Picking out hooves, how do you do yours?

Roxy's Mum

New Member
Jul 21, 2009
4,318
2
0
Dorset
Question in the title really. I worry that I seem to just hack away and could potentially be causing some damage.

Roxy has never been keen on having her feet lifted or picked out (I still can't do the backs at the mo) and sometimes her reaction seems as if she's in discomfort or pain. Is there an area on the sole of the hoof that is more sensitive? Is there a risk I am doing damage?

I think I've been quite ignorant up until now - but is there something I should definitely not be doing, and something else I should be? :unsure:
 
I get worst of caked stuff off. I always scoop round inside of the hoofl wall to get what I can out the white line. I then do the sides and cleft of frog. I actually findit easier with mine to go up towards me when doing this bit, but really you should go down to the floor.
 
I get worst of caked stuff off. I always scoop round inside of the hoofl wall to get what I can out the white line. I then do the sides and cleft of frog. I actually findit easier with mine to go up towards me when doing this bit, but really you should go down to the floor.

I am like you - sometimes it is easier to go the "wrong way" - with little hooves it is easier for me, I have the stiff brush on the end of the HP and always give a good brush out as well.
 
If she's finding it uncomfortable to pick her feet up, I'd suspect back/shoulder/hip problems rather than feet problems, unless she's hopping lame.

What does she do when you ask her to pick her feet up? And have you tried tying her in different locations? My Nelly horse is perfectly happy to have her feet picked up and out if she's tied in the corner of the yard where she only has to look in two directions for danger. However if she's in the middle or front of the yard she's very much on edge and snatchy with her feet should any traffic go past/a horse in the field spook/etc.
 
She has always been problematic with lifting her feet although she is always happy to for the farrier which usually makes me think she's having me on & trying to do me one over.

I have started to be very consistent with our feet training as I have been lapse since buying her really, going through fits & starts etc, but for approx a month now I've been religious in picking up her fronts every day. Some days she's fine and is absolutely brilliant.

She has a clear tap at the top of her leg with a succinct 'UP!', I run my hand down her leg to her feather which I grab and say 'up up'. I give her a good chance to shift her weight and often she will give me her foot (although more often than not she leaves it up to me to actually lift it!)

Sometimes there is resistance, I have to lean on her to get her to shift or she's happy to left me lift but won't voluntarily flex her leg. She literally stands there and makes me do all the work (she's such a monkey).

I try to remember to vary the amount of time I hold her foot up, sometimes I forgot just how long I've been holding on & remember this is still a bit new for her and must give her a chance to rest between lifts. If she does as expected, she gets lots of praise. If she tries to get out of it she'll do one of two things; either lean back to the point she'll hop (putting a lot of weight on me in the process if try to hang on) and sometimes go down on one knee, or she'll try to snatch her foot forward and often step forward or sideways in the process.

Anyway, the mechanics of the above is still a work in practice, my concern at present is much the actual picking. The last few days they've been packed full of mud & stones - I agree PFB that sometimes it is easier to pick out towards me. I also ensure I clean the whiteline & brush it clear after picking, her clefts are quite deep so I try to get all I can out of there. It seems she is quite sensitive around the bulbs and surrounding area which (I think) is when I tend to have trouble. Of course, I could just be making it up :unsure: I just don't know.
 
Last edited:
I think a video would be good RM! We need to see how things are for you!
I go from heel to toe, just being careful round the frog. At first I was a bit unsure what was part of his hoof and what was mud - sounds stupid now, but every horse's hoof is different and I didn't have a shoe to guide where I was picking out.
I thought Flip had weight bearing and balance issues when he wouldn't let me do it. Then I thought it was just cause he wasn't used to it (maybe held in a cattle crush to get his feet done on the continent). Now I'm of the opinion that it was a mixture of fear and dominance. Fear that he didn't have all his legs to do run if he needed to, and dominance, in that he wanted to do what he wanted.
I think the clue here could be how does she do with the farrier? Is she ok? That would tend to make me think there's a dominance/fear thing going on. Flip had issues with the trimmer but Nick squared up to him and now has his total respect. (wish I had it as well)
 
I am actually quite harsh picking out feet especially Harvey's dinner plates that weigh a tonne and he doesn't help to hold them in the slightest.

I generally go as deep as I can down the bars as thrush has a potential to raise its ugly head in there, I then do the rest of the hoof around the wall etc and the central groove of the frog.

I must be doing something right as over the past four years (touch wood) I haven't had any problems with feet.

I sometimes pick upwards with Harvey as it's the only way sometimes to get everything out. You are taught to only pick downwards but in all honesty the frog etc are extremely tough, just watch the farrier poking and slicing bits off it!! A hoof pick won't do any harm!
 
she is always happy to for the farrier which usually makes me think she's having me on & trying to do me one over.

Next time the farrier is out - watch her body language when he's working with her. If she's tense or bracing (muscles taut, eyes wide open, nose pinched, etc), get her physically checked out - either a physio/chiro to check her back or a vet for a lameness work up.

If however she's relaxed (head down, muscles and eyes soft, etc) and not showing any signs of distress or pain she's most likely just messing with you and taking a firmer hand/being a clear leader could well be all you need to do to resolve this.

I'd be inclined to tie her up (with a haynet if necessary), run the hand down the leg, say "Up" once and pick the foot up. Growl if she messes about and praise if she stands quietly. Once the foot is picked out (and I suspect she probably isn't sore if she doesn't mind the farrier messing with her), put it down for her - don't drop it and don't let her snatch it. Physically place it back on the ground, then reward with a scratch/cuddle/pat/treat/whatever she likes best. Then do the same with the others.
 
Next time the farrier is out - watch her body language when he's working with her.... if she's relaxed (head down, muscles and eyes soft, etc) and not showing any signs of distress or pain she's most likely just messing with you and taking a firmer hand/being a clear leader could well be all you need to do to resolve this.

She usually is, she doesn't seem to be tense - in fact she seems to quite like the farrier (she is a bit of a hussy & he is quite cute!) She has tried it on with him before but he takes no nonsense. He thinks she's just making hardwork for herself & trying it on. She's absolutely fine with the backs as he brings them forward to rest on a tripod thingy (:redface:)

I'd be inclined to tie her up (with a haynet if necessary), run the hand down the leg, say "Up" once and pick the foot up. Growl if she messes about and praise if she stands quietly. Once the foot is picked out (and I suspect she probably isn't sore if she doesn't mind the farrier messing with her), put it down for her - don't drop it and don't let her snatch it. Physically place it back on the ground, then reward with a scratch/cuddle/pat/treat/whatever she likes best. Then do the same with the others.

This is spot on what I do at the moment! (Phew, glad it seems I'm doing it right!) The other day I tied her up tighter as she was wondering side to side permanently & it only made her worse - she was getting proper fed up with me although in all honesty I really wasn't helping the situation. She gets LOADS of praise when she does it well. If she tried to snatch I've found holding the hoof with one hand & putting the other on her flexed knee and growling, more often than not, means she does not get her way. I also never drop her feet back on the floor, I always ease them down.
 
I don't tie up for feet, or for anything actually. I find it much easier to work with them loose and then they are not fighting being tied up as well as everything else.

Tobes is a git with his feet, as I have been a BAD owner and not picked them out. I have started dealing with this over the last few weeks, and he now offers to pick the second front foot up for me sometimes - not always.

The first front foot I deal with, I find I have to give him a second or two to get his other feet in position to take his not inconsiderable weight! I read an interesting thing in one of Mark Rashid's books the other day. He was having a problem with getting a horse to lift and keep his foot up when he was young. The old man he learned from saw this, and told him to turn around and lift his own leg up with the heel sticking out to the back. He then proceeded to lift Mark Rashid's leg up high and he of course fell forward.

I try to bear this in mind with regard to them balancing.
 
Just an observation from teaching .many people make life hard for themselves by being too delicate with a hoofpick and so the horse gets bored. I generally clean out mud stones etc in a couple of good 'digs' from back to toe and then finish off with either side of frog/brush sole ..probably less than 15 seconds per hoof.
 
I find that if I'm in a bad mood then maya is worse. If I'm patient and reward her she will stand for ages not even tied up and I can get the rasp on them, spray and pick them.

She is much more responsive to positve reinforcement. I normally know if I'm getting too hotted up becuase she will fart and I know this means she's feeling a bit nervous.
 
Does she have any stiffness issues causing her to want her foot back. Yann is right, you can't cause any harm to a healthy hoof. But any stiffness causing an ache when her leg is held up could be a reason. That said, she may just be trying it on.

I have had a breakthrough this week with feet :) Albert (14 months old) has finally grown a few brain calls and now picks his feet up before I get there :dance: it's something the other 2 do but Albert had a step back after his castration problems and feeling vulnerable with his feet being held thanks to one of the vets- and his pain from legs swelling up. I was so happy the first time he did it. Stood nicely for each one and I only asked for the first fore foot, then the rest he picked up before I got there.

To get this I have been picking his feet out sometimes twice a day but made sure I did it at least once, and all 4 each time. All 4, and with a hat on incase he flew one near me :stomp: lots of praise, scratches (he loves) when he had his feet still and I gave it back if he was good for a few seconds. If he was messing about he didn't get his leg back, and if he really messed about I shot him a dirty look and screamed/made loud noises at him. Simple. I think we have cracked it, he has been really good for about a week now and I even left him a day in-between and no difference.
 
Last edited:
Just an observation from teaching .many people make life hard for themselves by being too delicate with a hoofpick and so the horse gets bored. I generally clean out mud stones etc in a couple of good 'digs' from back to toe and then finish off with either side of frog/brush sole ..probably less than 15 seconds per hoof.

Agreed, It takes me no time to do all 3 and I am quite rough. Although I have been pretend picking with Albert to increase the time so he doesn't get a shock at trimming time.
 
If a dirty great 'oss can gallumph about on his feet, and he is sound, there's little chance of you doing any damage with a hoof pick, no matter how cavalier you get with one. :D :D
 
Yeah ditto that. I get on with it, no fannying about. If I'm using frog disinfectant I have that to hand so Joy doesn't put the foot down and then have to pick it up again.

Luckily she's great with her feet as she's now barefoot and wears boots.

I expect her to let her foot and support it. I refuse to hold it up for her.

I knew the little man was having problems when he started pulling his foot away. He was a bugger when I first got him as he basically stayed in his field and never came out. It didn't take long to set him up to know my expectations and tap into his will to please but it was the change in him that gave the first indication that something was wrong. He's better now he's on his supplement.
 
My big boy had issues around picking up his feet would snack his foot away even cow kicking me:stomp: then I discovered he had leg mites had the jabs and used pig oil and sulphur. Left his feet for a week then when I tried to pick his feet again the memory of the prior discomfort made him wary I released he was playing up so I decided to pick his feet pretending to be a farrier! No eye contact straight in with my shoulder do the job quickly and gentle put his foot down then loads and I mean loads of praise like the best horse in the world:wub:
Tried the treat route but he sussed me and would pick up feet until he got his treat!:tongue:Sneaky ponio.
 
Albi used to give me merry hell with his hind feet, shaking them all around, not kicking out per se but doing that "cycling" motion. Made me reet nervous, it did. Then I noticed he never did it for the farrier when he was trimmed and I realised that I was behaving nervously and he was feeding off of that! So I took myself to task and stopped worrying that he'd boot me... he never has yet so why did I think he would start? And since I no longer pussyfoot around and take a firm grip, even resting his hoof on my knee so that he feels supported, no more problemo's......
 
newrider.com