a moral question/dilema?

perkypinky

New Member
Nov 13, 2007
1,328
0
0
in view of the dreadfull treatment of the horses and ponies recently on the news i have a question for you all:-
If, Hypothetically, you wish to sell your horse or pony either to 'upgrade' or because it is out grown or for any other similar/valid reason - and you could not be sure that the horse was going to a genuine home either because there are behavioural problems or becuase it was getting older would the best solution be to have the horse PTS?
I ask because a lady on a yard near to us sold her pony and its offsping (3 years) to what she thought was a private buyer for his young daughter for long term ownership, who promised her that the mare and gelding would not be seperated - only to find them both advertised the next week seperately and for a lot more than she sold them for. When she phoned to complain she was told that she had sold them and they were his to do with as he pleased - which of course it true. She tried to buy them back but to no avail. :mad: There are many other similar stories out there. Now these 2 probably have gone to a good home where they will be looked after and loved - but many others, as we know, dont, and fall into the hands of the Ba***ard of recent reports, after being passed from sale to sale.
So the moral question / dilema is, what would NR people do for the best?
It is only a hypothetical question and not a personal problem that i have, as, luckily for me (and them) both the horses i have sold on, i go to see regualy and know that they are loved and very well cared for.:)
 
I don't actually have a good answer

that I feel good about unfortunately. It's true if you sell, you give up all say on the conditions for that horse. To expect otherwise without an adoption agreement is foolish.

There were times I wish I had bought a different horse that was better trained. I was at least his 3-4th owner in a year and felt someone needs to invest in this horse or he's going to slaughter truck.

So that someone would be me. It's really tough and expensive getting all this training and he may never be well trained like I want but we'll see. I have to keep optimistic since I can't bear to sell him.
 
I'm in this position with my fathers horse. My Dad is getting on and the horse needs a stronger more confident rider, he used to suit but my Dads age and physical deterioration has dictated that the horse must be replaced. We're currently trying to find a swop or part-ex, but its not going well at present.
 
I hope to never be in the situation where I have to sell my horse, but if I was for financial reasons or otherwise I would probably try to do a full/permanent loan first so that I still had legal ownership over the horse. If I needed the money from the sale for whatever reason or HAD to sell, I would try to find a genuine home where I thought he would be forever and put a first refusal clause in the sale contract?

If the horse was ill or a problem horse and needed special treatment and I had to sell it, I would be much more likely to PTS if I could not find a permanent loan home, as it would be horrible to have a horse suffer/sold as a riding horse when unrideable etc...

Other than that theres really nothing you can do most of the time if you have to sell your horse, other than try as hard as you can to see if the home is genuine & permanent. But people lie and theres never going to be a 100% way of telling, unfortunately :(

xx
 
I had a simular situation just b4 xmas, I sold a dartmoor filly to a 'lovely old man' who said he wanted as companion, home seemed fine etc, 2 hours after selling her for £50 someone told me he colects them till he has lorry load then they go to meat!:eek:
So I went back to him crying and told him my daughter is very upset so I need her back, which e agreed to but had to pay £100!
She is now with a mate of mine as companion to her brood mares:)
 
It is something I think about a lot. Very depressing - especially over here, where the nicer owners are even rarer, and skinny, neglected horses are more the normality than the exception.

Trouble is, our own horse is special, and we couldn't bear to see him in that position. I know my joePony is super special ... and Tiny Pony is special, and RosaMare is special ..... and before long you have to admit that they all are, and no horse should be in that state.

we can't save them all though :( And for every one we hold on to, that's one more who doesn't have such a good lot in life, and who we can't help. The best thing I think I can do, is give my horses the best education I possiboly can - not leave a single gap in their education, not be satisfied with 'good enough' but to keep on with their training til they are as best as I can manage, really good, safe, reliable citizens who are least likely to get passed on to poorer homes.

There is a bigger picture though, to look at. The price of a horse rises over his lifetime, and then falls. Older horses are worth less. Who buys them ? If you had the choice of all horses, for the same money, would you buy a 7 year old, or a 20 year old ? What happens to 20 year olds ? It's quite depressing when you look at it that way, but it's an inevitable consequence of the fact that a horse is a commodity. We think of him as our friend, our baby .. but we sell him like a used car. :(
 
my boy is 15 now - his old owner has said that if/when he retires they will take him back as retirement home till the end - but if not i think i would have him PTS rather than risk the sales/horse meat man/or lying buyers - hopefully i will never come to that but you never know what life has in store for you so you can never say never.
 
Have I taken this question up correctly? Is the question that; if you were selling and couldn't be sure where the horse was going, you would have it PTS as an alternative?
I hope I am wrong! I can't believe someone would consider that. I think the morally correct thing to do (but i think anyone who genuinely has some connection with their horse would do the same) is to keep the horse even though you have outgrown it. Even if you cannot ride the horse, surely you have built up some relationship with the horse so that even it's company is valuable to you. I know people into horses for 'business' can't always do this, but on a totally personal 'owning a horse for pleasure' basis i think we should be giving it more thought before buying.
 
we can't save them all though :( And for every one we hold on to, that's one more who doesn't have such a good lot in life, and who we can't help. The best thing I think I can do, is give my horses the best education I possiboly can - not leave a single gap in their education, not be satisfied with 'good enough' but to keep on with their training til they are as best as I can manage, really good, safe, reliable citizens who are least likely to get passed on to poorer homes.

exactly, we've got to remember that however heartbreaking the amersham thing has been, the majority of horses sold do not end up like this. they go to people like me, like everyone who's posted on this thread. remember that very few of us bred our own horses, most of us bought them - and the people who sold them to us didn't do them a disservice. if nobody ever sold horses, nobody would be able to buy them.

i also think it's our responsibility when we have young horses to give them the best education that we can, t make them as easy and uncomplicated and pleasant as possible, no special needs, no special tack needed. it's these horses who will make themselves loved and indispensable and most likely to have an owner at the end of their working lives who will do the right thing and not sell them on.

i do think selling elderly horses who are about to need to start slowing down is an awful thing to do. selling responsibly is no bad thing at all - our horses give us plenty of joy and i have no issue with selling them to let them give someone else joy as well when we've outgrown them - otherwise we'd all be overrun with our childhood ponies, bored and without a job!

but if we have a horse who for whatever reason is more likely than most to end up being mistreated - behaviour, age, whatever - then i think we have a duty to either keep in retirement or PTS. there are worse things to do to a horse, as amersham has shown. if the owners of the horses he bought for £1 had PTS instead, they'd have gone happy and healthy to the next life.

human nature is that people do want their 'money's worth' and a horse who they've had for 6 months before it starts to fail a bit, is more likely to be hard done by than their faithful companion of the last 10 years.
 
I really think it depends on the age, health and behaviour of the horse.

A well schooled healthy horse not too old should find a good home and I would be less concerned than I would about an older horse. Whilst veterans can keep on being useful riding horses I think it is harder to sell them and therefore I would prefer if I could no longer afford to keep an elderly horse eg I was very sick and had no income and my family could not help out then I would try and find a suitable loan home or perhaps a nice riding school who wanted something for lead rein riders or beginners to plod around on. If the horse could not be ridden at all then I think I would have to consider PTS as rehoming would be very tricky.
 
I have to agree with KateWooton about making sure that if I am selling a horse to make sure it is as wel trained as possible and I vet as much as I can who I am selling to. I have only sold 1 pony over the years he was bought as a companion for my mare as a yearling in poor condition. I did a lot of handling with him and backed him as rode him away. He was too small for me to ride, but I didn't feel it was fair for him just to be left in a field. So when I sold him I turned down a lot of inexperienced people before I found the right home for him, but obviously I couldn't garantee him future, just do my best to give him a good start.

Remember, if no one ever sold horses, then there would never be any expericed horses and ponies for people's first horses.
 
I firmly believe that if your horse is a happy hacker type, then you should keep it to the end of its life, whether as a field companion or on loan, I hate to see advertisements for 20+ year horses for sale, just so the old owner can make a few pounds to put towards their next mount.
We have a groom at my livery yard who still has her old 13.2 pony aged over 30, had her for 25 years, brings her in every night in the winter, makes alot of work for herself with no riding, but that pony adores her, and she can't have another horse of her own whilst she's got the pony to pay for. That is the sacrifice I think we should all be prepared to make for our horses.

I know it's different if you've a top class showjumper etc and riding is your profession. The hunt stables I worked for in my youth had a policy never to sell a horse on, they ended up in a retirement field, sometimes for years and would eventually be fed to the hounds, not a nice thought I know, but better than in a truck shipped off abroad somewhere.

Sorry about this, off my soapbox now...
 
the riding school I livery at has a field for the retired school horses not all of them are old some have physical problems so can no longer be ridden, and some have behaviour problems, my pony lives with them even though he is only 5 and not retired yet.
 
I really don't know, I've solved this problem by just keeping all of my horses, hence why I am now up to my eyebrows in various different shapes and sizes of the horses and ponies from my past (and future, we had a new arrival today!) Needless to say he is guaranteed a lifetime home with lots of love and will never end up in a bad way!!
 
When we take on animals, we assume a responsibility of them. If we are not able to take care of them properly, we either should not take them on in the first place or admit we are not coping with them when things start going wrong, and not just try and sweep them under the rug. There are places and people who will come collect your animals before it has gotten so far you are stacking dead animals into piles behind your barn.

Ideally, you should keep your animal (horse, cat, dog whatever!) till the end of their life. But in real life, majority of animal owners, especially with horses, are unable to do so and sometimes the reasons behind it are quite understandable. I haven't so far, and I am not going to start thinking I have done wrong by doing so. I have taken care of my animals well whilst I have had them, have even rescued few from a lot worse destiny, and will do my best in selecting the next home if I am selling them onwards. I don't think I should be accused of being a bad owner just because I wanted to get another horse and in the process had to give up on the other one. And it is not like the horses will always end up in a worse place, some of my horses have gone to brilliant owners and have flourished for many years afterwards.

Nina x
 
in a romantic and wistful way, i hope to have mine for the rest of their lives. Realistically speaking, they're young and horses live a long time, it's hard to know what life will throw our way and what choices I may be forced to make. I guess if they were still young and fit I would try a full loan with a view to buy. If they were old, there are certain circumstances where I would consider having them pts rather than leaving it to chance.

I read a blog called Fuglyhorseoftheday, she wrote about a place where people can retire their old horses in safety and comfort for a small monthly donation, that is in the USA. I wish we had a place like that here in the UK, .
 
...and it's not just those old or those with health issues either.

My gorgeous girl is in the prime of life and is a normalish healthy happy girl. I keep her in a way that suits her. She is out 24/7 and doesn't like being kept in. It stresses her.

If I had to have Joy rehomed then who's to say how the next owners would want or be able to keep her. After all, what is good for one horse isn't necessarilly good for the next.

I think that if the worst came to the worst and I couldn't keep her anymore I would do a permanant loan so I held overall control.
 
I retired Rambo at a highly recommended retirement livery yard in France ... Paid livery, vet, farrier, dentist, etc ... anything he needed.

It was a great for three years, but then ....

..... well, see my worried thread about my emaciated horse!!!!!!!!

Suffice to say I thought I was doing the best for him, and maybe for a while it was, bue now I've assumed the responsibility of looking after him myself. Whatever it takes. He's 25, I've had him for about 15 years. I can't afford another horse while he's around, but I still want him to live forever and am lucky enough to have free loan horses so am not entirely horseless. When I made my parents buy him for me when I was a teenager I always knew he was here to stay. Luckily my parents have remained financially supportive because even now I need the occasionally help!
 
If it was me ideally i would keep the horse for life if i could. I am in a dilemma now, i want to sell my mare because she is not what she was sold to me as, i already Fred who i adore and love to bits and is now retired and will always stay with me whatever. Problem i have with selling my mare is even though i am not overly fond of her i still care about her and am worried what will happen to her as she is soo opinionated. I bought her to event mainly but she is so nappy and will not work in a school or around other horses, i've had help from a behaviourist and she is the worst she has seen and knows that deep down she won't event. I could sell her as a hack or possible hunter but she won't hack alone, its going to be very hard to sell her and i won't lie i couldn't do it as i know she would end up changing hands or eventually meat. I may end up having to go to a dealer but again i won't know what will happen and fear she will go for meat. Everything has to be done on her terms and she will get nasty if you push her and she doesn't want to do it. She has all the obvious checked regularly its just her attitude and that is going to be the thing that lets her down as she won't give anything or do herself any favours. I really do worry what will happen, i would hate for her to go for meat and end up like those poor amersham horses, she doesn't deserve it. She is only 5 but i can't keep another horse that i don't get on with and can't really ride apart from hacking in company. I am sort of in that position and its hard to know what to do but i know i wouldn't have her pts as she could have a nice happy hacker or hunting home. sigh............

Anyone want a pretty tb x american paint dark bay mare?? very sensible hack with others!
 
I firmly believe that if your horse is a happy hacker type, then you should keep it to the end of its life, whether as a field companion or on loan

I'm very much of the same opinion, and I hope to keep both mine to the end of their days. However both of them were for sale for different but very valid reasons and I hope I've given them the life their previous owners would have wished for them. Horses will always be for sale, circumstances change, things don't work out, that's life.

What I'm personally not so keen on are serial horse buyers and sellers or people who casually cast aside a loyal family friend in the name of increased size, status or petty competitive aspirations. Sometimes people will rather sell than explore every avenue if they're having problems too. Worse still are people who 'want a foal' from a lame mare, especially if that lameness is likely to be heriditary, and then have no idea what to do with it once it stops being cute and get rid. When there are so many surplus horses and ponies out there going for meat it also doesn't seem right that so many are imported from abroad, many of them nothing special at all, but money talks.
 
newrider.com