Fat, poverty lines or what?

Jessey

Well-Known Member
Dec 20, 2004
29,852
18,963
113
Suffolk, UK
Just before our big ride we bumped into our neighbour while out on a training ride, she made a comment that jess looked good but was still fat proved by the lines horizontally on her shoulders and going up and forwards from her stifles. She has always had these, I never paid it too much heed but the neighbours comment has stuck in my head all these months.

What do you think they are? I remember as a kid being told abdominal lines were "poverty lines"

At 1 month old you can just see the shoulder line
661ff790fb627260dc5540f5d4811f57_zpsa25bb98f.jpg

At 18 months both are obvious
696228274deea667dfcf17d3c4e526c9_zps226944f0.jpg

A couple of years ago when she was very over weight
a18521c7aebcbd45623141239004dfd3_zpsba4be77f.jpg

In march this year, just got off the scales weighing in at a whopping 602kgs
0dad73115fb50a0784cf9133863a2675_zps313a3331.jpg

Just before the big ride
8c3f0388747276e8c73726fa3af9a855_zps287fe68a.jpg

Recently, the shoulder line very obvious
074ab5a6c18cfb662e06ce55c513338e_zps7fb49401.jpg
 
I always just thought it was her, but keep pondering it since the neighbour mentioned it.

Poverty lines is an old way of identifying the working horses of people who live in poverty, not because the horses don't get what they need but as they work hard they are lean and muscly and dont carry the extra weight (the owners couldn't afford to keep them fat) of those owned by more affluent people. Poverty lines is simply muscle definition, hidden when the owners can afford too feed more than really nec.

Jess doesn't really sem to fit into either 'fat lines' or 'poverty lines' as she has these lines when fat and thin, Perhaps its muscle, QH's are often double muscled, perhaps Poosmate can shed some light on it when he is out next weekend.
 
The shoulder line I believed to be a stress line.
Usually from the fit of the saddle, but in thin skinned sensitive types it could be from flies etc.
But since she has had it since birth, she is possibly a very sensitive little soul.
I don't think its related to fat-unless you had a really fat foal. Its more likely tension in the muscle.

I will try and find you a link.
 
What an interesting description of the meaning and origin of poverty lines. I had always been lead to believe they were the marked lines visible in an undernourished horse with not enough weight or muscle. In particular down its rump area and along its neck. I had never believed it associated with muscle definition on a well worked animal.

Just goes to show how very different the language of the equestrian world is in different areas or groups of people.
 
Haha maybe I got the glossy version told to me, my girl def hasn't ever been starved

ETA
Went and googled, didn't get much, some say it's a thin horse, others say incorrect working, other say just lean horses working hard like racers, all say it is only the lines you get down the butt along the hamstrings like jess has below. So still no idea about Jess's other odd lines.
image.jpg
 
Last edited:
Just managed to log on and see photos. They are not fat lines. They muscle definition on a fit well horse trained horse.

Something to be proud off she looks in excellent condition bang on the condition score of 2.5.

I think people are not use to seeing horses like yours that are lean and fit. Perfect

will try and post one if ginger s bum it looks the same.
 
Last edited:
I know it is naughty and I shouldn't admit to it, but I really like her in picture three!! But then Tobes is an appaloosa with a great big backside - due to some quarter horse breeding in there, and I really like it!!

Know I am a very bad owner!!

Edited to add, I have never seen a horse with those abdominal lines, so can't comment!
 
NF that article is really interesting, I see the muscle you mean for the ab line too, it does follow it perfectly.

I like her round too, but with cushings and that making her high risk for lami I just can't let her get that way again, tbh I like her best when she's covered and schooled loads as she piles the muscle on and goes really chunky without being too fat, but that takes an awful lot of schooling which I didn't mind when competing a lot but we don't do much now.
 
I was intrigued by the QH/muscle thing so googled some images and most of the horses have the same abdominal line, some had the shoulder line too (also came across a TB stallion that had very definite abdominal, shoulder and bum lines).

I was horrified though to also discover the trend for breeding QHs with huge muscle mass for the show ring - don't know why we get so upset about genetically modifying things in a laboratory when we do this to our animals because we think it makes them look better! Just scroll down to the second picture ...

http://theperfecthorse.blogspot.co.uk/2009/09/world-class-halter-horses.html
 
I know it's horrific, they breed specific genetic mutations in some cases for the show ring which cripple the horse eventually, HYPP being one.
QHs are a breed that get 'double muscling' though I don't really understand what that means, other breeds get it too but guess it's more obvious under the thin skin of the TB ancestry go the QH
 
I was horrified though to also discover the trend for breeding QHs with huge muscle mass for the show ring - don't know why we get so upset about genetically modifying things in a laboratory when we do this to our animals because we think it makes them look better! Just scroll down to the second picture ...

http://theperfecthorse.blogspot.co.uk/2009/09/world-class-halter-horses.html

That is horrible, doesn't even look like a horse! I too am another who doesn't understand the tantrums people throw about 'genetically modifying' things when we've been doing it for years to all sorts of plants as well as animals.
 
newrider.com