Another sad thread... sorry

bluntcrayon

New Member
Oct 21, 2009
1,172
0
0
Chelmsford
My sister shares a horse at a small DIY yard. One of the horses there has been on box rest for months, and this week the vet diagnosed some kind of problem with his hock joints. He now apparently needs 18 MONTHS box rest :eek: and may not even come sound after that.

Poor horse was clearly so stressed especially when we put out the other horses. He is boxwalking and becoming aggressive. At the moment the horse in the next stable is also in all the time but once he is better he'll be on his own during the day and then the others will be out 24/7 come spring.

To me it just seems a terrible way for that horse to live and in my mind the kindest thing would be to pts.

The worst thing was that he had no toys, no treat ball, no lickit etc etc... he did not even have any BEDDING and was on rubber matting with nothing absorbent on top. The stables are 'American barn' style so he has nothing to look out at.

The radio was on, as if that would keep him amused.

Can 18 months box rest ever be bearable for a horse (in the right conditions)? Or would you pts?
 
Depends on the individual horse really I suppose. 18 months is a very long time for a horse to be cooped up inside. I guess I'd try it and try and make things as interesting as possible and assess it from there.
 
I wouldn't keep mine on 18 months box rest, its not fair to the horse, especially with nothing to occupy it. It really is no quality of life.
 
Yes, it depends on the horse, I have three out five who would just not cope with that amount of box rest and I am afraid I would be looking at a very sad outcome. However, my Spanish mare is very stoic and accepts situations she is presented with so I think if she were to cope as time went on I would give it a try, the same for my other little girl Holly. She is very accepting and trusts what we ask of her so again I would give it a try.

Such a sad situation though, eighteen months is an incredibly long time for a horse in an enclosed space. Very difficult for all involved. :(
 
If my vet insisted on 18 months box rest I would be getting a second opinion.

I cant see what good that long in a stable would do the joints (all of them) and the only other horse I know of who was on box rest for that long ended up being PTS because his temperament became too unstable when he was finally let out

If it was mine it would be off to one of the veterinary hospitals.
 
I would also get a 2nd opinion...

If its the same outcome id probs PTS...its no good life being stuck in a stable for that long...think id go mad if i was made to stay in my bedroom for that long!!
 
I personally cant see what good 18 months box rest will do apart from send the poor horse doo lally. It would be utterly cruel for the poor thing. I would not even consider box rest for that long and would defo get a second opinion. God I feel guilty when Della has to stay in for a day coz of the weather!
 
18 months is an incredibly long time...

Having said that, my mare used to box walk in anticipation of being turned out each morning and would get pretty stressy if not turned out at a reasonable time, as deemed herself.

Last sept she fractured a splint bone as was put on 4 months minimum box rest and I was dreading it, but she has totally adjusted as it now very calm in the box. She normally has at least one toy to play with, big bedding to lie down in and to start with I made her stable as 'fun' and enticing as possible by hiding apples and carrots about the place etc. This dropped off a bit in the last couple of months as she settled down into a routine.

long and short, who knows, maybe the horse will adjust just fine... however, there is a huuuuuges difference between 4-6 months and 18 months! (and tomorrow may be the end of our eternal box rest as we attempt the first turn out, eek!)
 
20 years ago vets seldom recommended box rest but turning away to pasture for almost all injuries.

We had one horse who took so much flesh off her fetlock you could see the bones and tendons, obviously could not be turned out because of the risk of infection. Whilst in her stable however she had a constant companion next door (mare who hates being out anyway!!) and had twice daily grooming/playing/ stretching sessions with us. After 10 weeks she went out to pasture looking fantastic and with minimal problem.

I think you need to question the vets on the need for that much box rest, most hock joint problems usually are better served by gentle exercise to fuse the small bones. I cannot see the need for 18 months even for a break in a major bone
 
I'm sure some horses can cope with enclosure but it is just so sad, the owner of this horse apparently does not even come down to the yard (supposedly on DIY!) now he can't be ridden and as I said, he had no bedding when I was there. When I was down at Xmas the had shavings ran out and it looks like they have not been replaced since then. So poor horse has no bed whatsoever and is just skipped out as and when one of the other liveries is there. Owner's other horse is currently kept out 24/7 while others are stabled at night as she cannot be bothered to muck him out. Why do people have horses if they cannot be bothered to look after them :mad::mad::mad:
 
I would be getting a second opinion.

Anytime Tyler has been on box rest, the vet has said gentle exercise (i.e in hand grazing) is allowed as long as the horse is kept calm.

18 months is a long time for horse and owner.

I have such a big issue with people who are not able to provide their horses with the basic level of care, but at the same time I try to refrain from judgement until I know the individual circumstances.

Poor horse. Hope something gets sorted soon,

Jen
x
 
I'd also go for a second opinion at that treatment plan. Though realistically, with any of mine, I'd be more likely to turn them away than keep them on box rest. I've done box rest for 6 weeks for a chipped bone which seemed reasonable, but for a couple of tendon injuries and a ligament strain where the vet recommended box rest, I've agreed with them instead that I'll keep the horse out. Mine don't generally charge round for the sake of it so I can generally get away with full turnout as normal.

Where that isn't an option I'd rather go for turnout with a quiet companion in a restricted area. It's not exactly a normal life but is a far better option both physically and mentally than box rest imo. Box rest doesn't stop a horse moving or weightbearing on a particular joint anyway, so I work on the basis that as long as they're not going to be charging about, turnout to allow gentle pottering is the best bet and I can normally persuade the vets to agree!

I don't see that no bed is an issue though if the horse has rubber mats and doesn't mind peeing on them. Mine did his 6 weeks box rest on rubber mats with no bedding and had 2 winters in like that. Horses don't nest, they lie on the ground and rubber mats are an awful lot softer and warmer than fields!
 
Last edited:
i have to say i dont really like the bars in american barn style stables- i always think they must be depressing. can the owners not rig up a small outdoor pen near the stables, about the size of 4 boxes, and walk him out to it so he can spend an hour or so outside daily and get a change of scenery. poor boy doesnt seem to have much in the way of home comforts.
 
rose has been on box rest outdoors since she cut herself badly on new year's eve - we have walkways between the fields, so she is coralled in a bit of that with a haynet, so she can see what is happening, Molly and the donkeys are right next to her, and she is fine, it just stops her running around and damaging the leg further.

when she was on box rest for laminitis, six months, we put in deep litter, so she was well supported and she had the donkeys big stable which was 20x10 and we also fenced the concrete in front so she should come out onto that and stand, just to keep her occupied.

i don't see what 18 months would achieve. you could probably do it with a field shelter and an apron of hardcore or concrete, or all weather, so that the horse could be a bit more mobile. you could make an enclosure with sheep hurdles or electric fence, all things are possible with a bit of effort if the yard set up will allow it.
 
I really hope that the owner will do something. It seems to me that this person may not be the most proactive when it comes to caring for their horses and although all the options mentioned on here are perfectly viable, it may be unlikely that the owner will do any of them.

If the owner continues to be absent is it acceptable for others to do something for the horses benefit, in contradiction to what the vet said (presuming no second opinion is sought)?
I wouldn't want to see people get in trouble, but in the same token wouldn't want the horse to not be given a chance in maintaining its sanity while recouperating.
 
My mare has had a bad foot started as nail in foot, then abscess we thought clear and started turning her out again and it got dirt in and the vet had to cut a big hole in to clear he told me she had to stay in till hoof grew back, we tried turning out with a variety of boots all of which she got off even ate one of them to get it off. So since about Sept she has been in when the others are turned out in a morning she was stressing and pacing the stable there is nowhere she can go that is completely clear of mud I do let her round yard when we are mucking out and she is ridden when able to (weather and we up a big hill) also I take her onto the farmers garden area on a lead rope to graze when possible. She got so stressed one day when I let her in yard she attempted to jump the gate into the field which could have been disastorous I called the vet for advice and they have given her a mild sedative that lasts for 6 weeks it took a few days but now she is much calmer and hopefully she will be able to go out in late February the hole is nearly closed up now. I did let her have an hour in the field in the snow and she loved it but got very silly running round as she wasnt used to it.
 
Shame on the owner for not putting any bedding down! SAying that, it won't really help if the horse is cheesed off and not coping with box rest. 18 months does sound very dramatic and if it were one of ours then I would almost certainly be questioning it and getting second opinions. Sounds like the horse will go stir crazy, specially if nobody is doing anything to stimulate its interest during its time inside. The only way either of ours would cope is if they had each other close by and lots and lots of attention and time off OH and myself and even then it would be a fine line. Longest Joe spent was 3 solid months and that was bad enough. He has however done some box rest of 6 months - but he did get daily in hand walks and access for a roll. It does sound odd to me, but I'm no expert. Do hope something gets sorted tho - sounds very sad.
 
newrider.com