Has Anyone Else Found Monty Roberts Unsettling?

evie's mummy

New Member
Jul 13, 2006
273
0
0
Hi peeps! Saw Monty last night for the first time and have come away feeling a bit unsettled about the whole thing. I think it may be my fault as I've never seen him before and maybe in my mind had put him up on a pedastal as the 'magic horse whisperer'. Don't get me wrong I found his work with horses on the ground great. I certainly prefer his methods to the 'beat them into submission' old school ways, BUT as he started riding I found myself not clapping and actually wanting the whole thing to end. No doubt he is a very accomplished rider but he was showing some very skilled western moves (such as spinning on the spot, sorry don't know technical terms!) and I just thought STOP, that poor horses legs. But no he just went on and on and it just smacked of SHOWING OFF! I know that in English disciplines such as dressage and showjumping the horse is asked to make unnatural movements so I'm not picking on just Western riding, but to my very novice mind I don't think this showed alot of concern for the horses wellbeing! Also although his horse skills were good, his people skills are lacking as we went to his booking signing afterwards and he was just signing away, no eye contact , no chatting!
For me the whole show was just a commercial Monty Roberts plugging and I wouldn't go again. I felt a bit let down about the whole thing:confused:

And breathe....... sorry long rant!
 
I've been to a few both as a spectator and a helper, and whilst some have been impressive and there have been moments of real magic, others haven't been so much, so I know what you're talking about. I could have gone and helped out on the latest tour but to be honest didn't really fancy it. I do think it's worth remembering that he's in his 70's now, it might not be unexpected for him to be tired and go through the motions a bit late at night after a demo, he's only human after all.

What I would say is that if you get a chance to see Kelly Marks do a demo in her own right then do so, it will probably be much more what you were hoping to see.

BTW I'm not keen on those western spins either, they strike me as particularly pointless, although the average showjumping round probably takes more out of a horse's legs.
 
I have been to see him and I thought that there was nothing original about his methods at all.

the only thing I liked about the demo was the dually. His methods were just old mathods 'gentled' down with a twist that any horserider could do for them selves.

I will stick with the methods that have worked for me so far. My horses arnt brutalised or beaten like he seems to hint that the normal ways are all about.

He just wasnt for me.

Nikki xxxx
 
Never met him, never will I suppose, but he has brought to the forefront of the general public's mind, that horses have had a lot of coarse methods to put up with.

Anyone, throught watever media, who stands up and says don't be horrid to horses, can't be ALL bad!

gee whizz, I am standing up for Monty Roberts! It'll snow tomorrow! :D :D
 
What I would say is that if you get a chance to see Kelly Marks do a demo in her own right then do so, it will probably be much more what you were hoping to see.

Grant Bazin and Dan Wilson do demos too, they are/were Monty's demo riders, I really liked their approach too



I know what you mean though, but at the demos I went to we never even saw Monty get on a horse? but as Yann says he is getting on abit now, and the demos actually start a lot earlier in the day than when you arrive to watch, the setting up and viewing the horses to be used takes ages
 
i did, not really sure why. as ive said in an other thread recently, i really didn't like kelly marks' attitude to the owners of the horses used in the demos.

i certainly didnt *love* what i saw. maybe im strange, the people i went with thought it was all amazing and couldn't beleive that i wasn't the same. but i wasn't. unsettled is a very good word to describe how i felt. so you're not alone ;)
 
I haven't seen Monty Roberts, but I have been to a Kelly Marks demo. It wasn't mind boggling, just simple and quiet, but thats as it should be I think. I really rate her. I wouldn't want them to try to make it mind boggling, we get enough of that from Parelli (goes off to find tin hat ...).
 
That is a bit rude giving no eye contact at book signings but thinking from his point of view having done them for years, maybe not his kind of thing, feels stressed etc, still no excuse tho, a lot of people who are exceptional with animals arent that good with people.

I still take a lot what he teaches and couldnt have got some of my horses to where they are without it.
 
Which specific dressage or Showjumping movements are unnatural for a horse?
What could Monty have done that you would accept as showing concern?

Harry - nothing specific just I suppose that it is not natural for a horse to continue to jump rounds and rounds of jumps with very quick turns. As regards to dressage I don't want to open a can of worms and hurt anyones feelings but I don't imagine that a horse would choose to carry themself in such a strict 'outline' whilst trotting on the spot or spinning on its back legs (sorry no technical names!) I know that with this viewpoint you can then go to the extent of saying that riding a horse in any form is not a natural state for the horse, but in my opinion these things done in moderation are fine. When you ask what Monty could have done to show concern then my answer would be to moderate. He didn't need to keep showing the movement 10/15 times all the time asking the horse to go faster and faster. And then multiply this by the amount of time that horse is on the road exhibiting Monty's riding skills then it just smacks to me of him showing off his skills to the detriment of the horse.

I don't want to offend anyone by saying that competing horses is wrong because I have competed myself and I think many horses love their job. But I just feel Monty put the ' look at me factor' before the horses wellbeing. I felt unsettled because I really didn't expect to feel that way.
 
I have met Monty and all i can say is he is a very nice man who has helped bring good methods of training to the forfront of most peoples minds. He signed my books and chatted to me for a few mins, he took time to answer questions from people. Maybe he was just having an off day?

He may not be " the in thing" now and he is an old gentleman but on the whole he has done more good than bad for the horse world.

You can pick holes out of every horse sport for some reason, you just have to trust that the horseman knows how much his horse can handle and not over do it! This was a show for the paying public, why would he not " show off" just a little bit? I doubt he spends all day spinning the horse for the fun of it when no one is about.
 
I have said before on previous threads about Monty that I felt the repetition of his various methods OTT, particularly when a horse he was dealing with had already accepted his requests. Kelly Marks on the other hand I found much more sympathetic and didn't overdo the various demos. Perhaps because as a woman she is more "sensitive" to how a horse is responding, or just doesn't need to "show off" as I feel Monty does sometimes.

Incidentally, for the benefit of any male readers of this post, I hope I'm not coming across as sexist, talking about sensitivity, but I do feel women on the whole have a slightly different approach to horses? Apologies if anyone takes umbrage at this. :( :0 :)

I've seen Monty's and Kelly's demonstratons a number of times and whatever your feelings about what they do, I still think they are worth seeing, as long as you keep an open mind and enjoy them for what they are. I learned quite a few new ways to tackle problems, but also realised that they are not instant fixes for most of us, but certainly worth a try.

Roseanne :) xxx
 
All of the movements made in dressage, with the exception of short tempi changes, are made by horses naturally at liberty. They do produce piaffe and passage in an outline when they are showing off. Dressage harnesses all this and, admittedly asks for it in a structured way and for longer than most horses might do some of the movements.

As I understanding it, horses in the wild do not jump obstacles unless they have to, they either go around them or simply don't take that route. So I have always thought of asking horses to jump, especially repeatedly, unatural. A lot of horses seem to enjoy it though don't they?
 
Roseanne, definitely agree with you regarding Kelly, and no umbrage taken :D

Whatever you think of Monty and what he actually does, there's no taking away from him what has been achieved in terms of broadening people's horizons as far as horsemanship goes through his work and touring. Just like Wally says :D
 
. He didn't need to keep showing the movement 10/15 times all the time asking the horse to go faster and faster.

That's actually a pretty standard western reining move. I've seen it in the higher level reining competitions. Typically they do something like gallop down to one end of the arena, slide into a halt and then spin like a top. Its crazy to watch, but totally typical thing for a western reiner to be asked. That being said i dont' know what level this horse was at, I know top speeds are asked at the highest level of competition (kind of like canter pirouette in dressage competitions)

additionally, no, dressage is not totally natural for a horse to do. If it were a horse would be nice and supple from the moment we got on and it wouldn't be so hard to stretch them out! Why would a horse move sideways when they can just turn and go straight? its a lot easier. Horses don't usually travel in straight lines or do circles with a proper bend. Its harder work, and no one is making them, why should they? While a lot of the movements are seen out in the field, its not to the quality we would ask of them in the arena.
 
I've never seen him live , only on film , but have sometimes felt he was too much of a showman , but I suppose that's what he is really! I agree he's been a pioneer for more humane methods though.
What irritates me, every time I see ,it is that ghastly photograph of the Parellis , her posing lying backwards pouting over the horse's tail aaargh!:eek:Now that makes you wonder if she really cares for horses or just thinks they make her look cute!!
 
I know what you mean about Mrs Parelli and her pout! I have only watched one of the Parelli dvd's and it bothered me that they both wore spurs and how miserable the horses looked!:eek:
Monty - yeah he is a showman but I guess he needed that American bigness to get the message across and thank god he did for our horse friends. ;)
 
newrider.com