Saddle fit advice please

laceyfreckle

Well-Known Member
May 27, 2007
9,685
42
48
Essex/Suffolk
I would like some advice on the fit of my saddle please :-)

All advice/comments appreciated.

The saddle is a 17.5" T6 Cob saddle which has a medium wide gullet in it at the moment (no fish inserts in)
Harvey is a 13.3hh pony who is recovering from muscle wastage probs slowly. He is quite hard to keep weight on and was a bit dirty when these were taken, sorry.

Here he is without saddle on
002-17.jpg

005-18.jpg

He isn't bum high, just pic angle
Here's my saddle without saddlecloth etc
006-20.jpg

007-16.jpg

010-12.jpg

more to follow
 
I thought the fit looked ok, but there is only just under 3 fingers room under the pommel when unmounted and 2 fingers when mounted. He does still have a bit of muscle wastage but it is better then it was. I thought about adding a riser pad underneath until his muscles improve more (still has a hollow behind each shoulder) . I would have to ride without the riser pad and without a saddlecloth for shows though (first one in three weeks).

Pics with the riser pad

012-16.jpg

013-13.jpg

014-15.jpg

015-14.jpg

017-11.jpg

btw the skin wrinles in the above pic is just Harvey , he has really loose skin which is kind of odd.
 
Personally I'd say a 17.5inch saddle is to big for a pony of this size. It is generally a horse size saddle and would have thought a 16.5 would be a better size.

Also IF the saddle has been "fitted" to the body while there is muscle waistage he will struggle to put on muscle as there isnt the space for the muscle to grow into. Imagine him muscled up, the saddle would be to tight. It is generally better to have a saddle that is alittle wide and pad it out with a sheepskin, thus giving space for muscle to grow into. By adding the riser you are restricting space evn more. However without hands on I cant say if there is space under your saddle for musle growth :D
 
Last edited:
The main thing about it is, as mentioned, it is too long for him. It will be putting the rider's weight too far back and so he will find it impossible to muscle up as working correctly will be nigh on impossible for him. He needs more like a 16" saddle.
 
I also dont like the riser pad, in some of the pics the saddle is actually catching just on the edge of the pad so I think that might cause pressure points, you need to check whether the saddle goes past the last rib? My saddle fitter always says you should use as much of the back as possible to spread your weight but never go beyond the last rib, in the same respect there is no point having a small saddle because its a pony then ALL of your weight is on one small area of the pony's back.
 
Forgot to mention the saddle fitting history lol:-

Has cost me a fortune in fitting so far. Bought the saddle about 10 months ago from a good saddlery with a qualified (and well reccmmended by others) saddle fitter. Saddle cost £450 new + £60 to fit it. Bought it with medium wide gullet and with thin fish in. Chosen because it is interchangeable with gullets etc. Saddle needed re-fitting after 4 months which cost me a further £60 for the fitting + £20 to adjust the flocking and the fish was taken out. I wasn't happy with how the saddle fitted and Harvey wasn't very forward going in it so called the saddle fitter back out 8 weeks after the last visit, different fitter, same company. cost of £60 for the fitting, Gullet was changed to a wide but then was very low on his wither, wintec riser was sold to me for £14.99 and told to use that until his muscles/topline improved, fish put back in.

this was ok for a while but he started getting evasive under saddle and resenting girthing etc, also has difficulty with getting canter and his trot got very choppy. Saw a bowen lady who sorted out a couple of issues, she said his saddle was much too wide, without the riser it practically sat on his wither. so I had a play around put the medium gullet back in, put the fish in but it looks like it pinches on his shoulder with the fish in so took them back out.

With the riser there is a good three fingers clearence.

Where as I could get another saddler to be honest I've spent so much money on them this year and still haven't had a saddle that was 100%.
 
His muscle wastage has improved just not as much as I hoped. The original idea with riding in the riser pad over winter was that his muscles would have improved.

This is what his muscle wastage looked like when I got him (about 11 months ago)


012-17.jpg


end of last summer

002-1-1.jpg


and taken yesterday
001-13-1.jpg
 
Personally I'd say a 17.5inch saddle is to big for a pony of this size. It is generally a horse size saddle and would have thought a 16.5-17inch would be a better size.

Also IF the saddle has been "fitted" to the body while there is muscle waistage he will struggle to put on muscle as there isnt the space for the muscle to grow into. Imagine him muscled up, the saddle would be to tight. It is generally better to have a saddle that is alittle wide and pad it out with a sheepskin, thus giving space for muscle to grow into. By adding the riser you are restricting space evn more. However without hands on I cant say if there is space under your saddle for musle growth :D

I have added previous saddle fitting history now, :)

The main thing about it is, as mentioned, it is too long for him. It will be putting the rider's weight too far back and so he will find it impossible to muscle up as working correctly will be nigh on impossible for him. He needs more like a 16" saddle.

I also dont like the riser pad, in some of the pics the saddle is actually catching just on the edge of the pad so I think that might cause pressure points, you need to check whether the saddle goes past the last rib? My saddle fitter always says you should use as much of the back as possible to spread your weight but never go beyond the last rib, in the same respect there is no point having a small saddle because its a pony then ALL of your weight is on one small area of the pony's back.

I did have my own ponderings on the saddle length. I did ask the saddler when it was bought and she said it was fine (I didn't specify what length saddle I wanted as he didn't have a saddle when this one was bought) She did show me that if you follow the feathered whorl (where the stifle is) up to the topline in a curve you can still get a hands width between that and the cantle.

It IS one of those thing I sit and look at and wonder if it is or isn't though.

Don't really know why I ended up with such a long saddle though as I'm only5ft 2 and just over 10stone so not exactly huge, if anything I do find the saddle a bit big for me, but I put that down to having a 12.3hh pony before with a 16.5" saddle.

I hate the riser pad :o but it's the only way I can think of to get it higher over the wither without making the saddle out of balance.
 
I now avoid giving saddle fitting advice on an open forum ;) but have to say, whatever made the saddle fitter put a 17.5" saddle for a 5'2" rider on a 13.3hh pony?? Can you mark on one of the pics (or on Harvey with some chalk) where his last rib is for me please? (as kayjayhorses mentions).

I would say that this saddle isn't a good fit as it is, with or without the riser pads. I agree with what Madaz_Maddy says.
 
I now avoid giving saddle fitting advice on an open forum ;) but have to say, whatever made the saddle fitter put a 17.5" saddle for a 5'2" rider on a 13.3hh pony?? Can you mark on one of the pics (or on Harvey with some chalk) where his last rib is for me please? (as kayjayhorses mentions).

I would say that this saddle isn't a good fit as it is, with or without the riser pads. I agree with what Madaz_Maddy says.

I will check the saddle size tonight but am pretty sure it is a 17.5" if not it would be a 17" but I'm pretty sure it was 17.5" as I was surprised at the time.

I will mark on Harvey with chalk the entirety of his last rib and then put the saddle on and take a pic :D.

btw I did contact Juddpurs to come out, they arranged to come out but then forgot to email me details of appointment and cost etc. They were meant to rearrange but have heard nothing from them since other then they'll get back to me :confused:

Looks like I'm going to have to have a saddler out again though, thinking of trying Katie Eaton. Been through most of the saddlers round here now.:o

Just hope I can get some money back on my 'nearly new' saddle!
 
Im no expert on saddle fitting i have someone coming out to fit a saddle to my mare on the 29th but from previous enquiries id made i was told id be looking at a 17.5" and im 5'6 same weight as you and my horse is 16.1hh dont know if that helps any. When i first seen the saddle my first impression was big saddle on a little pony? Good luck i hope you get it sorted theres nothing worse than spending alot of money on something for it not to work out xx
 
I also by no means am a saddle fitter or know much about the subject but have been advised that due to muscle wastage, until horsey builds up muscle under the saddle, to use a half size gel pad. Apparently it's kinder on the muscles and allows blood to flow to them around the wither area - otherwise the weight of the rider and saddle can cut the cirulation off, leading to her having aching legs & therefore why she might sometimes nap.

Don't know if it's any help but thought it might be worth a mention?!

Trouble is with saddler fitters is you can seek several opinions and they will all be different - how do you know who is 'right', if there is such a thing, and which advice is the best to follow? I always feel it's a bit like a minefield...
 
Laceyfreckle, I'll kick Bob's butt for you severely. I'll ring him later. Sorry....Although I don't know why I'm sorry....I don't work for him anymore!! ;)

Just spoken to Bob's wife Cathy, she explained that when she phoned you to tell you Bob was half an hour late for your appointment due to an accident, and was just down the road... it transpired that you had emailed to change the appointment and Cathy hadn't got the email! ;) As far as Cathy understood, you were going to phone and re-schedule. Just seems like a slight communication breakdown - Bob is VERY reliable and worth the appointment. :D

Cathy is available now, if you phone her on 01986 874800 she will re-schedule you an appointment - she told me to ask you to call her. :D

Hope this helps - I will act as Juddpurs International Liaison! :D
 
Last edited:
Laceyfreckle, I'll kick Bob's butt for you severely. I'll ring him later. Sorry....Although I don't know why I'm sorry....I don't work for him anymore!! ;)

Just spoken to Bob's wife Cathy, she explained that when she phoned you to tell you Bob was half an hour late for your appointment due to an accident, and was just down the road... it transpired that you had emailed to change the appointment and Cathy hadn't got the email! ;) As far as Cathy understood, you were going to phone and re-schedule. Just seems like a slight communication breakdown - Bob is VERY reliable and worth the appointment. :D

Cathy is available now, if you phone her on 01986 874800 she will re-schedule you an appointment - she told me to ask you to call her. :D

Hope this helps - I will act as Juddpurs International Liaison! :D

Aaah ok, yes all the above is correct, except she said she was going to call/email back with cost and rearrange appointment lol.

I will give them a call.

ETA: Have called them and they're going to try and ift me in with Karen in a couple of weeks, They are going to phone back later today to confirm.
Callout is £40 which is better then I have been paying or free if buy a saddle over £300
 
Last edited:
Cathy called me back to let me know you were all sorted. :D

Karen is lovely. :) I hope they can sort you and Harvey out. :)

Thanks and me too!

I must have sounded really bad on the phone though because Cathy asked me i fI had a mobile number and I remembered I don't have as of yesterday as I happened to put it in the washing machine (in my yard coat pocket) :o:mad::eek: and it failed to survive.

(Think I'm having a bad week, also trying to make a pokemon cake for my sons birthday sunday and have managed to fail on 9 out of 10 royal icing recipies found on the net. The 10th recipe worked but now I don't want to see icing sugar ever ever again)
 
Saw a bowen lady who sorted out a couple of issues, she said his saddle was much too wide, without the riser it practically sat on his wither. so I had a play around put the medium gullet back in, put the fish in but it looks like it pinches on his shoulder with the fish in so took them back out.
QUOTE]

The two issues you talk about here says to me that the saddle is of poor fit to this pony.

The saddle is to narrow and pinches.

So you make it wider and it sits to low.

Therefor it isnt going to fit. He needs a wider saddle with either a high pommel clearence or cut back head. This design doesnt suit his shape.
 
newrider.com