That's a first my instructor made me cry

Sounds too pressured to me. Riding is all about leisure time and havng fun along with the learning;) I do wonder if you should try a different RI??

Whatever you decide, best of look and don't let it get you down. A little progress is always a bonus, be your main aim is fun;)
 
My RI has never ever made me cry. I've had a few since coming back to riding 3/4years ago and none of them have brought me to tears. They've all been good at commending me when I'm doing right and in fact the last one I had at the RS kept saying she enjoyed teaching me cos when she asked me to do something (heels down, leg on, sit up straight, etc, etc) I did it right away which meant she wasn't getting frustrated with me like she probably did with other pupils. She was great for praising me and we had a really good relationship. My new instructor is a lot harder on me but very fair and also gives me plenty of praise. I think she's grown to like me and is really pleased to see how much I've improved in my riding and she was impressed to hear I've even managed to gallop with Maple, which the mere thought of -a couple of months ago -would have filled me with terror!

I think a good RI would never make you cry - you should always come away from a lesson feeling positive about something, even if for you it all went horribly wrong - you have to look at the positive, and your RI is there to help you see what that is because that's what will keep you motivated and wanting to push yourself more next time to become a better rider! ;)
 
My RI has never ever made me cry. I've had a few ...They've all been good at commending me ...the last one kept saying she enjoyed teaching me cos when she asked me to do something .. I did it right away which meant she wasn't getting frustrated with me like she probably did with other pupils. ;)

that's nice. I wonder if her less than perfect pupils (like me..) would have been reduced to tears if they couldnt keep up.

I have cried tears of frustration when I have felt my riding ability was not up to the group I was in occasionally - and cried when it hasnt gone right due to frustration.

My instructor has occasionally had me crying, I hate it, she hates it. But she's also generous with praise.
 
I have cried in lessons, but that was alway usally due to me (in hindsight its due to me being pathetic!) it has NEVER been my RI fault that i have cried. She has never shouted abuse or be littled me or i simply wouldnt have her as a instructor. Riding is something which i enjoy and i wouldnt put up with it if someone was making me upset enough to cry.
 
God no! Horsemanship lessons are something I enjoy and love, tears of happiness is all I would expect! I have however watched no end of friends come back crying from horsemanship clinics after being shouted out, ignored etc. yet they still go back. Don't understand it myself . . . .
 
I have however watched no end of friends come back crying from horsemanship clinics after being shouted out, ignored etc. yet they still go back. Don't understand it myself . . . .

Because horsemanship RI are thin on the ground and when you add up the travelling and costs they don't think they can have anyone else come out i expect.
 
I've cried frm frustration in a lesson, with my instructor pushing me, but it taught me a valuable lesson about not giving up even when I want to. I was told to approach a jump and do it from trot but the horse I was on was very spirited and absoloutly flew at jumps. Everytime I got near the jump, the horse would go into canter. It took about 15 minutes of approach and circle away in trot with me in tears before we were able to jump from trot. I did hte jump once, and my instructor let me finish there. But the following week, I managed to get the horse to jump from trot in the first 3 tries.
 
I was very worried about having instruction again after the sarcastic bitchyness I had to put up with as a child but my Parelli Instructers are so positive and supporting I find myself doing things I'd never have expected swithout being asked:)
 
I actually have some kind of RI phobia! Because when I used to ride when I was about 11 or 12, my first instructor seemed to pick on me and upset me a lot, and my second instructor started off nice but then turned out just like the other one.

I'm 27 now and only just got back into riding again a couple of months go, still very wary of instructors. Fortunately though I seem to have found a really amazing one :D
 
Because horsemanship RI are thin on the ground and when you add up the travelling and costs they don't think they can have anyone else come out i expect.

Yeah, perhaps, personally if people are out of line for no good reason with the human it makes me think they could be the same with the horse, I have witnessed this many times also. I'd rather save up and go and learn from someone who I know I can trust in this way and only have a couple of lessons with a year, then stay with someone I'm not 100% with. My opinion has come with a lot of trial and error however so it's each to their own! :)
 
Reply

I haven't had my current Riding instructor shout at me, but before I moved the instructor looked down at me because I couldn't do something. But where I am now I have cried a couple of times becuase I got frustrated at myself for not doing something right. Anyone else cried because they got frstrated at themselves or is it just me?:eek:
 
not frustrated becuase i can't do something no. i don't believe in the word can't i use currently not quite there yet.
 
one insturctor has- my horse cantered off on a hack- not cloud!! and i couldnt stiop, horse swerved, i fell off. i got screamed at to get back on, that i was not pulling hard enough, useless ruining the horse etc. i also got told that when sed horse would not jump a jump, that i was ruining him- this horse had only been ridden by expeirenced riders- and i am not so much! and was to small, for him- had been riding a 12hh and put on a 15 hh!
have cried at pc camp cos i got jumped off again cos i tip forward sometimes and couldnt belive i fell off again!lol
 
yep a couple at the RS have. My freelance instructor never has made me cry though but we are very good friends and i have cried on her before off the horse so dont think she would want me snotting on her because of something she did lol!! :p
 
Last edited:
Glad you had an apology, I really dislike any instructor who is capable of making their students cry :( Fear or frustration is different, intimidation and humiliation is just not what riding should be about!

My old RS had a short term, stand-in instructor once. He told me to "tuck" when going over a trotting pole, I had no idea what the word meant! So I tried to do a jumping position, but it wasn't great... roll on the "What the hell are you doing?! Do you not care about that horse at all?!? You don't deserve to ride him... etc...." That was the first time he made me cry. The second time was when I had a jumping lesson over a combination in the dark and the aforementioned instructor resorted to thwacking Laurrie in the sheath when he kept refusing... Stupid man. I hate him!

I hope this was a one off, hopefully it won't happen again now that you RI has realised they were in the wrong :) Best of luck x
 
Not so hot on instructors myself, really hard to get a decent one who doesnt think that they are better than you. Where does all that come from?
Either they yell at you or ignore you and dont bother answering your questions. Sorry just a bit peed off with my RS at the moment they just dont seem that approachable think I will be looking about again.
 
I have cried many times at lessons. Falling usually does that to me but that isn't a problem. I also get really freaked out sometimes and panic over something can easily do and end up in tears. My RI rarely has anything to do with it. She tries to avoid it happening. She tries everything to get me to stop and just go do it. Soemtimes it even works. Mainly I just need a little time to calm down and think about it. It is really embarassing though.
 
Not so hot on instructors myself, really hard to get a decent one who doesnt think that they are better than you. Where does all that come from?
Either they yell at you or ignore you and dont bother answering your questions. Sorry just a bit peed off with my RS at the moment they just dont seem that approachable think I will be looking about again.

at the moment i don't know when my next lesson is, i've asked twice and not had a reply. normally over winter they tend to vanish as i've not had facilities but this winter i will have.

i can't help thinking maybe they are bored with teaching me and i'm to take a hint?
 
one of my RIs was up her own bottom, she regularly told us how she would have the horse working in an outline if SHE was riding it...yeh right!
someone complained about her rude attitude too and she changed her tune:p
My current RI who is also YO can be very rude, told me once that if she was the horse i was riding, she would floor me, just because I give a huge 'sqeeze' going over the jump, at wrong time and landed around horses neck....this was said infront of others...if i had of been a teenager id have probably been cut to the cookie:rolleyes: but i wanted to get off and smack her one cheeky cow:mad: even though i was wrong, I am learning :mad:
 
newrider.com