Always pushing my buttons!

How about teaching her "tricks" - but call them "tasks" so that some of the activists don't get on your back?

There are various means you can use to do this - clicker training is an obvious one. Employing your pony's mind may just be the key you need to start enjoying each other more - stranger things have happened!
 
'Trick' pony does appeal to me - it keeps both our minds busy and she'll get the exercise she needs and hopefully will help our bonding. I feel like I essentially have a very large pet 'dog'!!! This reassures me actually as we have had our dog since a wee pup and he is excellently behaved so we can do it! If I were to have excellent control of her on the ground I might at some point think about getting back on. However I still need to work with her whilst we wait for a new owner to come along so will think of what 'tasks' I want to teach her and not sure I can get her to sit up and beg!!!

I can see the benefits of clicker training but heard a trainer (in a book i have) talking about clicker trained horses being a bit 'soul-less' as it is all about performing for reward rather than working for their rider? Cant hurt though I guess. My other reluctance with clicker training is that I feel Rosie is a natural mugger - I gave her a chunk of my apple the other day and she followed everyone very closley round the field for the next half hour! With her being natuarlly pushy I dont think it would take long to develop a problem - does this happen with clicker training - that they are always expecting treats? I know in time the click becomes the 'reward' but just feel like treats would be setting a precedent???

Thats for the bit advice Wally - have been looking on 'tack' section and am totally overwhelmed - think that is one to get some experienced advice on - might get my RI to go through it with me.

I have thought about driving as Haffis are often used for this but 1) how would I go about getting her trained or finding out if she hasnt done it before (I think probably not) 2) where would i practise - only have 2 1/2 acres of field to play in. Kind of feel like i might pay out for training and equipment and then if i dont have anywhere to do the driving i am back to where i am now - field ornament!
 
that is what I, too, had understood about clicker training before I looked into it more deeply.

Clicker training for dogs is considerably different to clicker training for horses - although the basic principles of learning theory are applicable to all species, the actual process differs quite markedly between species, as far as I can tell.

I found clicker training absolutely ideal to advance the maturity, confidence, standard of behaviour and general education of a pony who - for a range of reasons - could have no turnout for a considerable period and who was, in addition, a stallion.

I did it using a couple of clicker books, a Circus Training book (gave me many useful ideas for tricks and activities) and various websites. The pony is now giving a great deal of pleasure to a loan owner as a thoroughly safe and competent ride-and-drive gelding who is 110% safe to handle under any foreseeable circumstance. Of course this was not the first pony I had trained, but it was the first I had used clicker with - in the search for something which would constructively occupy and develop his mind, and also control the degree of his physical activity.

I would have to write an essay if I were to ennumerate and describe the number of things he learnt to do on command/request. The more he learnt, the more quickly he learnt, and the more he seemed to want to learn! One thing to remember is that clicker training can be used VERY successfully to train horses NOT to mug - just as teaching a dog to bark on command is one of the best ways of stopping a dog from barking uncontrollably. Clcker training appears to be a useful method of UNtraining things, too - although I didn't have that problem.

I haven't really used clicker training since, I have not felt the need, but it is a very useful tool indeed, and I do urge you to look into it more deeply; even if you decide not to go ahead with clicker training, the learning theories are interesting.
 
Horses only ever work for two reasons - to avoid something unpleasant or to gain something pleasant. 90% of traditional training makes use of the first - the horse is trained that if they do what the rider wants, leg pressure, pressure in their mouths or the tap of a whip will stop. A lot of people forget this is how their horse learned to work, and believe the horse is working because it likes them, not because the alternative is unpleasant. Clicker training uses the second approach - the horse works to obtain a reward.

So in neither approach is the horse working "for you" :) You don't go to work every day because you like your boss, but because you get paid (or rather less rewardingly, because if you don't you won't be able to pay your bills ;)).

Clicker training is based on positive reinforcement (i.e. + sign - something is added to the situation that the horse wants) vs traditional training which is based on negative reinforcement (i.e. - sign, something the horse doesn't like is taken away). You can train exactly the same things using both methods, it's based on the science behind learning. The main difference is the context - with positive reinforcement, your horse learns to associate you, and riding and training, with a nice warm fuzzy feeling, and they will try to persuade you to work with them. With negative reinforcement, work becomes associated with avoiding something unpleasant, so the horse associates you with the "something unpleasant" - the horse will get on with you perfectly fine, but won't generally try to get you to train, ride or work with them (though they'll always be happy to see you if you bring their dinner).

Positive reinforcement training (clicker) is probably the best way to teach a horse to behave around food - most people are afraid to hand feed their horses in case they nip or mug. Clicker trained horses don't do either, even when food is available, because they've learned that's not the way to get food. I can prepare my horse's dinner in front of him, with him loose in the pen, and he will wait until I give the signal to eat :)

If you want to know more, I would suggest having a read of Alex Kurland's site (or Karen Pryor, if you're interested in training more than one species ;)). You can google both.
 
Also bought a rope halter last week and she seems much more attentive to me wearing it although I havent been out the field with it on and its on the way back that we have problems.

I know what you *mean* but the image of YOU wearing it was just too strong :D
 
LOL - cob size was way too big for me so had to reorder in pony size :rolleyes: Couldnt organise a tail without getting REALLY kinky! ROFL

Ooops ! Sometimes you just write stuff without rereading it as others would!
 
It all sounds quite hopeful, Anna - that's good.

Have you asked the people who've ridden her what they'd recommend?

As for groundwork, I tend to read books (I like Kelly Marks and Michael Peace - other people have different ideas) and websites and make up my own activities - to do with the horse moving its feet in directions that you ask, and listening.

I know what you mean about clicker training, and if Rosie's anything like Blondie, I'd be reluctant to try anything that involved treats with her. I'd also be reluctant to try anything involving small bits of equipment - I have trouble enough keeping track of hoofpicks - but people who've tried it say it's magic, so it might be worth having a go. (I think I'd be afraid of getting mugged in the early stages, before the message got through ..).

Sounds as if you're having fun with her anyway - that's great.
 
Haffis

Our bargycob is a haffi and so much of your thread reminds me of our early days with him. He keeps me constantly on my toes, throws down new challenges every second day, but is also incredibly rewarding and succesfully competing at RC level in show jumping and dressage, and doing pleasure rides. Do look at Angus's advice on leading (in bargeing horse - whits end thread) and I've also found Kelly Mark's perfect manners very useful. Totally agree with you that having one is an emotional rollercoaster
Oldbat
 
Hey Ive had a really good horsey day :-)

I was exceptionally brave today and went down and rode Cali, the share horse, all by my lonesome. I sat on him, with his owner around, 2 weeks ago and managed 5 mins of terrified slow walk round the field. It was the first time I had been on a horse in around 6 weeks since the fall were I hurt my shoulder and I was terrifed. It was only a few months ago Id been on 3 hour solo hacks on this same horse and was always looking for a place to canter!

Anyway, all we did today was a 20 min slow walk round the field, stop starting, circling etc and he was so good I think I might venture down the track a little way next time. In fact check me out - pic on board! He's such a lovely steady neddy.

I am really pleased with myself for doing this today - wanted to trot but just didnt feel able to, mainly because field uneven and I am terrified of falling as walk / trot transition was were all my problems started, but Ill get there.

So then I went to see the lovely Rosie who was fab again 2 days in row - she is just really chilled and cuddly at the monent. The rope halter and work around this has made a definate improvement. I walked her up the track and back (was a bit nervous but knew the gate at the end was closed so even if she got away she was unlikely to go hurtling into the busy road) and on the way back (when she is normally naughty) she plodded along with her head down skimming the grass ( I dont let her munch when walking ). We free schooled again and she got a bit OTT and wouldnt stop cantering for 5 mins but got her to stop and come to me so that was cool. If only I could translate the on the groung chilledness to ridden chilledness!

So after being out virtually the whole day, came home filthy, smelly and knackered but definately happy.
 

Attachments

  • DSC00435.jpg
    DSC00435.jpg
    27.9 KB · Views: 10
  • DSC00354.jpg
    DSC00354.jpg
    29.7 KB · Views: 18
Hey Ive had a really good horsey day :-)

I was exceptionally brave today and went down and rode Cali, the share horse, all by my lonesome. I sat on him, with his owner around, 2 weeks ago and managed 5 mins of terrified slow walk round the field. It was the first time I had been on a horse in around 6 weeks since the fall were I hurt my shoulder and I was terrifed. It was only a few months ago Id been on 3 hour solo hacks on this same horse and was always looking for a place to canter!

Anyway, all we did today was a 20 min slow walk round the field, stop starting, circling etc and he was so good I think I might venture down the track a little way next time. In fact check me out - pic on board! He's such a lovely steady neddy.

I am really pleased with myself for doing this today - wanted to trot but just didnt feel able to, mainly because field uneven and I am terrified of falling as walk / trot transition was were all my problems started, but Ill get there.

/QUOTE]

That's great, Anna - "all we did" was really a huge step - and it sounds as if you're getting on really well with Rosie.
 
I did speak to the riding school and the farm rider about what they thought I should do. Bev (farm rider) said she would not be suitable for the only bit of interest I have had - a lady in Oxfordshire who wants her for a second pony for her daughter - YO loves Haffis so is keen for her to get her! I would not be happy selling her to someone in their early teens - I think she is way too much??? RS have suggested I get her 2 weeks of intensive schooling and then try and sell her at the end of that? Farm manager suggests I sell her to any dealer that'll have her and cut my losses!!!! A couple of people have suggested I think about getting her retrained for driving?
In the meantime Ill just keep on with what Im doing :)
 
This is starting to feel suspiciously like a personal blog!
I have had such a lovely day today, and am thinking 'oh bugger' I think Im really falling for her! (which isnt necessarily a good thing if she need to be sold!) but as always despite the history, she really does tug at my heartstrings.
Today I sat in the field (and then the shelter as it rained!) and read a book (horsey book of course!) and she was so funny and sweet I was close to tears. I have been thoroughly slobbered, tasted, my book is filthy (sneezed on among other things!) and she shared half a packet of crisps! For a good half hour Rosie stood in front of me dozing while I played with her muzzle (apart from book eating as a 'carry on mum' hint, if I stopped) and it was just so chilled... I put out a tarp (just as a desensitising thing - didnt do anything other than lay it on the ground) and she has been picking it up and chucking it around and generally making me laugh.
We did a little walk as I wanted to see what the neighbours up the track were doing and everything was lovely. She may be an 'expensive pet' but you could pay the same money to go abroad for just two weeks and then still not be as happy and relaxed as I felt today :)
I think it has been an interesting experience for us both - she had the chance to come and 'check me out' in her own terms and it was great that she kept coming back to me when she had the whole field to wander and for me an exercise in trust - sat in a chair at chest level to half a ton of horse and no where to go makes you really question how much you trust them and if you are confident in your ability to get them to move if needed! Thankfully I sat and chilled!
Emotional rollercoaster not over yet!
 
Hmmm.... OK, here's a new plan: you keep her, do ground-work with her, play with her, then one day when you're both all relaxed, maybe you could start riding her again ... Maybe the YO or someone else would ride her for you from time to time, just to see how she's getting on. Or maybe you could find a sharer for her - an experienced rider who likes a challenge.

I agree, she wouldn't do for most young teenagers, although I have known a couple who were more competent and experienced than many adults. Someone like that, looking for a project horse, might be ideal.

But you don't have to sell her; if you'd rather have her to play with than a different horse to ride, that's your choice! And you might find that if you took her out for plenty of walks (did you say what she's like in hand?), she'd feel much calmer about the whole thing ....
 
I think we have been here before Linda..... head says i should sell her, heart says persevere. I have to confess to having looked at her a couple of times this week and thought - I wish I could ride bareback and just hop on! OK so Im not going to, but this is a mental leap of faith, the fact that I kind of want to! (Might think about a bareback lesson on a sensible horse though!)

I think for the sake of my sanity, pride and marriage (just kidding) I will leave her up for sale but as I have no one interested and am not being very 'pro-active' about it I may as well see what I can do with her in the meantime.

Am considering getting 'parelli' on her - I know they have lots of opposition, are pricey etc but it is something very structured that I can follow and work with and whether i like it or not I am a very goal/task orientated person - I need to know where i am heading or just feel lost. I have been looking at lots of NH stuff generally and do not think I would follow it 'to the letter' but would be good to have something clear cut so we arent both confused.

I think in the past I have dithered between NH (softer & horse friendly) and the 'make em do it or else' approach and i think a lack of confidence in my own skills and frustration has had me veering from one to another - I am finding a very quiet, gentle approach, lack of crops and harsh demands have given me a very different horse - one I like much better. I think Ive been converted! I have been looking for a local instructor that will be able to help me with the groundwork to riding transition in a NH style. There aren't many people locally - the one I like the sound of seems to specialise in groundwork only - I will email and have a chat with her. Lots of info available on groundwork but not much on that next step. I know this is all in the future, but am back to wanting that goal. Will investigate parelli level 1 before i spend my cash. The DVDs will keep me going for weeks if not months for the same price as 2 1/2 weeks professional reschooling (which i am not sure would be enough) and would only benefit her with a view to resale with no real benfit to me as a horseperson. See, am selling to myself already!

Some of this seems like going round in circles, and a new idea every other day, but the reality is, however I like it, that I have a horse I dont want to ride and cannot sell and if I dont continue to work with her she will just steadily get worse. And.... sitting in a field with horsey breath in your face and a grin from ear to ear is kinda priceless :)
 
The worst most challenging horses make the best, most trustworthy friends in the end, when they decide to give to you.

Keep doing what you are doing, sitting in the field, going for walks, grooming, chilling on the stable floor, best bonding ever. I spend hours just chilling out with my boy. We spend hours walking in hand all over the place. Just two friends out for a stroll together.

When I do venture on him outside, I make sure it is in the heat of summer and he has had a good gallop/play with someone, and when he is really tired he is just right for me.

I spend hours on him in the stable as well, when I was re-backing him, would spend time standing up and down on the mounting block. Slowly putting a leg over but without full weight, getting down again, when all the tail swishing and ears/faces stopped, then I slowly ventured to sliding on. Just sat there doing nothing while he ate his hay and walked round the stable to the water and door etc, could easily slide off if need be. It took around 3 months for him to decide the saddle and rider were in fact safe and not going to hurt him!!!! Some days if he was in a bad mood I would just skip it and wait for the next day.

We can now sit on him while he walks and grazes calmly in the field, and we jump off regularly and get back on, so if he moves too fast and we fall off, it is not a big thing for him as he is used to us getting on and off every 3-5 mins. He now, another 6 months later, accepts a rider on him in the field, although we are not actively telliing him to do much except to put his head up and walk a little, or trot, and then eat again. He now says 'This is OK, this is not scary' Job well done. We are still avoiding arguing with him, that will have to come in the summer when he doesnt want to be told what to do!

You are already hooked, you wont sell her!

Congratulations on your move to NH.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
First time putting photos on, hope this works. First day with the camera too, bad pics, but will improve. Very wet muddy pony today.

Busby
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Awww, he's looks like a cutie.
How deceiving can looks be though eh?
Rosie generally looks like butter wouldnt melt in her mouth! While I am usually wondering if there are devil horns under that forelock!
 
On another post someone said their pony had a trick up its sleeve, I said mine has a whole rucksack of tricks up his sleeve lol
 
newrider.com