Could you live without you're car?

MrA

Well-Known Member
Feb 8, 2012
10,919
9,958
113
My car is in the garage yet again, with an eye watering £700 repair bill. I have an old corsa.

I've just sat down and worked out my car costs me around 2.5k a year, thats staggering! I only earn 11k

This doesnt include repairs or extras, this year alone I've spent 1.3k on those.

So think its time to sell and resort to pedal power! My big problem is I own a horse, who's kept 6.2miles away. So thats a 12 mile round trip either once or twice a day. Is this do-able? Or am I insane?

I'm so worried that I'll regret selling but seems like my only option atm. Not looking forward to cycling there in winter when it's minus 5 I'll be honest!
 
Hmm, i'm wondering if you might not be cheaper buying a new car on finance on one of these 'just add fuel' deals? There comes a time when old cars are just not worth repairing. I had an old golf and when the clutch/gear box started going i bit the bullet and bought a new(er) car. Fortunately i was in a position financially to do that. The cost of repairs was more than the value of the car!!

I personally couldn't live without my car. I do a 60 mile round trip to work. Horses are a 40 mile round trip in OPPOSITE direction to work. I'd be scuppered with no transport!
 
I had a look at getting a car on finance, but its around £200 a month. Add ontop £150 for fuel. And my insurance is still around £700. Then road tax and mot after the first few years.

I simply dont have anywhere near enough for that. I dont really drive anywhere except for the horse, very lucky that my work is only 5 mins walk away. My bf only lives just round the corner too and can easily walk or get bus on the rare occasions I go out.
 
Just add fuel means just that :) the price includes your servicing, tax, insurance, everything. All you have to pay for is the fuel. What kind of weekly mileage do you do? a new peugeot will be far better on fuel than an old corsa. My friend has her 207 on this deal

http://www.peugeot.co.uk/just-add-fuel/
 
So you spend £150 on fuel a month for those local journeys? I spend around £120 a month to do over 800 miles to my work which is about 18 miles away. Although I guess fuel economy is low if you're doing short journeys for your engine not to warm up enough. You sure you're calculating correctly?
I couldn't live without my car but did have ponies as a kid and they were kept around two miles away so four mile round trip every day on bike. I managed, don't mind cold weather so wasn't too much of an issue, just a bit more difficult if there's an emergency I guess. I think it's harder to go from having a car to not having one. What about a scooter if it's just local stuff you're doing?
 
normally i don't like buying things on finance, but this seems a good deal and is better than putting good money after bad repairing an older car. And my friend's 207 is quite cute. She's on her second on such a deal.
 
Yeah I could live without my car.... I have never had one... cos I have never learned to drive!

I don't think a 12-mile round trip by bike is that bad. I used to do a 16-mile round trip to the farm for my share horse & it was fab cos I got so fit!
 
So you spend £150 on fuel a month for those local journeys? I spend around £120 a month to do over 800 miles to my work which is about 18 miles away. Although I guess fuel economy is low if you're doing short journeys for your engine not to warm up enough. You sure you're calculating correctly?
I couldn't live without my car but did have ponies as a kid and they were kept around two miles away so four mile round trip every day on bike. I managed, don't mind cold weather so wasn't too much of an issue, just a bit more difficult if there's an emergency I guess. I think it's harder to go from having a car to not having one. What about a scooter if it's just local stuff you're doing?

Not sure which car you have so guess that makes a difference? I drive to the yard twice a day some days so that adds on more. Also I do currently drive to go shopping and to my bfs but these journeys could easily be done on foot or by bike. If there was an emergancy I could hassle my mum for a lift or something. Not sure about a scooter just as everyone I've known with one has come off and they involve taking an extra test and stuff dont they?
 
normally i don't like buying things on finance, but this seems a good deal and is better than putting good money after bad repairing an older car. And my friend's 207 is quite cute. She's on her second on such a deal.

I guess I could always try without a car and then if I was really struggling could look into these in winter. Thanks they do seem very good deals, I like the little 207 so wouldnt complain.
 
i used to, when i had angel in London - public transport and cycle to the yard and a tackroom to keep tack in, plus friends to pick up feed etc. did it for years.

now i live in brighton ... busses to the yard are very hit and miss and nowhere to keep tack securely - my car is my tackroom so i kinda need it now. i could certainly 'survive' without a car but it'd be majorly impractical for the horses!
 
Yeah I could live without my car.... I have never had one... cos I have never learned to drive!

I don't think a 12-mile round trip by bike is that bad. I used to do a 16-mile round trip to the farm for my share horse & it was fab cos I got so fit!

Sometimes I wish I never had! Only takes me 20 odd minutes there and even less back ( downhill ) just wasnt sure if it'd take its toll day after day in winter rain and wind. I'll just have to grit my teeth and get on, looking forward to being very fit!
 
i used to, when i had angel in London - public transport and cycle to the yard and a tackroom to keep tack in, plus friends to pick up feed etc. did it for years.

now i live in brighton ... busses to the yard are very hit and miss and nowhere to keep tack securely - my car is my tackroom so i kinda need it now. i could certainly 'survive' without a car but it'd be majorly impractical for the horses!

Hmm this is my major downside. means my tack will have to be left at the yard, we keep all our tack in containers and someone lives on site but I know Ill still worry
 
Sometimes I wish I never had! Only takes me 20 odd minutes there and even less back ( downhill ) just wasnt sure if it'd take its toll day after day in winter rain and wind. I'll just have to grit my teeth and get on, looking forward to being very fit!

Well you don't know until you try :tongue: Admittedly there were days when I struggled to find the motivation to go - but once I got on the road it was fine - I was at uni and my horse time was what got me through the stress!
 
Well you don't know until you try :tongue: Admittedly there were days when I struggled to find the motivation to go - but once I got on the road it was fine - I was at uni and my horse time was what got me through the stress!

Very true! seeing my horse will be my motivation too and at least I will beat the nightmarish traffic round here!
 
Well that's the thing, I could find the motivation to cycle there far more than I could have found the motivation to sit in traffic!
 
Daughter has just traded in her car for a Citroen C3 diesel (8 years old) which is giving her 80mpg on town travel and cost £20 in road tax, £220 in insurance ( similar mileage to yours).

I run a 13 year old Toyota RAV4 that costs me £215 in tax, £275 in insurance and does about 35mpg, however it has cost me on average less than £200 per year in other costs (servicing etc) over the 7 years I've owned it.

I am sure you could make savings if you shopped around for the right car and provided you have a decent credit history loans are still available at low rates .

My 7.5t horsebox doesn't cost as much to run as your car!
 
newrider.com