Always pushing my buttons!

I am seriously considering selling her! <snip>
Confidence is at absolute rock bottom and really not sure what to do :confused:

I've been there - scared by a horse, and the only way I could get my confidence back was to do lots and lots of reallyi assertive groundwork with that horse, and at the same time to have lessons at a riding school, on their horses. The story doesn't have a very happy ending because the mare died before I could ever ride her again (she was quite old), but I did get my confidence back, enough to buy the baby Haffi that I've posted about on another thread.

I think it takes a long, long time to get confidence back, and it's very hard to do it on the horse that made you lose it. I agree, your working livery sounds a bad deal; could you find a sharer to ride your mare, or a loaner, so that you could ride other horses and get brave and strong enough to deal with her? Or, if that sounds mad, maybe you should think about selling her, and then buying another horse later?

From everything I've read, Haffis really need confident, experienced riders. I've just realised what a short time you've been riding; you are very brave, but I honestly think you're a bit over-horsed. I know reading the posts on here, it sometimes seems as if owning a horse is nothing but a struggle -- it doesn't have to be!
 
Haffi mares

If it was me - this is what I would do...

Ask my RI to ride her once or twice a week and help knock her into shape for me. In the meantime i would:
- persevere with her groundwork
- lunge her
- get some lessons on some more reliable horses - not plods - still something challenging just not as much.

After a month where your mare now has the benefit of being schooled by a confident professional and should have had some of her behaviour corrected - start having lessons on her again and take it from there.

I have asked for help with my mare and i'm glad I have - that's what professionals are there for. Its also a lot easier to learn when your not having to rectify behaviour every second.

Good luck
 
I've been following this thread with interest because I felt the same with my mare - after having her about two months her behaviour was such that I was scared to get on and was on the verge of selling her to the nearest dealer. I didn't and we are getting on pretty well now (touch wood), but it hasn't been easy. A lot will depend on how attached you have become to her. I echo those who have urged you to keep working with a good RI, and maybe something else to consider is loaning her out? My daughter's loan pony came our way because he'd been mis-sold as a beginner's pony and turned out not to be but his owner couldn't bear to sell him on because he's so nice, and now we have him while her daughter has loaned, in turn, a real beginner's pony and maybe in a couple of years she will, after all, be able to ride him when my daughter outgrows him. That might be an option for you - loan your mare to someone who will get a lot out of her while you re-build your confidence and gain more experience on either RS horses, or maybe you could find a loan or a part-loan/share horse to ride in the meantime?

I really hope it works out for you. don't do anything hasty that you might live to regret!
 
I have really appreciated all the support and good advice everyone. I
spent most of last night in tears over the whole thing and then not
being able to sleep cos my shoulder hurt :-( BUT...it seems that
virtually everyone with a new horse spends quite a lot of time
saying 'oh s%^t what have i done!' so Im not going to stress about it
and accept its just a part of being a new horse owner - summer is
coming and everything looks better in the sunshine :-)

However its a new day and I have to make a decision somewhere.
I didnt work with Rosie today - short of time and enthusiasm - just fed
and poo picked and hopefully will be feeling better tomorrow - shoulder
still stiff and sore but its one of those ones you know you have to
keep working or it will just seize up so am trying to ignore it and
just carry on as usual.

Another option I was offered by my riding school was a schooling
livery - they have her for two weeks or so and an experienced rider
would ride her whenever they have five minutes to get her back into
work mode. While this seems like a good idea 1. I dont think I will be
ready to get back to riding her in 2 weeks (confidence at zero)and 2.
although I havent spoken to them about the details I am pretty sure i
cannot afford this option. This is a short term offer as they only have
a stable free until it is filled so may miss out if I dont accept but
dont think this is the solution for us at present.

I think what I am going to do is concentrate on ground work with Rosie
in a kind but assertive way and really get her doing what I want her to
with minimal effort on my part - I might even think of showing in hand
but thats a whole other area to worry about one day. She leans on me
when I walk her (although this is getting much better) and doesnt stop
until she is within 6 feet of me when I lunge etc so have plenty to be
getting on with and there are lots of places we havent explored on a
lead rein yet. I am not going to ride Rosie for a while, but may get an
experienced rider to come over a couple of times a week to keep her at
it - a friend of my daughters is a good rider (has ridden Rosie once
when we first got her) and doesnt have a horse currently so am sure she
would be willing. If not people always want free rides!

I am going to go back to my riding school and continue to have lessons
on their horses. This may be the long way round but is a safer way
round - I get all the benefits of owning a horse, she gets worked, we
build our bond and I get to be a better rider. Win - win all round I
hope.

I have always been really good about looking where I am going but dont
do this on Rosie - I found I was looking at her to see if she was about
to be naughty and think this is probably one of the problems - my
neighbours daughter pointed out that when i fell in the field last week
she thought i was leaning forward - back to school i go!

Phew - I am so pleased I have managed to come to some sort of a
decision - I think I am too hard on myself (and Rosie) and set my
sights too high - Rosie may not be 'green' but I definately am - I
am 'over horsed' at the moment but it wont always be like that - haffis
are very long lived i hear so I have about 20 years to get good enough
for her!

The support and helpful comments have really helped me to get some
perspective and realise its not all my fault but whilst i have work to
do there is light at the end of the tunnel.

Anna
 
I'm SO glad you have arrived at what seems like a very do-able plan for you and Rosie. From your posts, it sounds as though there's nothing bad about her at all and you're just having the initial teething and getting-to-know-each-other problems that, as you rightly say, so many of us have(!!). Good for you for sticking with it, giving it some real thought, and not rushing into a hurried decision that wouldn't necessarily have been the best, long-term, for either of you. With your positive attitude I am sure that, given a couple of years, you'll be looking back on all this and smiling to yourself at how horrible it all seemed in the beginning. Good luck, and please keep us posted!
 
Just when I think I have it all straight in my head something else crops up.

I went to the riding school to say thanks but no thanks to their offer of schooling livery and book a lesson on one of their horses but 2 instructors (who have both taught me) and the YO are all pushing me to go with the schooling. Rosie would live in, I would go up twice a day to 'do' and would provide bedding etc (to keep down costs etc - am OK with mucking out for two weeks as only 10 mins up the road but chose live out grazing for a reason!) and whenever there was a suitable lesson I would join in - essentially having 5/6 lessons a week for 2 weeks to get us really going. In my head this seems like a really good (but very expensive) idea - however I really think it is too much pressure they way I feel.

I am generally a confident person but am just a bit low when it comes to anything equine at the mo. Eventually I will get fed up or bored and hop on her back with a 'right you little madam, Ive had enough of you messing me around and you're going to blooming well behave yourself' attitude - which is exactly what she needs! But I cant say when that day will be for me - might be tomorrow, or next week or next month or longer - who knows? I am confident it will come - I just dont know when.

Then the 'sensible' bit of my head says for goodness sake shut up whinging, grit your teeth, do the two weeks and then you'll be right as rain.' (but might not be - worse case senario I get soo fed up and scared I sell Rosie and never ride again - have you ever been in a job that one day you decided you hated and then couldnt give notice fast enough and nothing would ever make you change your mind? well I suspect i could, with a little push, get like that about riding)

Im very confused as to what to do for the best :confused: Have to give the yard an answer tomorrow. EEk!
 
Youv'e already answered yourself, you feel you want a rest from riding and work with her at home, if you feel thats what you want to do don't let others push you to do too much too soon. As you said there is no hurry, enjoy yourself with your horse and let things come in their own time.
 
Youv'e already answered yourself, you feel you want a rest from riding and work with her at home, if you feel thats what you want to do don't let others push you to do too much too soon. As you said there is no hurry, enjoy yourself with your horse and let things come in their own time.

I agree with this.

Your pony will not come to any harm if she is turned away for a while, or just kept in a routine with no work, until you feel the desire to start doing something again.

If and when you decide to return to riding you should treat her like an unbroken youngster and, with help and advice, start her on a program of groundwork so that you can build a relationship of mutual trust and cooperation.

Then when you decide to ride her again you will both have developed a different attitude.

:)
 
After weeks of being up, down and all over the place I have made the final decision. As fond of her as I am, Rosie is just too strong willed for me - I dont feel able to ride her, the walking in hand has gone back down the pan and she is back to rearing again, I cant get her attention for a minute if there is grass in sight and its just not working. I have tried really hard but just cant stay positive.

In the right hands she is a fabulous horse, gorgeous, willing, smart, responsive, fun, exciting, up for a challenge, lovely paces, loves to jump etc etc - with me shes bored and getting fat and lazy whilst Im constantly stressed out - not fair on either of us :(

Today I finally decided she's not for me and I have put her up for sale in the hope that she will find the right home for her and I will find the right horse for me. I bought her at least in part on impulse (I had seen several horses but none were right) - she was so lovely, there was others coming to see her, I didnt want to lose her and after a 15 minute panic in a car park up the road I put down my money. Silly cow but it seemed like the right thing at the time. I am sad but to be honest very relieved. Ironically I spent the whole day rebuilding her shelter as it blew down in a storm a little while ago!

I have contacted the owner of the horse I used to share and she has agreed I can ride him for a few weeks until the right one comes along so I can rebuild some confidence - he's 22 and really has been there done it all - I would trust him in a busy road with an artic coming - I dont even trust Rosie in the field!

It has certainly been a massive learning curve, to be honest a huge mistake, but I know so much more about what I am looking for in reality rather than what I thought I wanted! I wont make the same mistake twice and have a much more knowledgable home to offer no. 2!
 
Pm me and I'll send you an in depth explanation on how to walk her properly in hand.

That will set a standard for the rest of your work with her and, when you see the difference in her behaviour, you may start to love her again.
 
Its going to be an essay!

Well, today has been interesting. Firstly - here is the ad that I bought Rosie from -
Description
Very pretty 14.1 Haflinger Mare 7 years old. Hacks out on the Forest alone or in company. Loves to jump. Snaffle mouth. Quick to learn but needs further schooling. Good in traffic. Easy to catch box shoe etc. Lives out. Would suit teenager/lady rider (perfect mother/daughter share) Only for sale due to overcommitment - she is just not being worked enough. £1750 ono


Verbally - is she suitable for a novice? Yes definately.

Heres my ad -
Description
Easy to catch/groom/load/farrier etc. Excellent weight carrier. Breed info visit http://www.haflingerhorses.com/ or http://www.haflingersgb.com/ German passport.

Lives out 24/7 at Parley + very good doer.

In experienced confident hands she is a fabulous horse with great paces, very forward going at the slightest prompt. Previous owner advises she loves to jump.
However, she recognises Im a novice and takes the mickey and I dont have the experience or confidence to deal with it. Snaffle mouthed. Very reluctant sale but is totally wasted and I need a plod! So …not a novice ride! When my instructor rode her I was very jealous as in the right hands she is the ‘perfect’ horse and gorgeous with it. Does need a firm hand generally – can be very cheeky but will do anything for a carrot!

She’s very smart and loves to keep busy – needs more schooling but could go on to great things. I am keen to see her go to the right home – do not want her to be passed hand to hand.

I believe she was at a riding school and has been a ‘happy hacker’ since September. Ridden regularly through Burley and onto forest etc but not done much last couple months. 5star vetting last September – passed for hacking.

Incls Wintec adjustable gullet synthetic saddle - less than 1year old and 2 rugs (good makes, no rips)

If you have any questions or are interested, replies by email preferred

£2250 ono.


Would you recognise this as the same horse? I dont think I would!

My farm manager recommended a lady to ride Rosie for viewings. When I met her today realised she showed me a horse before I bought Rosie and straight away when saw me ride him said, no he's not for you - so feel some trust is there. Obviously very experienced horse woman and had 'great fun' riding Rosie. Rosie tried everything she could to get this woman off and nearly succeeded! She stalled, bucked, ran into the fence, wouldnt turn corners, keep her nose out as far as possible, skipped, turned and generally was very naughty - took her about 10 - 15 mins to give in! Eventually settled down and cantered/trotted for a good 15/20 minutes - the most work Rosie has done in a while! Was really interesting to watch as on top it is very hard to tell whats actually happening (too busy thinking oh s&*t here we go again!)

Anyway heres what she said;

1. Do not get back on that horse!
2. Her bit isnt strong enough - single link snaffle with cheek bits - she has no respect for it and absolutely no steering.
3. Supposedly professionally fitted saddle doesnt fit - it slides forward and when it does Rosie seizes the opportunity and drops her shoulder and its no wonder I came off - Ive only been riding a year and she has loads of experience and nearly fell off!
4. Shes very cheeky and needs to get back to some serious schooling.
5. First horse??? She's probably not even a second horse!
6. She is going to ride her every day this week so Rosie regains some manners and realises that the school is where she works not messes around. Hopefully by the weekend she will be being better behaved and will do what she is meant to for viewings/ trial rides.
7. Quote "This is great fun I havent ridden a horse like this in ages!" I was worried just watching her!

I didnt know wether to laugh or cry - it was funny seeing Rosie trying her hardest to be a little madam and not getting away with it. She wasnt mean to her but absolutely was not having it. And then when Rosie started cantering around all floaty she looked so beautiful I just thought if only I could do that.... only for a second though! I feel much reassured that its not me - she was never suitable for me and is a very strong, cheeky girl who needs a experienced rider. Neither of our faults - just mis matched.

Phew, fingers crossed she finds the right home and then I can start looking for my horsey soul mate :)
 
Pm me and I'll send you an in depth explanation on how to walk her properly in hand.

That will set a standard for the rest of your work with her and, when you see the difference in her behaviour, you may start to love her again.

Couldn't you post it in here, AengusOg - then we could all learn from it?
 
Went and sat on my horse share today and might have some lessons on him - lady that owns the yard nearby was really friendly and said you could rent their school for £5 a session - no real set time limit or could pay £12 per month for unlimited use - fantastic deal! Three months ago I was hacking out on this boy alone and cantering and all sorts - today I sat on and did a very slow walk around the field and thats all I felt able to do but at least I got on!

Did not have a good Rosie day today :-( Bev rode her for me again today then phoned the farm manager for a second opinion, she had a look and a little ride and the general opinion was horrific! They said she should never have been sold to me - it was without doubt the worst horse she had ever ridden and she wouldnt take her on if I was giving her away! LOL. They said she is completely wooden mouthed, extremely stroppy and even after a 10 minute canter did not give in but at least she stopped bucking! I have to laugh about it or Id cry! She reared (hard) as soon as she got on and was an absolute cow the whole time. In her (minor) defense I had put her on Magic calmer when i first got her and ran out last week - didnt bother as I wasnt riding her anyway but it suddenly twigged this might be why she is quite so horrendous. Will go get some tomorrow and double dose! They said I should do anything I can to get shot of her as no one in their right mind would buy her and even if it went to a dealer at half what I paid for her, then so be it! Oh bugger!

I have amended the ad - removed the saddle as it doesnt fit well and realised my no rips rug wasnt strictly true! Dropped the price accordingly.

I phoned my riding school as they really seemed to like Rosie (on the calmer!) and she will chat with her partner over the weekend so fingers crossed. If I go back for lessons Im not having Rosie! LOL!
 
oh goodness:eek:

I am sure that as upsetting as this must be there has to be a huge sigh of relief for you.
Definately sounds like you are making the right decision by moving on here.

I am sorry that it didnt work out with Rosie for you.

When you get your next horse it would be great if this nice lady could come with you for a look.
 
Its a bit strange really as in the first few weeks we had her we were walking and trotting around the field, I had a lesson on her in the corall and that went great - not sure what went wrong all of a sudden. Defo think coming off the calmer was a bad idea :rolleyes:
 
Part of me is so torn, I just can see Rosie going from home to unhappy home because no one will take the time, make the effort and spend the money to train her properly. i am wondering about sending her to be reschooled – cant say for sure about how long it would take but just chatted with a local trainer who charges £150 a week whcih incls full livery and average time around 4 weeks.

£600 is a lot of money to invest on top of the £2000 already paid (not including keep, shoes etc) but as she is, I will be lucky to get half what I paid. The trainer reckoned she could be worth twice what I paid if properly schooled but then she would say that wouldnt she!

Thats quite a gamble to consider - cut my losses and get possibly considerably less than I paid or invest a bit more, possibly still get less than I originally paid or maybe have a great school horse that goes to the fabulous competing home she should and I recoup all my outlay. The softie in me wants a happy ending for Rosie despite her being a bugger!

I just wish I could make a decision and stick to it!
 
Oh what a rollercoaster! Considering you only started riding last year, it seems you have done amazingly well, but unfortunately it has been a real struggle. I really wish you luck with whatever decision you have to make. It must be so hard.
xx
 
Just to put a complete spanner in the works I went over tonight and lunged her etc and to put her rugs back on etc and she was an absolute poppet - really sweet. I was half way through lunging her and my friend came over to chat so I stopped her and went over to the fence - she put her head down and snuck over behind me but seemed reluctant to come all the way. I gave her a chunk of apple (amazing what you can find in your pockets!) and she came and stood next to me while I nattered. I have been working with whoa when lunging (she just wasnt getting it) and somehow have got into the habit of putting my hand up when saying whoa - well today several times when I did, she wandered over, stopped and sniffed my hand - how pleased was I :D
I havent been feeding her the last few days as shes getting so fat and theres so much grass, but gave her a scoop of hi fi just to put her calmer in - i may be imagining things but she seemed to have difficulty with it - had to encourage her to finish it. Not sure if she has a teeth problem or she didnt like the high ratio of calmer to chaff.
This is the problem actually - I am always making excuses for her! Sometimes I think she is a total stroppy cow and other times worry that shes just a frightened little girl.
So... am going away next week - hubby will take off rugs, put them back on and feed but otherwise Rosie will have 5 days off. When I get back she will have had the calmer for a whole week, I will have had some time to think and will get her teeth and back checked just to be sure.
I think she is the kind of horse thats responds to a gentle approach but can take advantage of that also - its a fine line! The kids where never this much trouble or perhaps I just dont remember!
 
Mmmmm - gosh!

Sounds like you were definately sold or you definately bought the wrong horse!

Poor girl.

Can I ask - if the saddle didn't fit why was she ridden every day that week?

Or did I read that incorrectly?

She seems like a very unhappy girlie and mares are definately tougher work than geldings - in my very limited experience:D

Good luck with her!

You have a choice - spend 6 months getting her schooled - read all you can about groundwork and gaining respect exercises - maybe do a few courses/clinics.

Definately back off from the riding. Teeth, Back and tack? I havn't seen that mentioned.

I hope your shoulder and your confidence are healing well.

:)

dee
 
My saddle didnt fit - when pushed hard it rides up her withers. The rider used her own saddle - she checked it and it seemed OK. Rosie was supposed to be ridden everyday but by Thursday she said your wasting your money as she is not getting any better and even if she behaved with her that didnt mean that she wouldnt start all over again if someone came to try her :(

I am always making excuses for Rosies bad behaviour! Now I am thinking that the rider was what I call 'old school' ie the horse does as it told or else! and Rosie responds really well to a quite gentle approach. Trouble is she takes the mickey with it also!

I often get the impression that she is frightened but am I right in thinking that they wont munch when scared? She can be ears up, 'spooking' and being silly and genuinely seems frightened but the second the rope is long enough she'll munch at the nearest long bit of grass - doesnt seem to add up??? Now I am worried that the whole riding expereince this week has really put her off - whilst being ridden she spent the whole time with her head stuck over the fence away from the centre - she did that again today when i lunged her - both ways round she looked away and over the fence like she was frightened???
I am going to get her teeth and back checked - I think there may be a problem with her teeth (more excuses????) If she is sold it would be unfair to sell her with physical problems. However also want to satisfy myself that she isnt behaving like this with good reason. Hope the calmer kicks in quickly!
She was so sweet today I am back to wanting to keep her for a pet! She has me well and truly twisted round her little hoof!
 
newrider.com