Big boy runs away when scared help!

nurse9

New Member
Feb 16, 2011
83
0
0
london
Help all advice gratefully received!
My 15.2 heavy weight 7 year old cob that I have had for nearly five months has a habit of bolting when he is scared by something when out hacking alone:hot: and a lot of stuff scares him!
He did it the first time when I only had him for one week and I rode him in the sand school he bolted couldn't turn or stop him out the side door when he did a 90 degree turn at the fence. Absolutely killed my confidence so did pretty much 2 months of ground work had instructor out etc. Eventually got back on started to trust him rode daily in the school then started get out around fields for schooling felt really good then 3 weeks ago after hacking out in fields felt he had down well walking back relaxed on the buckle he went into a massive bolt I ended up falling off again broken wrist, cheek bone a ribs and 5 days in hospital:stomp:. Now OH wants to get rid of him:unsure:
He is a lovely gentle giant on the ground and never bucks or rears but I don't think I have the confidence to get him out of this habit.
He is my first horse although I have loaned before I got him.

I guess my thoughts are
*how do I help him to have more confidence?
*could it be a pain thing (teeth checked and ok)
*is he trying it on

Also I wonder if I have been asking too much of him because he fitness was not great when I got him, he was only doing 20 minute hacks most days. I wonder this because he was quite reluctant to work in the school and out in the fields a couple of days before this episode:redcarded:

Thanks so much for reading choccies all round :wub:
 
This strikes a chord with me as it is VERY similar to my posts from a year or so ago. First off, I really hope you're ok, that sounds like a very very nasty fall. Also, I'm sure this experience has been scary for your horse - he sounds like he could be a very sensitive chap who senses your fear and reflects it back - running because he's scared and feels you're not going to protect him so he better take things into his own hands. He's still quite young isn't he, and these big guys may have all the appearance of being able to handle themselves in a bar brawl but really they are like little children who want to be led...safely. Must be a heavy thing!
I found my boy started running more and more on hacks and if I wasn't balanced he would run more, I did several things -
1. Lessons on other horses - improved balance and confidence in my ability to be in charge - I look after my horse not the other way around.
2. My horse went away for retraining - 3 weeks resetting those bad experiences he'd had and then 3 weeks putting us together in lessons at the yard before coming home.
3. Lots and lots of schooling - transitions, circles, etc. Just stuff to show him you are his leader and he can trust you.
4. Walking out in hand
5. Hacking with others
6. Hacking with foot solider
7. Solo hacking
Solo hacking is just maybe something you shouldn't be doing yet with him. Other horses may be fine with it so soon but he sounds like he needs more time to bond and trust you. Im only getting to it now after almost two years of owning my boy.
I am concerned that you use the word bolt - is he stoppable (if you stayed on?) just unsure if he's bolting or just panicking and running - I realised from reading on NR that bolting is much more serious and is a term that sometimes gets misused. If it is bolting id be thinking very carefully about continuing if you are not an experienced rider.
Sorry for the waffling, hope it is of use. Of course I would definitely be getting saddle, teeth and back checks so you can rule out pain but 20 minutes is not too much for any fitness level I would have thought (as long as it's not 20 mins canter work lol!) but I do think the solo hacking is too much for him just yet. Take your time if you're up for the challenge and your OH can be convinced to allow you to keep him. A experienced rider could help reset his worries and a RI for both of you will help rebuild your confidence in each other. It might take a lot of patience, perseverance and determination but it can be worth it. All the best.

ETA - also what tack is he wearing - controversial may be but do you have brakes? I got told not to mess about as my horse knows his own strength. I'm very careful with it but he's now in a two ring butterfly bit with curb. I use my voice and learning to use my seat to stop him but in emergencies I know I've got back up.
 
Last edited:
my cob starting doing this a few months ago, he is quite confident for a (then) 4 year old, now 5 but after i brought him back to work from winter he would do this. i now think he was trying it on most of the time, although he still thinks about doing this when in a new situation he is not sure of, i didnt have any company to take him out with.
it did knock my confidence quite a bit but bit by bit i have got it back and have now achieved several solo hacks although still not 100% there yet.

1) firstly i got someone to walk beside me with a headcollar over the bridle so i was clipped on and they were leading me, this made me feel safe so eliminated the nerves so i wouldnt have to worry about him doing it, plus gave him a bit of confidence having someone on the ground. i also had someone to talk to so again helped with the nerves.
2) after i felt comfortable with that they walked beside me without being attached, then gradually started walked further away until they were quite a way behind me
3) after that they would drive/bike away from me but still there just in case

All of this took several months so go at your own pace and your horses until you get your confidence back, i also stuck to walk until i was ready to trot on my own, i also learnt how to growl! and back my leg up with a stick when he was trying it on (was sometimes a form of napping as he did it up the drive/gate out of the yard) he was worse when i was nervous so i learnt when he was trying it on and when he was genuinely worried.
Id also suggest groundwork is he is a new horse so he see's you as trustworthy, my horse was quite pushy and didnt listen but is much better now and it has reflected in his ridden work to as he hasnt tried it for a while!

The first few times he did it i was at a loss how to deal with it as id never had a horse do that before, but after first few if possible turn him on a circle to stop him, if the space is too tight squeeze one rein then the other (sort of like how some people ask to go on an outline) so you dont get into a tug of war. ive found the more groundwork (teaching him the word whoa on lunge) ive done the more he listens to my voice in the saddle.

if i felt him tense up and wanst confident to ride him through it yet i would get off and let him sniff what he is finding scary and that might make him more confident?

Good luck i hope you get it sorted, if you need chat about it PM me :)
 
Last edited:
Cant really better the advice you've already been given, both answers are fab advice :wub:

I have also been there with my youngster but 2.5 years later we alright now (Not perfect) but definatly a massive improvment.

Lots of ground work, walking in hand to establish trust etc

Then like caroline i was just led around on hacks for a while, good old OH!

I think 5months is still a very short amount of time to have full trust in each other or to know each other properly. Soi would take your time just building trust by little steps :smile:

Its gets easier to trust your horse when you know them inside out, i know exactly what freaks my lad out now so i can kind of prepare myself for the worst if i see somthing which he may find scary.
 
I echo all the advice given. I too have a heavyweight cob who is a wimp. :giggle: He is such a good boy though and tries his best to please but things can scare him and he will try and run for it. He is much better now though than he was. It takes time for a horse to put his trust in you and five months is no time at all. As others have said, do plenty of groundwork, have someone alongside when riding etc etc. Don`t even feel you have to ride him. Time spent in each others company will form a bond between you and you will get to know him better.
 
Once again great answers from NR peeps:happy:
I too didn't really think that five months was long for bonding but other 'helpful' people all say it is long enough. FM you are so right about his personality he is BIG but he is worried by everything I had to move him from one field because he was bullied by a pony half his size poor boy:unsure:
I absolutely love him he has helped me through some tough personal probs and I enjoy being with him:wub: I fortunately have no nerves with him on the ground when he mucks about when lunging or walking in hand he gets a growl and looks at me to say sorry mum:hot:
So my plan is this
1. Looking to send away for retraining (looking at avril tight @mysafrcobs I like her NH methods)
2. Get a good RI to back up the NH methods on board
3. Lots of in hand work
4. Possibly move yards to somewhere that has more experienced owners (I am field livery with not many other owners mostly kids)

BTW OH has fallen in love with him since having to do all the grooming and poo picking he even has asked to learn to lunge!! So prob convince him to keep the cowardly lion!!
 
Forgot to say FM I do think it is a full on bolt because it comes from nothing head down relaxed me dropping contact riding on the buckle, then head up top speed gallop with no brakes can't turn him as though he is not listening at all:hot:
Also my friend asked to ride him when I was in hosp I agreed just in school she didn't take him in the school he did same to her she baled and then her boyfriend got on him ( without permission) prince did same to him and he's hurt his leg this time he ran right across the fields:hot:
Needless to say they have my opinion on their behaviour. So yes I think the poor boy is terrified of stupid humans that keep falling off his back.

Sorry for waffling but I really care about this guy and I don't want him to be sent Fromm owner to dealer etc and ending up in a downward spiral:frown:
 
Firstly get all the checks done ie teeth/back/saddle to rule out discomfort. You say that you have trouble with your nerves when handling him - obviously he is picking up on this and likely making him nervous. Cobs can also be bolshy and are capable of running rings around you if they know they can get away with it (like any horse).

maybe think twice about sending him away to be schooled, as you will have to keep this up once he returns home to you, or if you do go down this route make sure you go up and have lessons on him regularly.
 
I think that there is the world of difference between a horse who spooks and takes off for a short while in canter, and one who goes into a blind bolt for no apparent reason. Horses who bolt like this need to be in very experienced hands, otherwise someone is going to get seriously hurt. You have already spent 5 days in hospital and your 2 friends have also fallen off him. He is learning that this behaviour gets the rider off his back and he is just going to do it more and more. You also need to think about other members of the public who you might injure by his bolts. How would you feel if he hurt someone out walking their dog?

I would stop hacking him and get the advice of a good RI who can assess him in all situations. I would pay a RI to take him out and see if he does it with them. I would also get the vet to give him a full MOT along with the saddle fitter, back person etc. etc. There may be an underlying physical cause for his behaviour, but the fact that he has learnt that running off gets him out of work, may mean that he will always continue to do it anyway.

It may be that he is suited to a home with no hacking, or it may be that someone more confident can nip the behaviour in the bud and stop him doing this. From what you have written, I don't think that he is the horse for you at this time.
 
Seriously, if this a genuine bolter you need to have along hard think about where you go from here because it's very dangerous behaviour.

- Start with ruling out any pain issues.
- Look at his management, does this seem to affect his behaviour? Some horses are much better kept out, or with no hard feed, or in single sex herds - the list is nearly endless but if you look hard you may find factors that affect him.
- Is there a common factor to the times he's bolted? Maybe he feels his rider isn't paying attention so he's responsible for looking after you? He's already been upset by something & can't take any more? He's tired/fresh /cheeky? (by the way I'd never ever ride something prone to bolting/taking off on the buckle end - far too dangerous IME)
- I can't see a lot of benefit in sending him off for reschooling TBH. A genuine bolter can't be schooled out of the habit because when they go their head is switched off & all the training goes out the window. I think you'd be better off getting someone who's dealt with these sort of problems to work with you both at home - fully explain the problem & ask them for an honest opinion.

Finally unless you can identify & avoid triggers then I wouldn't hack him in public, it's one thing to put yourself at risk but totally irresponsible to knowingly endanger others. Even if you hack on private land (or can identify & avoid triggers) you need to be very careful & never relax or trust him too far - your own & his safety depend on you being alert & ready to deal with any problems immediately.

In case you think all of this sounds very preachy I do understand the problem because I have a horse with a similar problem & have learnt to work around it because I can't face living without him. It's hard, sometimes dangerous & not something you can deal with unless you're realistic about both your limits. I wish you lots of luck!
 
MP thanks for your comments I agree bolting is not something I am able to deal with alone, but it does happen for a reason after discussion with others at the yard apparently there were other horses cantering up the fields on the other side of the tree line to the field I was in. I didn't notice this at the time!

WWA I dont have any nerves when on the ground but clearly I am apprehensive when riding having had a fall when I first got him.

PF he just continues to bugger off back to his field with no second glance as far as I can work out!

BnP I have had him since to beginning of march i bought him from a lady who owns a livery yard and occasionally sells for her liveries, he was originally from Ireland the seller had him for 6months prior to me buying. Woman than owned him had supposedly just used him for hacking and she wanted to move up to more disciplines and he was too slow:bounce:

Carthorse I appreciate your comments I def won't be hacking anywhere for the next two months as can't with broken wrist:poop::poop: I wonder how you manage your bolter and was it easier because you had had prior experience of this behaviour?

I am optimistic about him because he has been easy to train in all other areas that weren't quite right when I got him (manners on the ground feet tacking up farrier etc)
 
I'm not sure I would say he is bolting if he just goes back to his field. He is scared and is going back to a place of safety. That takes thought and bolters have no real sense of self preservation, they are just running and running with no thought to where they are going. To me he sounds like he is just spooking with you, running off, getting you off and going back to where he wants to be.

But I think you need to go back to basics with him. Lots of lessons (when you can ride again) and until then get an RI to school him for you and hack him out. He needs someone he feels confident with to teach him that running off is not the done thing.

Think you should get the usual checks done and then get a good RI to ride him for a bit and see what they think.

I have a big, strong cob but he is a bit older than your boy. He is bold and confident but only if his rider is. If I was nervous he would get nervous and start to take the mickey.
 
Nurse9 I don't do much hacking with mine nowadays, & none of it is on grass. What hacking we do do is only done when he's consistently calm, he wants to go out & the weather is good. I only do short, well-known routes that I've checked first - I don't suddenly like finding someone's put flags out! - & I take someone either on foot or on a reliable horse. If, at any point, he starts feeling tense & stressed we give him time to calm down then go home. The aim is to never put him in the situation where he starts to feel he can't cope, if I can keep him thinking & listening to me we're fine - with him it's very rarely one startle that will set him off, instead it seems to be a build up of vey minor things that he adds up & then one last thing is more than he can cope with.

On a plus for you Itend to agree with Tiga that if he goes to his field he's probably running to a safe place rather than bolting & if that's the case there's hopefully something you can work with. Mine just goes in a straight line, regardless of what's in his way, & has shot straight past home without even noticing. When he comes to he stops to a voice aid & seems quite bemused about where he is, looking round to get his bearings & seeking instructions & reassurance.
 
Interesting been speaking to anyone who will listen re: 'bolting' sad I know!!:mstickle: it seems to be more common with ponies in my yard and everyones got a story:frown: I am realising that it probably wasn't a full on bolt as I have heard stories of horse going through post and rail fences and even into cars when properly bolting. I have been analysing pre fall and I am now sure I just tensed up and pulled on his mouth which made him worse then faster tenser you know the story:hot:(although OH says I'm making excuses) therefore I am making a plan to move to a bigger yard with a bigger menage and a good RI.
I have decided that sending away for training may not help if I have the nerves when I get him home and I'm all alone again:cry:
Also have potential loaner who is very experienced and aware of all issues has experience of owning horses with 'issues'.:wink:

Also thinking of up bitting as a temporary measure for when hacking. Opinions please?!!??
 
It sounds like you've given it some good thought and come up with some good ideas.

I would also strongly consider the idea that he hasn't been backed properly or certain stages may have been missed out during the backing process. This is really very common in cobs who are thought to have laid back temperament, as they don't tend to really go anywhere at first when they're confused or scared, people rush them and you end up with a horse that has missed vital stages in its education.....could be a reason for running back to a safe place?

If the lady only had him for 6 months before you I would possible think that he was doing this with her as well (I'm a bit of a cynic!!) and he has been passed on.

I agree with your thoughts that this doesn't sound like true bolting, but also that you need experienced help with him.. Horses are to be enjoyed and you can't be putting yourself in harms way.

Personally I would take him right back to basics, get an RI to show you how to long rein, first in the school then introduce some obstacles and once he has mastered this in the safety of the school you can take him on little long reining hacks, maybe even with a footsoldier at first to help his confidence?

Also, taking it back to square one will also help you understand him and his reactions, so you'll be able to start reading him and intervening when he gets silly.

Just as an example, there was a pony on the RI that I was on for years, he was sympathetically backed and was a total star most of the time....however although the YO was very experienced she was quite busy and simply forgot to introduce the pony to scary objects and hacking out. The yard was in East London so no fields either. This pony was always very nervous when off the yard, even when just going for a walk around the roads, he just couldn't cope with being out of his comfort zone! We never let anyone out on him off the leadrein as he would have just gone at the slightest spook. Not because he was badly treated or naughty....he just had a gap in his education that was never filled or addressed.
 
Agree with what bNp has already said (am a cynic too) Am not sure that bitting up will help, IMO there's no quick fix even a temp one for a horse that is doing this - sorry.

Back to basics and see how he goes, every horse we've ever had apart from Rocky who was an ex RDA angel from day one, has had all gadgets removed when they've come to us. Plain snaffles and no martigales..... but it's a personal choice
 
Oh dear poor you :frown:

I totally agree with Flipo'sMum and you might have seen in other threads that I had a similar experience when my horse went from napping to swinging round and galloping off with me.

That was in March and I was ready to sell him as my confidence was shot to pieces (along with my right ankle) but the YO worked him while I wasn't able to walk and she felt it was worth a try to keep him as long as I had weekly lessons again and hacked out on a RS horse while my RI rode Prince so that I could watch him and see how he was out hacking.

I learned to lunge and discovered the pleasures and advantages of proper groundwork... and we still use that lots now. This week we managed our first solo hack ever and I am a MUCH better rider for coming through it.. I also changed his bit and bridle to give me more brakes, just as Flipo'sMum says too.

BUT I agree with others who point out how dangerous a true bolter can be and you need to talk to someone in the know to help you assess and weigh up what can be achieved.. hacking out may have to wait a while but that's not a huge sacrifice to feel safe.

I really feel for you because I know exactly what it's like to be where you are now. In fact you'll be on my mind as I hack out tomorrow as I'm still doing a weekly hack with my RI (now on her own horse) so that she is back up for me.

Also, Tiga... what you said about the true nature of bolting really made me stop and think. I would have described what my horse did as bolting but actually it was clear he was napping as we passed the way to his field and then when he ran that is where he went... so in a funny way it has helped me to see it as running to safety as he was scared rather than being nasty. Logically, I know even my YO says horses try it on but I'm not sure they are capable of thinking that way. All behaviour is a communication and if they don't want to go off the yard then it is more likely that it's about relationship and trust to keep them safe than a desire to break our bones!!!

Sorry for long musing... I think I'm thinking aloud and really MUST go to bed now.

Keep us posted on your progress with your cob xx
 
Nurse9 I think that sounds like a pretty good plan, just make sure you take your time so you are both happy with where you are before you move up a level.

One thing (& I've never met her so feel free to totally ignore me here!) I would say is be careful about the sharer & keep a very close eye on things to begin with - I've found that there are an awful lot of people out there who either say they have experience that they don't or who deal with problems in a way you may not like! She may be wonderful, but make your own opinion rather than believe everything you're told.

I'm not sure I'd up the bitting, not when you said
I am now sure I just tensed up and pulled on his mouth which made him worse then faster tenser
. If you feel you must then look at sonething lke a pelham ridden in two reins because at least that way you can only use the curb action if you really need it, the rest of the time you can knot that rein & loosely tie it to a D ring on your saddle with a piece of thin string. Maybe consider fitting a hunting breastplate too, that way you've got something to grab if you start to panic & it won't slide up his neck like a neckstrap will if he puts his head down.

Shetlander bolters aren't nasty, they don't even necessarily lack trust in their riders. It's hard to explain but it's almost as though something throws a switch in their brains & everything except the need to get out away closes down, they literally forget that you're there & are unaware of their surroundings. For example no runaway would run you through a hedge, they'd either stop, swerve or jump it - a bolter will go through it because it just won't register. They aren't sane when they do it, you can't train it out of them because there's nothing there to train & so the only possible home for them, IMO, is with someone who's aware of the problem & is willing & capable of working around it.
 
newrider.com