Riding School Diaries

Here is Heather. The clip is rather long but she explains turning at the beginning and end of it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cgqzSRfY-4Y&feature=player_embedded

I've just gone back and re-watched this and have noticed how mobile Heather is in her pelvis as the horse walks out. My RI badgers me to be completely still - I would never get away with that amount of movement. I'm always very careful not to drive and to relax but when I relax, my hips move with the horse :rolleyes:

I think I want Heather as my RI :tongue:
 
She is rather good! In fact you may see a rider trained by her at the next Olympics!

If you sit completely still you will be pushing down on the side of the horses back that want to come up, ie when the hind leg on that side is pushing off the ground. By allowing the seat bones to rise and fall with the horse allowing the horse to dictate the movement it will be more comfortable and walk out more. Obviously you should not drive with the seat (forward motion is from your legs) you can see what happens when Heather demonstrates that :) Heather or any EET or I think any Centered RI would have no problem with you relaxing the hips, in fact we would encourage it! Have a little experiment, relax your hips, then sit "still" and see what happens.
 
...relax your hips, then sit "still" ...

I think this is perhaps what RI is trying to get me to do. I desperately need someone to video me now that my lessons aren't floodlit (thank you daylight savings). I don't feel like anything above my hips is moving, but apparently it won't do! We'll see I guess...*goes off to hunt for the camcorder*
 
Do you think your RI has a problem with your upper body and is trying to sort that by getting you to sit still? Video would be great! The other option is ware a big baggy top so she can't see your hips:)

:giggle: I stopped doing that because she said she couldn't see my shoulders (which tend to be rounded). I *think* my upper body is improving. Will get video ASAP.
 
I really recommend being videoed. I found it really useful to watch myself but also Kathy has very kindly commented on my riding and that has helped a lot. I think I am lucky in my RI as well. Although she is not a follower of Heather she does seem to have a similar approach. She tells me to relax my hips and follow the horses movement rather than to sit still (although that be because my biggest problem has been riding as stiffly a plank of wood!)
 
Following on from my ride on the 'electric 'orse' (Strider) last week, I had a lesson yesterday and didn't tell the RI what I had done.

Mounted dear old Mouse, and RI came out of the tack room, did a double take and said 'wow, what a fantastic long legged riding position you have! You're clearly up for it today!' We did a lot of sitting trot again, building up impulsion through the corners and then using that for the horse to keep a steady pace down the straight in a consistent momentum. Felt really good. RI said several times 'you are REALLY riding well today!' As soon as the lesson was over of course I blurted out that I had been on Strider and she was really impressed and wants to have a go herself now!

A friend who doesn't ride often now (but used to ride a lot and is a naturally very confident person) fancied a hack today at the RS, so I went with her and enjoyed this beautiful weather roaming around the countryside. Perfect reminder of why I want to become a competent rider.

Now, something else I need to ask (ladies only)......

My seat position felt great and helped my balance, so I think I've got it right, but when I got home today and yesterday, HELL, did my 'ladies unmentionables :giggle:' hurt! Ow ow ow! Tried to go to the loo, but nooooo! Too painful! It will wear off later, but come on you lot, be honest, have you ever suffered from this? Do you think I AM sitting badly? Or am I just a weirdo?:ninja:

Answers on a postcard please.......
 
I think you just need to bring your hips more upright as it sounds like you are sitting in a "three point" seat, ie two seat bones and the ahem! pubic arch. By bringing the hips upright you will just be sitting on the seat bones ie your bum! The deeper seat you now have may cause sore seat bones so I really recommend you buy a seat bone saver. You really should not be getting a sore "you know what!" :giggle:
 
Well done LBRider! Must be very satisfying that the improvement after riding Strider was so obvious to your RI. In answer to your question - I used to get this problem really badly - to the point I even bough padded knickers!!:tongue:
It only happens rarely now as I really try and sit back on my seat bones. Sometimes after a lot of sitting trot with no stirrups does still get a bit uncomfy though.
Sounds like Strider really improved your position, but some small adjustments still needed for your own comfort!
 
** hands up** me, it's happened to me!

It only happened on one horse, which I blamed the saddle on but after my teenager had no problems I decided it must have just been the way I was sat :wub:

Mind you, it doesn't help that my jods are really tight, must get some new ones soon.

It sounds like Strider has really helped you LBrider, well done.

My lessons this week have mainly been concentrating on canter. Not been on the whizzy horse, so felt really strange to get a slower canter. Nearly got a full lap of the out door arena (which is bigger than the indoor and has horse eating monsters in every corner!!). Just as we were coming up to the corner where we started, he became unbalanced and went into a rather fast trot. If I'd have thought quickly, I should have brought him back into a steady trot and got back into canter at the next corner (but I don't think that fast!)

Oh well I'll know for next time.
 
Everyone sounds to be doing really well in their lessons. N_J you sound like your having a ball can i have some of what you're having? I am now going to go and catch up with all the links posted.

Pharoah, I'm feeling really good about my riding at the moment. I'm not a great rider or even a good rider, but I'm not feeling like a nervous rider either.

Wish I could bottle this, to save when the nerves come back. :giggle:
 
Thanks for the replies Kathyt1, sophie33 and N_J.

I was having a look around the internet regarding uncomfortable laydees par-tick-u-lars:giggle:, and came across a very old NR thread from about three years ago on this very subject. Most theories for what causes said problem were not relevant to me, and I really DO think my seat is better now - if it was a case of the angle of the pelvis, then I really should have been suffering worse before. BUT, I did suddenly remember that my RI put some kind of strange foam pad wedge under the saddle at the cantle (can't remember what she called it) which was going to protect the horses back and mine during sitting trot. I'm now thinking that this meant that although my seat was correct, this object was actually tilting me forwards with every movement. So, I have two or three weeks with no riding now :cry:while the kids are on hols which should give me time to recover, and when I go back I'll ask them not to put the wedge thingy under the saddle again - we'll see if that helps.

N_J, great to hear how positive you are at the mo. If you do manage to bottle some, please post to me! Know what you mean about reaction times by the way. My thought processes are so slow at times, by the time my horse has done something, I've thought about why, weighed up the pros and cons and decided on a course of action, the lessons over and we're back at the stable! D'oh!
 
It happened to me once - I bled after a lesson and if you rub yourself raw, of course it will sting when you go to the loo.
I used some savlon cream which sorted it out.
I also told the RI at my next lesson.
She was concerned and adjusted the lesson so as to prevent it happening again. Because the content of a lesson can cause this problem. How much sitting trot and sitting canter you do in a lesson and how much work with no stirrups will have an influence - for men as well as women.

You described a lesson in which your stirrups were longer? And you were sitting like a long legged dressage rider? The longer your stirrups the less weight will be in your feet - which means more weight on your seat.
If you ride with your thighs at less of an angle to your spine, that in itself would add to the weight on your seat and possibly tip your pelvis forward.

There is a different of opinion how riders should sit - Your weight is on your two "seat bones" part of the pelvis. But for stability you need a third point. My RI compares it to a camera on a tripod, though the third point is not weight bearing.
Some people use the pelvic bone at the front - were you taught that on Strider?
But we use the the tip of the spine - in other words we sit back rather than forward.
I learned to ride as an oap -when I was already old and stiff - there are saddles and horses on which I cant sit comfortably - horses that are too wide and saddles with high cantles and small seats on which I cant sit comfortably. The more foam, seat savers and blocks that are added, the wider the horse becomes.

I'd love to have a go on Strider and hope I will one day - but as said above - the point of sitting on the horse is not what you look like. It is to feel through your buttocks and hips what the horse's back legs are doing? To feel the movement and allow it - (as KathyT1 posted below). Later on you can regulate the stride and speed of the horse by adjusting the degree to which you allow or block the hind legs. You wont get this feel unless your seat bones are comfortably on the saddle.

It is all too easy for newish riders to go to a new teacher or to a simulator and have a revelation that all we did before was wrong. But there is actually a natural way for each individual to sit on a horse - may be you were doing that already? I put more weight on my right seat bone than my left, because my left hip hurts if I correct it. And you have a sore bottom either because of the content of the lesson - or more likely because you made some radical changes to fit the copy book model - whereas in real life neither a person nor a living horse has a perfect body.
 
EE does not recomend the 3 point seat as stability is not really what you are looking for when sat on a moving object. Stability as such comes from the core muscles and the ability of your lower back and hips to move and keep the lower part of the body seperate from the upper. Some classical teachers do recomend the three point though, including Sylvia Loch. I am not sure about RWYM, maybe somebody could confirm this?
 
Wow - it seems like you are all doing really well while I've been on holiday! Congrats Sophie33 on passing your test, and how exciting to try 'Strider' LBrider. He sounds another very useful 'tool' to add into the learning experience box.

I had a complete change last week, on hols in Suffolk. I decided to try and find somewhere to have a ride, as it's good to try somewhere new where you arrive with a clean slate. I'd taken a couple of tel.no's with me, but one was always on voicemail and the other not recognised, so I ended up going somewhere about 1/2 hour drive away that did a bit of everything. They offer 'normal' riding, western, vaulting, carriage driving, offer horses and ponies for 'baiting' and they have a herd of Camargues !

I had asked if it was possible to join a group lesson (I know some places won't take an unknown rider into a group) and the nice lady I spoke to agreed it would be OK as I had some prior experience. My small RS doesn't have enough adult riders to really be able to do group lessons, so I have weekly 1/2 hour private ones. I spend the next day wondering if I should have asked more about lesson content in case they were too advanced and wanted to stuff I hadn't tackled. But I needn't have worried.

When I got there I found they also had a camel! Friendly welcome, quick rider experience form to complete and I was told where to find my horsey. Found a gentle looking Camargue standing quietly in the stall, ready tacked up. Just had to attach the reins (odd clip on fixing like a dog's lead?) and take him out. Luckily the great weather meant we could have the lesson outside, even at 7pm. Four of us altogether, 2 lads and 2 lasses, riding 2 smallish greys and 2 big cobby types.

Pretty good experience, pleasant and clear instruction from an observant instructor (particularly good a spotting small errors - such as shoulder position in circles, etc.) My mount seemed a sweetie, perfectly suitable to offer an unknown quantity such as I was. I think he was quite elderly, a bit bony in places, narrow of wither compared to my usual British native types. But they were all quite willing and forward going.

Lots of trot work, with circles, serpentines and so on. My ponio quite competitive and keen to keep up with the bigger hairies ahead, so I could concentrate on getting my riding right rather than keeping him going. Rather oddly I found he was very willing in follow-me mode, but switched off like someone had pulled the batteries out when he found himself at the front! You could feel the 'go' just drain away. Strange.

This meant that the first canter attempt wasn't great. He had been very quick off the leg in walk and trot, so I assumed he would be the same in canter and asked quite politely and with small aids. This had little effect, and I had to smile when I found myself being 'chased' round the corner by the RI. I haven't been 'whoosed' at by an RI since I was about 9 or 10, so that was quite funny.

Once I realised he needed real encouragement when on his own it was fine, and he had a lovely smooth canter, and was easy to keep going once you had been specific and insistent about really wanting canter! After canter to rear of ride on both reins we moved on to work without stirrups. Again, this was really pretty enjoyable, he was easy to keep loose and sit deep on. There were a couple of hairy moments when he got a bit too keen to keep up with the bigger horses in front and really started extending briskly. I had a moment when I started to tense up with the extra speed and began to ping up from the saddle slightly. (RI "Try to sit lightly, Anne" - yeh, right, if I'm not careful I'm going to be sitting lightly on the sand soon) Made myself relax again and found I could disengage lower limbs and sit softly even when whizzing a bit - though my hips did feel to be swinging VERY actively!)

So it was mainly fun, not scary at all, thanks to a kindly instructor and very experienced RS pony who was clearly a past master at going steady for beginners, but will engage and step up for others. I liked the cool down too. After a good stretch round we had to aim for the slowest and most collected walk round the short ends, and then the biggest striding stretchy speediest walk we could manage along the long side. I loved this, and my ponio was a master at it - we got great transitions between the 2 stages, and he got a lovely disengaged lollopping hoof flinging walk that was a fraction away from being trot.(Sorry, can't describe that very well) It felt great, and he felt 16hh, like a real big horsey!

Apart from a couple of small things I was not too keen on a good experience, and some useful learning points. Realised I still fall back into bad habits in new situations (leaning forward into canter, like a maiden aunt hunching forward in the back seat of the old car to help it up the hill!, keeping too sharp a contact when the pony is rushing rather than using seat and small give & take through the reins. I know what to do, just don't always manage to do it)

Finished off by walking the ponios out to their field in the gathering gloom. Nice end to a day. Pint of prawns to anyone who got this far ( we ate lots of seafood whilst near the coast too!
 
I dont think that three point seat is an expression which helps any. Because the notional "third" point - regardless of back or front - is not in any way fixed to the horse, nor creating a rigid rider.

Now, I am not an athlete and up to any of you smart dressage riders, but I have a deteriorating low spine and would be in considerable pain if I rode with my weight on the tip of it.
 
newrider.com