advice please very long sorry

  • Thread starter Thread starter elliebelly
  • Start date Start date
E

elliebelly

Guest
I got made redundant some time ago and I am really struggling at the moment to keep my pony and the one I have on loan. I was nearly sending him back a few weeks ago but it meant he had to go and live out, which I don't have a problem with but I think he would. I originally got him on loan to keep my company in a field where they both lived out with a field shelter and he hated it. He got so depressed. Anyway I have had to move him back to his old yard where he is really happy but obviously costs have doubled to keep them both. Anyway long story short to keep them both advertised them both on loan but have no saddles for either. Borrowing one for my pony of a friend and seems to fit reasonable well although am going to get checked out by saddle fitter eventally and borrowing for one loan pony of original loanee.

Personally though I really don't think saddle fits him. Its a narrow / med fit but I think he needs wide or even extra wide. They rode him in it for 7 years. He as been known to rear in past but when my vet come out he said he thought it was a discipline problem. However I have been feeling his back a few inches away from his spine and he is not happy when i touch it in a particular area. I am going to get another vet's opinion but problem now is he is on part loan to another lady in order to keep him on yard. She agrees that she does not think his other saddle fits him and went and bought a wide one which she brought today but it looked even worst on him. Its a really old saddle and I think it needs reflocking also etc. She rode in it and said it felt alot more comfortable. Thing is now I am panicking as really need her to him financially but don't want pony in pain.. I have just looked up and saw a site with saddles to rent.

Till I get money for the saddle fitter I was thinking would it be better to rent a western one as it seems they fit most horses. Can you ride english style in a western saddle. He is 14.2 and quite stocky but not a very long back. He is a full size headcollar and bridle so would you suggest cob or full size for his back. Both I and the lady who ride him are over a size 14. I can then concentrate on spending the money I would use on the saddle fitter to get a vet out asap.

Thank you for your help in this matter:)
 
Hi,
So sorry to read about your problems :( I'm afraid I am about to add to them by saying that western saddles do not give a broad ranging fit at all. In fact, the majority do not fit, then go on to cause further problems for the horse. If you want that kind of saddle that fits more than one horse - go for a treeless. Barefoot are one of the better makes that you can get quite cheaply. :)
 
I used to have a barefoot till it got pinched. I also think £400.00 is not cheap but alot of money and certainly not money I have at the moment.

I always wonder how people in developing countries get on as they don't have saddle fitters, physios etc. It also makes me feel like I really don't deserve to have a horse if I can't afford a saddle fitter and new saddle etc. Oh well! just another thing to feel depressed about. Thanks anyway
 
I've never met anyone who has ever had a Western saddle fitted (and that's saying something because most of the people at my barn ride Western). And their horses get along just fine. And I agree with you, most people in the world don't have their saddles fitted. But their horses get along just fine too. Please understand, I'm not saying that you shouldn't get a saddle fitted--only you know what's best for your horse. But personally I don't see any reason why you can't ride with a Western saddle that hasn't been fitted to your horse (as long as it doesn't obliviously NOT fit). And I can’t even imagine a cowboy calling out a saddle fitter. :D

I think that more or less you can ride 'English' in a Western saddle. Personally, I’ve found that does take a little getting used to (the stirrup leathers are really something!) But you'll probably be most concerned with how your horse takes it, since Western saddles are a lot heavier and put the rider in a different position. If your horse is at all sensitive you might want to take it very slow.

And I really don't mean to rock the boat--I actually think people in the UK are on to something with this saddle fitting. But seeing as pretty much the entire horse world gets by with no saddle fitting, if you decide to rent the Western saddle and not call out the fitter immediately, I'm sure you’ll be ok. :)
 
I used to have a barefoot till it got pinched. I also think £400.00 is not cheap but alot of money and certainly not money I have at the moment.

I always wonder how people in developing countries get on as they don't have saddle fitters, physios etc. It also makes me feel like I really don't deserve to have a horse if I can't afford a saddle fitter and new saddle etc. Oh well! just another thing to feel depressed about. Thanks anyway

Hi,
I was thinking more of this http://www.horseandharmony.co.uk/shop/index.php?main_page=product_info&products_id=1999&zenid=t4f2q5roqgged7kflj925smil1 as they are cheaper than many other treeless saddles. I did not mean to imply £400 is cheap. It is just the cheaper end of the good western saddle market. Although, I was thinking more along the lines of getting one of the £250 saddles second hand which may well work out quite reasonable?
Regarding horses in developing countries - as I understand it they just have to put up with their 'lot'. There is documented proof of donkeys with three legs doing brick runs and all sorts of visible suffering - yet they endure and carry on, as ridden horses do to. I was under the impression that you wanted a saddle to fit... :confused: You would not believe some of the horses I have seen and the pain they were in but they were just schooled through it. :( You would not necessarily need a saddlefitter to fit a treeless saddle.
 
Last edited:
I've never met anyone who has ever had a Western saddle fitted (and that's saying something because most of the people at my barn ride Western). And their horses get along just fine. And I agree with you, most people in the world don't have their saddles fitted. But their horses get along just fine too. But personally I don't see any reason why you can't ride with a Western saddle that hasn't been fitted to your horse (as long as it doesn't obliviously NOT fit). And I can’t even imagine a cowboy calling out a saddle fitter. :D

Western saddles are a lot heavier

And I really don't mean to rock the boat--I actually think people in the UK are on to something with this saddle fitting. But seeing as pretty much the entire horse world gets by with no saddle fitting, if you decide to rent the Western saddle and not call out the fitter immediately, I'm sure you’ll be ok. :)

With all due respect I have spent time with back experts and seen first hand the amount of damage done by saddles that do not fit. The majority of saddles I get called out for do not fit. The most common problem I see is the saddle bridging. This is where the weight of the saddle becomes an issue - all the weight goes through the front and back and nothing in the middle. This is incredibly painful for the horse. Although it is amazing how horses can be trained not to react to pain. I see many horses that seem to get along 'fine'. On closer inspection they often have muscle spasm, soreness and damage. The average age of a horse in the USA is 7 years old. This is shockingly low. I believe 80% is due to lameness-related issues. When you only expect a horse to live a few years I see why saddlefit is really not an option. But over here we like to be riding our horses into their 20's. This is where it is really important to make sure the saddle fits well otherwise you may well damage your horse at the start.

Out of interest how would you tell if a saddle fitted or not? :)
 
With all due respect I have spent time with back experts and seen first hand the amount of damage done by saddles that do not fit. The majority of saddles I get called out for do not fit. The most common problem I see is the saddle bridging. This is where the weight of the saddle becomes an issue - all the weight goes through the front and back and nothing in the middle. This is incredibly painful for the horse. Although it is amazing how horses can be trained not to react to pain. I see many horses that seem to get along 'fine'. On closer inspection they often have muscle spasm, soreness and damage. The average age of a horse in the USA is 7 years old. This is shockingly low. I believe 80% is due to lameness-related issues. When you only expect a horse to live a few years I see why saddlefit is really not an option. But over here we like to be riding our horses into their 20's. This is where it is really important to make sure the saddle fits well otherwise you may well damage your horse at the start.

Out of interest how would you tell if a saddle fitted or not? :)

I do not want to turn this thread into an argument over saddle fitting. Especially since I think that it is probably more beneficial to have a horse fitted than not fitted. However, whoever told you that the average age of horses in the US is 7 :eek: was seriously misinformed. For a horse to be dead or even out of commission at that age is VERY unusual. And it is very common to be riding horses into their mid- upper 20's over here as well. My point was merely that most horses do not get fitted and go on to live long, sound, productive lives. And I am yet to hear a vet tell me (or my friends, RI, etc.) that the reason the horse is lame/sore is because the saddle was not custom fitted to that horse. I'm sure if we put a narrow saddle on a broad backed quarter horse there would be problems, but since most people sensible enough to get tree sizes that fit their horse, it's not really an issue (ie a saddle that cleary doesn't fit). Getting saddles fitted is just not common over here, and yes according to our vets, trainers, RI, etc. our horses DO get along just fine. I just have a hard time believing that the entire U.S. horse community is involved in a saddle fitting conspiracy :). Of course I think it would be more beneficial for the horses if saddle fitting was more common. And elliebelly you should do what you feel most comfortable doing. I just believe that not getting a saddle fitted (while it may not be preferred) is not abuse.
 
Hi,

Thank you both very much for your input. Ideally I would love to get a saddle fitter out straight away but I am looking around here for £80.00 and been told then looking at £450.00 for synthetic and £900.00 for a leather. The prices are unbelievable.

I would love to see someone who develops a well fitting saddle for the lower price market. No-one I ever met on diy at any of the 10 yards I have been on have ever had a saddle fitter all because of the finances involved and the the fact that it seems the fitter can never find you a good cheap second hand saddle anyway. I am sure I will work it out eventually.
 
However, whoever told you that the average age of horses in the US is 7 :eek: was seriously misinformed. For a horse to be dead or even out of commission at that age is VERY unusual.

And I am yet to hear a vet tell me (or my friends, RI, etc.) that the reason the horse is lame/sore is because the saddle was not custom fitted to that horse.

I just have a hard time believing that the entire U.S. horse community is involved in a saddle fitting conspiracy :).

I just believe that not getting a saddle fitted (while it may not be preferred) is not abuse.

Interesting points you raise. :)

The statistics for age came from insurance companies about 6 years ago. Although, that is the combined age for Europe and North America. But is indeed true.

In the UK we are regularly told that our saddles are causing problems. Then they are changed to ones that fit and the problems disappear. Not sure why it would be any different in the USA or anywhere else in the world?

I am not sure what you mean about he US being involved in a saddle fitting conspiracy? Sorry. :)

I would not call it 'abuse' either, although if you get a saddle which does not fit then it may sore the horse.
 
I would love to see someone who develops a well fitting saddle for the lower price market.

I am sure I will work it out eventually.

I would also love to see someone develop a saddle for the lower price market as I understand not everyone can afford the big money these saddles command.

Good luck, I hope you find a way :)

PS. Would recommend asking on forums if anyone has a Port Lewis Impression Pad you can borrow to help with working out if a saddle fits or not. :) Also, Copperbeech saddles are cheaper I think - maybe secondhand bargains are to be found?
 
yeah been looking at them but then the words not recommended for riders over 11 stone stand out! lol!
 
Where on earth did you get this? Certainly not true at my yard, where my 18-year old is the baby...

Not to say that proper saddle fitting isn't important, but really, let's not throw ridiculous stones.

As I said before - insurance company statistics. :) I was not referring to individual yards. I know of one top trainer in the US who is happy if 2-3 horses make it through training alive ... out of 50 horses. I guess it is this sort of trainer which does nothing for the statistics.
 
As I said before - insurance company statistics. :)

Hmmm. That's got to be seriously skewed towards younger horses due to the restrictions on insuring placed by the insurance companies themselves. When I tried to find insurance, I couldn't find anyone who would cover horses over age 15. So horses over that age are simply excluded from consideration in the figure you quote. It's no wonder the mean age of insured horses comes out to approximately midway between birth and age 15...the rest of them simply aren't part of the equation.
 
its best to make sure the saddle fits. BUT plenty of horsie experienced people would volunteeringly help you find a saddle that fits, so in that case I believe its not completely wrong to not get a professional saddle fitter to come out, just someone who is very experienced and who you trust. I live in Canada and I see plenty of people not bother with a saddle fitter either (including me) but I am not neglecting my horses either. One horse does go to equine massage therapies (a senior), and chiropractic appointments due to her age and her spirit, and the saddles are fitted by my RI and barn manager.

the average age is 7 yrs of age I actually believe. you look at people trying to make a profit by producing as many foals as possible and they end up selling in auctions for dog food/slaughter at a pretty young age(hence the average age is so low) plus you add racing, and other accidents ect ect. I don't want to bring up this topic so thats all Im saying about either.

depending on where on the back the horse is sore a fitted proper western saddle may be better than an english saddle because the western saddles distribute weight on a further area than an english saddle so maybe the painful area would have less weight to carry in a sense.

I don't know anything more(so no offense) but what i read from this thread but maybe 2 horses is too much..(I know I am the bad guy) but for me I only bought another horse when I knew if an emergency came up/vet/saddle fitter/chiropractor ect ect I would be able to take care of them both and not be stressing. Now I understand somethings happen, for example my new boy isn't gaining weight at all and as soon as I brought him home he pulled all the muscles in both his back legs and I had to get a vet out, buy a winter blanket, and put him on an expensive food all of which isn't what I had planned. But going on your defense now, half of the year I don't pay for board but then I pay close to 400.00 for board a month, plus another 200.00 for lessons so I do see that you are trying the best with what you have got as many riders do.

sorry for the huge reply..
 
its best to make sure the saddle fits. BUT plenty of horsie experienced people would volunteeringly help you find a saddle that fits, so in that case I believe its not completely wrong to not get a professional saddle fitter to come out, just someone who is very experienced and who you trust.

I really agree with this. I do not believe it has to be a saddle fitter but someone who has plenty of experience. :)
 
yeah been looking at them but then the words not recommended for riders over 11 stone stand out! lol!

have you thought about the extra weight a western saddle represents ? My saddle weighs about 38lbs. The weight for the horse to carry is me plus tack...

I have an appy who was western backed but I now ride english as well. I carry more weight than I should :( and she has arthritis in her hock. I only found out about the hock *after* I had invested in a custom fit western saddle (yep - I got my saddle fitted - albeit from afar !). So I ended up also getting an enlgish saddle so I have a lighter weight option ...
 
What about a secondhand western synthetic wintec saddle? Lightweight, affordable and comfortable...I just bought mine (weight of a leather saddle was an issue for me) and the saddle fitter suggested a very thick saddle pad for my mare as she does not have a lot of muscle on her back (yet).
 
newrider.com