what is a good doer


New Member
Aug 14, 2000
Visit site
Hello everyone,
Can someone explain the definition of a good doer to me please.

I think it is when a horse has no probelm keeping weight on.. am I right?



Well-Known Member
Apr 16, 2000
Yes you are right. A good doer is exactly that. Needs little food and gets fat watching the grass grow!


New Member
Good doers!

Harriet if you ever meet a Highland pony you will see the living proof of a good doer! I have one in particular who lived out with a bib clip, no rug (field shelter), 2 or 3 flakes of hay a day for a whole winter and still had a back which looked like a table top in spring. I am sure they could be fat on the proverbial concrete.


New Member
May 27, 1999
Washington State USA
Visit site
My Quarter Horse "good doer" is plumping up just on dormant grass and no exercise except her displays of high spirits (see Mature Rider..."idiot"). Her dorsal stripe is hidden in a newly formed "gully". She gives new meaning to my trainer's tactful word:



New Member
Aug 14, 2000
Visit site
great now my next question is...

The reason I was asking about Good Doers is.
My horse is Part Bred Arab/Connemara and believe it or not is quite portly, he was real fat when he came to me and is now slightly slimmer. He is now being fed Denghi Good Doer and baileys top line condition cubes.
The thing is lately there seems to be a change in his attitude. He is not worked hard but lately in the school he just cant be bothered, even leading him around he has become very laid back, not that Im complaining because he was quite fizzy so I cut his cubes by half and gave extra good doer chaff. Last night in the school whilst we were doing trot he just stopped dead as if to say I've had enough of this. I dont just go round in circles all the time and he is only schooled twice at week at the moment and gets hacked at the weekend. Its really weird just when I thought we were starting to get somewhere he throws another spoke in the wheels. I've only had him 4/5 months and he had done nothing before I got him.
Do you think its his diet - or do you think maybe I should stay out of the school and change his routine to see if that will give him his sparkle back?
Any advise greatly appreciated


New Member
Nov 18, 2000
Visit site
What's he like to hack out? Any different to the school work? It does sound like he's a bit bored with the schooling, but if he's the same out hacking, then it could be something else. If he hasn't been schooled much before he may not be able to concentrate for long periods and you may be better off schooling for very short sessions then recapture his interest by going for a hack. In fact, if you're working on basic schooling, you could do much of this out hacking and retain his interest. Or you could try introducing new elements into his schooling, like pole work or working him from the ground. With his breeding, he's likely to be quite bright and need constant new stimulation to keep his interest.
On the other hand, if he's showing the same behaviour out hacking, then I would definitely look at other possibilities. I doubt it's diet - but why on earth are you feeding him conditioning cubes if you want him to lose weight?! I'd suggest you switch to something like high fibre cubes or cool mix, or cut hard feed altogether and just feed good doer and a mineral supplement!
Have you checked his back and tack? If he didn't do much before you had him, he may well have changed shape with work (especially since he's lost weight) and the saddle may not be such a good fit - this would explain the sudden stops in trot and reluctance to go forwards. By the way, a horse with an uncomfortable saddle may only show problems in some situations - if he likes hacking, he may put up with the discomfort for the pleasure of going out. If he's bored with schooling, he'll be less tolerant.

Sharon H

New Member
Sep 4, 2000
East Sussex
Visit site
He could be aneamic (can't spell!) fi you have reduced the feed he may not be getting enough vits and mins, I would swap to a mix designed for good doers. There is a very good tonic for aneamia called Red Cell, it might be worth asking your vet to do a blood test if you've ruled out any other causes, ie. boredom and suchlike
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
L Feeding a poor doer with dietry intolerances Metabolic 2
Mary Poppins Good doer driving me crazy!!! Horse Care 25
Star the Fell Feeding a good doer Metabolic 9
L Poor doer owners Metabolic 15
P Rugging a good doer? Horse Care 11
P Best way to manage a good doer on new summer grazing? Horse Care 19
Ale Feeding a good doer for a little more oomph? Metabolic 15
Flipo's Mum Making feed more appealing to a good doer Metabolic 30
Ale Best feed/suppliment for a good doer with bad feet? Metabolic 4
Joyscarer Good Doer...or just greedy? Metabolic 17
Flipo's Mum Good Doer or Poor Doer? Cafe 39
Joyscarer Good doer support group Horse Care 14
Pigletsmum Feed advice for good doer, barefoot pony Metabolic 12
flump1967 Going into Spring with the best Doer ever Horse Care 10
wondergirl hifi light vs good doer Metabolic 3
leah&lydia What does 'green' + 'good doer' mean? Training of the Horse and Rider 7
Sisco Apple chaff/ very good doer? Metabolic 8
J Good Doer Not Done So Good Horse Care 20
J Feeding a good-doer? Metabolic 1
MaisieMoo Feeding haylage to a good doer? Metabolic 11
S Feed advice for hot headed extremely good doer Metabolic 14
P Hi-fi good doer Metabolic 3
P Dengie healthy hooves or hi-fi good doer Metabolic 11
Laura2184 Can you soak haylage and how much to feed a good doer Metabolic 11
A what would you feed my good-doer? Metabolic 19
A Trickle feeding good doer hay any ideas? General 10
beanz's mum Good Doer, Poor Doer...Excuse me?! Please help General 6
J Good doer owners - Advice needed General 15
nelle Good doer + spring grass = panicking mummy! Metabolic 7
laceyfreckle losing weight...normally good doer...advice? Metabolic 16
LokiSofi reccomend a feed for an older pony whos a good doer Metabolic 8
horseygirl123 Do i need to supplement dengies good doer ??? Metabolic 13
Fizz feeding the poor doer General 11
kirstinbell What to feed a good doer in the winter months General 22
Loopy_Laura feeding a good doer Metabolic 1
C Getting supplements into a good doer? Metabolic 26
S What Do You Feed Your Good-Doer? Metabolic 19
P Feeding for the poor doer who can eat anything...... General 30
Bobbin Good doer thats losing weight Horse Care 25
Bobbin Feeding a good doer over winter Horse Care 10
M Help with feeds! A good doer Horse Care 15
Colour_Crazy_Gi Good doer - if you put up a post about this before, please read this!! Training of the Horse and Rider 16
No_Angel poor doer and just chaff? Horse Care 22
CrazyMare Seaweed meal? feeding advice needed for a good doer! Horse Care 7
T Feeding the Good doer Horse Care 5
raggydoll coughing with dengie good doer?? Horse Care 9
S What is a Good Doer? 2005 Archive of Posts 15
H Cob poor doer? Horse Care 1

Similar threads