How Would You Deal With This Behaviour?

greys

Member
Nov 12, 2012
38
1
8
I have had Boris since February, he came from a RS sold as safe, steady & suitable for novices. He is a lovely boy, cheeky but good as gold in all respects except hacking out on his own. Now considering this is what I bought a horse for it is a bit of a showstopper for me so I was wondering if anyone had any advice how to deal with it?

The main problem is he naps, badly :furious: If I kick him on he reverses, the more you try & get him to move on the faster he reverses, rather alarming on the road. My current tactic is to get off & drag him on & then he will carry on for a while but really not ideal as he is 16hh & I struggle to get back on.

He was pratting around something awful on Saturday, napped at an A frame sign, napped at nothing & tried to leg it home, spooked totally OTT & I fell off on the road, then napped again at a farmers trailer loading lambs, by this time I had enough, got off & walked in hand back 2 miles. I was fuming as I was really sore after kissing the tarmac :poop:

Just don't know what to do really, I have an very experienced person taking him out on his own next weekend to see if he does the same with him or if he just taking the pee out of me, but not sure if it's better that he behaves or not. He has been fine out in company, I went out in company the Sunday before & he was so laid back I was actually worrying that he may be ill :banghead:
 
I think this is common with horses purchased from riding schools...they are rarely out on solo hacks (in my experience). Asking a horse to trust its rider and go out solo is a big thing, especially if likely to be faced with spooky things.

I would wait to find out if he does the same thing with the more experienced rider and then re-assess. You may find he is fine with the more experienced rider and therefore you need to assess your confidence/experience for hacking solo. If he does the same with the experienced rider then if he were mine I would be walking him out in hand for a good while to build confidence before expecting him to be able to go solo.
 
Sounds like he has got a little 'programmed' to staying with the others after he has been at the riding school. Or maybe its a problem he developed before being at the riding school.

As you have only had him since February, I think I would try and improve my 'bond' with him on the ground, join up might be good to get him taking your lead. Then start leading him out short distances away from the others, a circular ride is best. Hopefully slowly he will gain confidence and see you as his partner rather than seeking the security of the other horses.

Try the more experienced rider. It might work, if it does, get her/him to ride him out several times, then take over. Don't go too far at first, just build up gradually.

You have lots of options for overcoming this and it is difficult to make suggestions on a forum when you can't actually see the horse, or what's going on.

Enlisting the help of a more experienced person is always a good idea.
 
In this situation currently with my youngster, trying to sort someone she can go out with. You have only had two months, so could you carry on in company and gradually build up to on your own. Short route? Maybe foot soldier so its not a horse.

I have had instructor out with me to assess. Mine simply lacks confidence to be "up front" she is OK if I lead her off, then she starts her various run through of pony options. The instructor had to lead her a bit to encourage forwards. Being a cob she is pretty hefty when she decides to thrown the toys out the pram.

I have long reined with the same results as she won't be in front. We are leading out and covering two miles, do this a few times a week, building up fitness of both if us. She doesn't hurry home now so that's one area that's better. Its just going to take a bit longer.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for your advice, he is a lovely boy & I thought we had established a pretty good bond but Saturday's performance blew that theory out of the water.
He canters to me when I go to bring him in from the field & when I fell off, he stood there sniffing me as if to say 'are you OK'.
I was in a major sulk with him afterwards & when I was poo picking later in his field he followed me around, nibbling me & pulling the strings on my hoody when I was trying to be cross & ignore him :wub:
He is such a lovely boy but I am so disappointed that I have failed so badly on hacking out alone :redcarded: I have hacked him out alone before but not so far and this was an hour so maybe out of his comfort zone. I was feeling confident because we had gone out the weekend before in company for a couple of hours, even cantered across open fields & he had been perfect.
 
Horses like to be part of a herd. When you go out solo you are a herd of two. Maybe he's not seeing you as the herd leader just now so is taking matters into his own hands and wants to be temporary herd leader until he gets home again. The fact that he is ex RS is as others have said, probably the key to why he is behaving like this, but it will be good to see how an experienced rider is on him - although I wouldn't think just one ride would be enough to gauge this - often horses will give it a few rides before they test authority so the experienced rider might get on quite well for the first bit!

I'd look at building your bond more. Ride out with others, go infront, practice giving him direction that is different to the other riders - e.g. walk either side of a hedge for a little bit of the ride, if the other horse stops, you keep going for a minute or so. They trot, you walk, vice versa.

If you're 100% comfortable on the ground with him, then walk him out in hand. Get a foot soldier to walk at his head when you're riding solo, gradually with more hacks, get the foot soldier to walk at your leg, then further back at your horse's bum, and then behind, sometimes going different routes - e.g. opposite side of the road on the pavement or other side of a hedge.
It will take time if that behaviour is ingrained and your confidence is wibbling.
 
Like others have suggested you may well be asking him to do something completely new and totally alien to him, something that also runs contrary to all his instincts. I would personally deal with this by relationship building / groundwork, despooking exercises and as much incremental work with the hacking as possible. It's also worth making sure that there are no physical issues that could be contributing to the issue like saddle fit, any discomfort can reduce a horse's tolerance and willingness in difficult situations.
 
Like others have said I think this is common with rs horses as they havnt had the solo hacking experience before,its often new to them.I would be working on ground work,walking out in hand,perhaps leading to long reining,take a foot soldier,take the lead in company like suggested but for me with my horses Ive had I have found taking out in hand invaluable.
You certainly havnt failed,you have only had him since Feb which isn't a great length of time,it sounds like the ground relationship is already growing,he is coming to you in the field etc and I think with abit more time and working more on the ground you will have a great time.
 
When horses scare you/frustrate you, test your authority, behave dangerously etc it is very easy to get angry. But anger is bad state of mind for dealing with any sort of unwanted behaviour. And hanging on to the anger when the situation is over is even less useful. Horses are here and now creatures. In the field when he was following you around, he would have no idea why you were cross with him. So my general advice would be that however you decide to deal with it, stay calm & focused and don't let your reactions be driven by emotion.

I would echo the people that say this horse is probably lacking confidence as he has not had much (or any) solo hacking experience. So I would stop seeing him as naughty and instead see him as uneducated and unwilling to obey you over his own instincts/preferences.

2 months is nothing from a relationship building point of view. And being happy to follow you around and come to you in the field is not the same level of relationship as trusting you when he feels uneasy. He barely knows you, and has no reason to trust you with his life! (Which is how prey animals see things).

My advice therefore would be to make sure your experienced friend does not intend to simply insist he obey. If he is more scared of her than the scary hedge (or whatever) be may comply but it won't solve your problem. I had a young RS horse on loan who napped. Within a few months of groundwork, short hacking etc, he was gaining confidence and doing really well. He was then sold and he reverted to napping with the new owner. She gave him to 'an experienced rider' to 'sort out' as he was 'taking the piss'. That rider got him hacking solo by assertively (aggressively imo) riding him forward despite him spinning and rearing. The next time the owner rode him, he spun about 100 yards before the 'sticky' place and bolted for home so they ended up in a far worse situation than f they ha just been a bit more patient with him.

Good luck :smile:
 
Agree 100% with that, I think forcing a horse through any fear related issue (and that is what this is fundamentally) risks a sudden big blowout reaction when the horse has reached the end of its tether. How often do we hear about horses that 'suddenly bolted' and the like. I'd much prefer something I was sat on to think it's OK to tell me they were worried and look to me to sort it out for them rather than flipping out.
 
Everyone has said what I would have said. You may be asking your lovely boy to do something totally new, so take it slowly. Lead him out, learn to long rein, go a little way and then a little further, and ride circular routes whenever you can rather than out-and-back.

He sounds so sweet, I am sure you will overcome his issue.
 
I *think* he has hacked solo before as I was told that prior to the RS he was used for dressage & hacking out alone, he was only at the RS for 18 months. I didn't verify that with the previous owner to the RS so can't be 100% certain.

I know that he is pushing my buttons because he is testing me in other ways, refusing to have his feet picked, undoing his stable door & untying his quick release knot when being groomed there is no doubt about it he IS a cheeky so & so but that is fine I can deal with that behaviour just need to get a plan of action for the hacking behaviour.

When I trialled him he napped a little & they told me to get angry with him which is fine in a school stuation not so fine on a road. I will struggle to get company hacking as I am at a very small yard only 2 other liveries, one of which is a Shetland, the rest of the horses are the YO's either retired or eventers, looks like I had better invest in some good walking boots :ninja:
 
I'd set a day by and be passive and bore him into going forwards. Don't let him turn round, eat ask him forwards and if he refuses make him stand there. They often get bored and go forwards willingly in the end. When it turns into a fullon reversing fight they seem to get worse.
 
I *think* he has hacked solo before as I was told that prior to the RS he was used for dressage & hacking out alone

He may have hacked alone somewhere familiar with a trusted previous owner. But that doesn't mean he won't feel uneasy when it is a new place and new rider. Our kids might be confident at home, doesn't mean we would expect them to behave the same way if left with a stranger! The loan horse I told you about hacked solo with me. But it did not surprise me that he regressed a bit with a new owner because his willingness to go out was fairly new. A skill/behaviour has to be solidly in place before you should expect a horse to transfer the skill to new situations and with new people. But instead of asking me for help they went the 'quick fix' route of whacking him past the problem and ended up with a much bigger problem.

I know that he is pushing my buttons because he is testing me in other ways, refusing to have his feet picked, undoing his stable door & untying his quick release knot when being groomed there is no doubt about it he IS a cheeky so & so but that is fine I can deal with that behaviour just need to get a plan of action for the hacking behaviour.

Giving away his feet is a big deal for prey animals. I wouldn't see that as cheeky either. The other behaviours sound like curiosity which is nice, if annoying at times. :yellowcarded: You can definitely use a horses curiosity in training - particularly top overcome fear. I would not see that as behaviour that needs fixing, personally.

When I trialled him he napped a little & they told me to get angry with him which is fine in a school stuation not so fine on a road.

Sounds like 'getting angry with him' is what he is used to - (which is often the case in riding schools) - so you may have a slightly resentful horse as well as a nervous one. Horses have an opinion about how they are treated whether owners like it or not. And horses who are punished for showing normal horsey behaviour will resent it. They may comply but you'll see a lack of genuine co-operation. I personally see no place for anger in horsemanship. Assertiveness, yes, but not anger.
 
I had similar problems with Rubic when I bought her. She would hack out in company ok (although she would be bored stiff unless there was some action:tongue:) but when I tried to take her out by herself she would plant/spin/spook quite badly. I ate gravel several times.

I started off just riding in the school where we were comfortable, do my usual 30-45min schooling then head for a walk down the lane to cool off. The first time I tried solo hacking we had managed to get about 200yards down the lane before she spun so I walked to just before that point, gave her loads of praise the whole way there, when we reached that point and the whole way back. I made the turn home big and slow and kept the same pace on the way home too. The next couple of days I'd do the same and once she felt comfortable with that I'd just increase the distance gradually. If she planted or tried any of her other stuff I'd just take a deep breath and gently ask her forward again with loads of praise with any forward movement even if it is only a tiny step forward! Rather than pony club kicking or squeezing when she stops (or feels like she is going to stop) I just niggle with my legs and tickle with a schooling whip and the minute she goes forward I stop and reward her - it was a bit of trial and error to find something that worked, being too "loud" just upset her more. I was assertive but not aggressive, I stayed calm and didn't get angry. I think that once you get to a sticky spot if you can get a bit of what you want (ie forward) then it is best to call it a day and end on a good note.

It did take me a good few months to get to the point of solo hacking without any issues but it worked and she has been brilliant since then, even after moving yards twice. It is all about trust and confidence and it'll just take a bit of time for you both to build that up. Also, I had the same problem with hoof picking - that might not be cheekiness but a trust issue. Again little bits at a time with that and I'm sure you will both get there.
 
Last edited:
Yes I agree Wally. I think this is always better, than trying to have an out and out fight, especially on a public road, where anything can come flying round the corner. Plus that tarmac really hurts when you fall on it, not to mention the possible horse injury.

I had a wee issue with my pony once. She would not go through some concrete bollards. Leg on whack!....buck, more leg she started going backwards heading for a drainage ditch in reverse :eek: With her the solution was to get off and walk her through it, much easier and safer imo. After a few times she was happy if a little hesitant, so I did the standing still until she got bored. No more problems since:smile:

Slow but sure would be my approach and a foot soldier would certainly help.
 
Joy would still run backwards at speed if you clumped her to get her to go forwards. I've a number of plans for her numpty moments.

She'll follow me on the ground if I hop off, put myself between her and the offending object and just walk by ignoring her completely and expect her to follow.

If we are in a place of safety I have different approaches though. Most latterly I gave her 2 changes to go past. I didn't increase pressure because she knew what I wanted and shirt of beating her to death, it would not have worked. When she didn't go past then I did a turn on the forehand and backed her past which she didn't object to! I then walked her back past it again so we were back where we started and then walked her past normally (I say normally but I mean I took the opportunity for some nice shoulders in and collection, very pretty she must have looked!).

Using shoulders in is a good one for us. Gives Joy something else to think about but allows her to look and me to choose direction of motion.

We can also stand and wait it out. Joy hates standing still as she's very impatient. Wouldn't work on a pony who isn't impatient though.
 
Joy would still run backwards at speed if you clumped her to get her to go forwards. I've a number of plans for her numpty moments.

She'll follow me on the ground if I hop off, put myself between her and the offending object and just walk by ignoring her completely and expect her to follow.

If we are in a place of safety I have different approaches though. Most latterly I gave her 2 changes to go past. I didn't increase pressure because she knew what I wanted and shirt of beating her to death, it would not have worked. When she didn't go past then I did a turn on the forehand and backed her past which she didn't object to! I then walked her back past it again so we were back where we started and then walked her past normally (I say normally but I mean I took the opportunity for some nice shoulders in and collection, very pretty she must have looked!).

Using shoulders in is a good one for us. Gives Joy something else to think about but allows her to look and me to choose direction of motion.

We can also stand and wait it out. Joy hates standing still as she's very impatient. Wouldn't work on a pony who isn't impatient though.

This sounds like Boris moves backwards really fast but if I get off he is fine, not considered the turn & backing past or shoulders in, I will try those. I tried waiting it out on Saturday once & he won :devil:
 
I had a pony a long time ago whom I took on the road for a summer. I used him as a pack pony and walked with him.

For the first few days he was a pest; he was very loathe to walk out, and seemed to be always thinking about what he'd left behind.

I stayed on a farm one night, and the next morning there were a couple of girls tacking up to hack out. I got ready and accompanied them down the road until we came to a shop. They rode on while I tied the pony up and went into the shop.

When I came out and untied the pony, he was whinnying and looking along the road in the direction the girls had ridden. We set off in the same direction, and my pony was totally different now as he hurried on to catch up.

We never saw the girls again, but that pony was changed for the better from that day. He never dragged his feet again, and was always eager to see what was round the next corner.

Perhaps if you arranged with someone to ride their horse away down the road, and if you left ten minutes later, your horse may become easier to ride and less nappy. :)
 
newrider.com