Advice please ...

*JD*

New Member
May 20, 2009
104
0
0
Scotland
I was looking for a horse ... found one that, on paper, was perfect. Went to see her and fell for her. Now ... she has since injured herself in the field. The owner is currently in the process of getting me a copy of the vets report. She is slightly lame. Vet has recommended 3 months off in a smallish field then bring back into work slowly. This woman needs her gone in the next 2 months which will be nearing the end of the 3 months rest period and has offered her to me with all her stuff for longterm loan with view to buy although initially it was suppose to be a sale.

She has remedial shoeing done now and will have to have this for a good few months still for support.

Advice needed .. should I take her on and bring her back into work not knowing if she is going to come 100% sound or should I walk away now.

Any advice appreciate. And sorry its quite long!

Any experiances of this?
 
Reply

If I was you I would walk away as you want a horse that is going to be 100% fit and worth the money that you are paying for it. Thats what I would do if I was you, unless you love the horse too much not to take it on?
 
I think I'd probably try and speak to the vet involved and have an honest chat with them. At the end of the day, the horse could injure themselves the first day you get them. However, I'd want an assurance from the owner that you could return her/him if the injury did turn out to be long term or had long term implications once the horse was back in work. Would they agree to this? I don't even know if that would really be a viable option. Whatever you decide, good luck.

(Apologies for possible useless post :o)
 
I think I'd probably try and speak to the vet involved and have an honest chat with them. At the end of the day, the horse could injure themselves the first day you get them. However, I'd want an assurance from the owner that you could return her/him if the injury did turn out to be long term or had long term implications once the horse was back in work. Would they agree to this? I don't even know if that would really be a viable option. Whatever you decide, good luck.

(Apologies for possible useless post :o)

Yeah I will be speaking to the vet. The woman has been incredibly honest with me, unlike many horses I have been to view before!

Yeah she is leaving the country for good so wouldnt be asking for the horse back even if she did turn out to come fine after being brought back into work.

I really need to see the vet report to get it in my head what is the more sensible decision to make.

Thanks! :D ~I shall be posting again as soon as I get the report.
 
Perhaps you could take the horse on loan during the recovery period and see how it goes. It it doesn't work, the current owner has to make the decision about what to do - if it works, then you can buy as agreed.
Just a thought. (?)
 
I guess it all depends on what it say ... and I thought I may have got the vet report today but no such luck, well not yet anyway!
 
Perhaps you could take the horse on loan during the recovery period and see how it goes. It it doesn't work, the current owner has to make the decision about what to do - if it works, then you can buy as agreed.
Just a thought. (?)

That was the way it was probably going to go ... it would be from just before she was able to be brought back into work but I'm not sure how it would go if she wasn't suitable ... she wouldn't be in the country and wouldn't be coming back to this country! Maybe a family member of the owner would take the mare on.

As I said, no point in dreaming of what may or may not happen until the vet reports comes through. But I am so impatient!
 
I suppose it depends on what you want her for. and if she isnt 100% will it matter - If you want to do a lot then maybe it is worth a second thought

Well that is true. It would just be hacking, schooling and a jumping session say once every one/two weeks. So no competitions or "hard work". It may not be necessary for her to be 100% but just need to wait and find out.
 
What does your 'gut' feeling tell you to do?

Because... if after getting all the professional opinion (vets etc) you can, and the lady who is loaning to you has been upfront with you (she says you can have on extended loan for did you say as long as needed? or until riding fit?), then you still have to make the decision.

Most times I have trusted my gut instincts and they have rarely let me down, on the occasions I have made 'rational' decisions made purely on finance or logic I can honestly say I have not been entirely happy with the decision for one reason or another when I looked back.

An old friends saying is "You pay's your money - you takes your choice" or in your situation you don't hand any money over just yet!:D but its still your choice at the end of the day.

Love to hear what you eventually decide.

E...
 
It really depends on the nature and severity of the injury. For something that requires remedial shoeing it suggests a problem with the hoof or internal hoof structures and the vet's advice to restrict turnout and use remedial showing doesn't say to me that the horse will definitely recover to full fitness, which is a huge risk you would be taking on.

Have you had the vet's report yet?
 
What does your 'gut' feeling tell you to do?

Because... if after getting all the professional opinion (vets etc) you can, and the lady who is loaning to you has been upfront with you (she says you can have on extended loan for did you say as long as needed? or until riding fit?), then you still have to make the decision.

Most times I have trusted my gut instincts and they have rarely let me down, on the occasions I have made 'rational' decisions made purely on finance or logic I can honestly say I have not been entirely happy with the decision for one reason or another when I looked back.

An old friends saying is "You pay's your money - you takes your choice" or in your situation you don't hand any money over just yet!:D but its still your choice at the end of the day.

Love to hear what you eventually decide.

E...

Gut feeling says go for it. But I guess it is still a risk.

Yeah she said, I don't have to decide anytime soon and suggested the back end of next year or the spring thereafter.

I have posted on the vet area bit in the forum as I am sure it is a check or suspensory liagament desmitis, basically a sprain but couldn't be certain. No swelling, no heat, no pain - just alot of healing time needed. But still no vet report ... I shall keep you updated!
 
I got a 17 year old horse on loan she had a tendon injury so was no good for polo x any more. We have never had any trouble with the tendon since we had her and she is now 29 years old and still going strong { the old owner actualy ended up giving her to us as he said he wanted her to have a good home}
 
I got a 17 year old horse on loan she had a tendon injury so was no good for polo x any more. We have never had any trouble with the tendon since we had her and she is now 29 years old and still going strong { the old owner actualy ended up giving her to us as he said he wanted her to have a good home}

Do you know much about the tendon injury your horse had?

Was there a long rest period and remedial shoeing before being brought back into work?
 
think long and hard over this, speak to the vet that is treating him as you will get a very honest and straight reply from them, not saying the owner is going to lie to you but if she needs him gone she could sugar coat.

had a similar exp recently where my friends arab was sold and went crazy in the trailor on the motorway on its way to his new home, he had to come back and after alot of talking between the purchaser and seller, they decided to go ahead with having him.

when they rung me to ask if id look after him till he was fit to travel, i advised them not to rush into anything as they didnt even know wether he had any problems with his back, legs etc, wether he would ever get in a trailor again but they felt responsible for what had happened as they put him in the trailor. so they went ahead with it.

he came out of it unscathed apart from superficial wounds but they have now given him to me as they cant get him up there, so dont rush into anything, you could come out of it with a lovely pony, you could also look at it as a long term trial period to see if you click, but also you could put all your time and energy into a horse that you get very attached to and then find hes not right for you when and if you are able to ride him later on.
 
think long and hard over this, speak to the vet that is treating him as you will get a very honest and straight reply from them, not saying the owner is going to lie to you but if she needs him gone she could sugar coat.

had a similar exp recently where my friends arab was sold and went crazy in the trailor on the motorway on its way to his new home, he had to come back and after alot of talking between the purchaser and seller, they decided to go ahead with having him.

when they rung me to ask if id look after him till he was fit to travel, i advised them not to rush into anything as they didnt even know wether he had any problems with his back, legs etc, wether he would ever get in a trailor again but they felt responsible for what had happened as they put him in the trailor. so they went ahead with it.

he came out of it unscathed apart from superficial wounds but they have now given him to me as they cant get him up there, so dont rush into anything, you could come out of it with a lovely pony, you could also look at it as a long term trial period to see if you click, but also you could put all your time and energy into a horse that you get very attached to and then find hes not right for you when and if you are able to ride him later on.

Thanks for the very sensible post. But its true. I can take a risk and HOPE that it will work out for the best or it could go all wrong, its all about the risk!

At the end of the day, I could keep her as a companion or sell on as a broodmare ... but that is in the worse case senario.

Still waiting on vet report, hoping it will arrive this week and try and comprise a list of questions that I feel need more detail given and give the vet a phone next week.

I just want someone to say okay .. yeah it may turn out to be a really good relationship and horse for you ... but ... (highlight risks, etc) blah blah blah!
 
See I'm the voice of no reason :eek:...I'd go for it. I'm stupid like that but if you have fallen for this girl and if you can afford to keep her if the worst happens and she's never 100% sound then I'm afraid I'd be on the phone to the woman now telling her I'd take her. But then again I bought a horse sight unseen from a rather colourful chap from Ireland so who am I too speak!!!:D (Although he turned out to be the horse of my dreams and 5 years on I adore him more everyday!! ;)).
 
newrider.com