Buck stop?!!!!!!!

It's not in metal is it? Just webbing and nylon?

They are all basic training aids which could be used very badly in the wrong hands as a quick fix which doesnt address the real issues. Nothing I havent seen before though, they are just sticking them all in one place and selling them remarkably cheaply!


ETA I dont like the concept of the Remus though


xxx
 
Last edited:
Sorry just read the second part of your question, presumably the concept behind the buckstop is that it a) stops the horse getting it's head down and b) raises the bit in the mouth to pull the head back up (hence the little white pulley bit) - much easier to pull a horse's head up from in front than behind (where the rider is).

xxx
 
i just had a proper look athe buck stop on the site and realised that the webbing or nylon goes all the way ot the saddle and therefore now understand how it is supposed to stop a horse from bucking!!!!!:o
i still dont like it though and hate the over use of gadgets on horses, i think it is masking real problems either pain or misunderstandings between horse and rider. :p
 
Isn't this the gadget MR likes to use! I hate it, its a quick fix as JOJOBA said and IMO shouldn't be used.

Although this gadet is severe MR's is worse....his buckstopper works by the same method except a thin piece of rope is placed between the horses gum and lip which takes the full force of the buck.

It's a barbaric contraption. :mad:
 
I don't like MR's bit of kit at all. People come up with the 'if it's a case of use MR's buckstopper versus horse being PTS then it has it's place...' I'm not sure I agree.

But as has been said, the one there isn't anywhere as nasty as MR's.
 
I suppose all gadgets should be used with care, and preferably only under qualified instruction.

You can shoot me down for this - but, I have seen the Monty Roberts buckstop in use and been able to inspect the horse's mouth afterwards and I can honestly say that there was no reddening of the gums and certainly no sore spots! The same horse was looked at over the following days and it suffered no ill effects at all. But it was used properly and under instruction.
 
I suppose all gadgets should be used with care, and preferably only under qualified instruction.

You can shoot me down for this - but, I have seen the Monty Roberts buckstop in use and been able to inspect the horse's mouth afterwards and I can honestly say that there was no reddening of the gums and certainly no sore spots! The same horse was looked at over the following days and it suffered no ill effects at all. But it was used properly and under instruction.

That may be so but doesn't mean it didn't cause the horse a lot of pain. Instead of resloving the problem through understanding and gaining trust and insite into the reasons the horse is bucking, you're with a buck stopper using pain so that its memory of bucking is associated with one of pain and so the horse fears doing so.:o I just know that there are better ways!
 
You can shoot me down for this - but, I have seen the Monty Roberts buckstop in use and been able to inspect the horse's mouth afterwards and I can honestly say that there was no reddening of the gums and certainly no sore spots! The same horse was looked at over the following days and it suffered no ill effects at all. But it was used properly and under instruction.
This sort of comment never fails to amuse me. :rolleyes:

If you think it doesn't hurt the horse try this test (which I also put on another MR thread but got no takers).......

Get a thin piece of rope IE: savvy string, place it between YOUR OWN top lip and gum line, lift the taut rope up at an angle...then throw your head down into it with as much force as you can....ok did that hurt???

Yes?, (I know it does because I've tried it)...now just imagine the force behind a full blown buck.

Then come back and tell me it it has no ill effect on the horse!!!:mad:

Sorry..I'm in a bad mood today. :o
 
Yikes! Whatever next?? soon there will be no need for any of us to have lessons because all horses will be so strapped down we wont need to be able to ride, just sit on them like a rocking horse!! I shudder to think of all those poor ponies out there that are bucking due to severe pain and then get one of these strapped on to them!! when will people learn??

Bad mood or not india, your point is very valid and i totally agree!!
 
If I slapped someone across the face then a few minutes later the redness would have gone down and there would be no obvious signs Id done it, but it would still have hurt them at the time and Im sure they'd agree it wasnt an enjoyable experience! They'd think twice before they did whatever it was that caused it again.

Even at the height of Jack's bucking issues I would never have considered something like this for a second.

xxx
 
I think there is a difference between actual pain and discomfort. You can do the same test on your arm with a normal jointed snaffle and it will cause discomfort. I've even tested the feel of a normal bridle on my arm compared to that of a comfort bridle, and the ordinary bridle will actually weigh quite heavily on the poll area. But we all need to use bridles and bits.

I'm not pro the use of a buckstop, and I am also aware that there are other ways to deal with the problem and also the amount of time 'redness' would take to disappear. In the case that I quoted, the horse was looked at immediately. I cannot answer for all of you that have seen one being used, and no doubt many of you have before posting your comments.

But, I think there is just maybe some justification for using gadgets (much as I don't like them), if all else has failed, and in some cases, all other ways have failed, because it means that the horse can be brought back into use again instead of ending up at the slaughter house.

Nobody with any sense would or should use anything until they have had all the necessary checks done to ensure that there is no valid reason for a horse to be bucking in the first place.
 
Last edited:
I think there is a difference between actual pain and discomfort. You can do the same test on your arm with a normal jointed snaffle and it will cause discomfort.
There certainly is a difference between pain and discomfort. The mouth is a very sensitive area, so to suggest that testing a bit out on your arm would give you the same result as if it where tested out in your own mouth is absurd. But an even worst comparison would be testing the buckstopper mechanics out in the same way and then comparing the discomfort you'd feel on your arm to the actual pain felt on the gumline....try it and see!!


But, I think there is just maybe some justification for using gadgets (much as I don't like them), if all else has failed, and in some cases, all other ways have failed, because it means that the horse can be brought back into use again instead of ending up at the slaughter house.
In my opinion, there's no justification for any gadget to be used, they're only there to get a quick fix.....it has nothing to do with the 'if all else has failed' theory. Most horse behaviour issues and problems are man made or caused by fear or pain and using a gadget only serves to increase the degree of the problem in the long term.

Restarting from the ground up is the best way to help any horse overcome a behaviour issue - get their trust and respect and your half way there.....no need for any type of gadget, especially a buckstopper!!!
 
Using a gadget to overcome a problem is dealing with the symptom instead of finding the cause and solving the problem.... .... ....
 
Had a look through the website... quite scary looking gadgets they have:eek: If they ended up in the wrong hands they could cause some serious damage.. theres no regulations either..apart from a note of caution..I dont expect they would put the possible outcomes if used incorrectly as nobody would buy them!

I dont think I would 'invest' in one!
 
But, I think there is just maybe some justification for using gadgets (much as I don't like them), if all else has failed, and in some cases, all other ways have failed, because it means that the horse can be brought back into use again instead of ending up at the slaughter house.

Nobody with any sense would or should use anything until they have had all the necessary checks done to ensure that there is no valid reason for a horse to be bucking in the first place.

I agree. If the horse is bucking as a result of learned behaviour and for no other reason and all physical causes have been eliminated then you have choices, spend as long as it takes trying to overcome the behavioural issue, retire or slaughter the horse, or try something like this, which will cause the horse a single moment of discomfort and break that cycle. It's the real world out there unfortunately, time, money and patience aren't limitless. Are people seriously saying they'd rather send a much loved horse to slaughter than use a gadget like this in the right circumstances?

I've also seen it in use, the horse tried to buck once and then didn't thereafter as it worked out instantly what the self inflicted consequence would be. It showed very little evidence of any discomfort after that buck, I've seen professional showjumpers horses expressing far more discomfort in their mouths at the end of their rounds. Horses are routinely put through pain and discomfort in the name of training and nobody bats an eye at it. As I have also posted before I'm aware of at least two horses that have been fixed long term by the buckstopper and gone on to lead useful and happy lives with their owners, it may be a 'quick fix' but in the right circumstances and the right hands it works.

I don't like to see something like this on general sale though, it's too easy for anyone with a problem to buy and use one when the horse might be bucking for a damn good reason, and that's bad.
 
newrider.com