Bates changable gullet saddle what do you think?

Amy-Lou

Showing enthusiast
Nov 24, 2005
366
0
0
35
Norfolk
Basically i am trying one it is 325 pounds and really nice condition.
Want good and bad things about these saddles.
Thanks x
 
snowandpolohack040-1.jpg


We have a bates gp and love it and will soon get a dressage one when we have the money!!!
 
i love them was going to get the vsd for my mac but settled for a thorowgood only cos they do high withered, my friends was really nice to ride it
 
I have a wintec aussie stock saddle and have just imported a Bates one in leather (that came yeasterday) Fit wise as Elly Koopman has said probably wont differ as they are the same company. I personally like the Wintec one more thatn the Bates - the leather on the saddle flaps feels really hard and not at all supple like some saddles like the Henri de rievel saddles etc.
 
I don't like it :o I found it really hard and uncomfy.
The saddler also warned us against the changable gullet system as it implies it can fit any horse if you change the gullet, which isn't true.
 
Friend had a bates and loved it. I quite liked riding in it on her horse, perfectly comfortable and the VSD which she had was nicely versatile.

We tried it on my fella when I was having saddle trouble; shape of tree was totally wrong for his shape back so no matter what gullet was put in, it just didn't fit.

Changable gullets are fine when the saddle generally fits the horse in all other dimensions, which may drop or build a little weight or muscle - in which case gullet change is great. But there are horses they don't fit at all, or that change shape too much for just a gullet change to be okay - the gullet to my understanding doesn't alter the whole width of the saddle, just the front end.

If you are trying, I would make sure you try with a saddler there before buying to confirm that the rest of saddle is right shape, and that gullet will offer the adaptability you need =]

Nice saddles though :D
 
I seem to be fairly lucky in that both bates & wintec fit both my boys very well, so had no problems in ordering another style that they dont sell in the UK from abroad.

I would say if the saddle fits in general and you like the saddle to ride in etc, then no worries about buying it at that price
 
I have a bates changeable gullet saddle and I hate it I paid £700 for it and I may aswell have bought a wooden board for my cob excuse the pun...I have changed the gullet from wide, x wide and xx wide and hasnt made a bit of difference to the fit as now it rises in the back. I think if a changeable gullet saddle fits the horse then they are great but if not it doesnt matter what gullet you put in it wont make a difference.
 
It bounced around on my pony's back :( don't think the cair suited him at all. he is quite 'bouncy' though and goes up and down more than forward!
 
Well we're trying it today with my YO who used to be a saddle fitter :D
I'm having the problem with it coming up at the back ie the gussets arent big enough. I tried a thorowgood on him perfect fit at front but the back was floating in mid air you could get 3" in between back and saddle!!
So going to try it and see but if its not right will be going back and will have to try find something else :(
 
When my saddle came up at the back, this was because the tree wasn't flat enough to match the shape of her back. Rearrangig flocking would only do so much but couldn;t disguise the fact that the saddle was never going to fot her.

Adjustable gullets are very useful in attaining correct saddle fit at the front but it is importable to get a saddle that generally fits your horse in all areas as changing the gullet would not be helpful on a saddle whose panels/tree isn't right.
 
When my saddle came up at the back, this was because the tree wasn't flat enough to match the shape of her back. Rearrangig flocking would only do so much but couldn;t disguise the fact that the saddle was never going to fot her.

Adjustable gullets are very useful in attaining correct saddle fit at the front but it is importable to get a saddle that generally fits your horse in all areas as changing the gullet would not be helpful on a saddle whose panels/tree isn't right.

Yeah i agree!
I have a horrible feeling this saddle may not fit at back ive treied loads and running out of options.
He's only 4 yo so his back is pretty immature in muscle development and whatever saddle i get now may not fot in 6 months so i dont want to spend the earth on one but i do want him to be comfy!
 
I have my fingers crossed that you'll find the right one.

I've been through the heartache of having a saddlefitter incorrectly fitting an adjustable gullet saddle and causing my mare to have a chronically stiff back requiring physio. Consequently saddle fitting is a subject dear to my heart. :o
 
Bates and Winect are not the same they are on different trees.
Ours was professionally fitted and fits polo and me well. Our Gullet is a medium which is the one which fits the tree best and we have cair but with the insterts. We do see a saddle fitter twice a year tho to check it.
 
ahh we had exactly the same problem with a thorowgood too :( we tried so many options with the thorowgood but there was a visible gap at the back even in walk without a rider. and the bates was similar.

Hope you have better luck with it!
 
Great news!!

Well i'm smiling like a chesshire cat which means the saddle is a real good fit and even my YO said that while he grows we should be ok with just that saddle, I'm so surprised because i tried a wintec on him and that had a gap between back of saddle and his back but this one is fine!! WOOP WOOP!!
 
see told u wintec and bates are on different trees!! ;) I love mine!

Yes they must be because my friends wintec 2000 was a no no!!
Going to have a nice ride in it tomo and my YO is giving me a lesson monday so she can see if it looks ok with me in it!
 
newrider.com