Buck stop?!!!!!!!

India

This is a discussion thread and I feel that you are attacking me on a personal level, and not really reading or understanding my post, which is intended to help the discussion along and nothing else. I am certainly not being absurd and saying that gadgets are the same as trying a bit on your arm, of course they're not! Using words like absurd is quite rude I think, and totally unjustified. I was just pointing out another way of looking at things and another example (of discomfort), and I thought I'd put it plainly enough, but not so it seems. I have stated that I am not pro buckstopper, and will say so again so that perhaps everyone will get the message.
I know about gaining the trust etc - I am a TTEAM Practitioner P1 and I don't use gadgets. I am experienced, well read and well trained. With reference to the use of gadgets, as per my words quoted by you, I used words like 'think' and 'maybe' and I was hoping for some good discussion points to be added which may have helped the original poster who asked the question. Having seen the MR buckstopper in action, felt what it was made of and seen the effects etc. I thought it would be of genuine interest to those willing enough to listen. A horse person doesn't have to promote a particular gadget, method etc but should be open minded enough to take certain knowledge on board and learn about these things because it broadens the level of expertise. I am not a lover of some training methods, but I've taken the trouble to learn a bit about them.

There have been many buckstopper threads and they are always very controversial.

Some good and valid points from Yann.
 
Last edited:
I agree. If the horse is bucking as a result of learned behaviour and for no other reason and all physical causes have been eliminated then you have choices, spend as long as it takes trying to overcome the behavioural issue, retire or slaughter the horse, or try something like this, which will cause the horse a single moment of discomfort and break that cycle. It's the real world out there unfortunately, time, money and patience aren't limitless. Are people seriously saying they'd rather send a much loved horse to slaughter than use a gadget like this in the right circumstances?
Time and patience doesn't cost anything and that's all anyone needs to help their horse overcome a behaviour issue. If owners can't find the time it takes then they're obviously depending on the buckstopper to get a quick fix.... irrespective of the pain and trauma the contraption causes the horse.
As far as I'm concerned Yann, there are NO right circumstances where the buckstopper would be an acceptable training tool, but if you'd feel comfortable allowing an RA to use one on your horse that's your choice.... but it's not the road I was prepared to go down.

Are people seriously saying they'd rather send a much loved horse to slaughter than use a gadget like this in the right circumstances?
Anyone who truly loved their horse would never dream of sending it to slaughter just because of a behaviour issue...they'd help him/her overcome the problem irrespective of how long this would take.

:(
 
India

This is a discussion thread and I feel that you are attacking me on a personal level, and not really reading or understanding my post

As this is a discussion thread surely I'm entitled to question your opinion, theories and 'tests' on different tools and gadgets and likewise your entitled to do the same. ;)

If my posts appeared to be attacking you personally...then I apologise as this wasn't my intention, but the fact remains I do still question your testing procedures and would be very interested to read your views on mine.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Time and patience doesn't cost anything

They do if the horse is on livery, or with a professional trainer. If people keep a horse to ride and enjoy their patience may eventually become exhausted if they can't cure the problem and they will want rid. That's just how it is.

Anyone who truly loved their horse would never dream of sending it to slaughter just because of a behaviour issue

No but they might rehome it as a companion or sell it cheap, and that might be the eventual outcome.

As far as I'm concerned Yann, there are NO right circumstances where the buckstopper would be an acceptable training tool

That's your opinion and you're perfectly entitled to it.

but if you'd feel comfortable allowing an RA to use one on your horse that's your choice..

If push came to shove and all other avenues had been exhausted I daresay I would, if it meant my horse learned that it didn't need to buck out of habit any more and could resume a normal happy working life with me. My own experience of it, although very limited suggests that it's not nearly as horrendous as it sounds. Like I said plenty of stuff that's just as bad if not worse gets done to horses every day in the name of 'training'.
 
I don't quite know what testing procedures you're questioning India. I don't mind you questioning any theories but please do it nicely and politely. Perhaps I should not have used the bit/bridle testing thingy within the same context or sentence as the words pain? I think the jointed bit on the arm test and the bridle weight test are pretty common ones and are widely used just to demonstrate certain ways of feeling. Now that there are padded bridles around, if you hang both from your arm, the padded one will seem to be a lot more comfortable. It was not my intention to give the indication that they were on the same level as a buckstop.
If you pull anything tight enough it will cause discomfort and even pain, as with your savvy string. Is the same level of pain/discomfort we feel exactly the same that a horse will feel? I don't know, I'm not an animal scientist. But, a horse can feel a fly land on its body, so who knows. Something like the buckstop will only come into effect when the horse lowers its head to buck, so perhaps the horse will quickly learn not to do this. A quick fix? Yes, I suppose it is, but maybe it's better than no fix at all.

I suppose I'm trying to weigh up whether using a buckstop for one or two sessions might just save a horse from the slaughterhouse.

I think we all realise that there are horse owners out there that will not take the time and patience to retrain a horse with behavioural issues, and this is where an unfortunate animal will end up going from one dealer to another, and having been involved on a voluntary basis in horse welfare, I know what a heartrending sight this is.
 
They do if the horse is on livery, or with a professional trainer. If people keep a horse to ride and enjoy their patience may eventually become exhausted if they can't cure the problem and they will want rid. That's just how it is.
The thing is, a behaviour problem rarely occurs suddenly unless it's pain or fear related.... it usually develops over a period of time and is often man made. Any owner who know his horse well, will note the slightest change in his/her behaviour, find the cause and nip it in the bud - either with or without help from a professional.

It's only when a problem is left to fester that it usually becomes an emergency and that's when some folks either turn to the buckstopper or another mechanical gadgets to 'cure' the problem. Maybe if these folk had took the time to listen to what their horse was trying to tell them in the first place...they wouldn't be in the position they're in now?

The trouble is, if these type of folk can't find the time to look for signs and changes in the horses behaviour to begin with, they're highly unlikely to bother trying to find time to help the horse overcome the problem.

Just my opinion....;)
 
I agree with you. However in many cases those who are trying to help the horse aren't the same as those who caused the problem in the first place, it's possible to inherit issues or worse be duped into taking them on.
 
I can look at the two views here from both sides, from my own experiences.

Firstly;
However in many cases those who are trying to help the horse aren't the same as those who caused the problem in the first place, it's possible to inherit issues or worse be duped into taking them on.
YES. Take me as an example! The people who cause the problems are often not the ones who end up sorting them out.

Time and patience doesn't cost anything
Trust me, it really does. It costs you emotionally, it costs in vets bills, livery bills, trainers. I have worked out that SEPERATE to the cost of purchase, Jack has probably cost us around £7000+ this year. And Ive probably had 2 weeks riding out of him.

Anyone who truly loved their horse would never dream of sending it to slaughter just because of a behaviour issue...they'd help him/her overcome the problem irrespective of how long this would take.
I truly love my horse, but if his behaviour issue was so bad I couldnt ride him, no-one else could safely ride him, and I didnt think he was happy (even as a companion) - once Id exhausted all the options yes, I would have him pts. I would do everything in my power not to and to give him every chance, but if he was miserable ridden and miserable unridden, I would have to accept that his issues were unfixable and have him put down - anything else would be keeping him alive for my sake, not his.

Nobody with any sense would or should use anything until they have had all the necessary checks done
Therin lies the problem. I dont know about you, but I know a LOT of horsey people who dont have an ounce of sense. What about unhorsey parents, for instance? Pony has a saddle which is WAY too narrow and starts bucking. Horrified parents nip onto google, and find this amazing thing called the 'buckstop'. Pony suddenly finds itself ridden in a too tight saddle and every time it tries to say so, gets a good hard sock in the mouth. Problem fixed and little child can go off and ride every day again.
It's like draw reins - I think they possibly have their place in the world - in the hands of an experienced professional (who debatably shouldnt need them anyway, but that's a different argument) and not the general public. The general public (myself obviously included!) have far too much potential to use them completely wrongly.

When Jack first bucked me off I could have purchased MR's buckstopper, taught him that bucking meant an unpleasant pain in his mouth, and probably stopped him bucking. It would have saved me time and money, and maybe it would mean I would still have him now. He would be totally miserable and still in pain, but I wouldnt notice if I was that sort of person.

This is my issue with these gadgets - they are designed by professionals, but rarely seem to take into account the fact that it isnt going to be those professionals who ultimately buy them. Horses that buck are trying to say something - even if it is just 'Im a total monkey who knows bucking scares the pants off you'. But I would worry that the majority of people dont speak horse well enough, or with enough depth, to really know FOR SURE when a horse is acting from learned behaviour or when it is in pain. All the tests in the world would have to be done first - and how many people are going to shell out for that when a buckstopper costs £15?

xxx
 
Last edited:
I could have purchased MR's buckstopper

You couldn't because MR doesn't market or sell them. The specific buckstop being discussed here is nothing to do with him.

and probably stopped him bucking

Being as he had serious physical issues from what I can remember you posting I doubt that using something like this would have fixed him, he'd have found some other way of expressing his unhappiness.
 
I don't quite know what testing procedures you're questioning India. I don't mind you questioning any theories but please do it nicely and politely.
Doris, please don't patronise, it was your personal choice to interpret my posts the way you did!!

It's the test of the bit on your arm that I'm questioning, even if that test is widely used by many. The arm is a completely different shape to the horses mouth and the sensitivity is vastly different, so where's the comparison?

With the savvy string method the test is being performed in the same place the horse would suffer the pain...on the gumline. This is not intended to be personal so please don't take offence again...but why don't you try the test on yourself to experience what pain the horse must suffer by wearing the buckstopper.

A quick fix? Yes, I suppose it is, but maybe it's better than no fix at all.
At least we agree it's only a quick fix, but there other kinder ways of helping an habitual bucker overcome his problem without having to use a gadget that relies on fear and pain (that are possible causes of the problem in the first place).

;)
 
Sorry then, I could have purchased A buckstopper.

seeing as he had serious physical issues from what I can remember you posting I doubt that using something like this would have fixed him, he'd have found some other way of expressing his unhappiness.
Strapping him down in draw reins worked for 2 years, until I got him.


You've made me think of something interesting actually - since MR uses his buckstopper in public but doesnt market or sell them, is there not a risk of idiots making copies (or even making their own) which could do some serious damage?


xxx
 
Last edited:
I agree with you. However in many cases those who are trying to help the horse aren't the same as those who caused the problem in the first place, it's possible to inherit issues or worse be duped into taking them on.

No need to tell me that Yann...been there and got the t-shirt.

:D
 
It just looks like a bit attached diasy rein to me??????

would be ok to try and break the habit with but not for long term use.

I am talking about horses that do it out of habit and not pain of any discription.

Nikki xxxx
 
...Trust me, it really does. It costs you emotionally, it costs in vets bills, livery bills, trainers. I have worked out that SEPERATE to the cost of purchase, Jack has probably cost us around £7000+ this year. And Ive probably had 2 weeks riding out of him.
Jo, believe me, I know exactly what emotions are involed with owning an habitual bucker.... my Beau used to be one!!

I was refering to personal time and patience spent on the horse not a professionals. I couldn't even begin to work out how many hours I've spent helping him overcome his problem, but this time didn't actually cost anything. Admittedly, I did have to pay professional NH fee's as well, but pro-rota, these amounted to roughly the same price as it would have cost to have weekly lessons.

:)
 
That's my point - how many people can go down the route of the FULL process of elimination?

Just through PM on here I had people suggest to me over 15 things which could be wrong with Jack, all of which could only be confirmed by very expensive tests :rolleyes:.

I would be loathe to use anything which actually physically STOPS bucking (ie, by making the horse unable to buck), until I knew for sure that pain wasnt the cause. So I agree with you ;).


xxx
 
You've made me think of something interesting actually - since MR uses his buckstopper in public but doesnt market or sell them, is there not a risk of idiots making copies (or even making their own) which could do some serious damage?

Of course, but that stands for anyone doing anything remotely difficult in the public eye, all you can do is make the 'don't try this at home' clear and trust that your audience are grown up and intelligent.
 
Oh dear India - I wasn't patronising you, or anything like that, but I do expect some courtesy whether you agree with things I say or not and like it or lump it, there is a right way and a wrong way of speaking to people. I've carefully re-read all my postings on this subject and have nothing to reproach myself for.

Maybe my use of the bit thingy was a pretty poor example of discomfort, but it was the only one I could think of at the time, so just ignore that if it makes this discussion any easier, as it perhaps wasn't relevant to this thread. My somewhat bad examples are not worthy of so much discussion. You do seem to be be insisting on getting on, and staying on the wrong side of what I say - I don't know why, as I'm sure I've never upset you on this board before, and I'm not trying to now.

I take your point about the savvy string, and yes, that can be put in the same position on a human being, whereas a bit cannot. Totally, totally much better example, but does it answer all the questions posted on here just because it causes pain to a human being?

Myself, and Yann, and a few others have brought up some good and interestiong points, that's not to say they are all correct, and that we all agree with them, but interesting thoughts for discussion. Please lets not all get bogged down because we don't all practice the same methods of horse training, horse management, horse therapy etc.
 
Last edited:
. But we all need to use bridles and bits.

Do we, cuz I've seen plenty of people who are competent at bitless/bridleless riding;)

This sort of comment never fails to amuse me. :rolleyes:

If you think it doesn't hurt the horse try this test (which I also put on another MR thread but got no takers).......

Get a thin piece of rope IE: savvy string, place it between YOUR OWN top lip and gum line, lift the taut rope up at an angle...then throw your head down into it with as much force as you can....ok did that hurt???

Yes?, (I know it does because I've tried it)...now just imagine the force behind a full blown buck.

Then come back and tell me it it has no ill effect on the horse!!!:mad:

Sorry..I'm in a bad mood today. :o

I've just tried it(had a savvy string on me for once) and your right it hurt like hell:eek:
Oh dear India - I wasn't patronising you, or anything like that, but I do expect some courtesy whether you agree with things I say or not and like it or lump it, there is a right way and a wrong way of speaking to people. I've carefully re-read all my postings on this subject and have nothing to reproach myself for.

Maybe my use of the bit thingy was a pretty poor example of discomfort, but it was the only one I could think of at the time, so just ignore that if it makes this discussion any easier, as it perhaps wasn't relevant to this thread. My somewhat bad examples are not worthy of so much discussion. You do seem to be be insisting on getting on, and staying on the wrong side of what I say - I don't know why, as I'm sure I've never upset you on this board before, and I'm not trying to now.

I take your point about the savvy string, and yes, that can be put in the same position on a human being, whereas a bit cannot. Totally, totally much better example, but does it answer all the questions posted on here just because it causes pain to a human being?

Myself, and Yann, and a few others have brought up some good and interestiong points, that's not to say they are all correct, and that we all agree with them, but interesting thoughts for discussion. Please lets not all get bogged down because we don't all practice the same methods of horse training, horse management, horse therapy etc.

I couldn't see anything wrong or offensive in indias replys:confused:
 
newrider.com