Buck stop?!!!!!!!

well i hadnt seen it but heard of it,, of course theres no redding of the gums
as puts pressure on the bridge of the nose and poll/ neck

its not a training tool i would use,
i hate these so called quick fixs gadgets they oly make problems far worsr than what they was, what happened to find find the cause and sort the problem
i have had horses that buck and go them out of it
what happened to sit the trantrum, ie raise your bum of the saddle slightly in a x/c position so when you feel the horse is going to buck you off the saddle already so he cant buck you off then sit down hard and push him on

I think you may be thinking of a different sort of gadget to the one I reported on? There's nothing on the bridge of the nose in the MR buckstop so perhaps you are thinking of another sort of thing altogether. If you read some of the other posts, you will see where the 'gum' thing comes in.
 
Last edited:
Is it possible that someone could reply to this post please - it is a genuine query. :)

If the problem originally stemmed from pain caused by continually being ridden in a badly fitting saddle but still constantly persisted after a period of rest (and then only ridden in a made to measure saddle and once back checks completed)...would this not be an example of learned behaviour - an habitual habit?

If so, I'm finding it very difficult to understand how the buckstopper could address this problem...the horse is behaving and reacting in the way he does from the memory of pain and discomfort he's experienced in the past - even though the cause has been eliminated, he still associates being tacked up and ridden with pain.

How could the buckstopper address the problem, when the whole intention of the gadget is to cause the horse pain to break the pattern of behaviour? :confused:


Thanks :)
 
To be honest I thought I'd already explained my understanding of how it would work in an earlier post. If the horse's response to having a rider on had become so ingrained that progressive desensitisation wasn't having an effect (the only cases where you should even remotely consider using anything like this IMHO), then using this sort of device a) makes bucking the less desirable option for the horse and b) allows the horse to realise that being ridden isn't going to hurt and it doesn't need to act defensively any more.

Whether those one or two bashes in the mouth the horse will inflict with perfect timing are justified against a lifetime of utility if using it works is the question, and only personal values and circumstances will answer that as far as I can see.
 
...b) allows the horse to realise that being ridden isn't going to hurt and it doesn't need to act defensively any more.

Sorry this is short but I haven't got much time at the minutue....

This is the part I can't understand, as far as I can see, the buckstopper only confirms to the horse that being ridden IS going to hurt. Addressing the memory of pain with pain can never be the answer in my opinion.
 
The buckstop only inflicts pain if the horse is bucking.. if the horse then decides that bucking is a bad idea and doesn't do it again it causes no pain at all and that lack of wanting to buck and get another yank in the gums might give the horse an opportunity to realise that the saddle and rider aren't so bad and don't cause it pain.
 
I think you may be thinking of a different sort of gadget to the one I reported on? There's nothing on the bridge of the nose in the MR buckstop so perhaps you are thinking of another sort of thing altogether. If you read some of the other posts, you will see where the 'gum' thing comes in.

then explain why it has an attachment across the lower nose and goes the whole lenght of the sisnus to the poll then attaches to the saddle
that is stopping a horse from breathing so of course it would stop bucking
as many ways of control -- from the bridge-- ie like a drop nose band
to the lenght of where the bridge is-- ie nose attachment to the poll
so the horse cant work from his poll to a relax yaw
this is just tucking him up in head- and acts like the old fasion bearing reinsto keep a horses head up

not nice as this hurts horse iside and outside of his head and neck --
 
i skipped around a little so i dont mean to repeat things.

but what if it is the riding that does hurt, like said before a bad fitting saddle, or a bad back. the horse could start showing his discomfort with other behaviors. you might have fixed the buck, but he could start to rear now. then you might go out and buy the gadget to stop rearing, you could strap the entire horse down and hell still have the issue but no way to object.

it would make more sense to me to look at the root cause, it might be even cheaper than having to buy a million gadgets.

it probably works in some cases though. although i dont like them, they have a place.

oh, and isnt this just like a check rein? these are on just about every driving harness ive ever come across, not that you have to use them though.
 
The buckstop only inflicts pain if the horse is bucking.. if the horse then decides that bucking is a bad idea and doesn't do it again it causes no pain at all and that lack of wanting to buck and get another yank in the gums might give the horse an opportunity to realise that the saddle and rider aren't so bad and don't cause it pain.

But is that addressing or masking the problem?

The horse is acting upon pain being inflicted by the buckstopper each time he attempts to buck, so effectively this gadget is only masking the problem to get a quick fix - not actually addressing what caused the problem in the first place.

Sure, the horse will probably stop bucking through fear of receiving another unbearable jolt of pain in his mouth for his actions, but how long will it last before he either reverts back to bucking or another vice appears caused by the suppression?

The last thing any horse needs who's already got a fear of pain problem is a trainer that would use a gadget that intentionally inflicts pain to 'cure' it. There's plenty others good trainers around who get the same results without the need of such gadgets.

Thanks for your replies, but so far I haven't read anything that will convince me otherwise.

:)
 
But is that addressing or masking the problem?

The last thing any horse needs who's already got a fear of pain problem is a trainer that would use a gadget that intentionally inflicts pain to 'cure' it. There's plenty others good trainers around who get the same results without the need of such gadgets.

:)

This is exactly what I was trying to get across before I got insulted by other members :eek: I do not use "gadgets" and I have retrained many horses with my methods.
 
As far as I can see from this very long debate, almost everyone seemed to assume that pain is the reason for this particular horse bucking. What if the horse has put in a buck at some point and the rider has been so unsettled by this that they immediately dismounted and put the horse back in field/stable?

I was riding a young, green horse some years ago and, just as he went into canter, I lost a stirrup which bounced off his ribs before I could regain it. He put in a big buck and leapt forward with such force that I nearly went out the back door. When I sorted myself out and got my foot back in the stirrup, I had to ride him through another couple of bucks till he calmed down. I never new him to buck again in ten years of owning him.

My point is.....if I'd taken fright that day and quit at that first buck, would he have become a habitual bucker, and could he have been subsequently cured by a tool such as the one described here?.

It's not always pain which makes a badly-behaved horse; horses discover all sorts of ways to avoid work.........this may be what we are witnessing here.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As far as I can see from this very long debate, almost everyone seemed to assume that pain is the reason for this particular horse bucking.

No assumption here AengusOg...this is a case study of my own horse.

;)

Just to add....every horse bucks for a reason, although it's usually through pain or fear it's sometimes through bad riding - this is why riding through a buck isn't always the best option.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks for your replies, but so far I haven't read anything that will convince me otherwise.

I don't think anyone is trying to convince you, your views are fair enough. It may seem otherwise but I'm no advocate of the buckstopper myself either, I can just see that it might have its place in some circumstances.

The horse is acting upon pain being inflicted by the buckstopper each time he attempts to buck, so effectively this gadget is only masking the problem to get a quick fix - not actually addressing what caused the problem in the first place.

What caused the problem in the first place, pain, fear and bad riding should have already been dealt with. What the buckstopper would address is a deeply entrenched reaction to being mounted, and from what I can gather the horse normally only ever bucks into once or twice the first time it's used, not every time. It's kept there whilst the horse is ridden but doing nothing over a few weeks and then gradually phased out as the temptation to buck out of habit is overcome. I don't see that anything is being masked, it's just one means of convincing the horse that life with humans can actually be OK.
 
I honestly dont understand this thread at all!!!!!

Some 'gadgets' (for want of a better word) actually benefit horses. If they didnt then why would so many top class riders and trainers use them?? I do understand that some riders out there use horrific methods (cough ROLLKUR cough) to get results but these inevitably fail in the long run due to the damage inflicted.

Does it matter if the 'gadgets' are classed as NH or not???:confused:

I mean is this a result of the picture of the original buck stopper or are we talking about something different altogether???

But because this item causes pain is that a good reason to slam other things??? I mean there are really severe things out there that are used everyday and there are things that people also use everyday that actually help and dont cause the horse any pain when used correctly.

As I posted before I have used certain items and have found that with a little bit of care, consideration and good sense that these items have helped Kia enormously and I now have a happy horse that is not in any pain BECAUSE I used the items.

Just because some people personally dont use the 'gadgets' available doesnt mean that they are all useless, cruel or damaging.

Nikki xxxx
 
it's just one means of convincing the horse that life with humans can actually be OK.
Exactly my point Yann, using the buckstopper is just one means of getting a result (although I must disagree that it convinces the horse humans are ok).

In my opinion, there are better options out there.

:)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I mean is this a result of the picture of the original buck stopper or are we talking about something different altogether???
I think Monty Roberts buckstopper has mainly taken over this thread. It's much more severe than the one in the picture.

But because this item causes pain is that a good reason to slam other things???
I don't use any type of gadgets on my horses, I don't think they're needed - but that's my personal choice and if others find certain non-painful gadgets a useful tool to put in their toolbox then fine.....each to their own.

It's the gadgets that cause intense pain and distress to a horse, whether they're used in the name of training or reschooling by either a professional or amateur are the one's I'm totally against.

That help? :)
 
No assumption here AengusOg...this is a case study of my own horse.

;)

Just to add....every horse bucks for a reason, although it's usually through pain or fear it's sometimes through bad riding - this is why riding through a buck isn't always the best option.

India

I missed the point at which this became a case study of your own horse, I reread the posts and enlightened myself though.

However, I also found that in post number 62 of this discussion, when asked by lizzzy how you cured your bucker, you stated that you 'initially established what the probable cause was for him bucking'....

Then, when I made the point that it's not always pain which causes a horse to buck, and that that seemed to be the general assumption, you made the above quote in reply.

Did you not, by establishing the 'probable cause', make an assumption yourself; an assumption which you then based your retraining of the horse upon; an assumption which was just that, and by its nature, may not have been the real reason for the cause of your horse bucking at all!.

Just for the record, I could not condone the use of pain in the training/retraining of horses. Sometimes riding through a buck is the best option.
 
then explain why it has an attachment across the lower nose and goes the whole lenght of the sisnus to the poll then attaches to the saddle
that is stopping a horse from breathing so of course it would stop bucking
as many ways of control -- from the bridge-- ie like a drop nose band
to the lenght of where the bridge is-- ie nose attachment to the poll
so the horse cant work from his poll to a relax yaw
this is just tucking him up in head- and acts like the old fasion bearing reinsto keep a horses head up

not nice as this hurts horse iside and outside of his head and neck --

I'm still not getting you here. The only buckstop I've seen is the plain piece of string that goes under the top lip and fastens behind the ears, and then a long peice attaches to that and then to the front of the saddle. There was nothing over the nose, so no drop noseband effect. There is a picture in one of MR's books I believe. I saw this a few years ago, so don't know if there is anything else on the market now that could act differently, but obviously I would not be getting confused between gums and nose! Maybe Yann could help out here with a better description. I've not seen any of the others that maybe on the market so cannot think what you mean.
 
newrider.com