This thread started, I think, with a question from a newish rider and I answered truthfully with the instructions given me at my first lesson with our now long term RI. It was only when KPNut enquired, that I went into a further discussion and for the sake of exactness, I must now return and modify what I posted. In 1985 Charles Harris published a quite detailed text book The Fundamentals of Riding which includes a two page spread on The Rider's Seat. Although Harris emphasis that the three point seat with the tail bone and the two sides of the pelvis, is a starting point, flexible and adjustable, he does refer to three pressure points and his diagram shows the tail bone touching the rising slope of the cantle on the saddle. He calls this seat the "full buttock seat" and describes its advantages.
One of these is that it maximises the contact between the flesh of the seat and the saddle/the horse.
The contact between seat and saddle which will vary from rider to rider, has to be set in the context of teaching someone to ride, or training a horse to be ridden. Dont forget that for my RI, Rashid and Heather Moffett the next lesson, whether on a horse or on a simulator, is that, as the horse walks forward, one should be able to feel through one's seat the movement of its hind legs which will cause each of one's buttocks to first drop and then to rise, alternating side to side. This movement in walk is replicated in trot and is the basis for learning to sit to the trot.
Having established that habit as a new rider, in subsequent lessons, a more experienced rider will be able to do as Harris describes - to vary the pressure from these three stabilising points in numerous ways to help both the horse and himself according to their level of riding - lighter seat, heavier seat, weight to the outer side, weight to the inner side, weight a little to the front, weight a little to the rear etc. In the open type of saddle in which I was taught, the rider has great mobility on the horse which is what Harris is aiming for. He even mentions the situation in which one will dispense with the third pressure point of the tail bone and concentrate just on the two seat bones - but he points out that this requires accurate use of the rider's whole body.
My thoughts now, coming back to this are first that I misrepresented what Harris wrote by suggesting that the third point at the base of the spine was rather notional.
Secondly, that the way I was taught to sit in my first classical lunge lesson could have a lot to do with the fact that in that same year I was able to learn to trot bareback and six months later after hearing Rashid teach, I was able to ride transitions on my lesson horse using no visible cues. For Harris goes on to explain that the typical dressage saddles tho safe and comfortable have serious limitations - restricting the rider. "They lock or fix the riders body below the waist, and prevent the rider from becoming part of the horse, e.g. the rider is unable to use his 'seat' as an active aid to modify gait irregularities.
Using your seat to ride a horse and communicate with it is not some magical NH communication between horse and a sensitive rider. It now seems it was built on the way I was taught to sit on the horse in the first place, because unknown to me that "full buttock seat" maximised contact between my seat and the saddle. The open or GP saddles in which I usually rode allowed me to feel the movement of the horse under me, and absorb the information about it which the teacher was providing.
Riding styles and ways of teaching people to ride move on. On the same page Harris warns that Reams of equestrian nonsense are published - and this discussion if after all highly theoretical. But having slightly mis represented Harris yesterday, I needed to be honest and cite him more exactly today.