Am i alone??????

LAZY AND PROUD

helloooo
Mar 27, 2006
311
0
0
35
Coleford(ish)
hiya- please don't be nasty i already know how naff i sound.:o

right i have been sitting on a horse attempting to ride for a while now. i can walk trot canter etc and jump *with eyes shut:rolleyes: * 2.foot 6.
but heres the question- do any of you have MAJOR diaganol problems- im talking i've been riding for 7 yrs with numerous instructors and still can't get ir right. but i also genuinely find it comfyer*sp?:p * on the wrong diaganol- it actually now hurts to rise on the right one! so any advice (sympathy welcome:p ) or anyone else have the same problem or have got rid of the same problem?

thank you kindly for taking the time to read this.
lillie x x
 
:D no i get it wrong a lot of the time, but i can generally "feel" if I'm on the wrong one.
I've been riding about the same amount of time as you, but don't worry, I'm hopeless on canter leads and can't get a decent transition for the life of me!!!
Maybe try some lessons on a lunge, so you can concentrate on your diagonals?
 
i usually have a look down to check, took me a while to get the courage to do it in canter.

remember that it is harder for the horse on the wrong diagonal and they cant balance as easily. they will therefore not work as well.

how about practising sitting trot more often and then rising and trying to guess the diagonal without looking? that way you will feel more confident if you get it right and therefore want to do it more often?
 
hiya- please don't be nasty i already know how naff i sound.

but heres the question- do any of you have MAJOR diaganol problems- im talking i've been riding for 7 yrs with numerous instructors and still can't get ir right. but i also genuinely find it comfyer*sp? * on the wrong diaganol- it actually now hurts to rise on the right one! so any advice (sympathy welcome ) or anyone else have the same problem or have got rid of the same problem?

Hi! You don't sound naff at all!

Do you find that the problem is worse, better or the same when you are on a circle? Remember you rise when the horse's outside leg goes forwards. When you say you are more comfortable on the 'wrong' diagonal, do you mean that you are always more comfy rising when the inside leg goes forwards or are you always rising when for example, the right leg goes forwards no matter which rein you are on?

Do you have any problems with your hips? When you rise on the correct
diagonal on a circle, your hips take up a sort of 'uneven' position because usually your outside leg is behind the girth and your inside leg is on the girth. This might make your hips hurt.

Does any of this make sense? Maybe you could give an example of a trot exercise where it hurts to rise on the correct diagonal?

Good luck:)
 
It shouldn't actually physically hurt :o Is this on your own horse and tack or at a RS? If it's hurting you I woulld be concerned what it's doing to your horse.

I found getting the correct diagonal a nightmare until I had my own horse and could actually spend time getting to know the feel. I get it right most of the time now and only get it wrong when I'm concentrating on doing something else. I found at the RS you never actually got time to think about it or just play around with it which didn't help matters. I could always get it by glancing down but not by feel. Some saddles don't help either!
 
I've been riding ten years and I still get the wrong diagonal, but only on my own horse! He switches me, and it depends which direction we're going - if I'm going clockwise, he's fine, anti-clockwise and we have issues. I might start on the correct diagonal, but he'll do something (spook, take a canter stride, start peanut-rolling or chuck his head up and take a leap) to throw me onto the other!
I just have to keep saying in my head 'Rise and fall with the leg on the wall' and keep adjusting until I get it, so I'm not much help, but I totally sympathise:)
Hope you find a solution soon:p
 
Get nagged all the time about it and have been riding 6yrs. Tends to be more so when I'm jumping as I concentrate more on the horse's way of going
 
Remember this- "Rise and fall with the leg on the wall." You always rise up, out of the saddle when the outside leg extends forward. When it moves back, you are in the saddle.

"it actually now hurts to rise on the right one!"

It hurts to rise on the correct diagonal? And it doesn't hurt to rise on the incorrect diagonal? I don't understand. Where does it hurt you and how?

Best of luck.
 
hello

Hi All.
l am just working this out so PLEASE give me time.l am new to the site .
No your not a lone l get it wrong all the time so the way l am now l just
enjoy my self in stead of allways worrying about my legs. My horse is fine
and so am l. lt use to get to me as every one keep going on about my legs
and useing them right . l know l am NOT a good rider and NEVER will be . BUT
l LOVE my horse like one LOVES there and we have a good time .l do what l am able to and enjoy in stead of being down in the dumps because l can not
do it like the rest .l will stop now

From Mary
 
haha! i do! the shame! the shame! ive been riding for over 15 years and ... have i got them diagonals sussed? hell i have! mind you, theres always a 50:50 chance of being on the right one ... :D

Julia
x
 
if you cant feel it then try looking at the outside front leg.when that leg is going forward you should be up when it's going back you should be down.
 
I've been riding 9 years constantly (like almost every day) and I still can't do my diaganols. I jump, I hack etc etc, i'm quite confident on any horse. I feel the same as you alot of the time, i'm thinking, my god i've been riding for nine years and I till don't know half the things I should.

One day I'll get it...but at the moment I will remain clueless :)
 
your horse might have something to do with it feeling more comfy on the wrong diagonals. which diagonal you are supposed to be on depends on the way the horse is bent at the trot. the whole reasons for diagonals is to keep the horse balenced for a bend or turn (going up with the outside front leg helps them balence) try working on a large circle at the trot and when on the staight away have the horse bent slightly to the inside. Just keep practicing and you'll get it
 
Last edited:
i have a similar prob i am fine on my left rein diaganal but i can never get my right rein one so i practised riding in a strait line to the correct shoulder as if i was on my right rein, this helped for sum reason wether it was because of mussels which needed work or i needed to get correct balance on the leg i dont know but it's much better now
 
I get it wrong. After four years. Not only do I get it wrong but I get totally stressed.
With teachers who think it important I get really uptight.
So some kind teachers tell me to forget it and not bother about the diagonal and I get stressed by them too. I think they feel I am too stupid to bother with. Or if it really doesnt matter, why does it matter so much to some people?
I know dyslexic learners find it harder. if you are a person like me who muddles left and right or is left handed.

I do now know which is the correct leg to rise on, you rise as the outside front leg of your horse goes forward.
Buit if your co-ordination is bad (mine is) it is easier to learn to rise by thinking of the sit beat. Saying sit, sit sit to yourself rather than "rise". And then inserting your rise between.

I think RS pupils just need time alone with a horse to quietly work it out. That's what I did. But last week my RI said she wanted me to work on it particularly, and because I got worried, the horse stopped moving fluently and the whole thing fell apart.
So I decided to ignore her orders and the exercise, and just let the mare trot. You have to have a nice rhythm going in the trot. Once you have that you can check your rise and it wont be hard.

People say you can feel with your seat when to rise, but I cant. I feel the hind legs, but they dont cue me to rise.
Seat is a funny word in riding. Because it often means more than just your seat. Instead of feeling for the dip of the hind legs under you, I think it might be easier to sense which of your hips is sliding forward with the front legs of the horse? And rise to trot as your outside hip moves forward.

As for it hurting? That sounds bad. It isnt clear if you have a physical problem?
When you ride, do you have the weight even on both your legs? Does it always hurt your left leg? or always your outside leg?
My left hip hurts. But that is old age. And it hurts if I put a lot of weight on it, regardless of what the horse's legs are doing as I rise.

(Edited to clarify- as was written at night with many typos)
 
Last edited:
newrider.com