Advice Needed Please!

sjp1

Well-Known Member
Sep 14, 2009
6,963
461
83
Tobes is out with a ginger TB, and they are the best of mates. They take hay from each others mouths out in the field, mooch around together, stand one behind the other, and all is peaceful.

About three weeks ago, YO turned the cattle out which caused uber excitement. Tobes ended up kicking out and cracked the ginger friend on his leg. I was of course mortified and said if the ginger needed the vet, I would pay.

The owner of the ginger has lost her license due to drink driving. Therefore, YO and I do him between us. I used my super expensive antibiotic cream, imported from NZ, with melonin pad and vet wrap and covered it in vetwrap and duct tape to turn him out. YO and I did this between us as livery was not there. Livery who owns ginger and I rode out a week later, and she took the bandage off, stating it 'needed the air' She is a vet nurse. Needless to say, the wound had not scabbed and with the mud etc., it has now become infected. We rode together last Monday and even she suggested it was 'fizzing' but that was OK because it didn't smell?! So she did nothing with it, and I took her home. Tuesday morning I decided it was mega swollen and YO and I poulticed it, and then progressed to putting melonin pads and spray and gel on it. Livery came up yesterday, rode him out for two and a half hours, and today it is just awful. She bought some four year out of date Flamazine up, which we were instructed to put on it today, and this evening when YO and I took the bandage off it was much much worse and the leg is filled all the way to the hock.

Now, if it had been infected immediately, I would have paid for the vet asap. However, because the vet nurse has intervened and done everything all wrong, should I pay for the vet to treat it properly. Really what he needs is an injectible antibiotic, and she should know that. For 20 quid, the issue could be sorted, but because she feels she knows so much, she has made it all much worse.

Should I pay?
 
I can't see any reason why you should pay: the current condition is no longer due to the kick (and that wasn't your fault anyway). But if it means losing a friend, and if she's asking you to pay, then maybe you should offer to split the difference?
 
Not you that for such. You have done everything you could of at the time and since the event. Plus you offered at the time. Poor horse I can't believe she is riding it still with an infective wound.
 
I find it unbelievable that she would ride a horse with an infected leg, but apparantly, it isn't infected, it is scar tissue. So what is the yellow liquid running down his leg?? She is an unbelievably spoilt and me me me person, and if she wants to ride, she will, whether he has lost a shoe or is lame. She took him out for two and a half hours yesterday. She text me to ask me if I wanted to ride, so I suggested late afternoon which she can't do, in the hope that she wouldn't go, but she did. Her own mother who mucks out for the horse told her not to ride, but oh no, she as a vet nurse with 16 years experience clearly knows best and then started having a pop at YO which does a huge amount for the horse for free. Not because of the owner, but because she actually likes the horse.

I don't want to fallout with anyone, and I don't want Tobes alone. She text me to ask for my vets number - because she has worked for most of the other equine vets and fallen out with them - I wonder why, so I think I shall call vets tomorrow and say I will pay, but I want to know what they have said, because she will twist it to suit her own ends. Hopefully they won't be able to come until after Wednesday because she is off for a very long weekend with yet another new boyfriend, and then at least YO can hear what vets actually say, rather than liveries version.

Am SEETHING, but Tobes must have a friend and ginger is such a lovely, lovely boy. If I could afford two I would have him like a shot because she would get rid of him like a shot. He very much reminds me of my own TB ex racer I had to have PTS, just such a kind, gentle, lovely boy, with a whole load of quirks!!
 
If another horse kicked mine in the field, there is no way that I would expect the owner to pay for my vets fees. Not unless there was any way in which the behaviour was predicted, or expected in anyway. It's not the owners fault if a horse kicks another.

Horses are horses and we all take the risk of field injury if we decide to turn out in mixed paddocks. So no, I wouldn't have offered to pay the vet in the first place and I certainly wouldn't be paying now. How an earth can someone ride with a wound like that anyway?
 
If another horse kicked mine in the field, there is no way that I would expect the owner to pay for my vets fees. Not unless there was any way in which the behaviour was predicted, or expected in anyway. It's not the owners fault if a horse kicks another.

Horses are horses and we all take the risk of field injury if we decide to turn out in mixed paddocks. So no, I wouldn't have offered to pay the vet in the first place and I certainly wouldn't be paying now. How an earth can someone ride with a wound like that anyway?

this. best not to get involved. or sort it through insurance.
 
If another horse kicked mine in the field, there is no way that I would expect the owner to pay for my vets fees. Not unless there was any way in which the behaviour was predicted, or expected in anyway. It's not the owners fault if a horse kicks another.

Horses are horses and we all take the risk of field injury if we decide to turn out in mixed paddocks. So no, I wouldn't have offered to pay the vet in the first place and I certainly wouldn't be paying now. How an earth can someone ride with a wound like that anyway?

This. You've been more than generous with your time & stuff already!

I certainly wouldn't be offering to pay now unless it will make you feel better, you've got plenty of spare cash (now it's gone so far it's unlikely to be a small bill) & she'll stop riding him until it's healed.

If the leg is that much of a mess the YO needs to step in & insist that a vet is called. Do you have contracts & does it mention vet care in them? Often the YO has the right to call the vet at the owners expense. Failing that the YO could either threaten with the RSPCA or similar herself or say a blind eye will be turned if you do.
 
Shouldn't this be covered by insurance? I don't think it's your responsibility to pay either, but my yard insists on insurance as I am sure most do, so you should only be paying the excess anyway.
 
Shouldn't this be covered by insurance? I don't think it's your responsibility to pay either, but my yard insists on insurance as I am sure most do, so you should only be paying the excess anyway.

I don't think SJP's insurance would pay for another horse getting kicked in the field by her horse. That is just horses. I don't think SJP should have to pay at all. These things happen but IMO the way the owner has acted (still riding the horse etc) I wouldn't be paying a penny and tbh I'm not sure I'd be getting involved by treating the horse at all. Really, if there is concern (which there is), it should be the YO who should be telling the owner she needs to get a vet out etc. The owner should be deciding whether to pay for the vet treatment herself or claim through her insurance (if she has any) if the bill is going to be large.
 
I don't think SJP's insurance would pay for another horse getting kicked in the field by her horse. That is just horses. I don't think SJP should have to pay at all. These things happen but IMO the way the owner has acted (still riding the horse etc) I wouldn't be paying a penny and tbh I'm not sure I'd be getting involved by treating the horse at all. Really, if there is concern (which there is), it should be the YO who should be telling the owner she needs to get a vet out etc. The owner should be deciding whether to pay for the vet treatment herself or claim through her insurance (if she has any) if the bill is going to be large.

Not SJP's insurance - the woman who owns the horse that got kicked. Surely that should be covered by HER insurance?
 
An update!

The vet came today. I wasn't there as was at work, but YO was there, mucking out nearby.

Livery fancied vet and fed him a lot of rubbish. That it had only been a week ago - YO corrected her - that she had done this that and the other, she has been up three times since the 11th April, and that was to ride. The first time she took the dressing I had put on off and left it off, declaring it should breathe, the second time announced it was fizzing, but that it didn't smell so it wasn't infected and then on Saturday after YO and I had been poulticing and treating it since Tuesday and said it didn't look that bad, rode him for 2.5 hours and put four year out of date Flamazine on it which she insisted we use and which had black in it, which looked like mould.

She failed to mention this to the vet, who said he would put money on it that it was a chipped bone. Vet was quite aghast that injury happened 16 days ago and then she told him that she had thought it was a chipped bone on Saturday???????????!!! A.M.A.Z.I.N.G!! Why did she take him out for a long and hard ride if that was the case? She only called the vet because YO text her on Sunday and said she really thought the vet was absolutely necessary.

Words fail me really. However, I have text her to say that I will pay for the horses call out and antibiotic. My horse kicked hers, and I think it is only fair. Her horse was absolutely not to blame, he is a gentle soul, unlike my thug! I will call the vet (who is my own) and properly explain the situation, but if the horse does have to have surgery, that will be down to her. She has no insurance, and I personally think that unless you have cover (which I pay for on a monthly basis for mine), or loads of money, it is irresponsible.
 
I worry that by paying for anything you may be seen as admitting liability & she may try to use this against you if he needs expensive treatment or doesn't come right. Can you say that you'll pay for XYZ provided she signs something saying that you aren't admitting liability? And get it witnessed too.
 
You may be right CH and that is a good plan.

However, ours are the only two in their paddock and YO actually saw Tobes double barrel him. The cattle were being turned out and galloping across the field and for whatever reason, after the two horses had galloped about in high excitement, Tobes decided to back up and double barrel him. I really don't know why, as they are the very best of friends, sharing hay out of the same pile, they never argue at the gate to come in.

Tobes was kicked by his previous best friend when coming in for no particular reason, so I guess it is something they do when over wrought.

I do feel I am responsible (or Tobes is), and it isn't that I have loads of money, but a peculiar sense of right and wrong. Horses do kick each other, but I always pay for smaller vet bills myself, and if something catastrophic went wrong I have my insurance to cover it.

It is always going to be Tobes fault that poor ginger got kicked, but I do think as a responsible owner you should have either money or insurance to cover incidents like this. And if she doesn't have insurance, she probably doesn't have public liability either. :hot::hot:

I would be very worried if I didn't have that. When feeding Tobes the cool Spillers Fibre Cubes, he was like a maniac, imagine if he had actually connected with the car he double barrelled at :help:

Do you think that if it got to that anyone who was being an arbitrator would actually think I should pay for an extremely expensive operation when the owner has been stupid enough not to have liability insurance and vet cover? I must admit I am quite naive sometimes!
 
I don't actually think you should be paying out one penny towards vet costs. Never mind that the silly cow has probably made the poor horse a zillion times worse by her own actions.

The whole point is when you keep horses in with other horses, sadly accidents do happen, and yes, some of it is caused by one horse being a bit too aggressive with the others. But that is part and parcel of keeping horses, it happens in the wild and it happens in captivity. We, as horse owners, have to live with that risk. That is one of the many reasons why most responsible owners either insure their animals or have a sensible savings plan to cover any unexpected vets fees.

It is NOT your responsibility to pay any fees, despite the fact you like the horse that Tobes has injured. I also believe that by doing so you are leaving yourself wide open to a much larger claim at a later date.

The owner sounds like a first class bitch and shouldn't be allowed within a mile of any horse, but that is another thread altogether!:devil:
 
You may be right CH and that is a good plan.

However, ours are the only two in their paddock and YO actually saw Tobes double barrel him. The cattle were being turned out and galloping across the field and for whatever reason, after the two horses had galloped about in high excitement, Tobes decided to back up and double barrel him. I really don't know why, as they are the very best of friends, sharing hay out of the same pile, they never argue at the gate to come in.

Tobes was kicked by his previous best friend when coming in for no particular reason, so I guess it is something they do when over wrought.

I do feel I am responsible (or Tobes is), and it isn't that I have loads of money, but a peculiar sense of right and wrong. Horses do kick each other, but I always pay for smaller vet bills myself, and if something catastrophic went wrong I have my insurance to cover it.

It is always going to be Tobes fault that poor ginger got kicked, but I do think as a responsible owner you should have either money or insurance to cover incidents like this. And if she doesn't have insurance, she probably doesn't have public liability either. :hot::hot:

I would be very worried if I didn't have that. When feeding Tobes the cool Spillers Fibre Cubes, he was like a maniac, imagine if he had actually connected with the car he double barrelled at :help:

Do you think that if it got to that anyone who was being an arbitrator would actually think I should pay for an extremely expensive operation when the owner has been stupid enough not to have liability insurance and vet cover? I must admit I am quite naive sometimes!

If she doesn't have insurance she'd need the money (and motivation) to pursue you herself if she wanted you to admit liability and pay for everything? Do you think she would? Do you have legal advice through your insurance.

I totally understand that you feel a bit responsible but I think this could turn into even more of a minefield if you pay. It is very nice that you have offered though and I think that under different circumstances (ie with an owner who got a vet out when required and didn't ride a sore horse just because that is what she wanted and not what suited her) it would probably be a lovely gesture that would be much appreciated but in this situation I wouldn't want to get too involved!
 
Oh dear, I think I have made a big mistake offering then.

I just thought it was Tobes fault, and I didn't want her to then get her a... in her hand and insist they were kept separately. Her own horse has been a lot happier in with Tobes - previously she had insisted hers was a rig???!!!!

She wouldn't care if hers was alone, as long as it suited her, Tobes is massively unhappy alone, as hers is, and I just can't have that for Tobes. I would have had to move him if the situation had continued.

Why do people have to be so awful? I really should know the answer to that, I do work with people all day every day in the private sector!!!
 
Wow it's when I hear situations like this that I'm pleased I keep my horses in together and away from other horses/owners!

Personally I don't think you should have to pay anything at all....
 
newrider.com