Benefit behind..

Maybe to learn to be ok with just one stirrup in case you lose one? *shrug* I dunno really. never tried it myself on purpose anyway lol.
 
:confused: not sure?

to make sure your nbot actually using your stirrups to push up from?
and to help your balance?
 
I would say the same - so that if you lose a stirup you can cope but in reality if you lose a stirrup your going to be sitting not rising.

I guess if you were one sided it could maybe possible slightly help only in probably 0.001% of people though and in general I cant think of any good it could do! :confused:

I am intrigued - do you know why?? what made you ask??
 
I'm actually very good at doing rising trot with one stirrup (although I've never deliberately done it before!), i don't have to break in rythm to lose or retake the stirrup. I'm also one sided due to collapsing my right hip, something I am constantly working to correct, so being told by the RI yesterday (not my private ones, a BHS school one) to ditch one at a time wasn't appreciated.

Apparently it was to demonstrate how much we all rely on the stirrups. Well no sh*t sherlock, if they're there we're going to use them. I don't however, see the need for several circuits with only one stirrup? Point taken after three strides love. Then we were all told we were rising too high (with two stirrups), and told to lower our rises. Great effective teaching there. :rolleyes:

Was only doing the lessons with the team to try and increase jumping confidence (otherwise I'd just turn up for the comps!) but after two awfully dull flatwork (read, drill) lessons I'm fairly certain I don't want many more with this woman, jumping or not.

Oh, and whilst I'm ranting, how high does she want our hands? Does she honestly think I can get my lower leg further back when the stirrup bar is several inches in front of my pelvis? Did she think I could actually stay upright and do that at the same time? There was something else she was mentioning about myself and two others, that I specifically recall I was *not* doing, but I figure that as she was saying it with her back turned, she didn't mean me. ;)
 
Last edited:
once my stirups were to long and i lost one stirup in the rising trot in a lesson!
actully this monday!!! =] its not impossible (but then i am really clumsy) and i proved to my self i can keep my balane with out it =]
 
How strange, I can remember years ago, might have been in the era of putting paper under your knees to make sure you gripped with them :D, having to learn rising trot without any stirrups. Seem to remember it was rather tiring and totally pointless, bet I couldn't still do it :D
 
my riding instructor has had us do that sometimes.

This way if you loose a stirrup over a fence or in the middle of a competition or something you know you won't throw your horse and yourself off balance. You dont' want to be relying on your stirrups to be holding you in place. Its also helpful to get rid of one or two and then try to pick them back up without looking or shifting your position around too much. You shouldn't have to stop to pick up a stirrup.
 
my RI always does stuff like this with us. we have to sit and rise trot with none or one stirrup. if u hack out and loose stirrup then u wont have a problem getting it back and been unbalanced.i once did that over a jump (lol but it was an accident:D)
 
I would imagine that to be very damaging to the horse for that long...I hate riding lessons like that! When i used to have school lessons my good instructor got swapped for a really crap one so I quit! She had us trotting one 20m circle without stirrups and then back to the end of the ride which was in halt. Our old instructor would have had us jumping a 3ft fence on the circle and the rest of the ride cantering around!
 
The only time i've purposefully been told to and ridden with only one stirrup, is when we do lose and re-take the stirrup exercises in trot.
 
there is a reason for doing it - my instructor made my lesson do it once...
if only i could remember the full reason. i think so that you had to rise from the horse rather than forcing a rise (came into it somewhere). Intuitively most people would rather lose the inside stirrup as on a circle you are pushed to the outside (read into physics for reasons - centrafugal and centripetal forces all over the place ;)). the point of the exercise was so that you lost your outside stirrup making your inside stirrup pretty inaffective but meant that you sat/rode over the centre of the horse better as you physically made yourself sit more central as you didn't have the outside stirrup to counteract the falling out the outside door.
Thats what the reasoning is as far as i can remember - it did help to, it doesn't not make you ride squint unless you are just doing straight lines (and then it shouldn't make any difference).
 
newrider.com