Am I being over sensitive?

I probably wouldn't take it further and go to her with the issue and how you feel about - vote with your feet. To be honest I semi agree with what someone else has already said - it was another family member that said the comments, not the rider herself.

I think in that situation I'd research and hire myself a new trainer/rider to school correctly and positively, also one that includes you in the routine and what they're doing - make a schooling plan etc. As your current rider has broken her ankle, then she can no longer forfill the service you are within your rights to look elsewhere.

I'd then just stick with the new person and IF the issue arises with the rider/YO/mother, THEN I'd explain my reasoning in a very 'matter of fact' way. What can they say? Not a lot really... They've then lost a client because of it and I'm sure will learn their lesson.
 
I think thats totally out of order and i wouldnt be happy about it either! :poop:

Im starting to really hate FB as it just seems like a chance to have a bitch about other people.

Ive been having problems with it recently,people from my yard making hurtfull comments to each other about me.
When will people grow up?? :stomp:

But yeah i would probs find a new trainer or have words with YO

x
 
I like to think of it this way if my sister had made a comment about my work manager on her facebook I would very likely be getting fired from my job.

It is unacceptable and I would be having a quiet word about it. If I was the YO I would want to know so that it didn't happen again.
 
Regardless of if it was the younger one who made the comment, the older one could have replied along the lines of she has no problem with the horse bucking. It would make me think they have been discussing the problem.

And? What's wrong with that?

Can anybody here honestly say that they believe they don't have the right to discuss their work with family and friends? I think you'll find everybody does!

I moan about my own horse as she's also not perfect and can be a challenge. This doesn't mean to say this isn't balanced by other factors and I love her to bits. I'm sure hubby finds that hard to understand when I announce that 'Joy tried to kill me today!' Of course she didn't, she was just challenging and I like her challenging moments for all my protestations otherwise. :wink:

Not everybody lives on facebook and reads all comments. I certainly don't and just use it for messaging so it's entirely possible that it's been missed.

I stand by my comment that this is a parenting issue. The rider herself didn't make that comment and we don't know that she even saw it. All we can glean is that the sister knows about the bucking. She could just have been a witness to the bucking and the rider may not even have discussed with her! There are a number of unsubstantiated assumptions being made and I feel sorry for that poor girl.

Even if it had been discussed, how does anyone know that means she doesn't enjoy the challenge and get a great deal of satisfaction when she gets the horse goes well to balance things out. Just because it's somebody elses opinion that the injury gets the rider out of riding a challenging horse it doesn't mean to say the rider herself shares that opinion.

At worst, at this stage, I would view this in exactly the same way I would if I told my hubby something in confidence and he let slip a passing comment in public which made my life awkward. There have been a lot of unsubstantiated negative assumptions made on this thread. A passing comment isn't the whole picture so I personally think being sensitive purely on a comment by a child really isn't called for.

Yes I'd be getting sensitive if, having actually spoken to the rider herself and the YO about the younger daughter's useage of facebook, I wasn't getting the responses I wanted when I raised the issue. I don't deny that it wouldn;t be upsetting to read that about Joy. However I think that perspective is needed.

This poor girl has done nothing wrong except not respond to a comment on facebook which she might not have even seen! :poop:



Her abilities as a trainer are another subject entirely and should be dealt with on their own merits. Either the horse is improving or it isn't. The comments on this thread about her and her state of mind, despite there be no evidence of this being her opinion, are far worse than what started the thread off in the first place! I think that she's the victim here. Put yourself in her position. :frown:


Yes it's not nice that not everyone loves our horses as much as we do (Joy cetainly isn't going to be everyones cup of tea) but this really has snowballed based on nothing the rider herself did.

This is this girls job we are rubbishing here. Surely it's wise to actually discuss it and get facts and then go from there? Hardly fair to be thinking about getting in another trainer based on the comment of a child on Facebook which is what many of the responses seem to be suggesting!!!

However wronged the OP feels by the throw away comment of a child, the rider in question has every right to feel 1000 times more agrieved if she were ever to see this thread :poop:
 
Last edited:
The joys of facebook eh???! I am not on there, so don't know what it is really like but sounds like it can cause an awful lot of hurt feelings and trouble. I wouldn't read too much into it mind, teenagers don't always realise they're being mean!!!!!
 
sorry you are having trouble nicola, how very unprofessional, i do no of a girl who schools horses and is very good if you want her number and will travel to you if you are allowed on your livery yard her name is Karen i will PM you if you want to xx
 
And? What's wrong with that?

Can anybody here honestly say that they believe they don't have the right to discuss their work with family and friends? I think you'll find everybody does!

I moan about my own horse as she's also not perfect and can be a challenge. This doesn't mean to say this isn't balanced by other factors and I love her to bits. I'm sure hubby finds that hard to understand when I announce that 'Joy tried to kill me today!' Of course she didn't, she was just challenging and I like her challenging moments for all my protestations otherwise. :wink:

Not everybody lives on facebook and reads all comments. I certainly don't and just use it for messaging so it's entirely possible that it's been missed.

I stand by my comment that this is a parenting issue. The rider herself didn't make that comment and we don't know that she even saw it. All we can glean is that the sister knows about the bucking. She could just have been a witness to the bucking and the rider may not even have discussed with her! There are a number of unsubstantiated assumptions being made and I feel sorry for that poor girl.

Even if it had been discussed, how does anyone know that means she doesn't enjoy the challenge and get a great deal of satisfaction when she gets the horse goes well to balance things out. Just because it's somebody elses opinion that the injury gets the rider out of riding a challenging horse it doesn't mean to say the rider herself shares that opinion.

At worst, at this stage, I would view this in exactly the same way I would if I told my hubby something in confidence and he let slip a passing comment in public which made my life awkward. There have been a lot of unsubstantiated negative assumptions made on this thread. A passing comment isn't the whole picture so I personally think being sensitive purely on a comment by a child really isn't called for.

Yes I'd be getting sensitive if, having actually spoken to the rider herself and the YO about the younger daughter's useage of facebook, I wasn't getting the responses I wanted when I raised the issue. I don't deny that it wouldn;t be upsetting to read that about Joy. However I think that perspective is needed.

This poor girl has done nothing wrong except not respond to a comment on facebook which she might not have even seen! :poop:



Her abilities as a trainer are another subject entirely and should be dealt with on their own merits. Either the horse is improving or it isn't. The comments on this thread about her and her state of mind, despite there be no evidence of this being her opinion, are far worse than what started the thread off in the first place! I think that she's the victim here. Put yourself in her position. :frown:


Yes it's not nice that not everyone loves our horses as much as we do (Joy cetainly isn't going to be everyones cup of tea) but this really has snowballed based on nothing the rider herself did.

This is this girls job we are rubbishing here. Surely it's wise to actually discuss it and get facts and then go from there? Hardly fair to be thinking about getting in another trainer based on the comment of a child on Facebook which is what many of the responses seem to be suggesting!!!

However wronged the OP feels by the throw away comment of a child, the rider in question has every right to feel 1000 times more agrieved if she were ever to see this thread :poop:

Excuse me ! at what point did I say they could or could not discuss what happens at their place of work.

I do not see that anyone has "rubbished" the girl or the job she is doing simply saying to the op that way in which the manner was adressed is not acceptable.

If you think it was acceptable then thats your point of view, no need to dam everyone elses. The business manner would be for the daughter regardless of which one to take any issues to the boss to be passed on the client.

In the long and short the op is a paying customer and it should not have been discussed good or bad on facebook. When you run a business its inappropriate !
 
In the long and short the op is a paying customer and it should not have been discussed good or bad on facebook. When you run a business its inappropriate !

Joyscarer was just saying that it was not the rider who discussed the horse, it was her sister. Her sister is not part of the buisness and while it was not an appropriate thing for her sister to write, it's not really fair to make assumptions about converstaions which may or may not have taken place between the rider and her family without first discussing it in person.
 
Excuse me ! at what point did I say they could or could not discuss what happens at their place of work.

I do not see that anyone has "rubbished" the girl or the job she is doing simply saying to the op that way in which the manner was adressed is not acceptable.

If you think it was acceptable then thats your point of view, no need to dam everyone elses. The business manner would be for the daughter regardless of which one to take any issues to the boss to be passed on the client.

In the long and short the op is a paying customer and it should not have been discussed good or bad on facebook. When you run a business its inappropriate !



Quite right, business matters shouldn't be discussed on Facebook. But it hasn't been 'discussed' on Facebook by the rider has it? There is no evidence that the mother or rider know this has happened so therefore when the term, 'unprofessional' enters into the equation that's bang out of order and may impact negatively on them. Serious stuff when you run a business.

There has been one comment made by a child, not the rider herself, and yet there are assumptions in this thread that the rider:

A) Has seen the comment
B) Agrees with it
C) Discussed it with the younger sister which lead to that comment
D)Is unprofessional
E) That the rider doesn't actually want to ride the horse in question


Now I'm sorry but that is pretty damn hard on that poor girl and yes I do deem it to be rubbishing her given there is no evidence for any of this. I find it deeply worrying that others can't see that either as they blatently guilty of doing what they have projected this young rider has done despite her not having written a word on the subject!

Yes I do damn everybody elses opinion who goes so far as to deem her guilty and suggest not using their services without even getting any evidence. I will not stand by and be a sheep when some poor girl has the worst thought of her and her integrity slammed.

As I have said, I do not feel the comment by the younger daughter is appropriate and therefore if the person concerned is that upset then speak to the YO. If after getting some real evidence and feedback on this the response is not to her liking at that stage decide the service is not right for you.

Skib has certainly raised some very interesting points that I too would want clarified if it were me in this situation. However, Skib has phrased them as questions that may need answers, not made assumptions as others have.

Innocent until proven guilty is what the justice system in this country is built on but that doesn't appear to be the values upheld on this thread. Questions need to be asked by the OP if that's what she wishes to do as none of the 5 points I have listed have a shread of evidence to back them up.

Once again I suggest that we put ourselves in the shoes of that poor rider and read through the opinions written about her. There is a difference between having doubts as Skib has quite rightly raised and actually making suggestions as to moving yards or ditching the rider when there are no facts as yet to merit this as she hasn't done anything wrong. That poor girl!
 
I'm going to be annoying now, is it a good time to use these..

:balanced:a:):sluggish::skull::skip: i never get to use them and i think the mood needs lightening here.

I think the YO needs to be approached to find out the facts, don't assume to presume (i think thats it. lol) Although i have been guilty of this in the past. It's is always easy to judge and not see things clearly when you are upset/angry.

Erm....*gets coat and leaves* :redface:
 
Anyway, on FB she made a comment that she had this accident usual comments off her friends, etc. Then her younger sister made a comment about oh well look on the bright side at least you don't have to ride (my horse) anymore.

Well frankly I was quite annoyed by this comment as it wasn't necessary, and if they had a problem providing the service then I should have been told about it.

I made a comment to say "thanks XXXXX", and left it at that thinking I'll have a quiet word at the weekend with YO.

Anyway, the younger sister then put on a comment, along the lines "sorry but sometimes your horse likes to buck and to be an ass".

I do not thought think it is unreasonable to assume that the rider did see the comments made by the younger sister given that she posted about having an injury to her friends who then responded. I would say it is probable because, having made the post, she would then recieve alerts directing her to the comments and being unable to ride, would be more likely to have time to actually read the posts.

The comments made by the sister indicate some knowledge of the riders negative attitude to riding the horse.

The rider does not contradict her sisters tackless remarks and the posts are left for all those with access to her FB to see.

The rider has not messaged the OP with a concillatory comment/email, or contacted the OP to recify the sisters' lack of good manners.

It is unprofessional and I do feel the OP has every right to be offended.

For these
 
I'm going to be annoying now, is it a good time to use these..

:balanced:a:):sluggish::skull::skip: i never get to use them and i think the mood needs lightening here.

:

Yeah, well said! lol, I was gonna post something weird and random to lighten this up, but you beat me to it with the icons....hehehehehehehe:wavespin::skip::skull::inlove::cloud9:a:)
 
Just to balance things out, I have never said the rider of my horse is not good at her job at all. She is a very talented rider.

Of course people are entitled to a personal opinion, I have never said otherwise, but when it comes down to business matters, these are probably best kept as personal, and my original point being, if there was a problem then I should have been consulted in the first instance.

If they no longer want to assist in the schooling of my horse then I should be told personally and not read comments on FB.

I will be talking to YO at the weekend and will politely mention these comments and ask if there is a problem and take it from there.

Such comments can and will lead to clients leaving livery yards, and at the same time 'bad mouthing' these places as well. It leaves a sour taste all round.

I have had a number of issues with this horse, she is far from perfect, and I suppose they might have got fed up with her, and I am sure as a family they have talked about us (and I don't mean in a nasty bitchy way). What they say behind closed doors is their opinon, but as soon as these opinions are placed on FB for all to see, they are no longer personal.

Maybe I am being over sensitive, but that's me!
 
I think if it had been the business' facebook page then it wouldn't have been appropriate and you wouldn't be overreacting so much but if its the rider's own personal page then this is the risk we run with fb and everything else, everyone has an opinion and a right to that opinion. No offence to your horse but from working in a call centre there are alot of advisors who come off the phone saying 'god that guy was a nightmare'. Their own opinion. If the customer happened to hear that comment outside of work (as long as no dpa was being breached) then I don't really think there can be a lot said about it.

I think this is the difficulty with business being mixed with friendship. Its really difficult to keep the two separate and times like these really test our relationships.
 
Just to balance things out, I have never said the rider of my horse is not good at her job at all. She is a very talented rider.

Of course people are entitled to a personal opinion, I have never said otherwise, but when it comes down to business matters, these are probably best kept as personal, and my original point being, if there was a problem then I should have been consulted in the first instance.

If they no longer want to assist in the schooling of my horse then I should be told personally and not read comments on FB.

I will be talking to YO at the weekend and will politely mention these comments and ask if there is a problem and take it from there.

Such comments can and will lead to clients leaving livery yards, and at the same time 'bad mouthing' these places as well. It leaves a sour taste all round.

I have had a number of issues with this horse, she is far from perfect, and I suppose they might have got fed up with her, and I am sure as a family they have talked about us (and I don't mean in a nasty bitchy way). What they say behind closed doors is their opinon, but as soon as these opinions are placed on FB for all to see, they are no longer personal.

Maybe I am being over sensitive, but that's me!

absolutely agree with you Nicola. That sounds like a sensible plan of approach.

I think it also highlights that kids need far more educating on the internet. It's very easy to think you are conversing with only 1 person when sat behind a laptop but you are not.

the only 'assumption' that actually crossed my mind when i read the OP was the unprofessional point of view. Had it been me, riding horses for money, i'd have deleted the comment. as has been said word spreads and if i'd seen comments made about my horse i wouldn't employ said person anymore. Behind closed doors is all well and good. On the internet, absolutely no.
 
Having taught a class of Yr 6's 10-11 years of age about internet safety. They are absolutely not aware of internet security, posts are put up for all to read. They were given a questionnaire, which was later shredded that asked them about parents jobs, times at work, when the house was unoccupied etc and they had no problems answering any of the questions. If i'd of been a burglar i'd of been a rich one. I have to agree that some comments made by youngsters are of a 'silly' nature but they probably only think that the 'friend' reads them when anyone can access the info that they put. Again i have to say that the teenager/child probably didn't know what they were putting but parents have obviously not said don't write anything about clients.
 
I think if it had been the business' facebook page then it wouldn't have been appropriate and you wouldn't be overreacting so much but if its the rider's own personal page then this is the risk we run with fb and everything else, everyone has an opinion and a right to that opinion. No offence to your horse but from working in a call centre there are alot of advisors who come off the phone saying 'god that guy was a nightmare'. Their own opinion. If the customer happened to hear that comment outside of work (as long as no dpa was being breached) then I don't really think there can be a lot said about it.

I think this is the difficulty with business being mixed with friendship. Its really difficult to keep the two separate and times like these really test our relationships.

I agree to an extent but in retail if you mention that you work for Dixons on FB (for example) and that a customer was being a pain in the ass, it is very likely that you will be fired even if you don't name anyone. My friend was fired from her retail job for making a comment very similar to that one. You have to be very careful on FB these days.
 
Just to balance things out, I have never said the rider of my horse is not good at her job at all. She is a very talented rider.

Of course people are entitled to a personal opinion, I have never said otherwise, but when it comes down to business matters, these are probably best kept as personal, and my original point being, if there was a problem then I should have been consulted in the first instance.

If they no longer want to assist in the schooling of my horse then I should be told personally and not read comments on FB.

I will be talking to YO at the weekend and will politely mention these comments and ask if there is a problem and take it from there.

Such comments can and will lead to clients leaving livery yards, and at the same time 'bad mouthing' these places as well. It leaves a sour taste all round.

I have had a number of issues with this horse, she is far from perfect, and I suppose they might have got fed up with her, and I am sure as a family they have talked about us (and I don't mean in a nasty bitchy way). What they say behind closed doors is their opinon, but as soon as these opinions are placed on FB for all to see, they are no longer personal.

Maybe I am being over sensitive, but that's me!


Spot on. I totally agree with you and your approach in this post and your opening post.

Of course there's always a possibility that at that stage you meet with unprofessionalism and an attitude you don't like when you talk to the YO and/or daughter. Don't get me wrong, I'd certainly be going ape at that stage should that be the case!!!! I hope not though and I hope things settle down for you soon.

Owning a less than perfect horse myself I know she's not everybodys cup of tea but I love her to bits and can't see why everyone else can't be as gushing about her as I am. I had a sharer for her once who must have found it hard to announce she wasn't go to continue sharing because of Joy's typical Welsh Dness. If negative thoughts about her had been written down publically then that certainly would be very hurtful and I'd be piddled off too but it's down to perspective. I wouldn't have been able to afford to buy Joy if she didn't have her quirks and was perfect. I'd find it less challenging and more boring too.
 
Last edited:
newrider.com