Advice needed - Stabled 24/7

doolally_tap

New Member
Jun 3, 2007
305
0
0
I've been offered a horse on loan with a view to buy. Owner would like him kept at the yard he is currently on - but there is no grazing AT ALL until at least February next year (field is getting fertilised or something).

He has previously been an RS horse so has been getting plenty of exercise and opportunites to stretch his legs out of the stable.

If I were to take him on it would be on full-livery (work commitments) and I would only be able to ride him 3/4 times a week over the winter...... but would feel terrible having him stabled 24/7.

I'm pretty sure that agreeing to this would be the WRONG decision, but wanted to hear your thoughts before I contact the owner and say no thanks.....
 
I think I've already posted in your previous thread that I am not a fan of this - it's really unfair on the horse!

Is there no other alternative i.e. another local yard. I would ask. Also, would the owner be willing to exercise the horse for you as you will probably pay a bit for full livery but won't have the benefit of turnout so you may be able to come to an agreement i.e. she lunges him for you every day or hacks him out etc?
 
The owner is pregnant so can't help with exercise. She currently owns the yard which is used for a combination of livery and also a low-key riding school, for which this horse was used. She is selling the yard to a relative and closing the RS part of the business.
 
Well, I don't like the idea of no turn out - from my (limited) experience, the horses unless they are doing a lot of riding school work become sharp - and I don't think its fair on them (unless there is a medical reason) to be stabled 24/7 - our pair were spooky and bad temepred when they had limited turnout - I noticed a change the moment we moved yards and now they're on full turnout through the winter at home they're different characters altogether! (Thats not to say they don't appreciate a warm dry stable when the weather is awful now and again!)
 
Yes it's not a good idea as horses who are stabled 24/7 get a build up of energy and when you ride them they can be more sharp than normal.

HOWEVER it will give you a chance to see the worst your horse can throw at you with regards to freshness!
 
I still fail to see why people think it is ok to stable a horse 24/7, I am dreading this winter becasuse for the first time I am on a yard as opposed to my own grazing and there is limited turnout over the winter, somtimes none:eek:

I have actually rented a field across the road for mine as I refuse to keep them cooped up all winter.
 
I hate them being in all day - How would you like to be stuck in a room, smaller than usual, for 24/7 then coming out for a bit.

Im ok with in at night, i mean its like there 'bedroom' :p:p
 
Are you a very, very good rider? You'll most likely need to be one, with nerves of steel too, to cope with a horse who's used to being exercised a fair amount who's gone to 3/4 times a week with no turnout at all.

I think it's very unfair to stable a horse 24/7 unless it's per veterinary instructions (and even then I wouldn't like it on a personal level but can understand the reasons for it).
 
I wouldn't do 24x7 stabling unless my horse was on box rest.

Horses need to go out for their mental as well as physical health in my view.
 
just answered your other post on this-

NO WAY to 24/7 unless you really have no choice (ie box rest) . hard work for you and miserable for the horse.
 
Well MY 2 horses are stables 24/7 and it is not ideal but thats the way it is... and they are OK ......
We do the best we can for our horses, and turn out is not always available. In fact on my travels I would say that it is not necessarily the norm..

As long as they come out and do something every day, be it ridden lunged or put in a walker they will survive.

why would you turn down a horse that you otherwise like just over an issue of turnout:confused:
 
Are you planning on buying reasonably quickly if the horse is right for you? And do you think this might be the ideal horse for you?

If you really like the horse then after buying you can move him wherever you want so putting up with the current yard might not be long term.

Is there no turnout at all? Not even some time loose in a school? Don't have to have grazing to have happy horses that get some time outdoors. Is the horse happy with his current living arrangements?
 
Well MY 2 horses are stables 24/7 and it is not ideal but thats the way it is... and they are OK ......

Agreed. Daffy copes just fine without turnout. It's not what I would choose for him if I had the option, but it was my only option last year, and we didn't have any problems. No fizzyness (and he spent most of it out of proper work) and his behaviour was no worse than normal. This year moving is an option, although I'm not sure where we could go yet, but they're still out during the day, and I'm waiting to see what happens first - he may be better off in 24/7 this winter.

I too do not think that you should discount a horse just because it is stabled all winter - it may not be, ours were in in the 2nd week of september last year, they're still out during the day this year.
 
Not sure on your situation but could it be worth thinking about sharing with someone else who can exercise the horse the the days you can't?
Has this horse been used to this situation for some time or has he gone straight from ridden for probably a few hours minimum most days on a school to stabled 24/7? If he's not been used to it I certainly wouldn't want to sit on him
Would be better all round to look round for different loan horse in a place that offers facilities you and the horse would prefer.
 
As long as they come out and do something every day, be it ridden lunged or put in a walker they will survive.

The OP has already stated that she'd only be able to ride 3/4 times a week and the owner can't ride at all. That's 3/4 times a week that the horse is potentially in the stable for a full 24 hours a day.
 
Never mind the bad behaviour (as if the signs aren't enough to put people off 24/7 stabling) you might have to manage with the horse being stabled 24/7 - it is incredibly stressful and unnatural for them. Many develop behavioural problems and 'vices' as well as the much higher risk of suffereing gastric ulcers as well.
It's not worth the risk and, to be honest - in my opinion - if an owner cannot satisfy the horse's miost basic - and most important - needs then they shouldn't have a horse, unless they have abdolutely no choice.

It's expensive, time consuming and hard work and I can't accept that, just because lots of other people do it, it qualifies as ok to stable a horse 24/7, as horses just don't think this way and it's a very human perspective.

I'm aware that there are other cases (i.e. when the owner has no other option/its for a short period/box rest, etc) but I personally would think of keeping own horse like that, out of choice, regardless of any other fantastic facilities there may be (of which the horse will most likely not exactly appreciate, i.e. gallops, a walker, indoror school etc).

This is only my POV and I fully appreciate that there are quite a few horses who do not object to being stabled 24/7, and that many owners keep their horses that way successfully, either way. I would not condem anyone keeping their horse this way as there are usually pretty good reasons for it.

:-)

xx
 
Last edited:
There are a bunch of horses by the horse I ride's field that are stabled 24/7 including stallions :eek: It's awful to see. I actually didn't look forward to getting her in because I'd have to pass these ponies looking so sad.
Yes they were looked after but I just can't agree with it.

However, If you started riding this horse you could build up a relationship with the owner and maybe get the horse moved.
 
I afraid I wouldn't go for it - I couldn't stand watching the poor horse (and it's fellow prisioners) stuck inside all day, everyday, unable to do anything about it:(

If you are however going to making a decision pretty quickly about buying him (and therefore being able to move him) than maybe think about.

Have you any options of moving him somewhere else with turnout nearby? The owner might be glad to let him have some TO.
 
I don't really understand why everyone is suggesting you don't loan the horse on ethical reasons (I appreciate the work, behavioural ettc. concerns) - At the end of the day the horse will be stabled 24/7 whether you take it on loan or not. If you like the horse then I'd go for it, at least then you have a chance at changing the way it's kept.
 
newrider.com