I am considering continuing with my BHS exams (I have passed stage 1 riding) and getting to stage 2 to help my knowledge and confidence...but fitting it in will also be very difficult as well as paying for it. Did anyone dive in and buy a horse with gaps in their knowledge? People have had differing opinions on this with some saying that the most experienced horse owners probably would fail some aspects of the exams, with others being very encouraging....all opinions welcome.
Regarding the exams, I have studied and passed my BHS Horse Ownership exams, plus I have read all the BHS stage 1, 2 and 3 books from cover to cover - several times! I have found that they have given me a really good level of knowledge which has assisted in my practical experience.
Over the years I have been on several yards and I have found that different yards have different cultures. I have found that horsey people tend to lean towards one approach and then can get very set in their ways and not open to other ideas. If you do the courses and get some qualifications, at least you know that you a good foundation knowledge and then you can make an informed choice on how to keep your horse. They certainly cannot do any harm - plus they are fun.
My horse is on part livery, but my yard manager is open minded enough to allow me to change from the yard routine and keep my horse in the way that I believe suits him best. Therefore he lives out at night and comes in for 6 hours during the day, he is rugless for most of the year, he wears a grazing muzzle, he has no hard feed and soaked hay. If I hadn't had my prior experience and if I simply didn't know any better, he would have just slotted into the routine that 95% of the horses are on (i.e. in at night, out for 5 hours per day, fed twice a day, on haylege etc.). You can argue that perhaps this would have be OK and that horses are adaptable creatures and in some way they are. But I think that if you are going to take on the care for an animal and expect them to work for you, you owe it to them to be prepared with knowledge, time and money to treat them in the way they deserve to be treated.
I would even go as far as to say that I think that you should be able to prove that you are capable to look after a horse before you are allowed to buy one. I remember going to see one horse for share and as she was tacking up the horse to ride, she was feeding him a whole bucket of dry feed (i.e. she didn't put any water in) because she felt that the horse would be grumpy if she was ridden on an empty stomach. When I told her that her horse may well get colic she asked me what colic was? I felt so sorry for her horse.