Riding School Diaries

On the half halts - do you do anything with your seat and legs or just check on the outside rein? I am trying to check on the outside rein, still my seat and push on with my legs all at once - find it impossible! Maybe I'm making it too complicated...

With half halts, I think it depends on what you want it to achieve. If you want to go down a gait, I would sit back and half halt so would be using my seat but put my leg on as soon as we've made the transition so don't lose any of the energy.

If I just wanted to slow the horse into a steady trot, I would half halt and slow the rising but keeping my leg on so the horse didn't go into walk.

If I wanted the horse to collect in trot / canter from extended trot / canter, then I would half halt with my leg on so they didn't go into a downward transition.

So in answer to your question, it is all three!!! Why is nothing simple when it come to riding ???? :giggle:

LBrider, I'm really pleased your lessons are going well. I know what you mean about posting how well everything is going, then suddenly everything goes wrong, that's sod's law :yellowcarded:

Got another lesson tonight, so excited :dance:
 
I was always a total failure in conventional riding school lessons, and this last question may be explains why. The trouble with the new NR categories is that these questions of sitting to trot and half halt should really be discussed in other sections - and have frequently been discussed before.

I am not an RI - but if you havent managed to learn something in the conventional way, I can offer an alternative or two which worked for me.

To sit to trot. Forget your arms and legs. You sit on your seat, right? So to ride trot sitting, you need to understand what is happening under your seat.

It isnt, as you may suppose, a bouncy up and down movement. It is more a side to side movement. The trouble is that most people tense up when they first sit to trot or canter and this is what causes you to bounce up and down in the saddle and lose stability.
Luckily you can experience the same movement in walk. So start in walk by sitting evenly on the two sides of your bottom, weight on your two seat bones. As your horse walks forward you should feel first one side of your seat drop, and then the other. Breathe slow and deep, relax, and count the steps in walk - one two three four - till you get used to the feel.
What you feel through your seat bones are the steps taken by the hind legs of the horse. As he lifts his left hind leg off the ground, you feel your left seat bone dip a little. Imagine a table with one leg missing - that is the corner that dips. Then he lifts the right hind and your right seat bone dips. But as that right hind foot touches ground again, the right seat bone will be lifted, and the left seat bone begin to fall.

The good news is that the movement is the same in trot. Only in trot the rhythm of the gait is 1,2,1,2, because the diagonal legs (e.g. right front and left hind) move in unison. But if you ask for a slow trot and give yourself time to relax and feel through your seat you should feel the alternate dropping of your two seat bones, just as you did in walk.
Once you have felt it, you should allow the horse to move your seat bones, one side, and then the other.

If you are still having trouble with sitting trot, it might be helpful to have a lunge lesson or a lunge lesson bareback. The instructor will control the horse leaving you to think about that rocking movement under your seat.

Feeling the horses hind legs under you, isnt just the key to sitting trot - later it will help you cue the horse at the right moment for lateral work (turning and going sideways) and for the correct lead in canter.


Half halt is confusing terminology as you are not halting the horse at all. My OH doesnt half halt at all, so it isnt exactly esstential. And in riding schools it is often counter productive as students are asked to half halt and then ask for canter.
The half halt is just a couple of touches on the rein with your fourth finger.
It reminds the horse you are riding him -so it is useful out hacking. It collects the horse a little, which means it brings the front end in and the back legs under, so the horse is nicely gathered together to push off into canter. It is hard for a horse to change from a fast, strung out trot to a canter.

In our RS we ride canter from walk, so the half halt isnt needed. Our RI doesnt believe in complicating things. I have only just learned to ride trot canter transitions in the school and it truly felt as if we were almost stationary before the first step of canter. But this mysterious transition is not what riding schools look for when first introducing canter.

As to balance at the corner. There are different opinions on this. Some trainers do teach you to keep your shoulders in line with the shoulders of the horse. Doing this involves twisting your body at the waist because, as the horse goes round a corner, its shoulders and hips are not parallel to each other - they are on different raddii of the same circle.
We learn a different way - that riding circles and going round corners, we remain straight, on our own radius of the imagined circle - our shoulders remain above our hips. This was the method described by Charles Harris who studied at the Spanish School in Vienna and I find it a great help out hacking to be able to picture the centre of the circle as I canter fast round a left corner and keep my balance.
Most riders are crooked to some extent and may find turning in one direction harder to balance than going in the other. To prevent my outside right shoulder creeping forward, I imagine an elastic stretching to the opposite knee, and then stretching it.

I and others have posted these answers before. But I hope it is helpful to add them to this thread.
 
Thank you N_J and Skib, both replies are very helpful. On the half halt, now l've read both of your detailed descriptions I think I do use the half halt all the time but just thought it was something more complicated!!
On sitting trot I am going to try and use your method Skib because I think my problem comes from twisting to one side at the waist and that I need to keep upright and straight (while still moving with the horse!) to solve the problem. I must admit to having never really got the hang of the side to side movement in sitting trot. I've done it on a simulator but on a real horse I find that the best I manage is to move my back so I stay with the forward and back movement, but don't manage side to side as well. Will try again next week and see if I can do it.
Thanks all
 
:biggrin: Good lesson today. Couldn't make my normal lesson last night so had a private lesson. The best thing was my sitting trot - thanks Skib! Because for the first time I managed to move my seat bones separately and I was much better. The only proviso is that, because it was a private lesson, my horse was less inclined to rush - so it will be more difficult back in the group next week. But it was a great feeling - kind of an odd movement but I stayed in the saddle.
On the not so good side I could NOT get my horse on the correct leg in canter on the left rein. Tried at least 10 x :redface: He is bad on that rein but RI said it was also my fault because
1) When I move my outside leg back I also move my inside leg forward so can't give him a strong enough signal to go.
2) When he goes to switch on the the correct leg he does a really odd rocking horse movement and I just sat and let him - if I'd push him on at that point he probably would have gone forward on the right leg. So that is something to work on for next time. Did manage to canter a few 20 metre circles though (on the good leg!)
 
Sophie - I am glad it helped -
But to clarify, I dont think of it as moving one's seat bones - it is more being able to feel one's seat bones dipping - one side of your seat and then the other - as the hind legs move. This is easiest to feel in walk. it is allo9wing the horse to move - not really "moving" oneself.

In trot, it can be very hard to feel on some horses -and easier if I close my eyes! Not a very sensible thing to suggest.

This is not something to worry abut in the long term because it is a bit like riding a bike. Your brain and body seem to absorb the info and you just sit to trot without having to make any conscious effort.
 
Thanks Skib - I think I was allowing him to move them rather than doing it myself.... although I've never moved them before even if I've thought okay just relax and let him move you - so I must have been 'doing' something...
 
Couple of good lessons this week and last. Nothing of great pith and moment to report but nothing dire either -I suppose that's good? Oola the Fjord last week - really stepping out in a very purposeful fashion. It's nice to ride a forward going pony as you can concentrate more on what you're doing than keeping the energy up.

Molly the cob this week. Did her best impression of Molly 'nice but dim'. A poor tawny owl had hit the telephone wires outside the area and crashed to the ground on the floor just outside the arena. RI had spotted it the evening before, but had forgotten to dispose of it. It was totally dead, but one wing was just moving slightly in the breeze. Each time we passed it Molly had to do a double take, ears pricked and have a good "OOOOOhhh, what's that thing?" look at it. And I mean EVERY time, on each rein, and every circuit!:redcarded: "Ooooh" Bless her, she never actually spooked good and proper, but she was thinking about it every time! It was like she forgot about it in between each circuit and then, suddenly, "OOooh - look - a THING!"

We finished up with a few little cross-poles. Molly's not a natural jumper, a little 'heavy' in her style, though she can pop over them well enough. What I did find a bit unsettling was the way she dropped her head just a little coming off the jump. There wasn't a lot in front on the way down, and I found it hard. Probably as she was not exactly fluid
 
Sounds good Selside. I am yet to try jumping, so am very impressed. It is actually much easier to ride a forward going horse isn't it? I find it much more difficult to do everything (I mean everything hand position, leg position, rising to the trot - the lot!) on a horse that is dawdling. Molly sounds a sweety though, I also feel I have something in common with the 'nice but dim' horses!
 
OOh, don't be impressed, Sophie33..........

We are only talking about hopping over knee-high cross poles here! Mind you, when you do get on to jumping (should you wish to) you'll find the same thing applies.

A mount that is more forward going into the jump and hence flows better over it is much easier to learn on than a steady neddy that plods in and heaves him or herself over it!
 
It sounds like everyones lessons are going well.

Sometimes you have a lesson that makes you feel great (like MP's last lesson on another thread) and others just feel 'good'.

My last lesson I was on a big bouncy cob (and I don't usually 'do' big :giggle:) I knew I would have problems with sitting to his trot and was mortified when the ri told us to take away our stirrups. I thought that there was no way I would stay on.

Anyway, I realised that if I concentrated really really hard on keeping my leg in the correct position and on the horse, I was alot steadier. I think I'm gripping with my knees which is making me unsteady. Got my stirrups back and bounced along aarrggghhhh.

Plan for lesson tonight, ride with longer stirrups :wink:
 
It sounds like everyones lessons are going well.

Mine definitely not. I have these lessons from time to time where I can't ride the horse. The common factor last two times is trotting over poles. I know it is good for the horse but I give up. There must be an instinct which auto selects the smooth ground out hacking and confuses both me and the horse if I over-ride it.
 
Awwww sorry that your lesson's aren't going well skib.

I personally don't mind trotting poles and as long as the horse picks his feet up, don't notice that I'm going over them.

BUT once I'm out hacking, I find the ground so uneven it makes me nervous :frown:
 
:banghead::stomp::banghead:Trot without stirrups tonight with our eyes shut. After all this time, I was worse than useless, had to keep grabbing the front of the saddle, knees creeping up, tensed up body with no flexibility. Zero balance and only stayed on by luck. The young kids in the class who have been riding less time than me did a better job. Arggggggh!:stomp::banghead::stomp:

OK, rant over. Pass me the corkscrew........
 
Poor you LBRider - but i'm sure you were better than you think you were. And as a long term sharer of lessons with kids I wouldn't worry about them being better - I think kids are just better at relaxing and going with it than us oldies!
Anyway hope you enjoyed the wine and are feeling better about the lesson now!
 
Thanks Sophie, and yes, feel better as I've decided there's no point in beating myself up over it, waste of energy if I do! Also I had a semi private the next morning where we put a lot of focus onto core stability, lightness of seat, softening of mouth etc, and I did get some spankingly good trot out of her at the end. So all is well.

When is your test? I thought you'd said end of July or did I dream that?
 
Glad you followed up with a good lesson. I often find a really good follows a particularly poor lesson, not sure why though....
My test was going to be at the end of july but different peoples holidays mean it has been put off until September. I'm not complaining...

I had a really fab lesson tonight though... RI put gloves between my calf and horses side to try and stop me moving my legs too much. Dropped them lots of times but definitely helped by making my very conscious of keeping legs wrapped around horsie. And toward the end I once managed to walk, trot and canter and keep them both in place!
And my sitting trot was definitely better again (so wasn't a fluke last time!) thanks Skib.
And in canter I got him on the correct leg on his bad rein (third attempt but still!)
All in all I'm most happy, one of those nights when things seem to click :biggrin:
 
Mirrors!

So, group lesson last night with the shiny new mirrors right across the A end of the arena. Amazingly useful tool, great way to sort out positional issues and also acts as a constant 'nag' for: shoulders back, heels down, shoulders/hip/heel etc.

But.....FLIPPIN' 'EK! I've been moaning about my weight for yonks now, but I saw myself last night and thought Holy C**p! That's incentivised me, I can tell you. It's salad and Hoola Hooping for me from now on.
:hot::bounce::running::spin:
 
I am jealous of the mirrors LBrider. The best we have is areflection in a window in the outdoor school and I find even that useful...
But you can't judge your weight from how you look in jodphurs - I reckon they add at least a stone to everyone!
 
newrider.com