A loading debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter vieshot
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Gordysgirl, have you tried using a halter? If not it might enable you to get him on calmly and quietly even if he's not convinced :)

Yes I have. I have been taught how to use it correctly, however in the past his reaction to pressure was to rear - we have already had one disaster which resulted in him going over backwards on the yard. Thus my approach now is it will take as long as it takes and we are just patient with him & do not push it.
He will go on calmly & quietly - when it suits him!
 
Something I'd like to add, not to agree or disagree with anybody, as both "sides" so to speak, have given often interesting and valid responses, is that with horses biting each other in the wild etc but not being scared of each other, why then are some horses 'head shy'? That's presumably from being tapped/smacked on the face which could be viewed as similar to a dominant horse biting an inferior horse on the face, and yet that presumably wouldn't led to a 'head shy' horse.
Some of the difference between horses biting each other and us hitting them may be down to the intent behind the action.

Another possible reason is that dominant horses, when their teeth actually connect (or nearly connect), tend to go for necks, flanks and bums more frequently than heads. That's because the threat of aggression has usually caused the subordinate horse to start to move away already. On the other hand, attempted head biting is seen frequently in fighting or play-fighting between males. There you can actually see something akin to 'head shyness', where the participants pull their heads up and to the side, out of reach of the other's teeth. Presumably it's quite an easy and natural skill for a horse to acquire.

Because a form of 'head shyness' comes easily to young male horses, I am not in favour of smacking them anyway near the head (or in the mouth) for nipping - because it panders to their natural instincts and is liable to turn what was intended as punishment into a game - as well as making them more 'head shy'! If you're going to hit them, it's better to do so on the chest.

Being a pwactical and not a fwuffy person, but who would prefer not to hit horses if at all possible, I have found other ways discourage nipping that are 100% effective. I believe one can and should stop nipping and mouthiness at an early stage (as soon as foals get their milk teeth in fact). The main method I use is described briefly here:
http://www.newrider.com/forum/showthread.php?t=155714
It applies equally well to people and clothing as to leadropes. It doesn't lead to headshyness.
 
Something I'd like to add, not to agree or disagree with anybody, as both "sides" so to speak, have given often interesting and valid responses, is that with horses biting each other in the wild etc but not being scared of each other, why then are some horses 'head shy'? That's presumably from being tapped/smacked on the face which could be viewed as similar to a dominant horse biting an inferior horse on the face, and yet that presumably wouldn't led to a 'head shy' horse.

Because unfortunately more often than not we, as humans, don't judge horses behaviour very well. In a herd a horse who was pushing his luck and for example nipped at another horse would more than likely just get a threatening look by the other horse or teeth waved in it's face.. my equivelant to this would be a hand waved in the offending horses face and my displeasure made clear - basically replicating the "get out of my space with those teeth" reaction from another horse. Unfortunatley some people's reaction would be a smack on the nose.. an action which in my humble opinon does not relate to a horses behaviour and which they don't fully comprehend.

Horses don't DO 'taps on the nose' or other 'wrist slapping' punishments we like to justify. To be honest I would much rather see a horse whacked on the body and shouted at for being aggressive than slapped on the nose, because though it might seem more forceful or harsh it's an action they can understand. They took the p*ss and the consequence was an unhappy herd leader and the equivelant of a hoof up their back side. It's very sad to see the amount of unhappy, confused horses around because the reprimands used on them, although perfectly justified and not particularly brutal, are just not something the horse can put into context or relate to his behaviour.
 
Some of the difference between horses biting each other and us hitting them may be down to the intent behind the action.

The main method I use is described briefly here:
http://www.newrider.com/forum/showthread.php?t=155714
It applies equally well to people and clothing as to leadropes. It doesn't lead to headshyness.

Interesting reading FB but somehow I would feel easier giving a stubborn, non loading horse a light smack on the bum with a crop than jabbing it in the gums with a stick to stop it chewing a leadrope!
 
What would you suggest as a positive experience? We have taken him to hack, taken him & just let him eat, as soon as you bring working back into the equation he says no!
I was thinking more along the lines of (shock! horror!) food rewards (but not bribes) for nice and prompt loading. However, you may not consider anything like "clicker training" to be suitable for teaching horses - obviously that's up to you - or your horse may not be sufficiently food motivated (though most are!) . However, the crucial point is that, for a reward to be really effective, it has to happen close enough to the action or behaviour being rewarded for the horse to make the connection. So while letting him eat at the end of the journey (or even after he's unloaded again at home) may be pleasant for him and foster a "good mood", it is very unlikely to reinforce the manner of loading itself because it's too separated in time for a horse's mind to appreciate. As horses live from moment to moment, you have to reward (or punish) in the moment too.
 
I was thinking more along the lines of (shock! horror!) food rewards (but not bribes) for nice and prompt loading. However, you may not consider anything like "clicker training" to be suitable for teaching horses - obviously that's up to you - or your horse may not be sufficiently food motivated (though most are!) . However, the crucial point is that, for a reward to be really effective, it has to happen close enough to the action or behaviour being rewarded for the horse to make the connection. So while letting him eat at the end of the journey (or even after he's unloaded again at home) may be pleasant for him and foster a "good mood", it is very unlikely to reinforce the manner of loading itself because it's too separated in time for a horse's mind to appreciate. As horses live from moment to moment, you have to reward (or punish) in the moment too.

We have tried food - this works to the point where he knows he will be positively rewarded for forward steps into trailer. If no food is given until he is completley in he won't work for it - too bigger step! He then of course learned if he came part way in he would get something - so he would go forwards & backwards & forwards etc. He is only food motivated to a certain extent, again it is mood related, sometimes it works a treat, others he couldn't care less! He wasn't rewarded at end of journey, he was rewarded once in. Although again we have abandoned this method now!
 
Interesting reading FB but somehow I would feel easier giving a stubborn, non loading horse a light smack on the bum with a crop than jabbing it in the gums with a stick to stop it chewing a leadrope!
With respect, that's not what I advocated! I use my finger, not a stick; and it's the soft palate, not the gums. The aim is to cause instant mild discomfort, not pain.

As for a smacking a non-loading horse lightly on the bum, is that really going to be effective if normal leading hasn't worked??
 
Interesting reading FB but somehow I would feel easier giving a stubborn, non loading horse a light smack on the bum with a crop than jabbing it in the gums with a stick to stop it chewing a leadrope!

i have read this post from FB, and i read it that she means

To place your finger in the horses mouth and touch the roof of the mouth as if to tickle,so the horse believes it is the rope that is tickleing and uncomfortable and would most certainly not want to chew it again,

and with the broom handle, not jabbing but placing the handle there aswell as the rope gently so then the horse doesnt get the soft chewy rope but a rough handle instead which is not so appetising[sp?]

Going back to loading, a smack on the bum is going to make the horse fearful and untrusting of their leader, a tickle and a different texture in their mouth will put them off eating the rope as not appetising[sp?], not make them fearful:)
 
We have tried food - this works to the point where he knows he will be positively rewarded for forward steps into trailer. If no food is given until he is completley in he won't work for it - too bigger step! He then of course learned if he came part way in he would get something - so he would go forwards & backwards & forwards etc. He is only food motivated to a certain extent, again it is mood related, sometimes it works a treat, others he couldn't care less! He wasn't rewarded at end of journey, he was rewarded once in. Although again we have abandoned this method now!
Fair enough! If your horse is rewarded by the first step but not by going on completely, it should be possible to build up from one to the other in stages. That's what one would try to do using CT. It does sound, however, as if he inadvertently learned "forwards & backwards" instead. I'm afraid that sort of thing easy happens unless one is really careful to reward the right behaviour precisely. It's not as easy as it looks - just like "feel", it's an acquired skill!
 
Fair enough! If your horse is rewarded by the first step but not by going on completely, it should be possible to build up from one to the other in stages. That's what one would try to do using CT. It does sound, however, as if he inadvertently learned "forwards & backwards" instead. I'm afraid that sort of thing easy happens unless one is really careful to reward the right behaviour precisely. It's not as easy as it looks - just like "feel", it's an acquired skill!

Well this is it...he moved forwards got instant reward. Thats right isn't it? Therefore he learned moving forwards gets reward. So he figures that if he goes back out then comes back in again he will get rewarded.
He will go all the way in with food after an hour or so...but its pretty ridiculous!
When would one reward the behaviour if not as I thought?
 
So he figures that if he goes back out then comes back in again he will get rewarded

Is he rushing back out? If so you need to work at making that your movement by asking him to back out again as soon as he's loaded. You can then gradually increase the length of time before you ask him to back out again. Once that's the case you can work at rewarding him for not rushing out as well.
 
Is he rushing back out? If so you need to work at making that your movement by asking him to back out again as soon as he's loaded. You can then gradually increase the length of time before you ask him to back out again. Once that's the case you can work at rewarding him for not rushing out as well.

Erm its not really a rush..but the moment you apply pressure & ask for him to stop the backwards he will go up or sideways & off the ramp. We have tried the backing out, but he will then start to anticpate going back out again backwards which I don't want to encourage as this makes him harder to keep in. I don't want him to start rushing out backwards.
It really is complicated. I am not particularly NH or otherwise, I just do what works, so I did have a parelli lady out which did the job initially, but once we are going places it all goes to pot again!
 
Maybe he is scared of when the box gets closed, Porsha was scared of this when i loaded her, and kept rushing out, after many attemps and rests from loading i called a parelli instructor who was magic and trained porsha to walk over the ramp, in and out,in and out until porsha would happily go up the ramp and then stay in until we closed the doors and repeated this so she knew the doors would then open and she would be unloaded and repeated, have you had an expert out who is recommended:)
 
An interesting debate indeed. :)

Echoing Kirby's thoughts here...

In my opinion, using a cattle prod to motivate a horse to load is, at best, distinctly less than ideal and, at worst, downright reckless - reckless because you really want to avoid provoking a potentially violent physical reaction in a large and powerful animal. (See http://break.com/index/angry-horse-fights-back.html for an example of such provocation and its result.)

That man absolutely deserved every single ounce of that. :mad: :eek:

Also - I really don't understand how, after having tried to get the horse into the trailer in a humane, 'normal' way, using a whip or cattle prod etc is going to persuade the horse otherwise?!
Or is it for the owner's benefit, letting their frustration out in a seemingly acceptable way? It may as well be as far as I'm concerned as I think that these methods are completely and utterly unacceptable.

x
 
Last edited:
I don't think you can compare using a whip to a cattle prod not if the whip is used in a sensible way.

ETA and I did watch the video and the man got what he deserved although i don't see how it relates to loading.
 
Last edited:
Erm its not really a rush..but the moment you apply pressure & ask for him to stop the backwards he will go up or sideways & off the ramp. We have tried the backing out, but he will then start to anticpate going back out again backwards which I don't want to encourage as this makes him harder to keep in. I don't want him to start rushing out backwards.
It really is complicated. I am not particularly NH or otherwise, I just do what works, so I did have a parelli lady out which did the job initially, but once we are going places it all goes to pot again!
Gordysgirl - I think you could usefully take this further in one of two directions.

The first is to combine food reward with pressure and release through the headcollar/halter, as suggested already. These would have to be coordinated, it's twice as much to think about and, of course, timing still needs to be spot on. You also need to be sure that your horse has learned how to yield to pressure - not just when he wants to move forward anyway but also in situations when he may be reluctant to do so. If you watch any of the trainers who demo trailer loading -- for example, Monty Roberts or Richard Maxwell -- you will see that they spend time reinforcing the "yield to pressure" lesson, making sure it is thoroughly understood by the horse, before they go near a horsebox or trailer. Following this path, you might find that your horse loads better than before, and the food reward is just an added bonus, rather than being instrumental in producing "willing" behaviour.

An alternative is to use purely food rewards via the technique of clicker training. This isn't just about giving a food reward at the right moments; it is about the horse learning that actively trying to find the "right" behaviour (right being what we have decided, of course!) is a good and worthwhile thing to do. One of the side-effects of CT is that it can turn a rather ploddy, uninterested horse whose mind is elsewhere into one that is totally focused on the task at hand. It creates a positive mood in which misgivings, even fears, are more easily overcome. One often gets the impression that the horse is so concentrated on what it can do that it regards previously worrying things as irrelevant. If your horse doesn't seem to mind going into and being in the trailer that much, it should be a doddle to teach him to self-load with CT.

For one reason or another, clicker training won't suit everyone. However, anyone who does intend using CT with their horse should take time to learn how to do it properly. This really is essential, because it's quite easy to get it wrong, mess things up, confuse your horse, teach unwanted behaviours, etc. The consequences of poor use of rewards may not be so dire as poor use of punishment, but they should be avoided all the same.

If you really want to investigate the second path, I would highly recommend Ben Hart's new book "The Art and Science of Clicker Training for Horses". It's the best I have read on the topic so far.

Good luck whichever way you decide to go!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com