Is a horse a luxury?

Kite_Rider

Cantering cabbage!
May 18, 2009
11,035
9,441
113
Following on yet again from Tina's thread and some of the replies, is a horse really a luxury?
I used to get this comment from one of my work colleagues until I asked her to just add up how much she spends a month/year on hair, make up, expensive holidays, gym membership, going out with her mates, clothes, shoes, handbags etc etc

She was very shocked that I spend way less than her on my 'luxury' than she does on hers.
Now I'm not saying that horses are not expensive but are they really a luxury? From my own experience most of the horsey folk I know give up pretty much everything most people see as a normal weekly/monthly/yearly outgoing to enable them to keep their horse/horses.
So I suppose they are a luxury if by definition that means having something other than a roof over your head and food in your belly and just surviving from day to day (been there and done that too!)
I suppose we are all just very lucky that we can afford to have our little (or not so little) luxuries.
I don't see Belle as a luxury I see her as an essential to keep me sane, fit and healthy both physically and mentally.
 
Definition of luxury from freedictionary.com

1. Something inessential but conducive to pleasure and comfort.
2. Something expensive or hard to obtain.

Sounds like it to me, I'd class a horse as a luxury :)
 
Of course a horse is a luxury. In the same way that anything is (car, gym membership, hair appointments etc.). I feel so lucky to be able to have my horse, but I work really hard and have saved really hard to be in the position I am to be able to afford him. Everyday when I see him I feel so lucky that I am able to have him in my life.
 
A horse is only a luxury in the same way that any hobby is a luxury.

But for some reason horse ownership seems to be perceived as being in some way "elitist" (for want of a better word), whereas the likes of fishing, golf, scuba-diving, restoring old cars and so on are seen as perfectly acceptable ways of squandering your disposable income. I wonder if it's a throwback to the many centuries when it was only the powerful elite who owned horses - the sort of ingrained low-level resentment that us Brits are so good at sustaining :D
 
A horse is only a luxury in the same way that any hobby is a luxury.

But for some reason horse ownership seems to be perceived as being in some way "elitist" (for want of a better word), whereas the likes of fishing, golf, scuba-diving, restoring old cars and so on are seen as perfectly acceptable ways of squandering your disposable income. I wonder if it's a throwback to the many centuries when it was only the powerful elite who owned horses - the sort of ingrained low-level resentment that us Brits are so good at sustaining :D

Agree with this -yes they are a luxury but plenty of other people have luxuries too!
 
Agree with this -yes they are a luxury but plenty of other people have luxuries too!

I agree, I think the difference though with a horse is that its an ongoing luxury you cant just put in the garage if you cant afford golfing fees, or giving your sat night up if your skint ! Its an ongoing daily cost. , even down to fuel to get to see the animal.
 
No - a horse is a sentient being that we are priveleged to have a very special relationship with. They are part of the family, and a fairly cheap part too - do you know how much it costs to raise kids?
 
No - a horse is a sentient being that we are priveleged to have a very special relationship with. They are part of the family, and a fairly cheap part too - do you know how much it costs to raise kids?

Yes I do, thats why I also dont have a horse at present. If a horse is cheap for you ( dont you keep scully on full livery?) then fair nuff !
 
No - a horse is a sentient being that we are priveleged to have a very special relationship with. They are part of the family, and a fairly cheap part too - do you know how much it costs to raise kids?

i whole heartedly agree. My boy has been part of my life for 17 years now. And you cut your cloth. If i know i have big horse bills coming up I economise and I always make sure i save something for unexpected costs. I have plenty of friends who waste far more money on fast cars and alcohol than i've ever spent on my horse! To me, my luxuries are my hair appointments and my hand bags. Not my horse.
 
I think sometimes it comes down to priorites and luxurys mixed together. If you woke up one day and found at the end of the day you had nothing - you have to take a hard look at what you can do about it. Thats when luxurys come into it I think. I could of easily kept my luxury but not looked after him very well and jepordised other areas of my life.

What would you do in that position, as it can happen to people?
 
Any pet is a luxury. They are not necessary for you to live.

Horses for me are not always a luxury, they are a job and pay my bills! So it does depend on how you look at it. Alfie is a luxury sure, but I can guarantee in the year I have had him I have not spent more than £200 keeping him. So very little in the scheme of things!
 
Yes I do, thats why I also dont have a horse at present. If a horse is cheap for you ( dont you keep scully on full livery?) then fair nuff !

No - she is on DIY and I spend around 2hrs a day looking after her - fortunately my kids (4 of them) are off my hands now so I can afford her!

Child - £10,000 a year v Scully - £2,500 a year !
 
Last edited:
I think it depends .. sure if horses are just your pet or hobby then yes deffo a luxury .. but say you are a professional show jumped/eventer and that is ALL you do .. then I wouldn't say they are a luxury as they are then your living .. ?
 
No - she is on DIY and I spend around 2hrs a day looking after her - fortunately my kids (4 of them) are off my hands now so I can afford her!

My mistake sorry I read on your blurb page she was on full livery obviously situation changed now.
 
No - she is on DIY and I spend around 2hrs a day looking after her - fortunately my kids (4 of them) are off my hands now so I can afford her!

My mistake sorry I read on your blurb page she was on full livery obviously situation changed now.

£10k a year for a child? Who came up with that figure?
She was for a while - the only place I could get until a vacancy came up where she is now.

Child costs - http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2013/jan/24/cost-raising-child-up-58-per-cent-decade - widely reported in the press and news channels - £222,000 to the age of 21!
 
i think if you were to over analyse as such you could call anything in life a luxury!!
but as an above poster pointed out horses in particular seem to get a real name for it.
example....My best friend earns roughly the same as i do
She recently built a fantastic house that makes me drool when i enter it.but she would not think anything of spending big money on a handbag and buying the best of clothing and gets her hair done, goes on hols... ect!!
I on the other hand live in a 2 bedroomed cottage, buy my clothes when they are a necessity :giggle:never go on hols and will settle for tesco's best clothing. dont get my hair done but when i announced to her that i was getting a horse a few years ago she warned me of the expense, questioned did i really need one?? more or less said horses were for the rich!!!
Now she was only looking out for my interest's BUT there is a taboo there that horses are a luxury and i personally think that its no more a luxury than anything else in life. it just depends on your finacial situation at the time and what your willing to do for your horse.Basically how much you want one!
Its no more a luxury than a lot of other hobbies/habits.
But thats just my spin on it. it may not make complete sense :redface:
Good thread though!!
 
She was for a while - the only place I could get until a vacancy came up where she is now.

Child costs - http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2013/jan/24/cost-raising-child-up-58-per-cent-decade - widely reported in the press and news channels - £222,000 to the age of 21!

Well I dont particually believe that, you could spend as much as you wanted on your little darlings really, I certainly dont spend 10k a year! Anyway its a bit of a daft argument really bringing a child into it, if you fall on bad times at least there is help out there for you and your children. Its a shame there isnt a weekly pet benefit :yellowcarded: lol As pets are are huge sentiment to life.
 
newrider.com