Fear of roller!! - LONG!

gordysgirl

New Member
Dec 8, 2004
2,377
0
0
Derbyshire
Visit site
We have a 4yr old Nf on our yard, he was backed last year but has done little. He was a very easy youngster, always quite bold & confident but incredibly sensible & was always fabulous with children. His owner (quite novice) rode him a little last year & early this year mostly out with me. We didn't do much other than get him used to going out on the road & around fields, not much more than the odd trot here & there. Due to other commitments he has been out of work for a while.

About a month ago she popped a roller on him to lunge him, he was tied up happily on the yard when he flipped all of a sudden, snapped the baling twine & bronked around the yard. Unfortunatley no one was able to catch him (wasn't there so am just relaying story in this instance) & he then jumped 5 bar gate (he's about 14hh) back into field where he eventually calmed down he was caught.

So I started to help her out, we took it all very slowly & went back to groundwork, she had a few leading issues so we got on top of those. We did work on the road & in the field to get him listening to her & for her to regain confidence as she had become quite scared of him. Over the weekend we put the roller back on again, he got quite worried to start with but after a couple of minutes was fine & happily ate his hay, We left it at that.

The next day we put it back on & took him for a walk & he was perfect, didn't bat an eyelid. And again we fed him with it on loosly just so he associated it with nice things. He was fine.

Yesterday we put it on & he stood quietly, then once again he flipped - this time he tried to jump gate & didn't make it, not only has he hurt himself but he has destroyed the gate too! He was quite badly shaken & he is extremley sore this morning.

I have come to the conclusion that pushing the roller issue is not a good plan but we need to move forwards somehow. It is definately a fear thing, he is not being naughty, but we have no idea what has triggered this off as he has always been fine with the roller previously.

We are going to try & sort some kind of round pen if possible but in the mean time any ideas on how we could progress? I have suggested we continue with his groundwork for now, and once again their confidence in each other is low. Sellign him on is not an issue, and to be fair if she was to sell him, I would probably buy him!

Should we move on to putting a saddle back on & see how he goes. It might just be a roller thing, but I would not want to suggest her getting back on until we have some clue as to why he is frightened?

Any ideas would be much appreciated.
A whole tin of cookies for reading this!!:)
 
At 4 years old he is only young, and if he hasn't any experience of rollers previously, he will just be warey and unsure of them. In my opinion, as he isn't being naughty, with repitition he should lose his fear. IF you think it's an option try putting the roller on, just while the pony is stood, for a short period of time, then remove it. Do this a good few times and hopefully he will learn it isn't anything to fear. :)
 
Is it possible that he's sore in his girth area? It sounds a bit like a response to pain to me. He could have a tiny sore spot, or even a thorn that is hard to find especially with hairy winter coats. I mentioned a thorn as it would explain why he only sometimes flips with the roller on. I have also known this kind of thing happen with sore withers as a result of a winter of being rugged.

If he is not sore I would persevere with the roller with plenty of padding, in an enclosed space, maybe in his stable to start with then moving into a school or similar on the lunge. I wouldn't try the saddle, personally, until he's happy - too expensive to replace if he damages it!
 
He had the roller on lots last year & earlier this year, she wasn't doing anything different with him than normal. We have thoroughly checked over the roller for any pressure points & have checked him over & there doesn't appear to be any sore patches.

I would like to persevere, although I am concerned that we cannot hold him if he goes berserk & I don't want him to damage himself or us.

Would it be sensible to try again when(more like if actually) we have a round pen & let him run it off & just keep persevering with it?
 
If there is definitely no pain I think all you can do is persevere. (It may be worth getting him checked by a physio or similar in case there is any deep muscle pain for example. I think I would start with leaving it on him in the stable. I would probably try leaving it on for longer periods, removing it before he complains, rather than letting him run it off but I don't know the pony so your way may be better for him.
 
First, you have to determine whether it is the roller which is causing this behaviour, or if it may be something else setting him off, and it's just coincidence that he has had the roller on each time.

It may be a tying-up issue/other horses' movements around/any amount of other things which cause him to take the initial fright.

When I put a roller on a horse I always do a bit of work with them to settle them into the roller. That way they get to feel how it feels, and it allows them to become comfortable wearing one.

Only after fifteen minutes, or so, doing some simple in-hand work, would I then tie the horse up and expect him to stand for a similar period, keeping him under observation during that time.

There are several possible problems with this youngster, perhaps a fear of the roller, perhaps a fear of being restrained (with, or without tack). It could be insecurity, or may be when other horses are near to/away from him.

With young horses you can't really expect them to accept anything for longer than a few minutes here and there; you can gradually extend the time as they progress.

I wouldn't leave him in the roller in his stable as he may seriously injure himself if he takes fright.

You could try having him on a lunge rope and, without tying him, run the hand end of the rope through a tie-ring (not twine, as it has to be free running) and move away from him, but keep hold of the rope. The rope now goes from your hand, through the tie-ring and on to the halter/headcollar. You can now stand quietly and observe him, and try to see what is causing his behaviour.

If he decides to go you have control over him as he will be able to back off, but he can't break anything and get loose. You'd then 'play' him on the rope and, as soon as he stops, let the rope go slack, praise him, and ask him with the rope to step forward again.

That will teach him that he has room to move, and is not restrained tightly, so that he can come to terms with his fears, and also that he cannot just break things and run away.

He runs back to his field because he feels safe there. You must try to give him support and praise (when good) so that he can feel confident out of his field too.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
First, you have to determine whether it is the roller which is causing this behaviour, or if it may be something else setting him off, and it's just coincidence that he has had the roller on each time.

It may be a tying-up issue/other horses' movements around/any amount of other things which cause him to take the initial fright.

When I put a roller on a horse I always do a bit of work with them to settle them into the roller. That way they get to feel how it feels, and it allows them to become comfortable wearing one.

Only after fifteen minutes, or so, doing some simple in-hand work, would I then tie the horse up and expect him to stand for a similar period, keeping him under observation during that time.

There are several possible problems with this youngster, perhaps a fear of the roller, perhaps a fear of being restrained (with, or without tack).

With young horses you can't really expect them to accept anything for longer than a few minutes here and there, you can gradually extend the time as they progress.

I wouldn't leave him in the roller in his stable as he may seriously injure himself if he takes fright.

You could try having him on a lunge rope and, without tying him, run the hand end of the rope through a tie-ring (not twine, as it has to be free running) and move away from him, but keep hold of the rope. The rope now goes from your hand, through the tie-ring and on to the halter/headcollar. You can now stand quietly and observe him, and try to see what is causing his behaviour.

If he decides to go you have control over him as he will be able to back off, but he can't break anything and get loose. You'd then 'play' him on the rope and, as soon as he stops, let the rope go slack, praise him, and ask him with the rope to step forward again.

That will teach him that he has room to move, and is not restrained tightly, so that he can come to terms with his fears, and also that he cannot just break things and run away.

He runs back to his field because he feels safe there. You must try to give him support and praise (when good) so that he can feel confident out of his field too.


Thanks for the response. We no longer tie him up with roller on as when the initial issue started he was tied up so I had him on a long ish lead rope & held him, however i am no match for scared pony.

We did consider putting lunge line on & trying it in the field as sort of a half way house with the other horses around him? Or would that just be doing it his way?

I agree with not putting him in stable, I had advised owner against doing this as I would think it ishighly likely he will hurt himself & is he did get upset it is too small a space to go in without the liklihood of person getting hurt too.

The idea of tie ring is a good one, will give him a few days for his leg to settle down firstly then start again. We have tried to take it very slowly & calmly, but as you say at some point he has to learn to trust us & he can't run away from every situation he is unsure about (although I appreciate this is what his natural instinct is telling him to do.)

Thansk for all your help.

Heres hoping we can make some slow progress & yesterdays situation doesn't reoccur.
 
however i am no match for scared pony.

You won't hold him on a head collar, but you could on a training halter, if you trained him onto it first.

.[/QUOTE]We did consider putting lunge line on & trying it in the field as sort of a half way house with the other horses around him? Or would that just be doing it his way?..[/QUOTE]

I wouldn't do that..........you could end up in a tangle with the possibility of a stampede with trailling/flying lunge rope to keep them going.:eek:
 
You culd try putting on something soft, like a crepe or elastic exercise bandage in place of the roller. Try just laying it over his back first, and then fasten loosely with a quick untie knot or bow. This is the TTEAM way of starting a young horse and getting it used to the feel of something around its middle, so taking a step back and doing this might just help.
 
I'd definitely do a pain check first, just to double check. Pain around the shoulders can very often first show up when something tight (roller/ saddle) is put on. There must be a reason why he's started doing this when he was presumably fine last year, and pain would be the thing that certainly springs to mind.

Assuming that's clear, I'd start off with an elasticated surcingle. It's not a roller, but will mimic to some extent the feel with a roller, with the advantage that it will flex when he moves. So he gets used to there being something there, without it being restricting. When he's ok with that, I'd go on to a roller with an elasticated girth, so there is more restriction but still some give.

Working in the field sounds like it would be your best bet as that's where he's always heading back to, so in the short term it's the best place to reduce your accident potential. The downside is that he might see the field more as his space and you'll have less control, which isn't a good position to be in if you have the roller half on or off. I wouldn't see that doing it his way is the same as giving in to him or something though. If it gets him happy and comfortable with something in surroundings that he's happiest in, there isn't really a problem as long as it's safe (which may be your issue in the field).

I'd also though do some work first, doing something he's settled and happy with doing. Sometimes with youngsters it can be easier to introduce something at the end of a work session than at the start - for example, my youngster when I first saw him was being introduced to wearing boots. For a few sessions he was worked with no boots on, then at the end of the session, the boots were put on and at first he was asked to just take a couple of steps, then they were taken off. That progressed to putting them on partway through working him, so he gradually learned to work in them, then they could be put on at the start.
 
We use a pressure halter on him for most things other than tying up. He responds much better to it than a standard headcollar.

Zingy - will try the elasticated surcingle & see how it goes.

Maybe a compromise would be to do work in field but when other horses are in. I could possibly leave mine out as am happy that he wouldn't get in the way but might provide Bart with some moral support, I have been using him as lead horse to give bart some confidence out & about.

I figured with the field he is less likely to damage himself if he gets loose or panics, at least he wouldn't be on concrete or near a gate!

So, keep up with the groundwork & then slowly introduce a surcingle until he is totally happy with it, then move on to re introducing a roller & so on. Owner is happy to take it as slow as needs be which is good as I think this may take some time to resolve.

Its just so strange how he has gone from a happy relaxed pony to a very nervous panicky state without any particular reason that we can identify.

I really hope it works out as he is such a lovely pony.
 
Can you not get an oldish roller from some where...put it on so he is comfortable then bang him out for the day with it on...keeping an eye on him. Do you use a pad at all? It could be that its pinching either the roller or a girth...so a girth sleeve may also help. Use of a different roller with a different weight/texture? Placing it slightly further back? There are lots of things you could try to help him tell you what is wrong :p I would stick with him with this one as he is only young. Might be worth getting a physio to give him a once over...if its muscular it could tweek every so often and he may feel as though the roller is restricting/eating him
 
Yeh we've had a good play & initially I thought is was the pad underneath as it was alight colour & I thought he might be catching it out of the corner of his eye, so I have removed it.

Think she has physio over at some point to give him a check over.

hadn't thought of turning him out with it on, its not an expensive roller so it wouldn't matter if it got destroyed, though i think i would still be having heart palpitations if he panicked!! Will suggest it to owner & see what she thinks. If we did that on a weekend when someone was around all day then he could be supervised.

Hmm...lots of food for thought there though guys, will pass it all on to owner & have a good think about it.

There is no way he'll be given up on, he's too lovely, just wanted to get a few more ideas on how to deal with it.
 
And i presume it does the trick otherwise you wouldn't do it.
i think that sounds like a viable option. Have spoken to owner, we will start with the surcingle, then move to turning out with roller on!

I can imagine the looks we'll get having him turnout in a saddle!
 
He had the roller on lots last year & earlier this year, she wasn't doing anything different with him than normal. We have thoroughly checked over the roller for any pressure points & have checked him over & there doesn't appear to be any sore patches.

I would like to persevere, although I am concerned that we cannot hold him if he goes berserk & I don't want him to damage himself or us.

Would it be sensible to try again when(more like if actually) we have a round pen & let him run it off & just keep persevering with it?

Hi I dont think letting him go nutso in pen is going to help him because he has got to the panic state, you need to gradually put roller on dont try lungeing just put it on give him a carrot and take it of hopefully he will associate roller with yummy carrot or something he likes that wont put weight on if it needs monitoring, reward his good behaviour no matter how small. Always end on a good point even if you build up from 5mins a day to 10 after a week or so. He isnt that old may be just had enough if he has been broken and backed before 4yrs old, give him space make it fun not such an issue, they pick up if we r stressed or nervous, you obviously have a great knowledge of breaking and working with horses and its frustrating when it isnt working or testing your patience. Hope it all goes well for your sanity and the horse
regards kirsty
 
Hi I dont think letting him go nutso in pen is going to help him because he has got to the panic state, you need to gradually put roller on dont try lungeing just put it on give him a carrot and take it of hopefully he will associate roller with yummy carrot or something he likes that wont put weight on if it needs monitoring, reward his good behaviour no matter how small. Always end on a good point even if you build up from 5mins a day to 10 after a week or so. He isnt that old may be just had enough if he has been broken and backed before 4yrs old, give him space make it fun not such an issue, they pick up if we r stressed or nervous, you obviously have a great knowledge of breaking and working with horses and its frustrating when it isnt working or testing your patience. Hope it all goes well for your sanity and the horse
regards kirsty

I agree you are probably right about the round pen. It may be too enclosed.

The thing is, we have taken it really slow with him & gradually increased his time in roller & 9 times out of 10 he doesn't bat an eyelid, then that one other time & he gets extremley upset. It is just so unlike him, and finding the explanation behind it is baffling me!

My other feeling is maybe it is to do with his owner, she lacks confidence in him now & I wonder whether he just doesn't trust her. but I would find it very hard to say to her, leave us to it for a bit & see how we get on - think she would be quite upset by this.
 
You could explain to her that, as he's a young horse in training, it's very important that he gains confidence from a confident handler at particular times, and that nervous/agitated people sap a horse's confidence, sometimes to the point where they become so afraid that they may panic.

Try to help her to be confident and control her heart rate/breathing rate when working with him, and how to watch her horse for signs that he is in need of reassurance so that she can respond to that correctly.

The voice is a great calmer of horses if they are used to it, and the voice can be used long before the hand can be laid on a nervous horse, or if a horse is dangerous to approach through panic. Using reassuring words/tones also has a calming effect on the speaker of them too.
 
Owner is improving, she used to say 'good boy' to pony all the time whatever he was doing - I think almost to convince herself he wasn't going to do anything silly. I have been encouraging to ignore unwanted behaviour & really praise the good stuff!
When he panicked this time, she still ran away though - I am obviously clearly daft & wandered straight up to him to calm him down & he settled but I don't think she would have been able to do that & I dread to think what else might have happened.
I have suggested that Ihelp her out & we work together on it - I showed her all your replies & she was very grateful! :) She seems to be taking the situation onboard. I have been offering to handle him for her when we take him out of the yard & have been talking her through my/his reactions to certain behaviours.
For example he used to barge her about a bit, so i spent some time showing her how I would lead him & he is much better for her now.
One very small step at a time I suppose, its far from an ideal situation, but I'm concerned the pony isn't happy & i don't want the owner to be unhappy either!! God I can waffle..:o

The only other slight problem we have is that other owners on yard don't agree with pressure halters!! They seem to think it scares him?! It has never been used inappropriatley & I doubt I would be able to control him without it. I did ask them how they would deal with it...and didn't really get a response.

Its pretty unlikely that is the problem isn't it?!
 
Pressure halters used correctly don't scare horses.

People who don't know how to use them, but try (and fail) anyway do scare horses.

Come to think of it, they scare me too. :D:p
 
newrider.com