Advice needed - separation anxiety

juliecwuk

Well-Known Member
Mar 2, 2006
7,888
761
113
43
Wolverhampton
My friends daughter bought a horse at end jan. purchased off a friend so knew her history. But we had NO IDEA the extremity of her anxieties :(

Her one main anxiety is being alone....in the field it's actually not too bad as long as horses are in adjacent paddocks (and since mine are Nextdoor I leave Rosie out the majority of the week, I only bring her in if D is being brought up)

But up at the stables is a real issue. If bought up on her own she really stresses - rearing spinning calling pawing dancing... Will lead happily though until there, eat her food but then stress even if a haynet there. However if just one horse there then she's not even slightly stressed.

Problem is the girl is 14 and whilst naturally fantastic with horses she is now feeling her confidence slip away and has now admitted to avoiding bringing her up solo for the last month really as she is scared what she will do.

I hadnt realised she was that bad :( its difficult when u own one horse on a livery yard :( I have 3 horses and have given her permission to bring up any one of mine if she ever needs to, problem is she has relied on this not continued with getting her happy with being solo.

Please give me advice!

I have said i am going to bring D up as often as I can solo as she doesn't scare me. So I am bringing her in twice a day if I have time. I intend on starting small and building up. To a certain extent I feel she needs to just be up there to learn to cope but if in stable she does try to mini rear like she wants to jump although she hasn't jumped out I feel she may.
 
some just don't settle if they are alone - my cob mare Molly has very big separation issues as well and if she were to be box rested, everyone else would as well! she box walks, sweats up, has the runs, she would be skin and bone in a week as she gets so anxious - she is now 22 and is better than she was, but when she was younger she was dreadful. she never jumped out just got herself into a total tizz and you had an awful lot of mucking out to do as she would trash the stable.

some will improve if you expose them bit by bit to being left and increase the time and often they are better if they don't have an audience. so your plan may well work, gradually building her up to it etc. but some never get. to be honest i never leave one of mine in alone anyway, if one is on box rest, they have rotational company unless it is the pair of donkeys then they both stay.

could she not get a £10 shetland as company? there are stacks of very cheap ponies going for meat, going for nothing at auctions, get her a tiny cheap pal who she might even share a stable with? I know it is not solving the problem by teaching the horse to learn to cope alone but sometimes it is easier and kinder to go at it from another direction? it makes management much easier for the owner as well.
 
The horse won't be being stabled its just when the girl wants to tack up to ride or groom. She doesn't have a stable of her own she used mine. She normally ties up outside and occasionally uses the stable. D is terrible outside too.

We have been giving her a calmer, I thought it was working a little but seems prob not...

Unfortunately rent on our yard is full price even if a Shetland so but feasible. She can have Rosie as a permanent companion as I only ride her once a week. Tbh we treat the 5 as a herd and we mostly ride together anyway. I think she's really sad about losing her independence as she has to rely on others being in (personally I don't really see it as too much of an issue as she can bring any one of the 4 others in with D)

I am worrying D will never cope, but then as she can bring any of ours in then she doesn't have to be alone. Think the independence bit is because she has Lost confidence riding her too...
 
Last edited:
Practice, practice, practice!

Hens suffers seperation anxiety and I've seen him pick up canter in the stable if he thinks he's been left!

Does she leave the mare with a haynet?

Henry used to be quite anxious on the new yard (I have no stable) so I just carried on bringing him in and giving him a haynet on the yard. On Saturday morning he had the farrier, he tied up on his own then two horses returned from a hack AND left him and he did nothing more than fidget about and have a poo!

When I first had Henry at the RS he had to be stabled in the barn as he couldn't cope in a normal stable he would trot from his haynet to the door to make sure he wasn't being left.

We know each other that well now that he settles because I'm there, that's taken a LONG time though!
 
Our Tess is getting worse, she started when she lost her Pair bond of 12 years 5 years ago now - she was withdrawn for sometime and then Acorn took his place in her affections,but she didn't stress too much, Charlie Came along and one or the other would be with her most of the time, but now if one is not in the same field(not necessarily grazing area) with her then she stresses, sweats and in bad weather the field is trashed with her pounding around, think she would know better at 22 - even if you take out of the field to walk up the lane for in hand exercise and she can see them she starts - we went down the school of thought she will just hve to get used to it, there are 3 others just over the fence but that does not make her feel any better about it.
On the other hand she will happily leave them in the field and go out for a hack on her own.

So watch this space, after much deliberation we are hopefully picking up an older field companion for her next week if we can get things organised......... that way she will always have a constant even if the boys are in and out and swapping about.
 
I just feel so sorry for the owner, she has so much love and natural horse understanding but the mare is just over horsing her currently.

We never leave a horse without a net on our yard (I'm very funny bout that, hate seeing horses without anything when tied up), but as of yet it doesn't settle her unless there's a horse in my stable.

I have permission to work with her, I'm going to start this afternoon and keep track of how it goes. I haven't yet seen her at her worst...I feel I may today....
 
If the mare was only bought end of January there is every chance she simply hasn't settled in enough yet to either trust her new owner or to feel confident enough in the separation scenario. It soundsl like you are being kind and patient and helpful and you can probably not really do a lot more - I think given time (and your help) the girl will gain the mare's trust and hopefuly it will not be as much of an issue. Totally understand why the young lass might lose confidence, it is easily done and I wish I'd had somebody to tell me years back when Storm was cheeky and unsure that time and patience would probably help loads! I don't think with separation anxiety there is a quick fix, it seems to be something you just have to work through. Joe and Storm were terrible at being apart when we first moved them home, because they'd moved house etc and "clung" rather to each other (I think Storm was worse than Joe). Weirdly enough when JOe died last year she was just fine on her own - perhaps testament to the fact that she'd finally settled in and felt okay about being left? (If only they could talk !!!!).
Do hope things improve for her - and I think its really nice of you to be so considerate - I know some folk on yards aren't that thoughtful.
 
I'd work on bringing her in, to start off with just lead her to the yard, tie her up, give her an apple, untie and walk back to the field. Next day wait 30 seconds before giving her the apple and taking her back, slowly build it up that way?

I've started doing clicker training with my dog so my brain is very much in the 'break it down into tiny steps before building it up' mode.
 
day 1:

brought her in solo, this afternoon....put her in my stable. There was a horse in the nextdoor stable but when that horse is eating its net it cannot be seen....so effectively completely solo.

Tied the haynet right at the doorway....D ate the net and was a little anxious - head over door looking around during every mouthful but not completely stressing....

i had to go in to take her rug off and picked up the buckets on the way out - que some dancing which she always does when expecting tea....but i didnt feed her and she stopped. i left her to it and popped back everynow and then (was only chatting on the car park) and she was still eating with head over the door and when saw me danced, so i just ignored her. eventually i approached and she was dancing so i walked past, then eventually i stopped near her door and she carried on eating.

She didnt once mini rear, or really over stress. she was actually in about 50 mins.

It was quiet on the yard though, only a few people about but no horses coming/going - i feel that will be the time she really shows stress. am going up in morning so will repeat.

so far so good though....havent seen the dangerous behaviour yet.
 
Last edited:
day 1:

There was a horse in the nextdoor stable but when that horse is eating its net it cannot be seen....so effectively completely solo.

Although not able to be seen,I would have thought horses could sense each others presence when that close by??

Hopefully was a good start and you are right that she didn't know other horse was there,but I think you may want to try it totally solo before getting too optimistic.

Seperation anxiety is a PITA,have dealt with it several times and am currently doing so again with new cob.
Frustrating as hell and really limiting at times as to what you can do,no sure fire way to sort it either,just patience and hope for the best!!
 
updates!

we have continued to bring her up solo, she really has settled SO much more! we did have an incident when she jumped out of the stable and hurt herself - but that was because the herd escaped from the field and she panicked and tried to follow suit.

Anyway, she is coming up to the stables solo nearly everyday for an hour or 2. Sometimes a horse may be turned out past her and she doesn't even react! i wouldn't say she is fully relaxed yet, but a long way towards where we need her to be for the girl.

When tacking up solo she does get fidgety and the girl is unconfident so i just tack her up. Tbh it is more than manageable with approach/retreat methods, and after 2/3 approaches with the saddle she will stand and eat hay whilst i put it on.
 
I've only just seen this thread!! I can totally empathise as this is what Inca does, she will totally turn herself inside out with anxiety...and it doesn't help that one of her field mates is her mum so there's even more of a bond there.

It really is just a practice practice thing, I bring in Inca before the others every day so she spends some time on her own on the yard just tied up while I mill around. I tend not to try and do anything with her while she's showing her disapproval at being on her own as I find this makes her channel her frustration toward me. Whereas if she's left to come to terms with it on her own, but I am there for company, she tends to settle much quicker.

She's come a very long way in the last month and we're now working on getting her travelling and loading as this can also cause her more anxiety as she's effectively shut in on her own, so regular short trips to quiet venues just to mill around or hire a school and we're seeing improvements every time.

I also do walking out in hand and other groundwork exercises to build her confidence in me.
 
newrider.com