Parelli?????? For or Against it.

I myself like Clinton Anderson better. (but also quite expensive). I like all the "softening techiniques" that Clint shows you. He is easy to understand and lately on his tv shows has been doing a variety of training, although mainly western I did see a program last week where he was showing how you incorporate the training into any disipline.
I have seen Chris Cox in person and a demo and really liked some of his training techniques and now I use some of his also. He has a really good colt starting program as well.
And if you set back and look at most of the well known trainers alot of them are doing all the same things, just the approach is a little different.
 
I agree dwoodie. I like Clinton better, but he is really going commercial now too. He is also getting more expensive, but his videos are still cheaper than Parelli's. I've seen both of them at shows several times and Parelli always answered a question by telling you what 'Level' to buy to find the answer. Clinton gave a concrete answer about what to do.
 
no problems with training methods and teaching people ways to do things and games etc,
can not stand the way it is marketed (over the top showmanship nonsense) and quite obviously out to make as much money as possible.
 
1. I agree totally with NicP's first reply.
2. Yann - Anyone using any method can be too harsh.
3. So what if he makes money. we all have to make a living and I can think of much worse ways.
4. To judge a man/ woman by appearance alone is VERY shallow.
5. At least what he teaches is well put across, easy to follow and makes alot of common sense. He has far more years' experience than most of us put together and he is trying to make the world a better place for the horse.
6. Most people will rant about any good RI they have found, but I see no reason to d**n someone because of their beliefs just cos you dont agree.
7. Finally, I tried several top RI's, a racehorse trainer, and two of Scotlands top showjumpers to try and cure my boy of vertical rearing. It all made him worse and was a total waste of money. Now working on L2 of Parelli and I have a non rearing, softer and more confident horse AND I dont have to sell him or put him down for being dangerous.
 
2. Yann - Anyone using any method can be too harsh.

Very true, but escalating pressure with the only upper limit being what it takes to get a result is an integral part of the method. I also disagree with horses being hit on the head and face, which appears to be acceptable too.
 
Indifferent really, although, I do beleve it is far too commercial. I get sick of people who effectively 'worship' his tecniques and are convinced that they will work for every rider. Having said that, some of the techniques seem pretty usefull, but other than that, not too keen.
 
i dont like it tbh, i saw abit on tv and i must admit that it looked like something that comes out of a backend of a horse.
i just dont think that waving a whip at a horse so that it moves away from you and towards you etc is no contact work.
i just don't really get on with what i've seen on the parelli tv shows that i've seen. i could be mistaken but personally i just don't gte on with what i saw
 
I love the teachings and I take my hat off to Pat who has managed to get his word across and fill his back pocket several times over in the process (and Linda for getting in there before anyone else!!)

Like with any training method, it can get ugly. I find with non natural it takes a while to get ugly and a while to make it pretty again and when it goes ugly it goes ugly with a bang. Natural methods get not so ugly but much quicker but are quicker to resolve.

I am not a fan of this 'seven games stuff' at the start, bores me and my horse because of his personality but all the psychological theories have helped me understand and motivate my horse so I get the 'real' him and use to the seven games to teach particular tasks and build a confident friendly attitude towards me. And also now at no point is my horse NOT allowed an opinion, I wont hide his cry for help.
 
I am for a more natural approach to training the horse and I think that parelli would help you to build more of a bond with your horse:) although I do not belive in the people who are total dead set on parelli and ride out on main roads with no tack at all not even a strap to help turn the horse!!:eek:(no offence if anyone does this) I just think that no matter how much you understand and trust your horse you can not guarentee that it will act calmly in a given situation!:):)
 
I agree with you all of you on different points, but it seems to me there are more people against it then for it. I guess really truly I am neutral, because I know nothing about it.
 
Very true, but escalating pressure with the only upper limit being what it takes to get a result is an integral part of the method. I also disagree with horses being hit on the head and face, which appears to be acceptable too.

Not sure about that - I went to the Parelli thing at the NEC and there was no way any of the horses were hit on the head and face so I suspect people doing that aren't doing it right. I haven't actually done any of it myself as yet and I certainly wouldn't if I was expected to hit my horse on its face or put enough pressure to make it bleed. No way.

The carrot stick is used to rub over the whole body including the face but there is no more pressure than if you used your hand.

I don't know the history but at the show, PP was indicating that there had been somebody in the UK who was meant to be working for him and doing his stuff over here who badly let him down. Maybe some of the bad experiences were down to that?

As I have said, I personally find having a programme to follow helpful but that doesn't mean to say I would follow everything blindly - I think it is up to us to find what suits both us and our horse.
 
I think Parelli works really well for some horses and people, I think everyones just gotta find the right type of Horsemanship for them and their horse, and Parelli works brilliantly for some and not for others, it can though depend on how the human understands it especially with the home study packs and how they relay it to the horse, that can have a great impact on how you get on with it;) I find it odd though that a few people I've come across will say its a load of rubbish or judge it when they haven't given it a a try even or at least properly. Fine if you don't have an interest in it but how can people judge it when they haven't tried it:confused:
 
newrider.com