Buck stop?!!!!!!!

Hi India

I am interested to know how you cured your bucker, Adam likes to throw one in every now and again, but it is something I live with.

We intially established what the probable cause was for his bucking then worked slowly on regaining his confidence from the ground up. Basically he was restarted from scratch....it took around eighteen months for him to become a completely safe ride, but it was well worth the time and patience.


I'll pm more details to you later if your interested. :)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It just looks like a bit attached diasy rein to me??????


Nikki xxxx

exactly what i thought when i saw it, and strike me down instantly but we use a daisy rein on my daughters pony because he is a smart little sod and knows full well that he can put his head down and evade her and she is too small to pull him back up.
I don't particularly like the thing but without it she can't get anywhere with him, in all other respects he is a great little pony, as bombproof as they come, not a bucker ,rearer, kicker or biter so we don't want to sell him on, i can ride him and he doesn't attempt it as he knows he can't. so sorry but in this case i think the gadget is the answer, if someone has a better suggestion i'd like to hear it, :)
 
Can I just say, when I said "Free lunging", this means just off of a lunge cavesson so no side reins.

I am sorry but this is a forum and eveyone is entitled to their views. I have shared mine with you and do not appreciate the way you have worded your posts. I am not pointing the finger at anyone, just stating how I see things. My views are expressed from my methods which are very successful and I have been rehabilitating horses for many years. The way I do things is not going to be the way everyone does things but that doesn't mean I do not have the right to express my opinions, it's called freedom of speech. If you don't like my views, just ignore my posts rather than attacking me.
I am not dismissing gadgets alltogether. All horses are individual and should be trated that way. I have used a couple of what I call "non restrictive" training aids in the past, but defo would not now as I have seen the damage they can do.


You have have summed it up nicely!!!

It is a public forum. I can word my posts exactly how I like.

I never once said your name, and I did start with 'I beg to differ' which you picked out of that post.:rolleyes:

I am ENTITLED to MY opinion. As long as I not being agressive in posting I dont really mind how people take my posts. If anyone was being aggressive then it certainly wasnt me. It is a free web and not everyone likes what they see on the web.

You were the one damning everyone who has ever used such things on their horses.

Oh and I never said YOU used sidereins ;)

Nikki xxxx
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You have have summed it up nicely!!!

You were the one damning everyone who has ever used such things on their horses.

Nikki xxxx

How exactly have I done this?? I haven't stated any names, I said in general maybe riders should look at themselves before using gadgets, as in check that the rider isn't doing anything to affect the horses way of going before fixing their head into position. "gadgets" should be used as a last resort is what I am trying to make clear and again, if you do not like my posts, just don't respond to them. - end of
 
I just like how you pick out certain things in my posts.:rolleyes:

Not interested in having an online debate with you really.

You went off the deep end and took offence to a post that YOU felt was specifically directed at you. It wasnt. I would have mentioned you by name if it was.

You can take what you like from my posts I dont mind :)

End of discussion. :)

Nikki xxxxx
 
I just like how you pick out certain things in my posts.:rolleyes:

Not interested in having an online debate with you really.

You went off the deep end and took offence to a post that YOU felt was specifically directed at you. It wasnt. I would have mentioned you by name if it was.

You can take what you like from my posts I dont mind :)

End of discussion. :)

Nikki xxxxx


Can you not just leave me alone please? I have said on my last two post to ignore them if you do not agree with them. I am finding you very offensive.
 
It is a public forum. I can word my posts exactly how I like as long as I am not swearing.

Is that true mods? :confused: Im not saying I think you were being offensive N+K, Ive been doing work rather than reading this thread so havent seen what has gone on the last page or so, but I think it's possible to be incredibly rude without swearing at all - I dont think simply not swearing means that you arent being offensive.

xxx
 
I was being literal Jo.

I just felt that my post were not offensive as they were not aimed at amyone in particular. I felt that my posts were getting taken out of context really.

Not really interested in this anymore. I was interested in the whole buck stop thing just as I hadnt seen it really.

Nikki xxx
 
I don't think its a good thing to be selling that kind of gadget to anyone with a credit card but don't see so much of a problem with an experienced professional using it in the right circumstances. By right circumstances i mean pain has been elimiated as much as possible and trying to ride the horse through it without a buckstop has failed. And it should be used to stop the horse bucking long enough to think and realise having someone up there isn't so bad, not as a long term thing worn every time the horse is ridden.

People do get seriously hurt by bucking horses and horses do end up canned for it. I'd rather a horse get one yank in the gums than end up at the pedigree chum factory. I keep my horses whether they can be ridden or not but not everyone has that attitude and realistically a rideable horse is much more likely to have a secure future should something happen to its owner.

If I'm riding a horse that bucks then I'll try to keep the head up with the reins to stop real 'head between knees' type rodeo broncs and if pony gets a yank in the teeth trying to buck, tough. A buckstop is almost better than that since its timing isn't dependent on the rider's hands and is softer than a bit. Plus is does nothing at all to bother the horse if it isn't trying to throw head down to buck.
 
Hi all and especially the moderators that may be watching :0)
(I have always admired the wonderful and thankless job done by forum moderators, in fact there should be a National Holiday declared to honour Moderators and their friends, families and horses.....errrr is that laying it on toooo thick????? I thought I may have gone too far, we all know moderators dont have friends....lol)

If i put any of these devices on our 'problem child ' pinto, he would head for the nearest tree to knock me off, if that didnt work, regardless of pain, he would go up and over... he only gives one warning, then he throws himself on the ground in a hissy fit....lol :0) At that stage I call him a "girlie man" in my best Arnie voice and walk home...lol.
In his defence, this is the pinto in the pic, he performs well with or without bit or halter and is a gentleman... but once having tasted conditioned response training that allowed him the freedom of choice, he wont go back to any form of physical restraint....... honestly, why should he?

Rob
 
That looks like one extremely dangerous horse you have there, LodgeRopes.

Did you allow him to become like that, or did you get him that way?
 
Turn my back for a couple of days and look what a huge discussion I've missed! Try to be friends again folks. :)
I think it's a shame that the buckstop refered to in the original post is on sale, but a lot of severe gadgets are on sale and that's not ever going to be stopped. Things will only change for the people who take the time to educate themselves in other ways of approaching problems.
I've thought long and hard about clinicians and trainers who use severe or drastic methods in demos. I think that if they have already spent time using their normal methods to solve the problem then that might just be justified in claiming they have to go for a "last resort". But of course they haven't, because they aren't around long enough to do so. I don't think any trainer can claim a horse is "last resort" on the say-so of a third party, even if it's the owner. You need to work with the horse yourself and come to your own conclusions before you do that. I've met several "last resort" horses who had been to supposedly expert trainers who were no such thing.
If you allow yourself to be forced to use severe methods in a demo because otherwise the horse will be sent for slaughter then you are being emotionally blackmailed.
There are many many trainers worldwide who can help bucking horses without using gadgets like a buckstop - ever.
So taking this into account, my conclusion about Monty Roberts using his buckstop in demos is that he isn't really that bothered about it. If he thought it was an awful tool then he'd recommend that the owners sent the horse to one of his trainers who was able to sort out the problem, and refuse to be pushed into a quick fix. Does that make sense? However, we know that many of Monty's trainers would also be comfortable using the Monty buckstopper as a training aid... so either they don't have the skills to deal with a bucking horse without, or they don't see it as a particularly awful gadget.
 
Thing is in the correct circumstances it does address the problem, if that problem is a pattern of learned behaviour, the original causes of which have been eliminated.
If the problem originally stemmed from pain caused by continually being ridden in a badly fitting saddle but still constantly persisted after a period of rest (and then only ridden in a made to measure saddle and once back checks completed)...would this not be an example of learned behaviour - an habitual habit?

If so, I'm finding it very difficult to understand how the buckstopper could address this problem...the horse is behaving and reacting in the way he does from the memory of pain and discomfort he's experienced in the past - even though the cause has been eliminated, he still associates being tacked up and ridden with pain.

How could the buckstopper address the problem, when the whole intention of the gadget is to cause the horse pain to break the pattern of behaviour? :confused:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
AengusOg...
I think his hissy fits are all his own work...... i hope that Sharon did not train him to act like that with me...lol :0)

Only joking, we have tested so much gear on this horse over the years he accepts anything.....for a while, then he gives an honest opinion (which is what we are really after). We made an offer on him to prevent him going to the knackery as he reared, bolted, bit and stomped....the previous owners had resorted to using a spanish snaffle upside down so the port compressed the tongue, martingale, head check and some other piece of tack that we had never seen before. We took him back to square one, played the 7 games, halter groundwork, hackamore riding, Lyons conditioned response reining in a plain snaffle bit, then finally back to just a rope halter for pleasure hack outs these days...
he is a gem....and he will always remain on our property despite some ridiculous cash offers for him.
I jokingly put him down and make fun of his hissy fits and sarcastic sense of humour, but he is a good mate and since I got trampled by a young colt earlier this year, this Pinto escorts me everywhere in the paddocks to make sure i'm OK, he will even leave his feed bucket to accompany me.

Rob
 
I suppose all gadgets should be used with care, and preferably only under qualified instruction.

You can shoot me down for this - but, I have seen the Monty Roberts buckstop in use and been able to inspect the horse's mouth afterwards and I can honestly say that there was no reddening of the gums and certainly no sore spots! The same horse was looked at over the following days and it suffered no ill effects at all. But it was used properly and under instruction.


well i hadnt seen it but heard of it,, of course theres no redding of the gums
as puts pressure on the bridge of the nose and poll/ neck

its not a training tool i would use,
i hate these so called quick fixs gadgets they oly make problems far worsr than what they was, what happened to find find the cause and sort the problem
i have had horses that buck and go them out of it
what happened to sit the trantrum, ie raise your bum of the saddle slightly in a x/c position so when you feel the horse is going to buck you off the saddle already so he cant buck you off then sit down hard and push him on
 
newrider.com