You know what, I may not be popular for my reply but I do feel that it's worth saying and I do have some experience in this matter.
You have to stop looking for something long term, serious, the one etc. Men can smell it a mile off, and they are not attracted to it. It sounds to me like you need some time on your own, to discover who you are and what you want out of life. Time on your own is good, although cliche, getting in touch with yourself and liking who you are is very important. I had three year between serious relationships, and to be honest was very happy and would have continued that for a year or so more. I had not been on my own since I was 18, and at 26, I wanted to experience an adult life by myself. Although I agree it can take along time to get over an ex, I think you are still habouring feelings for him as it's familiar, many people stay with the wrong person because it's habit, and habit alone. I must admit, staying with a shitty ex you know, can be more appealing than the dating market.To me you are holding to much hope for each and every date, you need to treat it just like going out for a coffee with a new friend, have fun but don't look to far into it.
When you are ready I woild recommend that if you don't have an issue with it, go shooting on your local shoot...well not quite shooting but beating maybe. There are many men out picking up, beating and shooting that you could meet in a different environment than dating. Round here they are mainly professionals, outdoorsy and some farmers with land lol... Think outside the box! Other hobbies also could generate meeting new people.
I don't mean to sound harsh in my comments but I think you are a bright lady, with self respect, and any man would be lucky to have you, I think you cow,d just need to give yourself more time...and place a higher value on yourself when you do get dating!