Is a horse a luxury?

Well I dont particually believe that, you could spend as much as you wanted on your little darlings really, I certainly dont spend 10k a year! Anyway its a bit of a daft argument really bringing a child into it, if you fall on bad times at least there is help out there for you and your children. Its a shame there isnt a weekly pet benefit :yellowcarded: lol As pets are are huge sentiment to life.

I like to remind my mates on a regular basis that I am a single parent without child benefit. They seem to forget that I have more outgoings than they think.
Luxury is anything that isn't essential. I don't think there's any argument that could convince me that a horse isn't a luxury based on that definition.
I think it's just that we are wondering on this thread if a horse is more of a luxury than other hobbies or indulgences. Is it the ultimate in luxury? It's definitely more of a commitment anyway!
 
For me it depends on how you view your horse and your situation as in:
1. Do you see your horse as irreplaceable and comes top priority before other material things??

2. Is your horse one that needs vet, physio regularily or can you get away with the basics within good horse care and luckier than me there fore lol

3. Have you your own land and saving on livery bills.

4. How do you define a luxury - something that costs money and material or something that costs money but part of your family so you go without material things.

I would say a horse is a luxury as they cost me alot lol but then again I could buy things cheaper for them but i chose not to and go without material things for myself and havent had a holiday in 5 years. I think they are a luxury but looking after them involving expense is a neccessity as not material luxury so different ball game.
 
Yes I think they are a luxury, as is any pet....but I wouldn't be without them (obv unless financially we couldn't keep them).

I don't spend barely any money on myself and am really frugal when spending money for 'us' so that I can keep my luxuries!

With regards to kids costing £10k per year - definitely realistic if in nursery as our nursery bill will be almost £9000 per year anyway!
 
People think owning a horse is expensive that's why it gets seen as for the rich.
I barely know I have mine financially, by comparrison to the others on the yard who are to and fro with feed bags, rugs tack. A bag of feed lasts me all winter.
It depends what you want, a hardy type is less expensive.

To some kids are a luxury if you can't have any, a new car is a luxury, a cruise, holidays.

Eta can someone remind me what a holiday is?
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't class them as a luxury but more a lifestyle choice,I'm not rich at all but choose to have malaika over nights out,nails, fancy clothes and cars etc
The friends I have that are my age are not interested in horses at all and they call malaika a luxury,but they are jetting off on holidays,having £100 hair dos,wardrobes full of designer clothes etc I don't do or have that.its a choice I think rather than a luxury.
 
I think they are a luxury in the first instance but then we have a duty of care.

I don't think any one should say they 'love' their horse, cat or dog if they are prepared to pass them on just because the going gets tough.

Obviously its ok to 'pass them on' if they can find a better home for them than the one they already have.
 
Yes they are, however much we like to think we can't live without them, we could - essentials are what you need to survive.

Exactly that.

There's no doubt they greatly enrich our lives, but that's it. A luxury is something that is non-essential to survival.

I couldn't possibly expect my ponies to be seen by a family struggling on a low income feed and clothe themselves to see my ponies as anything other than a luxury. I feel to postulate otherwise shows a complete detachment and lack of appreciation of the harsh realities of life when there are those who don't even have the necessities for survival, let alone a minimum standard of living expected in this country. It wasn't that long ago that hubby and I struggled like that and I'd have cheerfully slapped anyone if they felt their right to ponies was on a parr with our right just to get by!
 
Exactly that.

There's no doubt they greatly enrich our lives, but that's it. A luxury is something that is non-essential to survival.

I couldn't possibly expect my ponies to be seen by a family struggling on a low income feed and clothe themselves to see my ponies as anything other than a luxury. I feel to postulate otherwise shows a complete detachment and lack of appreciation of the harsh realities of life when there are those who don't even have the necessities for survival, let alone a minimum standard of living expected in this country. It wasn't that long ago that hubby and I struggled like that and I'd have cheerfully slapped anyone if they felt their right to ponies was on a parr with our right just to get by!

Totally agree, through personal Circumstances a year ago I walked away from business/home/lifestyle with 2 children, a grandchild, car and what I could fit in it. If people want to parp on to me about what is an essential I would be happy to describe !! I managed to afford to keep my 2 dogs but had to rehome my Horse and cat. Heartbreaking but its a harsh reality of what life can throw at you sometimes. This is when you get down to the nitty gritty of what a luxury is and what is your priority and basic needs for survival ! Theres being a bit skint and theres having NOTHING and starting from complete scratch all over again. Not even owning a knife and fork and a plate.
 
^^^^ Completely agree.

I love my boys so much and would not like to think about life with out either of them but the true fact is if something happened to my OH or family and I either need the money to take care of them or worse the time to care for them the boys would have to go but only after I would try and reduce costs as much as possible.

To me they are a life style not a hobby and a very expensive one at that as I spend every penny I earn on them so they can have the very best care and treatment. I on the other hand have not had my hair cut in over year.
 
A luxury, but then again, for me personally, one of the only ones in my life!! I would say they are a lifestyle choice. I can't imagine not having them now - but of course I did survive for 34 years before they came along...............lol
Horses for courses and all that.................I pretty much spend all of my money on them and have spent every last penny (quite literally) in making this place horse-habitable. Good job really, as I'd not afford to keep them on a yard anymore, given that around here you cannot get grass livery and most yards are VERY expensive - a small mortgage I'd have said. So I'm glad I spent all I had!! I do go without a lot of things for them, but only boring old things like new clothes etc etc. Who needs lots of clothes - surely the only things we need are horsey friendly ones?!! I make my hair go longer between colours. I still spend on make up because I look such an ugly old hag without it - but I do buy cheaper brands nowadays - no more custom blended formulations for me...........
 
A horse IS a luxury, but then so are lots of things - having kids, going on holidays, eating nice food, getting your nails done. It's a massive luxury if you own a thoroughbred that you keep in full livery at a top yard and never ride, but if you've got a cheery cob that you have loads of fun with and who lives out most of the year, you're probably not spending more than some people do on nails maintenance!
 
Of course they are a luxury! Just like getting your hair cut, nails done, buying make up or clothes, running a car, or the ability to go to go to the supermarket and not have to count every penny you are spending.

I agree whole-heartedly with JC....people who think they are not a luxury need a reality check.
 
I agree with JC too. And if we did lose some of our income and were struggling financially I can assure you that 'cutting our cloth' or 'tightening our belts' just so I could continue to support the horses would NOT go down well with my partner or children LOL!
 
Yes. It is a luxury. So is riding them. Running is cheaper for keeping fit and dogs are cheaper for company.
 
Absolutely horses are a luxury - but then so are holidays which a lot of town folk feel they 'must have'.

My horse costs an absolute fortune - they just do. Shoes, hay and straw (especially this year because the weather has been so horrendous) are the biggest constant expenses I have found. Livery, frankly, is a drop in the ocean because I am DIY and get up early and rarely have YO do any jobs.

However, I don't go on holiday and I would guess a decent holiday for two weeks would cost per person near on £500 at least. But the horse is still more expensive - I reckon if I didn't have him, I could probably afford a cruise or nice Carribean holiday!!! Hmm, as he was pretending he was a Spanish school horse doing his airs above the ground when I went to catch him, luxury holidays and no Tobes looking a plus!!!
 
Mine cost me a great deal less than most people assume. I am on DIY grass livery and do everything myself.

We go without a great deal of what others take for granted, like holidays, nights out, new furniture and household goods in general. My sister gives me clothes she no longer wants. We also watch our food bill and utility bills in order to ensure we can feed the horses and have there feet done etc.

My husband earns similar money to his work mates, most of them seem to struggle without horses and the wives work, which I don't atm.

Tbh I don't understand what they do with their money, if my horses are an expensive luxury what are they doing with their money to be so hard up?

I suppose its all about choices. Life is something like a game of chess, you have to make the right moves at the right time to make things possible.
 
Yes they are, I sold my car to buy a saddle for my horse.

Gave up one luxury for the other one.

I probably wouldn't work so hard if I didn't have my horse though.
He makes me go to work even when I'm feeling sick or can't be bothered.
And I'm trying hard to get a promotion to have more money to spend on him.

I see him as my motivation :)
 
Yes I am much the same Ale. Its kind of hard to get motivated over a new three piece suite or whatever.

I have done a lot of jobs to pay for my horses that I just wouldn't have got out of bed for for any thing else.
 
newrider.com