Buck stop?!!!!!!!

Doris, I'm really at a loss as to why you think I'm constantly trying to get on the wrong side of everything you say, I've already apologised for the post you took offence at (even though it wasn't my intention to offend you in the first place). In my last reply to you, I answered the query you put to me regarding what tests I was refering to...as far as I'm aware I answered this query politely, courtesly and in my opinion also made valid points...we even agreed the buckstopper only produces a 'quick fix'. :)

As the savvy string test causes pain in the human being, then the buckstopper must produce intense pain to a horse when his weight from a full blown buck is thrown against it. Although the test doesn't answer every question on this thread, it certainly goes a long way in confirming just how severe the gadget actually is.

I've also read and replied to quite a few interesting posts on this thread and hopefully contributed some myself. ;)
 
Fair point, but doing something to ourselves doesn't automatically prove that the horse experiences it in exactly the same way. The horse I saw buck into the buckstop didn't throw it's head around or try to reverse out of the discomfort, it just looked surprised and you could literally see it thinking carefully about whether to try another buck or not. Severe pain causes violent reactions in horses and that isn't what I saw. I know that doesn't prove anything categorically either, but I do think it's a point worth making.
 
Why has this thread got dead personal all of a sudden????

I cant see anything wrong with anything that has been said???:confused:

I agree with the not causing too much pain and there are things out there that do this but people think are perfectly ok to use.

A jab in gob wont sort out major problems but it might make a horse think twice!!!

Some gadgets I agree with as I am using one at the mo but causing pain I dont agree with.

Nikki xxxx
 
9 out of 10 problems in a horse are due to fault of the rider (unless there is a physical problem with the horse).
Maybe some riders need to take a look at themselves before cranking the horses heads into position with a gadget.
I am not a fan of gadgets at all and don't believe any of them have a use. Nothing beats free lunging and a good bond between horse and rider.
Why use any gadget??
 
Anyone who truly loved their horse would never dream of sending it to slaughter just because of a behaviour issue...they'd help him/her overcome the problem irrespective of how long this would take.

:(

Thats not totally fair - my horse is supposed to have been shot (thank god for bent dealers who sell them on the sly!!) as she was regared as dangerous and hurt that owner very badly - they were honestly afraid she would kill someone or be constantly passed around cos of her temprement (which she was until i got her), having her killed seemed the kindest thing to do.

I personally dislike gadgets BUT im open minded enough to never say never for every horse. My horse cant handle most gadgets as she has a stupidly sensitive mouth BUT my friends horse works well in a market harborough and it makes him safe enough to hack out.
 
9 out of 10 problems in a horse are due to fault of the rider (unless there is a physical problem with the horse).
Maybe some riders need to take a look at themselves before cranking the horses heads into position with a gadget.
I am not a fan of gadgets at all and don't believe any of them have a use. Nothing beats free lunging and a good bond between horse and rider.
Why use any gadget??

Well I beg to differ really!!!

I would NOT have been able to build up Kias back muscles enough to take a saddle by just lunging alone. He went around with his head in the air because he had found it easier to move this way when he out his back and pelvis out when he fell in the trailer.

He could not allow himself to relax enough to lower his head and in the beginning even found grazing difficult even though his back and pelvis had been fixed. He had a big lump of muscle that he had built up because he went around with his head in the air.

I am GLAD that I have my harbridge as he now doesnt need it because he knows that it is ok to lower his head and he doesnt have any pain. He was shown and went into a lovely outline easily before his accident.

And before you go off the deep end and say I only did this to make him look better in the show ring he is still only getting ridden once or twice a week even though he is perfectly sound and fit. He is not being asked to go in an outline yet either as he is still a bit unbalanced in canter.

Gadgets when used properly and sympathetically can have wonderful result with no detrimantal effects on the horse.

Side reins can be classed as a 'gadget' too.

Nikki xxxx
 
Monty Roberts said

"I've got people who are critical off it (buckstopper) and say I shouldnt use it but theres people all over the world that have been bucked off and paralysed and dead people in the ground that have been bucked off"

IMO there are times and places for gadgets like this. Last resorts. The horse MR was using it on was unrideable and by the end of the night his rider was on him and cantering around.

Its stupid for people to say patience costs nothing, it costs a hell of a lot when you're paying livery/schooling fees. I dont see the buck stopper as a quick fix, I see it as one last attempt to sort the horse out.
 
Last edited:
Yup there is NO SUCH THING!!!!!

I mean curly's probs are all your Rach :rolleyes:;)

Shocking isnt it!!!:rolleyes::D

Nikki xxxx
 
Well I beg to differ really!!!

Side reins can be classed as a 'gadget' too.

Nikki xxxx

Can I just say, when I said "Free lunging", this means just off of a lunge cavesson so no side reins.

I am sorry but this is a forum and eveyone is entitled to their views. I have shared mine with you and do not appreciate the way you have worded your posts. I am not pointing the finger at anyone, just stating how I see things. My views are expressed from my methods which are very successful and I have been rehabilitating horses for many years. The way I do things is not going to be the way everyone does things but that doesn't mean I do not have the right to express my opinions, it's called freedom of speech. If you don't like my views, just ignore my posts rather than attacking me.
I am not dismissing gadgets alltogether. All horses are individual and should be trated that way. I have used a couple of what I call "non restrictive" training aids in the past, but defo would not now as I have seen the damage they can do.
 
Fair point, but doing something to ourselves doesn't automatically prove that the horse experiences it in exactly the same way. The horse I saw buck into the buckstop didn't throw it's head around or try to reverse out of the discomfort, it just looked surprised and you could literally see it thinking carefully about whether to try another buck or not. Severe pain causes violent reactions in horses and that isn't what I saw. I know that doesn't prove anything categorically either, but I do think it's a point worth making.

Not in all cases but in this instant I think it does Yann. Like humans, the horses mouth is full of nerve endings...especially in their lips and gums. Even MR states the gadget should only be used as a last resort, so doesn't that in itself suggests it's quite severe?

Each buckstopper clip I've watched shows MR driving the horses forward and when they attempt to buck, he drives them more. From what I've seen, the horses never appeared to have an opportunity to either reverse or show any type of reactions immediately after any buck.

Maybe MR doesn't follow the same procedure every time? :confused:
 
Thats not totally fair - my horse is supposed to have been shot (thank god for bent dealers who sell them on the sly!!) as she was regared as dangerous and hurt that owner very badly - they were honestly afraid she would kill someone or be constantly passed around cos of her temprement (which she was until i got her), having her killed seemed the kindest thing to do.

But do you know what caused your horse to hurt his previous owner so badly that she feared he would eventually kill somebody? Had he ever shown signs of a behaviour problem before...if he had, how was the issue addressed? More to the point, would you ever consider having him shot just because of his behaviour problems?

I can understand and admire the courage some people have when they decide to have their horse pts because it's got a behaviour issue plus either a serious injury or progressive ailment..but I'm afraid I'd find it very difficult to understand why anyone would choose to have their much loved horse pts because of their problem, rather than helping them overcome it.

Again, just my opinion. ;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Monty Roberts said

"I've got people who are critical off it (buckstopper) and say I shouldnt use it but theres people all over the world that have been bucked off and paralysed and dead people in the ground that have been bucked off"
According to MR's statement, there doesn't appear to be any other way to teach a horse to stop bucking except by using a buckstopper.

True...there are some seriously wrecked folk out there, there's also lot's of other training methods that help the horse overcome exactly the same problem....but he won't tell you about those.;)

IMO there are times and places for gadgets like this. Last resorts. The horse MR was using it on was unrideable and by the end of the night his rider was on him and cantering around.

Its stupid for people to say patience costs nothing, it costs a hell of a lot when you're paying livery/schooling fees. I dont see the buck stopper as a quick fix, I see it as one last attempt to sort the horse out.
In my opinion, there's no time or place for any gadget that's used to produce pain to get a result. These type of gadgets only mask the issue, they don't address the problem.

Maybe stupid in some folks minds, but as mentioned earlier - I was refering to the owners time and patience. but even so, isn't it worse if you carry on paying schooling fees and still get no results? With a good NH instructor and plenty of time and patience, any horse should begin to show small signs of improvement within the first few weeks.;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm with Yann on this one. Having seen MR use one and listening to his reasoning and the circumstances in which it would be used. Its not supposed to be a quick fix instead of using other methods. Its the last chance method when everything else has been tried and pain issues ruled out.For seriously dangerous horses, where the alternative is being PTS - or being sold on to a new unsuspecting buyer. If my daughter had a new horse that suddenly exploded in a frenzy of horseapaults and she broke her back, think I'd be wishing someone had used the buckstop, followed up with training before selling on.
 
Having seen MR use one and listening to his reasoning and the circumstances in which it would be used. Its not supposed to be a quick fix instead of using other methods. Its the last chance method when everything else has been tried and pain issues ruled out.For seriously dangerous horses, where the alternative is being PTS - or being sold on to a new unsuspecting buyer. If my daughter had a new horse that suddenly exploded in a frenzy of horseapaults and she broke her back, think I'd be wishing someone had used the buckstop, followed up with training before selling on.


I agree. When I first heard of the Buck Stop I was very anti, it looks and sounds horrific. As others have said, though, Monty isn't recommending it's use on every horse that bucks just like he doesn't recommend Join Up for every horse with an issue.

On rare occasions the problems are just too entrenched so if this gadget can help a horse who is on borrowed time then so be it. It's a bit like draw reins, I wouldn't want everyone using them all of the time but for the truly remedial horse who has run the gamut of tests and retraining it surely has to be worth a try.

Ideally we wouldn't do anything remotely negative to our horses and if we didn't screw them up to start with there wouldn't be any need. As others have pointed out, though, it's not usually the people who screwed them up who end up sorting them out! Time, patience and kind but firm handling can go a very long way but there's a small minority where it can be beneficial to be cruel to be kind.

Things like the 'patience post' are much more reprehensible to me.
 
In my opinion, there's no time or place for any gadget that's used to produce pain to get a result. These type of gadgets only mask the issue, they don't address the problem.

Thing is in the correct circumstances it does address the problem, if that problem is a pattern of learned behaviour, the original causes of which have been eliminated. I would much rather see no pain or discomfort caused to horses in training them, and the time taken that's needed to deal with issues with kindness and patience, but this is real life and we are talking about a tool of last resort. From what I've seen MR does use a variety of other methods to work with bucking horses, but I have to admit some of the justifications I've heard him use in demos regarding keeping his demo rider safe etc are a little tenuous though.
 
Ideally we wouldn't do anything remotely negative to our horses and if we didn't screw them up to start with there wouldn't be any need. As others have pointed out, though, it's not usually the people who screwed them up who end up sorting them out! Time, patience and kind but firm handling can go a very long way but there's a small minority where it can be beneficial to be cruel to be kind.

Things like the 'patience post' are much more reprehensible to me.

I agree, in an ideal world we wouldn't have these type of problems to sort out in the first place. However, as I've already mentioned, my Beau came with excess baggage courtesy of his previous owner and did a grand job of totally wrecking my confidence. There where different options open on how I could deal with the problem, and after checking out various methods of training, I chose to go down the pain free retraining route....I wasn't prepared to allow a trainer to intentionally inflict pain on him to 'cure' his problem....my view was and still is, any horse can overcome this problem without the need of such a severe gadget.

I'm not quite sure what 'patience post' your refering to or why you should think it's much more unacceptable, could you explain in more detail please.:confused:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
newrider.com