i know the conversation has tended more towards bareback riding, but i just thought i'd mention that i actually *love* sitting to the trot without stirrups. it really gives me much more of a feel for the horse's motion, as well as makes me more aware of my position as a whole, and deepens my seat tremendously!
in fact, sitting to the trot without using stirrups was the *only* way i figured out how to use Heather's techniques for moving with the motion of the horse, which i thought was just about the coolest thing ever.
i agree that *learning* to sit to the trot for the first time without a saddle can be a harrowing experience at best, but the "feeling" of it, once you've ridden a bunch, helps amazingly. the "relaxing the stomach muscles" thing really does help, too... but maybe it's more helpful to think of relaxing your lower back? try this: take a deep breath, and while you let it out, think of your spine as a pile of children's building blocks. imagine one block falling into place on top of the next as you exhale, which will also place your shoulders a bit "back", and hopefully into alignment with your spine. visualize the blocks falling gradually into place, and when thy are stacked on top of one another to form your whole spine, think of them as a VERY flexible unit that can give and take with the motion of the horse's back.
i don't know if this seems too "hoky", but it helps me bring everything into place, and get more of a feel for things.
-cyn