Box rest hell finally ends!!

Mary Poppins

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2004
13,662
4,789
113
Visit site
Today Ben has a vet check up. He is now 6 months post surgery and has been on full box rest all that time. It has been difficult to say the least.

The bottom line is that he is still lame. His stifle is still swollen and he trots up 2/10 lame normally and 4/10 lame under flexion. I am absolutely gutted that there has actually been very little improvement in all the time he has been on box rest. It makes it seem like a pointless waste of time, money, energy and tears.

I told the vet that I was really struggling with handling him and that my nerves were completely torn apart. We agreed that a phased return to turnout was in his best interests and that the only option we now have is to wait and see if turnout and gentle exercise could help him. He did say that he has seen stifle injuries like his take 18 months to heal properly so I wasn’t to lose hope.

But I have lost hope. I just know that he is going to decline. We agreed on 6 weekly check ups from the vet and 6 weekly physio appointments so that discomfort and decline could be spotted early. And I have decided that as soon as he starts to get worse, it will be time to say goodbye to him because I just will not watch him suffer any more than he already has.

The vet is keen for me to keep hacking him out in walk daily. He says this is good for Ben in all ways and would be good for me as well. The only problem is that I have lost my nerve and the very thought of hacking him like I used to seems unreachable.

So I am sorry it isn’t better news. I feel completely heart broken. I have tried everything to fix him, I love him so much and I know we are facing the inevitable end. I don’t ever want to be involved with horses again after he goes. The good times do not make up for the bad. It is too painful and I can’t describe how sad and completely gutted I am.
 
I can imagine how you feel - but one thing that stands out in your post - the vet said not to lose hope. Please please don't. You can't say for certain he will decline. Cross that bridge when you get to it. I know it is easier said than done but having faced an un-healable / un-doable injury in two horses I have owned, I can only speak from experience. Don't lose hope. I know you have tried everything to fix him, he may not be fixable and you know that. I am sending you my biggest encouragement and positive vibes. I would have loved to read that things were almost back to normal for you both - but, not today.
However, why not see what the turnout and gentle exercise bring? Things still do have a chance for getting better. Stay strongxxx
 
I can imagine how you feel - but one thing that stands out in your post - the vet said not to lose hope. Please please don't. You can't say for certain he will decline. Cross that bridge when you get to it. I know it is easier said than done but having faced an un-healable / un-doable injury in two horses I have owned, I can only speak from experience. Don't lose hope. I know you have tried everything to fix him, he may not be fixable and you know that. I am sending you my biggest encouragement and positive vibes. I would have loved to read that things were almost back to normal for you both - but, not today.
However, why not see what the turnout and gentle exercise bring? Things still do have a chance for getting better. Stay strongxxx
Thank you. I just feel like I have been positive for the last year and always believed that he would get better, only for me to be completely shattered at every stage. I wish that I hadn’t put him through any treatment, it all seems pointless looking back.

Maybe I just need some time to pull myself together. I am just so disappointed right now.
 
I was so happy when I saw the title of this thread. Then I opened it and started reading and my heart sank.
As Trewswrs said, please don’t give up hope. Deal with it day by day and enjoy your time with him. Would you consider keeping him as a non ridden horse? 2/10 th lame is ok for a retired horse under no pressure to move around.
 
I'm gutted for you that the improvement hasn't been more :( but the turnout will no doubt help him mentally and the vet obviously is still hopeful it will help physically too.
Sometimes phasing back to turnout can be a very difficult process, I've often found going to a small space 24/7 easier and physically less traumatic than trying to do an hour or so, before back to the stable, and gradually increasing as they can get over excited and act out at each turnout. What approach did your vet suggest?
 
I was so happy when I saw the title of this thread. Then I opened it and started reading and my heart sank.
As Trewswrs said, please don’t give up hope. Deal with it day by day and enjoy your time with him. Would you consider keeping him as a non ridden horse? 2/10 th lame is ok for a retired horse under no pressure to move around.

Yes, in hindsight the title of the thread doesn't exactly match what I was writing!

I would of course keep him retired, if he could be retired. The vet says that light exercise is better for him than retirement. He has arthritis in his back, hocks and fetlock and needs to keep gently moving or he will risk seizing up. We are only talking about walking out in straight lines for half an hour a day. So it's not exactly hard work for him, but should be enough to keep his arthritis joints happy.
 
I'm gutted for you that the improvement hasn't been more :( but the turnout will no doubt help him mentally and the vet obviously is still hopeful it will help physically too.
Sometimes phasing back to turnout can be a very difficult process, I've often found going to a small space 24/7 easier and physically less traumatic than trying to do an hour or so, before back to the stable, and gradually increasing as they can get over excited and act out at each turnout. What approach did your vet suggest?

The vet was more concerned about him getting colic which is why he wants a phased turnout. He is out on his own in a paddock of about 1/3 acre at the moment but it is surrounded by horses. He had 2 hours today, and this will increase by 1 hour everyday over the next week. He will then stay out during the day for a week and then we will turn him back out with the herd overnight. He will be sedated for this!! The vet didn't want the sugar in the grass to cause colic so wanted this introduced gradually.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
The fact that your vet is saying don't give up hope should be encouraging, nowadays they're usually very wary of saying anything like that for fear of being sued so he really must feel that there are grounds to hope. You also say he has arthritis, that being the case you could well see an improvement after some turnout - box rest is hard on arthritis & a little bit of walking each day isn't enough to stop it being a problem. Don't give up yet, and don't start looking too hard for signs of problems that you'll take as the end. No he my not come back sound, but if he's comfortable does that really matter so very much? I learned it didn't & we just tailored work according to what he was happy with.

Big hugs. I know it hurts to hope, but it hurts even more to despair & ultimately neither will change a thing x
 
I have been there with Sasa, Molly, Rose, Big Ears, Mouse, Ferguson and Vodka. All very different all very difficult. So I understand how down you feel and how hard it is. But the vet isn't giving up on him and you may be surprised. Rose was given 7 days to live and went on for another 6 years. Molly was written off age 9 and lived to 26. I am having issues with Murphy since his colitis so I know how hard it is to keep managing them daily when they are wrong.

Give him a chance to settle down. You will probably find that in time you can hack him out to keep him ticking over. I ride Buddy most mornings, 30-45 minutes walking to keep him supple and fit, he probably has a lot of aches and pains - you don't want to look at his tendons in front - he has stiffness in his neck and probably a bit arthritic too. But he is out all day once he is ridden, and has a double stable so he can move very easily.

Deep breaths, take it a day at a time. It is horrible feeling you are on the slope to the 'day' when it ends, but vets are generally pretty inexpert at predicting things. Mouse had surgery for lymphoma, highly recommended given what she had, she got through the surgery fine, then it all went pear shaped. You just can't tell how things pan out. Once he is out 24/7 he will be happier. I have had to create a mud paddock for Murphy to try to get him right, so if he could have a bare paddock it would really help Ben as you could control the feeding.

Sod's law you are coming into grass growing season but better to get him out now than in a month as the grass is beginning to grow.
 
I really hope the turnout helps, both physically and mentally. I found it tough to retire Ramsey at 24, because he hated it at first, but ultimately it was the best thing, and he settled into it. I feel for you so much, but hope the vets guarded optimism is proved right, and Ben can enjoy being a much loved companion. Everything crossed for you both.
 
As others have said already, your vet hasn't given up hope, so, you mustn't either, you never know once he's out and moving more things may come good, if not he will still be able to have a life being retired surely? It's not time to give up on him just yet. Hopefully more turnout will help his mental wellbeing and you'll get your calm and sensible boy back and be able to enjoy riding him again.
 
Oh @Mary Poppins I am so sorry to read this, you have gone above and beyond for him. Your vet has said don't lose hope, although I can imagine how hard it is to keep being optimistic. I think turnout will help you both as others have mentioned. You've come this far with him don't give up just yet. You say you don't ever want to be involved with horses again fi he goes, and that's very much how I felt about my old boy. Sorry I don't have anything useful to say but sending you hugs.
 
As others have said already, your vet hasn't given up hope, so, you mustn't either, you never know once he's out and moving more things may come good, if not he will still be able to have a life being retired surely? It's not time to give up on him just yet. Hopefully more turnout will help his mental wellbeing and you'll get your calm and sensible boy back and be able to enjoy riding him again.
People say this, but to me, if he is trotting up lame and compensating for his injury, he will be in pain regardless if I am riding him or not. If he was sound when not in work that would be different because it would be the work that was causing the lameness. But he is lame regardless, and lameness means pain.
 
I disagree with what you say Mary. Owning animals always involves their loss. My RI prevented me buying a horse years ago because she didnt want me to have to go through the pain, but I do regret it. I love my daughter's dog to bits and yet she (not yet 2) almost died 3 months ago.

I am now turning to the hacking question. You had a bad fright years ago and were always nervous of hacking . But if you ride in walk first in a field and in clover leaf loops extending only little by little you should recover your nerve. I realise that calming an older or unwell horse involves cutting their food which may be hard with Ben!
Some of us here ride on yards where Ben would not have been operated on, but having made that decision you have carried it through really well and conscientiously and he may yet benefit having happy times. If I lived nearer and Ben were no so wide I would willingly share and hack him in walk. So you could look locally and try to find an o.a.p. who might share him. And I dont mean a young expert rider who can withstand bucking.
It worries me very much that you are now frightened of your horse. I am not saying anyone should get on a horse and ride and take risks. But I do think you should restart the leading and ground work with him - a refresher course may be for both of you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
Sorry to hear that, Mary Poppins. I guess moving on to turnout will at last given him a better quality of life until you reach a final decision. Whatever the outcome, you will have the peace of knowing that you tried every possible option to make him better.
As to never wanting to ride again if you lose Ben: i think this is a perfectly normal reaction in your situation. You might conme to feel differently in a couple of months or years, though. So just keep an open mind about it.
 
People say this, but to me, if he is trotting up lame and compensating for his injury, he will be in pain regardless if I am riding him or not. If he was sound when not in work that would be different because it would be the work that was causing the lameness. But he is lame regardless, and lameness means pain.
Would he not be able to have a low dose of bute? Or is it that you feel any pain is a reason to not go on?
I agree that pain is unacceptable but with careful management it might be controllable to a degree.
He’s your horse at the end of the day and if you feel that any ache is unacceptable then obviously that is your choice, whatever you decide will be the right thing for you.
I was simply trying to look on the bright side that’s all.
 
newrider.com