Asking opinions/advice?

Cortrasna

Grumpy old nag
Aug 5, 2009
9,950
3,481
113
Ireland
Just been having a little ponder about how useful the internet and, in particular, horsey forums are. Always easy to find a wealth of knowledge for any little problems that crop up, be it riding, veterinary or just day to day care.

But it has occurred to me that the opinions I most usually value are those of people who have experienced the same thing I might be querying, and their chosen method of dealing with or even the experience of a friend and how friend dealt with the issue.

One can very easily just 'google' almost any given subject within the horse world and come up with lengthy and detailed answers, some credible and some not so convincing.

Then of course there are the forum members (not aimed at this forum or anyone in particular!:unsure:) who reply with very obvious quotes from recognised experts that they have gleaned from google or some other search engine. Then they claim this as their own knowledge and encourage the original poster to follow 'their' theory and treatment, or whatever, even though they have absolutely no real idea if what they are suggesting is correct in any way!:redcarded:

I have to say that this side of the wonderful internet and shared knowledge does worry me slightly. Especially if you imagine how many first time owners might well be asking for help and opinions, and in their ignorance follow some crackpot theory that someone has googled and posted without any substance in accuracy, merely to boost their own online ego and try to bluff a greater knowledge than they actually have.

Just a little pondering and would like to know if anyone else has any opinions on 'internet opinions' as it were?:smile: And do you find it as easy as I think I do to spot the 'bluffers' and ignore their waffle, and take my answer from the opinions of people with similar experience to my query who give me their own first hand knowledge and opinions?
 
Great thread Cortransa!

I am similar to you, I post on here for other peoples experience, not google ability. I tend to ignore googled responses on here and other forums (you can generally spot a mile away) as anyone including myself can google all day long, what I am after is people having been through it. I try to be honest and if I dont know I would never pass off info I have found as my own knowledge.

I do find it easy to spot the bluffers after a few threads, then sometimes depending on the forum they sit on my ignore list.
 
Last edited:
Then of course there are the forum members... who reply with very obvious quotes from recognised experts that they have gleaned from google or some other search engine. Then they claim this as their own knowledge and encourage the original poster to follow 'their' theory and treatment, or whatever, even though they have absolutely no real idea if what they are suggesting is correct in any way!

Good God there are people who do this?! Why have I not thought of doing this myself sooner.... :yellowcarded:

I have to say I'd not noticed (sometimes I am completely blind to the obvious) so will keeping a beady eye out from now on! :nerd:
 
I often think the problem with forums is you get so many different opinions, it's really hard to know which way to go!

I thought that about LWTB when she started her horse hunt, my head would have been mush to have so many different opinions on the one horse! Too many cooks and all that.

As a novice, I unfortunately find it very difficult to 'spot the bluffers'. I think it's also very easy to see a collective of people online giving one opinion and thinking 'oh yes, they are right', and it's not till someone else (usually with years under their belt) comes along to give another point of view that you take a step back and think about it.

Personally I tend to look for certain posters for opinions that I really value now.
 
Its not an awful lot different to the "professionals" thread... If I hadn't had here, my pony would probably still be in a her narro-too-long-by-a-mile saddle, I probably would have listened the vet telling me I was a rubbish mum and didn't manage her sweet itch, rather than pushing for more, I wouldn't have rebooked at how I handle madam (that was the original reason I came back to NR after a couple of years away).... and I most certainly wouldn't have gotten through the last six months with pony. I felt so alone and helpless, with no one in real life who has had this the internet was a god send and after initially scaring me witless, made things a whole lot easier.
 
I think the horse world in particualr is full of different opinions on how to handle, ride, groom, feed, manage horses. Even the `professionals` differ. I think you should read everything you can and then go with what you feel is best for you and your horse.
I do this myself when training my horses. I know many people who will follow one particular `professional` avidly and think others are wrong or their methods won`t work. I say look at all methods and pick out of each the ones that work for you.
For anything medical, illnesses, injury, then I think the best advice is from someone who has experienced the same problem with their horse and overcome the problem successfully.
 
I don't think this forum is as bad as some for the 'google' quotes but people often take advice as correct because they see it on the internet whereas is someone on their yard said it it would be considered more objectively.

I am amused by threads which all run in one direction until someone disagrees then lots of others join in with the disagreement. Read or write with caution is always my view!!
 
I am amused by threads which all run in one direction until someone disagrees then lots of others join in with the disagreement. Read or write with caution is always my view!!

I think that is to do with people not wanting to go against the grain, but that is what we are here for, opinions and to be objective, members just need to be honest and say what they think, as long as its in a respectful manner, I think forums would be a richer place like that!
 
I'm always after the emotional and practical sides of my problems as I can find the 'facts' through Google.

I tend to be one of those who doesn't post to agree unless I have something extra to add. However I am always ready to disagree if my very limited experience merits it. I'm comfortable bring in a minority and despite knowing little I know enough to know there is more than one way to skin a cat.

I love the fact that everyone is like that. We can all have a range if opinions and not get into a cat fight and take it personally.
 
I'm always after the emotional and practical sides of my problems as I can find the 'facts' through Google.

I tend to be one of those who doesn't post to agree unless I have something extra to add. However I am always ready to disagree if my very limited experience merits it. I'm comfortable bring in a minority and despite knowing little I know enough to know there is more than one way to skin a cat.

I love the fact that everyone is like that. We can all have a range if opinions and not get into a cat fight and take it personally.

Thats more or less my sentiments JS - also agree that even if we do disagree - we are very polite at disagreeing on here aren't we? Quite refreshing IMO!:biggrin:
 
Cortrasna, I rarely google anything horsey, I just ask you! :tongue: You are the wikkipedia of all things horsey IMHO!

I was given some advice today that I just went I donnnnnnnnn't think so!! (in my mind of course, I did politely say I didn't need bute for the scratches on my horses bum!) :yellowcarded:
 
I use all three at different times....

Miss Whiplash (RI) who knows everything about everything.
Other RL horsey friends, although there's not so many readily available since we left the yard
Online - through forums and general googling. Actually, if someone chooses to google info and repost I'm not too worried - saves me the bother ;)
 
The internet i guess is no different from buying a lot of books on one subject. They will all tell you different things and books become out of date. You can also talk to a lot of people and you still get different answers.

I know it's not possible unless with have any science people on here, but for the people who tell you if she/he was my horse i would do so and so i'd love to have a carbon copy to see if their method worked, since i have been told some really odd things over the years!:bounce: I have also done some odd thngs over the years as well.

The people who google and copy and paste are only hurting themselves by being something they are not, and would be better to read up on the subjects they simply copy. Are these desperate to be liked people? If other posters can spot a mile away then they gain nothing by doing so.

As for the forum, when i lost Jack i couldn't have asked for more support, everyone was so kind. It really helped since those close to me didn't know what to do or to say.

We have discussions on here rather than the nasty out to get at posts. Everyone has something to offer whether you are a novice or lifetime owner. I don't see myself better or worse than anyone else
 
But it has occurred to me that the opinions I most usually value are those of people who have experienced the same thing I might be querying,

I love the wealth and range of experience available here, and that people want to offer support as well as advice.

Even though I do have some experience, I still learn sooo much, and even if I disagree, it makes me think about why I prefer another way, so I still learn. And opinions from those who have actually experienced the particular problem of course carry more weight than those who have just read about it, but there is no way I have read ALL horsey books out there (not for want of trying though:happy: )

I agree it could be a problem if a total newbie horse owner relied soley on internet forums for advice they could soon be in trouble, but I would really hope that someone in the real world would step into steer them in the right direction. And at least this forum is friendly enough that people can offer differing opinions without being shouted or laughed at. The reader then just has to decide which opinion they think makes most sense/fits their situation.
 
I became a WAY better horse owner because of the internet - I let my horse deteriorate with DJD of the coffin joint because I only had my trainer and my farrier to go with. Eventually my trainer spotted the issues with the remedial shoeing, thank goodness. I then became very educated about feeding, one of the first posters on the board I was on then to talk about low starch feeding, and now the whole board is on the case and I harldy post on feeding threads anymore as there are so many educated peeps on there :biggrin:. That is just one area where the web has helped with my horse management, and learning about new things that I have adopted.

I agree you have to pick and choose from opinions but I'd far prefer that than being in the wilderness as I was before. The learning curve can be much shorter when you have others who have been through it.

It is very interesting now, posting as a professional saddle fitter, looking at it from the other end of things. I can see how it is a minefield for the owner, expensive and terrifying, and I hope I can help in most instances, but of course some people are more open to this kind of advice than others, which is all fine :).
 
Where the actual riding and handling of horses is concerned, I think new riders tend to adopt what works.
The people on a Forum most likely to have effective solutions are those that have most experience and have time to share it on line. But they must also be able to put the horsey guidance into good, clear, jargon free English.

I discovered NR following an internet search for info on riding over 60 found a single thread on NR. There was no other hit. It has never occurred to me to repeat this search or that people on NR were lifting info from the internet.

However, it was also clear that the people who helped me frequently cited experts whom they themselves had heard teach - ranging from UK Olympic coaches to NH trainers - so there was no question of separating their original experience from that derived from outside sources.

We were a generation that used books and lectures - Harry Hobbes and others devised a syllabus for me to get to know NH, and it was always valid to cite "authorities " on NR.

I was really grateful to Kate recently for referring to an academic article available on the web. The web has become a wing of our new library?

Where NR is invaluable is that it provides an interface between the "authorities" and subjective and selective individual use of those authorities -
 
I'm still very much a novice - but I'm gettin better at spotting the bluffers!!! NR has helped me loads - sometimes when I've felt downright despairing with my horse problems!!!!!!!! My problems are mainly to do with handling issues - and I've found generally on here that you lot are brilliant at helping other people over-come stuff, for instance - leading problems etc. Guess what I'm saying is I trust you guys - wouldn't be so trusting on another forum though!
 
newrider.com