Advice please

Bengi1991

New Member
Mar 22, 2006
1,123
0
0
Sorry guys for not being on here much but have been really busy with one thing or another but I really need your views and opinions on this matter.

We bought 20 acres of land of a local farmer and planning went in last month to put a american barn on withb 7 stables and a hay store and a all weather arena. This would be in a village approx 4 acres from the nearest house and would only be used for the first couple of years by myself and my kids for our two horses with eventually having a couple of liveries on there for mates.

Here is where I need the help !!
The village is up in arms about it, well some of the village about twenty of them to be precise. They dont like horses and do not want them on the road or near their homes. They say they smell and the stables etc will cause pollution and that having the stables there will cause a disturbance with cars and horseboxes etc. ( I dont even own a horse box and cannot drive one neither )
They have started a petition and been to the local papers and have contacted the envionment agency and local county council about this. I have paid a surveyor to have everthing drawn up properly and everything is going to be done properly from the barn to the arena .
I just want your views on this do you think they are right. ( the villagers)

Here is the link to the papers if you want to see it

http://www.thenorthernecho.co.uk/search/display.var.2192399.0.objections_raised_to_stables_plan.php

Please bear in mind I am not opening a riding school and only want to use it for myself and my children thanks
 
Whilst I agree with you that it probably wouldnt cause any problems and would be ideal for you and the horses. If the people in the village are objecting surely it is not the right place to be doing it?

If you keep your horses on a piece of land you need all the friends in the area you can. The other way is to pursuade the people who are objecting that
1) Horses dont actually smell as much as people think they do
2) It would be self contained so you wouldnt be riding on the roads
3) It is NOT a riding school and its just for you and your kids

Im sorry to hear your having trouble with locals. Good luck
 
Thanks the funny thing is I spoke to the farmer up there who has fields surrounding mine and he has cows in there and he said that they complain about everything up there he even had a complaint about the flies !!
Not being funny but if you live in the country surely you expect to live near cows, horses, sheep etc and the smell that goes with it :D
 
Ohhh it's the townies moving out to the countryside again! If you do everything right and highways don't have any objections then there is little they can do about it. I know you've put plans in but talk to planning and make sure they know exactly what will be there and what you will do. In fact if planning says no and you really want to p the neighbours off then you have enough land to stick up a big agricultural barn and all you have to do is send a letter in to planning to say you have erected it (double check exactly waht you have to do but it is that simple) You use it as 'storage' for the summer with the horses living out then start filling it in inside. If anyone questions it you claim 'animal welfare' as your horses couldn't cope with living outside through the winter as you had hoped. They then give you restrospective planning.

7 stables is nothing and even if you did have 6 liveries there that would be limited extra traffic. Ignore them and laugh at their narrowminded stupidity. Then when you are in make sure you wear high viz at all times on the roads and put the muck heap the opposite end of the stables to the houses. Oh and get chickens so that the cockerels crow- let them complain at that and get laughed out of town! Don't waste any time worrying about it.
 
Cheers thats what I thought too. So do you not need planning permission for the agricultural barn then ??
 
Unfortunately if you are in a conservation area there is a lot they can do to stop you. Horses are not agricultural and if you followed the barn route the council could well make you take it down unless you prove agricultural use.

I assume you investigated the planning issues before buying the land, what are the planners views and what are their delegated powers??

Been through the planning mill several times!

Oh and people in new barn conversions 30 yards from our indoor school blamed all pests on the presence of horses...don't know how they missed the fact they were buying next to a large stables when they looked round :confused:
 
we had this problem! but wth 2 stables and fencing our fields....not with papers invloved but i believe a petition, headed by the person who had told us not to bother getting planning,
villages do,seem,to,fit,the,stereotype
sit it out, i didnt look at the linkbutfrom what you said they shouldnt have a leg to stand on. stay polite and maybye discuss it
as soon as someone else tries for planning theyll move on
 
thanks do you think though the fact that the council have recd 20 objection letters though that it will make a difference
 
Saw the link and added a comment in your favour.

If they were all so concered when the 20 acres came up for sale then they should have bought it. Think themselves darn lucky that a developer is not sitting waiting to change use for building more cheap cr*ppy housing.

If you were starting a pig farm I can understand why they may be anxious about the smell etc. but there is nothing more satisfying and beautiful than looking out of a window and seeing horses grazing. In fact moving to the country (8 years ago), after living most of my life in a town, I would say I expected to see horses everywhere.

I had the chance of an additional acre site right next door to me as the local farmer was putting 10 ft high deer fencing all round. This one acre was asked to be left and could we rent it for grazing (thinking it would be better than the fence in front of neighbours window). Acre was left unfenced but neighbour objected to its use for grazing and so promised to maintain it to the high standard of his lawn. I was well p1**ed off. Neighbours btw are lovely people (makes it worse) but they found massive stones in the land and has been left to go to scrub land ever since.
 
Read it
the reasons sound awful yocoulstill keep horses there anywy without stables andhorse dont smell so stuff abouthorses is unrelated
this is just a building
they dont seem to have complaints about the actual building..

we had letters of complaint andstuff, but didnt make a difference- thersa play school behind where we built ** stables,and they argued the poo woud attracthore flies- but we haveur muck heap ourtopfieldso itwouldmakeno their complaints made no sense, aparently also the chidren could het hurt.because midishetland ponies are goig to jummpa 6 footfence to attack them...

surely the letters should be in complaint of the building not the horses, othewise,putup a field shelter put the horses on the land now, and argue the stables are in the villagers best interests!
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the comment that was really good of you
Yes I think they are just complaining about the horses and not the building
 
Hi
Just posted in your favour - been thro it too - our villager(s) - it was really only one - complained. His objection read like we'd erected an equestrian centre! He has a small holding - goats and cows - and said our muck heap was offensive (he has one much bigger!)
Get friendly with your Councillor and find out what obj letters say (does council have a website? - you can read them on there) If obj are to buildings then speak to planning and find out if you can put in mobile shelters without plan perm. I know its not what you want but its better than none.
Keep us posted.....
 
http://www.derwentside.gov.uk/getmedia.cfm?mediaid=2880

Page seven this site tells you exactly what is listed or to be conserved.

from what i can gather there are a couple of houses, the church etc within the village are listed buildings.. but i am right in thinking that you are in the "excuded zone" (tudor drive??)

There is nothing on the land that has a specific conservational interest.. any rare orchids that your horses could potentially scoff up... (not that i've met a horse yet that likes eating orchids.. but you never know??) any rare animals in your fields.. flutterbyes (butterflies for the uninitiated ;) ) doormice, etc etc yadda yadda ( unlikely to have doormice as their habitat is hazel woods)

anyway a stables is only going to add to the "feel" of the village surely?? it's going to make it more historically correct surely???

besides it's only a conservation area... it's not like it's a national park you're in.. and in my thoughts they should get back to the city where they belong!

anyway thats my tuppence of thought
 
Geez... you'd think if you lived in the country you wouldn't mind a few horses. If someone bought 20 acres to build a horse farm around here I think everyone would be thrilled, even if it was a riding school. They'd probably want to give you tax breaks for not making another shopping mall :rolleyes:. I just don't understand, if you live in the country or nearby what do you expect? No farms of any kind? I live in the suburbs and on good days I can smell the manure on the corn fields ten miles down the road. No one says we shouldn't have more farms! Land is valuable and stables are much better than more development.
 
newrider.com