Barefoot trimmer over farrier? Why??!

I still remain unconvinced about the amount of time that EP's train to be able to give then enough training in nutrician and management as well as trimming. That's one heck of a broad based course in such a relatively short amount of time. I don't see how the course can be that detailed in its content?

Having said all that I am very impressed with the trimmer my yard mate has in. Nice bloke and the results of his efforts have been spectacular on her horses feet.

However I am very happy with my farrier who has the benefit of being extremely interested in barefoot as well as shoeing and will recomend both depending on the needs of the horses and owners. He's also into his research and writing and keen to push forward the role of the modern farrier. He recognises that with the increase in the leisure horse and move away from the working horse there are more and more cases where he sees little point in shoeing. It's my farriers open mindedness as well as his skills, training and numerous awards that makes him my choice.

I have one barefoot pony and one that's shod so it would be daft to change away from the farrier who does both well :)
 
I have used a trimmer and generally have afarrier. until today mine were all barefoot which the farrier promotes, but I decided that while Belle's hoof grows down following an abscess being cut out I'd put front shoes on her, then it will be back to barefoot. The trimmer I had was very good but my mare had not had anything done to her feet for 9 months (self trimming) and really the trimmer didn't do much to them, it has only been while Belle has been out of action for a month that her hooves have lost shape other than that they look after themselves fine and one of my ponies is much the same.
 
I've never come across a trimmer who did a 6 week course and then went out earning a living, all the ones I've met and used have spent an awful lot of time and money getting trained and accredited with one or other of the major trimming organisations.

The time spent training is a bit of a red herring, farriers spend an awful lot of time learning to work metal and last time I looked there wasn't actually anything in their syllabus specifically about trimming unshod horses or trimming for performance. It's a sad fact that a fair few farriers do see grass trims as far less important than the trims they do for shoeing and don't give them the same care and attention. If they did there would be no reason to switch to a trimmer at twice the price.

I still remain unconvinced about the amount of time that EP's train to be able to give then enough training in nutrician and management as well as trimming

They aren't meant to be nutritionists, all they do is advise on what generally works or helps in terms of diet, routine and infection control. That information is gained empirically, not in a classroom.

I think I can see this one from both sides, I've used (and use) excellent farriers and excellent trimmers, and also encountered the less good of both varieties. It's about being informed and finding the right individual for your requirements.
 
hmmm wheres wally? im sure she can answer this one , i mean she can tell us what farriers really do learn, but im sure is aint just how to put a shoe one or how to make one. i love picking the brains of my farrier.
 
Farriers do the equivalent of 23 weeks college time spread over 4 years during their on the job training - of course it isn't all metalwork!
 
i love my farrier would never have anyone else unles it was completly nessasary he spends ages making sure my boys feet are perfectly banlanced he must have spent about 40 mins with him tonite always give him a treat too :) tee loves him
 
My then farrier was great with my shod horse but used to tell me about advising people to boot badly behaved horses. My youngster is barefoot and is touchy about her feet and tbh I didn't want him around her.

My EAP was recommended to me and from the start was very impressive with how she handled my sometimes challenging young mare. She soon had her behaving well with no booting involved. She also explains what and why she was doing, checks her movement, gives me a photographic record and leaves me with a written report. I loved the whole process but unfortunately she's no longer able to come out to us anymore.

She's also spent years adding to her training, taking months out to go and do further practical and theoretical courses.
 
Last edited:
Reading through this thread, it is obvious that getting a good farrier/trimmer can be pot luck.My horse was originally shod with a well respected remedial farrier but when i moved yards he wouldn't travel so i had to find another.all the good ones books' were full so i went with a newly qualified one,trained by an excellant local farrier.i then went on to witness him hitting a horse in the stomach with a hammer, also subsequently heard he had split a horses nose with a pair of nippers.this 'proffessional' is still working! i heard of a very experienced EP and was keen to understand'the difference'.Well, that was 4 years ago and we have not looked back.Don't get me wrong, it has not been easy for us and not a cheaper option.I have put in alot of hard work and time helping my horse have the best feet he can possibly grow.
His behaviour has changed-he is an ex rescue deemed too dangerous to ride.
His diet has changed completely-horses weren't designed to eat the volumes of cereals and starch manufacturers would have you believe.
He no longer has white line/seedy toe-something he was allowed to suffer with,by farriers,the whole time he was shod.
The change i have witnessed has convinced me to change my proffession as a human nutritionist for the last 23 years to train with UKNHCP for the last 3 years(admittedly at my pace) but you can't realistically qualify for 2 years, training in every aspect through 7 modules and then mentoring with 6 qualified practitioners and 6 months case studies.
I don't know where the 6 weeks and you're qualified comes from? does anyone know?
Once you understand the workings of a hoof and the effect a shoe could have on some individuals it is a 'no brainer'
Obviously not all horses are best suited to going bare,some manage a lot better than others.
Surely the question is - Does my horse need shoes?
 
Sweeping statements like this should be backed up by information.

I have taken this from the EPAUK website about qualifying to become a trimmer.(http://www.eptrain.co.uk/)

(trimmed text from website)

Just to add to this, also from the aboive website:
* 23 days in the classroom
* 12 days practical training
* Approximately 200 hours home study
* Conducting 8 mentored case studies
* 4 days shadowing a senior EP


I wonder how many classroom days and practical sessions farriers have on hoof trimming in comparison.

I am still very much on the fence about farrier vs EP.
 
We have used our farrier for 15 years and wouldn't swap. He is ace and notices if they've eg. gained weight, lost weight. carries supplies of eg. antibac, I had one with a bit of seedy toe . Does donkeys brilliantly, even once did one of my goats ( Not happy about that, but did it anyway and free) He will liason with our vet if need be too. Will advise on feed, supplements etc. I haven't needed to investgate barefoot trimmers. Interesting though in case ours ever retires but with 9 ponies and 5 donkeys I couldn't ever do £40 a time unless I come into a fortune, which is very unlikely, and if I did , I would rather rescue more donkeys and old ponies from the auctions. Last month I went to an auction, there was a frantic little donkey tied to the railings, only a foal, it was raining heavily, we walked past and he brayed loudly. His owner appeared through a throng of people and shouted 'Oh shut up Zac, and untied him, only to tie him amongst ponies that bit him. That poor little thing had recognised his owner by sight amongst the crowds of people. Haunted me since. I wish I'd bought him home ,but a jack donkey colt would have cost me too much money in more electric fencing, unit, gelding , worming, blah blah blah I have gone waaay off topic except for the cost of another TRIM.... still wish I'd bought him :(
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Forgot to say that none of our are shod. Beth was until a couple of years ago, then I was ill and now she has old macs which we are just about to start using regularly.
 
when my dad trained, he worked as an apprentice for 7 years (he paid the person who was teaching him, not the other way round!) it took him a lifetime and several thousand (if not hundred thousand) feet to be the farrier he was. nobody (apart from trimmers in my experience) claim to know everything after a course- if they do i would get rid of them sharp because if they make a balls up they will never ask for anyone elses opinion and will cripple your horse before admitting defeat. or blame your previous "podiatrist" :rolleyes:

farriers see more than you think- they watch as you walk them up the yard, they see the wear of the feet, they feel stiffness in the rest of the body not only the legs. they understand the hoof structure, and can enhance the hoof using shoes (rather than just cover it up like boots IMO)

if they had to watch you trot it up i would actually be more worried!
 
Last edited:
I don't understand what you mean by enhancing a hoof by putting a shoe on it?
I want to see how comfortable,or otherwise, my horse is in his bare feet,rather than 'covering it up'with a shoe.
Boots are meant as a support and stimulus to growth when a horse is newly de shod to enable it to recover and stay comfortable.
As i said, sometimes you are lucky to land a good farrier, but if their books are full, you have to go with the next best until experience proves otherwise.I'm sure that is the same with some trimmers.
Begs the question how do you determine a 'good' farrier or trimmer.
In my experience, farriers are under a time limit, don't want to engage in a conversation about your horses feet, don't want to see or ask for a trot up.Don't want to give second opinions on each others work'because he's a friend'.Don't know about diet,nutrition or ways to help with hoof health.
Maybe i've been very unlucky.
My EP watched my horse move very closely, took an hour to trim, then extra time taking photos and advising on an exercise program to stimulate areas of growth.All for £40, great value i feel.
Also EP's and trimmers have to complete CPD-continued professional development yearly to keep them up to date with new research and training.
Correct me if i'm wrong, but this is something farriers don't have to subscibe to as yet.
I'd rather someone was dealing with my horse using the latest research and knowledge and not a long in the tooth farrier who qualified 15+ years ago and was totally unaware of anything new.
 
Personally and based on previous and current experiance, for barefoot, i'd far rather opt for an EP trim based on the wild hoof method, but for me, that is simply down to terrain where kept and the terrain I take the horses over when working, the hoof has to be able to cope.

When BoBo came to us he'd been trimmed by Wally 2 to 3 weeks previously, in a standard farriers trim. Now Wally & Francis had them all winter on the hill, hill terrain is vastly different from the fields we keep them in. Within 2 weeks of them getting here master BoBo was showing signs of flaring, and rapid growth on the outer wall, esp at the toe, as well as softening of the frog/bars/sole, our land doesnt have the drainage a hill does and the moist (but not wet) ground was of course allowing for rapid growth to happen, and after watching BoBo for a week it became very easy to see that even slightly long in the toe his gaits are starting to be that little bit off & him being a shet and prone to lami as a breed, i was not happy about the increased pressure being put on the pedal bone due to it being out of alignment via the long toe, the last thing he needs is foot stress to cause separation.

So I trimmed him up, low heel, good ground contact with frog/bars, rolled toe & rasped out flaring. Did him again last night (I do 4 weekly trims) and the difference in the structure of frog/bars is already apparent, we have far more callous happening, the outer wall needed nothing more than the roll touched up & there was no casting sole to remove and no rapid growth in the toe.

The general state of his feet when he arrived was really really good, its just that a farriers barefoot trim did not suit his new lifestyle & this quickly showed through in his hoof growth.
 
Just to add to this, also from the aboive website:
* 23 days in the classroom
* 12 days practical training
* Approximately 200 hours home study
* Conducting 8 mentored case studies
* 4 days shadowing a senior EP


I wonder how many classroom days and practical sessions farriers have on hoof trimming in comparison.

I am still very much on the fence about farrier vs EP.



Well a farrier generally trains full time for 4 years and 2 months rather than the 2 years part time of that EP course.

They do 23 weeks in the classroom rather than 23 days.

The rest of the 4 years 2 months full time course is spent on the job training rather than 12 days practical training and the 4 days shadowing a senior EP.


Having said all of that, where I think that the EP's are way ahead of farriers is that they are required to take ongoing training to keep abreast of modern developments.

Quite frankly I am appalled that farriers are not REQUIRED to do this :eek:

I personally think that the way forward for modern farriery is to make ongoing training and assessment mandatory.

My farrier is interested in research and development but unfortunately he isn't the norm for a farrier.

At the end of the day though I think that what really counts is results. There are bad examples of farriers (and I've come across a number of those) and bad exmples of EP's.

The EP working on my yard mates horse who has problem feet has been amazing. His allround approach to horse management combined with excellent trimming has got results. The farrier wasn't so insistent on the management whereas the EP was blunt and said that if the horse wasn't managed in line with reconmendations then the feet wouldn't improve which would reflect poorly on him and would refuse to continue! I like that commitment to welfare ad this is an approach that modern farriers would do well to adopt imho :)

I'd like to see modern farriery adopting some of the elements of the EP and I'd like to see EP's more interested in good shoeing where appropriate.
 
The EP working on my yard mates horse who has problem feet has been amazing. His allround approach to horse management combined with excellent trimming has got results. (Quote)



This is the bit that is so often missing with barefoot horses, esp those in transition, the owners just are not informed that a good barefoot horse is only achieved through correct management & the owner plays a very large part in that management.
 
This is the bit that is so often missing with barefoot horses, esp those in transition, the owners just are not informed that a good barefoot horse is only achieved through correct management & the owner plays a very large part in that management.

I have to agree with you.

I do think that with the increase in the amount of leisure horses as oposed to working horses that farriers are going to have to adapt to be able to offer the best care possible to the horse.

If the best elements of the farrier and the EP were combined as standard then the benefit to the welfare of horses would be emense :cool:
 
In my experience, farriers are under a time limit, don't want to engage in a conversation about your horses feet, don't want to see or ask for a trot up.

Some farriers are under time limits, though I'm told by my farrier that that often comes from working with large establishments where the owners want trims done in 5 minutes, not 30. They then carry that across to the rest of their work unfortunately. Or they have trained as an apprentice in that environment and think it is normal.

I am very lucky with my farrier. He spends around 30 minutes trimming each of my ponies and was there for 2 hours in total this week, much of which was spent discussing trims. He'll explain anything I want him to, show me exactly what he's doing and why and doesn't have heart failure if I tell him I'd like to do some maintenance between trims. In fact, he gives me instructions and a rasp :D

I don't know what training there is in the syllabus for trimming for farriers, but he has certainly studied all of the main barefoot trims and can therefore trim the best way for any specific horse. That could have been part of his degree though rather than his initial training, or could be something he's studied independently. He'd never ask me to trot a horse up unless he suspected a problem and he doesn't make a big deal out of assessing a horse, but he's been a farrier for years and can just do it while he's chatting. I don't notice him doing 90% of it, but that doesn't mean that he doesn't.

I could use a barefoot trimmer, but I don't see the point. It would cost me twice as much and get me someone nowhere near half as qualified. Though I do see why people would opt for a trimmer if they couldn't get hold of a decent farrier and it's nice to have that option to do so.
 
For us, in a nutshell;

Farrier could do no more, feet had continued to fall apart despite his best efforts. EP came out and within a few months a horse who was in pain just standing was field sound.

All his problems were created by previous bad farriery, they have been solved by subsequent excellent trimming.

Can't ask for better than that really can you? :cool:

There are always going to be good and bad of every profession out there. I can say that it's certainly true of my trimmer that she is 100% committed to professional development and continues to come up with new methods or different theories depending on what she's learnt recently. Having said that, I wouldn't hesitate to use a good farrier again if that's what my horses needed - but this is working for us.
 
newrider.com