first so I had a lot of work and investigation done, then the remembered issues, boredom and his protesting about his management.
He was moved to a yard with different management, and much more varied work which he thrives on, and helped to overcome his remembered problems. He has bucked (small) about twice since - and this is the horse that used to have a rodeo display every session. I wont say he's cured, but he's on the right track. He has put on weight and chilled out.

I would never have used anything to stop him bucking though - his bucking is his way of telling me something is wrong - if I frighten him out of that he'll either keep it bottled up or let it out in a different way!

Surely horses which are habitual buckers that have no pain are telling us they dont want to be ridden for different reasons? They arent just bucking for the fun of it?

xxx
 
Surely horses which are habitual buckers that have no pain are telling us they dont want to be ridden for different reasons? They arent just bucking for the fun of it?

My guess would be that their reaction is so ingrained because of past trauma they can't help themselves, it more or less becomes a reflex reaction to the situation. Just like a headshy horse for example, nothing is hurting but they automatically defend themselves by throwing their head up when anyone goes near their ears.
 
My guess would be that their reaction is so ingrained because of past trauma they can't help themselves, it more or less becomes a reflex reaction to the situation. Just like a headshy horse for example, nothing is hurting but they automatically defend themselves by throwing their head up when anyone goes near their ears.

Taking your example a step further Yann.....

The cause of the problem has been eliminated but the horse still has unpleasant memories of whatever caused him to become headshy in the first place and automatically still defends himself by throwing his head up.

Would it then be acceptable 'as a last resort' to stand him under a low overhang so that each time he throws his head up – he automatically get a painful bash on his poll? The overhang only comes into effect if the horse attempts to throw his head up, therefore he'll soon realise that keeping his head down is the better option.

What's your opinion on this example compared with the training theory behind the buckstopper and do you think this 'cure' would mask or address the problem?

:)
 
Good comparison :D The situations possibly aren't exactly the same though as a) the horse throwing its head up doesn't normally endanger anyone or stop it doing a job b) there are often easy workarounds to the practical difficulties it causes c) Headshy horses usually respond well to desensitisation.

If a horse had such a deep seated problem with having its ears handled that no amount of time or patient work helped and the head throwing meant the horse was dangerous to be around you'd have to decide whether one bump on the head (assuming that persuaded the horse to think twice before head tossing again) was justified or not.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
lets consider the probable life of an habitual bucker

passed from piller to post for less and less money, each new owner trying his or her own method for stopping bucks, or more likely the bucker seriously hurting the new owner and off to the sales again goes the bucker


unless it's lucky enough to land with someone who will put the time and experience in to stop it, or someone who wants a feild ornament

then landing up at the slaughter house a few months down the line


i'd rather put a confirmed bucker down than put a horse through that
and i'd certainly give the buckstop a go if it was just habit
 
If a horse had such a deep seated problem with having its ears handled that no amount of time or patient work helped and the head throwing meant the horse was dangerous to be around you'd have to decide whether one bump on the head (assuming that persuaded the horse to think twice before head tossing again) was justified or not.
But we all know that one bump on the head wouldn't 'cure' the problem...the same as one jolt in the mouth from the buckstopper doesn't 'cure' a bucker. Sure, after a few painful bangs on the poll the horse would probably stop throwing his head up, resulting in a quick fix....but at what cost to the animal in the long term?

He'd no doubt find other ways of expressing his trauma by developing other vices and behaviour problems – then what would happen? Maybe he'd have other painful gadgets used on him to 'cure' those problems 'as a last resort'....and so the vicious circle would continue.

How can any training method that relies on pain being inflicted on an already traumatised horse ever serve to convince them that humans are ok to be around.

:confused:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
But we all know that one bump on the head wouldn't 'cure' the problem...the same as one jolt in the mouth from the buckstopper doesn't 'cure' a bucker

No, but it stops the horse bucking temporarily so you have the opportunity to demonstrate to it that having a rider on board is OK and won't hurt. That's all it does. It also works, and in the instances I'm aware of there's no long term cost to the horse whatsoever, they stopped bucking and are now happy to be ridden.

As an aside are 'quick fixes' always the least desirable route in horse training?
 
lets consider the probable life of an habitual bucker

passed from piller to post for less and less money, each new owner trying his or her own method for stopping bucks, or more likely the bucker seriously hurting the new owner and off to the sales again goes the bucker


unless it's lucky enough to land with someone who will put the time and experience in to stop it, or someone who wants a feild ornament

then landing up at the slaughter house a few months down the line

This happened to me, as some of you may know..................

I agree with Yann on many points here (just can't figure out yet how to do more than one quote :rolleyes:).

It's purely down to the type of person I am, (soft I guess :o), that stopped me from selling my mare on. I did not want either other people to get hurt (even though that consideration was not given to me), or Zara to be shot. If I get hurt, I don't work. If I don't work, I don't get paid. Yes, I sat through the first bucking fit, but I didn't/couldn't sit the second. I got hurt, but I recovered. It could have been much worse. I have a mortgage, bills, my husband and my other assorted critters to think of. I had an old gelding at the time who needed a lot of care (and medication, which equals money!:o). I had two horses, neither of which I could ride, and I couldn't afford to keep them both AND buy another!! I couldn't see a way to pay for a really good trainer, for example - given that there are few where I live, therefore would have encurred high travel expenses, etc.

I can honestly say that I have considered this kind of thing. I don't really care what anyone thinks of me for admitting that. I know (and my friends know) what kind of person I am, end of.

No, I have not used a gadget (other than changing from a 'nutcracker' snaffle bit to a myler comfort - does that count???). I decided to do everything in my power (including learning every possible cause, every possible solution from every conceivable angle, getting in help where I could, etc.). I, though have had the wherewithall, time, patience and perseverance to do that. Some people wouldn't. It caused some horrendous arguments with my (non horsey) OH - dangerous horse - sort it or sell asap, etc.

Having said all that, a year down the line and I'm riding her again. She's not tried to bounce me off again..........YET;)!!!!

What I'm trying to say is that If it came to the crunch, sorry guys, I'd use it. Looks to me like the horse wouldn't be able to give themselves a major jab in the mouth as it looks too short to allow that amount of generated downwards momentum, although I could easily be wrong.
 
No, but it stops the horse bucking temporarily so you have the opportunity to demonstrate to it that having a rider on board is OK and won't hurt. That's all it does. It also works, and in the instances I'm aware of there's no long term cost to the horse whatsoever, they stopped bucking and are now happy to be ridden.

As an aside are 'quick fixes' always the least desirable route in horse training?

It would still take more than just one jab in the mouth to stop the horse bucking temporarily and even then it's only a case of the horse accepting that having a rider on is the lesser of two evils.

Maybe the two horses you've refered to in the past where an exception, but I'm pleased it worked out well for both of them.:) I just wonder how many horses that have had pain inducing gadgets used on them actually overcame the behaviour problem without any secondary vices developing – it would be interesting to find out the rough percentage of MR's buckstopper success rate...do Recommended Associates keep any records?

In my opinion, painless quick fixes have their place in horse training as a means to enable the trainer to address the problem on a longer term basis – these type of quick fixes can be of benefit to the horse and trainer. It's the 'quick fixes' that are produced by pain inflicted methods that mask the problem rather than address it that I consider to be the least desirable route to take.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I just wonder how many horses that have had pain inducing gadgets used on them actually overcame the behaviour problem without any secondary vices developing – .

secondary vices may not be as bad as the origanal "sin" :)

when i used a little prod with my finger to my foals tummy as he reared (i'm sure no one could say i inflicted pain) he disliked it enough to stop him rearing in hand

his secondary vice is pawing the ground

if he has to do something to express his impatience, pawing the ground is preferable to rearing

eta horselass i didn't know you'd had and overcome such problems. :) good work :)
 
Last edited:
secondary vices may not be as bad as the origanal "sin" :)
Maybe not, but it's probably the only way an already traumatised horses is able to express himself.

Wouldn't it be preferable to spend as much time as it takes on the initail problem to begin with, than having to spend extra amounts of time 'curing' the secondary vice?

:confused:
 
depends on the horse, once a horse has a trigger reaction of bucking to a certain stimulus, you need some way of breaking the cycle, then you can get the horse to realise "well maybe it isn't so bad" instead of "buck, buck like hell"

breaking the cycle is the hard part

and i don;t mind my foal pawing, if he needs an outlet, then he can keep that vice for now

you dont; have to solve all problems at once

start with the most dangerous

you know what you're doing, though, not trying to teach you to suck eggs.
 
Last edited:
depends on the horse, once a horse has a trigger reaction of bucking to a certain stimulus, you need some way of breaking the cycle, then you can get the horse to realise "well maybe it isn't so bad" instead of "buck, buck like hell"

breaking the cycle is the hard part

and i don;t mind my foal pawing, if he needs an outlet, then he can keep that vice for now

you dont; have to solve all problems at once

start with the most dangerous

you know what you're doing, though, not trying to teach you to suck eggs.

I agree, you do need to break the cycle - but there's many other ways of doing it than inflicting pain to get a result.

The thing is, there's a big difference between the discomfort felt by a little prod to the tummy and the pain inflicted by the buckstopper, your foal needed to realise that rearing was unacceptable and this was a very good way to remind him.

A true habitual bucker (or any other horse with a serious behaviour issue) is quite a different story though, they already have major trauma issues embedded in their brains usually stemming from memory of fear/pain, and as mentioned in a previous post.....the last thing these type of horses need is a training gadget that intentionally inflicts more pain on them to a get a result.

My view is that if the behaviour problem is addressed correctly and without causing fear, pain or distress, it's highly unlikely that any horse would develop secondary vices anyway.

:)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
newrider.com