- is that because he finds it hard work? He doesn't do it when we transition from trot. I wonder.
Like you, I would be wary of tail waving though at dressage competitions some of the top horses do it and I dont think anyone worries?
We learned our first canters from walk. It isnt something I ever liked doing, but that was the RI's way.
You need to prepare the walk for canter. Just as you need to energise the trot and compress the horse to transition to canter so that the horse can get its off hind leg well under to push off, one needs to do the same in walk prior to going into canter,.
If the horse is stretched out in walk it can't canter directly from that position which is why after walk on a long rein across the diagonal one needs to gather up the reins and shorten the horse to get the ensuing canter.
My party piece with Maisie was halt to canter which the girls would challenge me to do. I would always say, I cant do that. But as I said that, I guess she was taking one pace of walk which got a good halt with her legs right under her body. And when the yard girls replied, Yes you can Skib. Just ask her. She did indeed canter. In some ways halt to canter is easier than a leisurely walk to canter transition.
I have done it with Ella in the school - I mean walk on the diagonal and into canter by the corner but I havent done it out hacking with Ella. Being run away with by Ella at her top spooked speed has made me a bit nervous. We canter out there on our own, but I insist on asking for both the upwards and downwards transitions and aways trot to canter.
The other thing to think of with Sid, is the context. If he has come from a RS where kids cantered only from trot, he wont be expecting canter from walk. Context is eveything. If you normal use the voice to ask for canter, and asked verbally when he was in the correct walk - my guess is that he would do it.