Avoiding dominant horse in field

evie's mummy

New Member
Jul 13, 2006
273
0
0
Following on from todays thread about catching horses I wonder if you lovely lot could give me some help with my new gelding who is starting to get a bit too big for his boots and herding both me and my two mares. They are all happy and settled together but he does occasionally try to bully them, just generally herding them and showing them he's dominant. But now when i try to catch the smaller pony in particular,he is herding me off with scary faces and swinging his bum at her, when she makes a run for it he then chases her as far away from me as possible. She is not bad to catch but he is making her very nervous of me as she knows as soon as I appear he will start to bully her. He is also starting to guard the gate making it really awkward getting the other two in or out. When I am in the field poo picking etc he is always in your face, normally just being nosy but it is starting to feel too much and I'm getting nervous around him which is soooo not good for the whole situation. Help. How do I get him to just back off. Ps if anyone recommends Kelly Marks Perfect Manners I've ordered it:D Just need some advice before itcomes through!!! By the way he is an ID x 15.3 chunky monkey and 5 so really going through the 'kevin' years generally:eek:
 
Hi,
I use to have a similar problem with a gelding where i stabled my pony. He use to want to get all the attention and be brought in and it made me quite nervous going to get my pony out of the field. If the dominant gelding is catchable, catch him and tie him to the fence or bring him out the field and put him in a stable, that way he can't bother you or the mares.

When cleaning take a lungeing whip into the field with you and use it to make him back off when he approches you, tie a plastic bag to the end of it if he won't move with the crop alone. Use very over powering movements with him like he does you.

I have learnt to do this when i clean my field so the barror doesn't get kicked or knocked over. Although my horse isn't agressive with my while Im cleaning the field I like her to know that I have a job to do and she isn't welcome near me while I am busy. I only had to 'shoo' her off 3 or 4 times before she realised that she had t show some respect and stay back, although she does need a reminder every now and again by just throwing my arms in the air and go at her like she would me if she wanted to 'shoo' me off.

ETA : you can also put some carrots and apples as far from the gate as posible in several piles spread 20/25ft apart to keep the gelding distracted but it could mean putting the others horses at risk if he wants to guard his food!!

Hope this helps and tell me what the book is like, I was thinking about getting it because my mare is very bolshy when she is in season :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Why not try sending him away like Monty Roberts does ? make sure your hands are by your sides and open the up and shake them ...like a preditior (lion)...he's a flight animal so you'll be sending him away.

good work on ordering the book it'll really help out.

I think a lunge whip will only scare all the horses...and could cause a problem with leading two horses in.
 
I sympathise with your problem :rolleyes: .
I have similar issues with a 16.2hh hunter-type gelding kept in with my horses.
All the liveries have complained about him, but YO has yet to do anything about it (and there are no other local yards to move to so we're stuck).
I would certainly recommend Kelly Mark's book :) (some great stuff in it) - but I'd also comment that we've found the only thing which works at present is a lunge whip (not to hit him with - just wafted sharply at him).
We all hate using it (I'm very much of the "scaring is a last resort" school), but he charges at you full pelt and whilst I'm all for NHS, I don't have enough faith in it to stand there whilst a horse (who has already floored numerous liveries) gallops at me :rolleyes: .
We're all still trying to encourage him to back off in other ways (Kelly Marks' ways included), but I wouldn't go into the field without whip in hand ;) .
 
as an emergency measure for horses that wont take no for an answer (or where stomping, waving and yelling isnt enough), i find that hurling a small object in their direction can help, ahem. but obviously that depends on the horse - i wouldnt recommend that for a spooky one!!

Julia
x
 
I couldn't work out from your post whether he is chasing her away from you, or keeping you from taking her out of the field.

Horses are very motivated by resources, things that are important to them. Either he has taken a strong shine to the pony, and feels insecure when she's taken away from him,

or

You're the important resource - provider of food etc., and he doesn't want anybody getting between him and you.

It sounds a bit more like the second one, I think. Is he a bit funny around food etc. as well?
 
Capalldubh - you've hit the nail right on the proverbial head! :D He does have an issue with food, he is ghastly around feeding time, some of the faces and stable kicking you just wouldn't believe:eek: I don't think that he has taken a shine to her at all, he just seems to want to get in my face! Thinking about it this has all started 'cos I started given little 'un a treat to get her in as my youngest son spooked her by grabbing her headcollar and from then on she was wary of being caught. Obviously big 'un has cottoned on to that fact and smelt the treats a mile off , greedy so and so:D He is a right nibbler as he is only 5 so I have never given him treats at all.
Help how do I right this situation 'cos on the one hand I want to encourage little 'un but don't want to be stamped on by the big hairy beast!
To add to his situation there are three of them in the field and the two bigger ones (big hairy beast plus my other mare) are completely neurotic if left on their own for even a minute. The other one is the small pony (who is being bullied) she doesn't mind being on her own, but sometimes I have to catch her first if my sons are riding. Doing the gauntlet of getting them in, in any sort of order so that the neurotic ones are not stressed and the pony is not bullied is becoming unbearable. Put into the mix two children who I have to try to keep out of hairy beasts way it all becomes a nightmare:( HELP
 
How I solved this problem

When the herd at my yard was turned out this year, there were a few high spirits. My horse was very awkward to lead at the time - he sometimes didn't want to come away from his pals. When he did come to me, it was a nightmare when the others then tried to herd him away.

One day, the instigator of this herded him away then brought the entire herd down the track towards me. I had a headcollar and lead rope with me and a thick padded jacket on.

I started slapping the headcollar on my back, swinging from side to side as I backed towards the gate. Once I felt near enough to make a quick exit should it all go pear shaped, I stood still, fixed the leading horse straight in the eye, put my left hand in the air with the fingers wide, growled, slapped myself with the headcollar faster and harder and took a step towards the lead horse. He stopped dead!

The herd scattered in trot and the lead horse tried to sneak round the back. I did the same thing again and this time I kept moving towards him. When he backed down, I reinforced it by swinging the lead rope in his direction because it had a longer reach.

At no time did I make contact. Subsequent to this I was still able to catch this pest of a horse for the farrier without difficulty and I was also able to get my horse in without the interference of the pest.

The pest wasn't scared of me and if I invited him to me he came, but he also knew that if I looked him in the eye and gently shoo-ed him, he was to respect my space and stay away.
 
try having 3 or 4 piles of carrots or apples or a feed buckets with treats or abit of feed in them far away from the gate and far spread out. then go and catch your ''little 'un'' take a lunge whip in with you to defend yourself if the gelding comes towards you.

has he ever done this before? has he always been turned out with mares? he may be better if there was another gelding in the field or if he was put in a field with geldings so he can't be 'the stallion'. If he has always been turned out with just mares then he could just be a greedy guts, so the fact that he can munch away while the pony is being led out may come acroos as some sort of reward for leaving. Leaving you alone means he can have a treat, may work, may not depends how greedy he is and how much he wants the food!!
 
albilusitano said:
make sure your hands are by your sides and open the up and shake them ...like a preditior (lion)...he's a flight animal so you'll be sending him away.
This does work on most horses except mine of course :o i did it n jorji (my 2yr old who gives kisses) just gave me a kiss n looked at me funny :p the others walk past me lol !

but i did that sort of thing 2 a mare who used 2 share the feild with mine n had no manners etc n used to barge anything out the way to get out etc . it worked with her :)
 
Firstly, if he isn't your horse, make sure the owner is aware that you will be trying to stop him. She shouldn't mind, but prevents some embarassment when she catches you chasing her horse;)

He is only asserting his authority over your pony - you, like Capalldubh said, are a resource, be it for food or just plain attention. And he see's no reason that the small pony, who is lower in the pecking order than him, should get first dibs.

Feeding and distracting him will only mask the problem, and in the long term make it worse.

What you need to do is tell him that YOU are herd boss whilst in the field and YOU will make the decisions as to who, when and where you give your attentions to.

So when you go to catch the pony and the horse comes over, chase him off! Yell 'go away!!!!', jump up and down, flap your arms, whirl the lead rope and head collar above you head if needed, all directed at the horse, and literaly chase him off - run at him if nessesary. Have a set boundary and everytime he comes within it, chase him away. I guarantee he will run! And will then stand at a distance staring at you, probably snorting;) Stand glaring at him for a wee while than turn and march off. If he looks like he's going to come back again, repeat it.

You will probably find the pony will run too, to begin with, but if you direct it at the big horse said pony shouldn't be bothered and easily caught after horse has gone.

Even just one or two tantrums on your behalf will soon have him staying well clear.;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have a very dominant horse. He is 17hh and a HW IDx. The way i have sorted it out (same problem as you to begin with 2 horses, he would gard me so i could'nt get to the other horse) is routine. I always stroke Max (IDx) if he comes up to me (leave him alone if he dose not) but then i walk off, if he follows i drive him away a la Monty Roberts ( eyes on eyes, squared up used my rope to flick round me if he stil wont go) as soon as he moves away i can go and get the other one Tom without problems. I have aknowlaged Max ( petting) is there and our bond is still strong but i don't want him, so now he knows this is all ok and will leave me to it with Tom.

I never feed treats as this causes all kinds of problems.

Do you have someone who can catch up the youngster and just hold him in the feild when you catch pony? make a fuss of him until you are safe?

Your boy is young so with a bit if dominant body language yourself he will work it out. Sounds like a case of too big for his boots and not understanding what he is ment to do.

Good luck!
 
All the confrontational body language and sending away can work really well, but occasionally a horse will be so dominant that it will 'call your bluff' and be prepared to fight :eek: So the first time you try that I would ensure that you are near a fence, gate etc and can make a hasty retreat if it goes the other way! Then you can assess his body language. If he stops and backs off - even slightly, you should be on a winner. Personally, I wouldn't take food. Lets face it, they can eat a few carrots in record time and food can and often does increase aggression in horses. I also wouldn't 'make friends' with him in anyway. I like troublesome horses to be wary of me and keep their distance (so I always give them hard eye contact if they take a step toward me and hold it until they stop). Otherwise I find they come up to greet and still chase my horse away :rolleyes:

If behaving dominantly works, you should quickly get to the stage when you can just glare and twirl the end of the lead rope. I've found that quickly the one that I'm catching doesn't worry or move away from this as they know I'm there to be nice to them, and I'm lead mare and their ally.
 
He does have an issue with food, he is ghastly around feeding time, some of the faces and stable kicking you just wouldn't believe

I think if you sort this out, the field problems will sort themselves out! If you're getting the Kelly Marks book, I expect there will be useful advice. In the meantime, I'll have a think... Shannon has had food issues that got worse when she moved to a new field and I got very expert at never being between her and the other horses, because it doesn't occur to her that in chasing them away from precious me, it's not a good idea to knock me flat on the way!

I think horses can be a bit like people about food - if they've had food restricted at any stage, they get very protective about all their resources and act rather neurotic. I think you said he was a new arrival? He may also still be settling down, and feel a bit more insecure than usual, so the food issues may partly resolve themselves as you all get used to each other and set up routines. He's not deliberately being bad, it sounds more as if he's afraid you're going to go away and leave him all on his hungry ownsome in a relatively unfamiliar place :(

What worked with Shannon was making sure that she knew she had to wait (she definitely knows what that word means now!) until I was ready to give her the bucket. It is much easier to do this when not in the field!

It would probably be a good idea never to feed in the field where possible, so the gelding doesn't associate you in the field with food! Maybe try doing specific things with each horse in the field? I used to take a curry comb and give Shannon a light groom when she approached me with the "happy face", pricked ears etc., but ignored her when she gave me "the look" ;)

Anyway, hope things improve for you soon - let us know how you get on!
 
I have much the same problem, we have Bo (8yo) and Jess (3yo), both of whom want to be boss and Phoenix (30 something) our pony who just wants to stay out of the way :o Bo I can deal with, he is never agressive, just in your face but Jess can be nasty.

It got very bad last year, the peak was last spring, I bathed Jess and turned her out. I went back to swap headcollars to get Phoenix in. I went in the gate and all 3 were milling around, before I knew it Jess had spun through 160 degrees and I was pinned against the fence with both barrells coming my way. She hit me square in the stomach :( She would also chase me in the field (and the other 2) and kick out and was horrible around food.

For months I couldn't go in the field with her with out fear of her chasing me so I began working with her over the fence, I would call her over and fuss her, then when I was finnished I would say 'AWAY' and switch my body language to be more agressive, often she would 'argue' this but because there was a fence I could always stand my ground without fear of hurt. I then ventured into the field and did the same thing (with a lunge whip on standby) she was fine until sent away (she thought she was boss) and got nasty again so I upped the anti and brought the whip into play, as soon as she turned I stopped, that day it took 3 cycles of this before she finally wandered off. Since then she is fine, the away command is still practiced almost daily, just to be sure :D and she is a doll to catch still :D

With both Bo and Jess's food I taught a 'wait' command.
I would have Jess in the stable and come out with her tea and say 'wait' and then until she stood still and turned her head away a little she didn't get it, some days this could take an hour or more, with casual 'wait' to remind her throughout, but after the first few times she had it sussed, now when she wants anything, she stops and tips her nose to her shoulder to say 'please' :D and is very patient around food, as you walk in her stable now she backs off and tucks her nose automatically and waits like that until told she can have her feed.

Best of luck, I know its a really hard situation to deal with.
 
if they've had food restricted at any stage, they get very protective about all their resources and act rather neurotic. I think you said he was a new arrival? He may also still be settling down, and feel a bit more insecure than usual, so the food issues may partly resolve themselves as you all get used to each other and set up routines. He's not deliberately being bad, it sounds more as if he's afraid you're going to go away and leave him all on his hungry ownsome in a relatively unfamiliar place
exactly what we went thro' with our rescue cob, who was very aggressive around food to start with. With months of time and set routines, similar to Jessey too, he is a changed man. We kept to consistent rules, fed him on the yard with limits on behaviour, sent him away if dominant in the field, etc. Now he's a big cuddly baby (unless it's windy....).

I think it takes them time to realise that they ARE going to get food / grazing and they're NOT going to starve today.
 
I have a nightmare getting Oscar out of the field when all of the horses are around the gate wanting food - it gets much worse in winter as well, so I know how you feel. Luckily he is the dominant one, and is only agressive to the horses, not me, but I wouldn't like to get in the way in a scrap. I have resorted to actually catching one particular culprit/escape artist and tieing her to the fence before opening the gate. Does your dominant horse (like mine) always get to the gate first? If so, could you catch him over the gate before going in, tie him up a bit away, and then get some peace to catch the one you actually want?

Also rather than give the harder to catch one treats in the field, as long as you can catch her a couple of times without treats after perseverance, maybe you could get her used to getting her treat once out of the field - that was she still gets her reward without making the others jealous.
 
newrider.com