Toby and our Journey

sjp1

Well-Known Member
Sep 14, 2009
6,963
461
83
Firstly, thank you lots to everyone who has been so helpful. Annareeves especially gave me the kick I needed to carry on. As you have all been so kind I thought I would make a diary to bore you all to tears, but thought I would start at the beginning.

I bought Toby as a four year old Apaloosa from a dealer in Sussex in December 2008. I had had to have my thoroughbred ex racehorse PTS as couldn't get him sound and he began to get depressed. He was a beautiful chestnut who was neurotic when I initially had him straight out of a racing yard, but as my farrier said, he was very aptly named as he turned from a ugly duckling who made a fresian cow look over weight into a beautiful swan. We had a very close bond but I had to be extremely careful where we could and couldn't hack.

Once Swan was gone, I decided that I wanted a much more robust horse who didn't have to have two courses of antibiotic injections if he nicked himself, who I didn't have to poultice because he had an abcess in the foot - you get the picture.

Many years ago, I had an apaloosa and loved her - she was brave, compliant and the sort of horse everyone would love to have and so I decided that was the way to go. I looked at a couple locally - one was cow hocked and nappy and the other was just too fine and I was worried that I would have the same issues I had with my thoroughbred.

I saw Toby advertised, went up to Sussex, viewed him, rode him and thought he would be perfect. The dealer was concerned he would be too quiet for me, but that was just what I wanted. She also said he was bombproof in traffic but a nightmare on the ground. That didn't bother me - I had had several horses straight out of racing for a bit of r and r and they had all got issues and all came right. I rang her later that day, made an offer on him, had him vetted, and friend and I drove up from Devon with the trailer the next weekend and collected him.

He refused to load and they put a chifney on him. He went up.

Once home, the two mares belonging to my friend gave him a very hard time. Finally after a week, we separated the mares and put him in with the dominant one. Three days later he had won the battle and at 4 became the leader.

His ground manners improved, he didn't run over the top of me anymore, but he became increasingly spooky under saddle. I never knew what to expect from one day to the next and was always left with a slightly uneasy feeling. We got around it by going the long way round - everything was on Toby's terms or a massive fight ensued.

We would go for long hacks with friend and sometimes he was good, sometimes not. He bucked like fury and I changed his saddle to treeless - thanks to Skippy's Mum for all her help! He bucked much less but on occasion would bronc and buck - there was no rhyme or reason. Whipping around he would do and he scared me rigid one day when on a steep track in the woods he whipped around and we nearly went over the edge.

Friend owns a bomb proof cob who although fairly dead to the leg is as good as gold and nothing phases her which is quite a tricky friend to have.

It all came to a head when about six weeks ago we were hacking up to a fun ride and Toby absolutely flipped out when some horses came galloping down a field. He reared, tried to climb the hedge and really frightened me. Needless to say we went home and at that moment I would have been ecstatic never to have set eyes on him again.

I went home and told OH I was going to send him to a friend of ours who is master of hounds. That I said, would straighten him out. OH asked me if I wanted his heart broken. I immediately knew that I didn't and decided to put my pride to one side and get a NH instructor.
 
I was lucky enough to find a fantastic NH instructor who came out on the Tuesday following our disaster. She maintains that when the pupil is ready the teacher appears and she had had a cancellation for that day.

Toby once on his rope halter and long line had several strops. He reared, kicked ran all over the paddock - I had let him 'get away' with so much that any discipline caused him to be hugely over reactive. Whatever she asked him to do was to him a major issue, but she stuck with it that first day and he finally complied.

Friend was astonished at the change in him after that first lesson. He had bitten friend badly some months previously and when I was away one weekend he had attacked her and had made her curl up in a ball on the floor in the field. This he had never done to me, but if reprimanded would attempt to kick me.

All seemed to be going well but after our third lesson, Toby decided that he really didn't want to be doing this. We had been nearly three weeks since instructor had last been and he attempted to kick me several times whilst he and I were doing our exercises and finally reared, boxed and took off up the field.

This was on the Thursday and I posted feeling extremely sorry for myself. Everyone who posted was fantastic and gave me the kick I needed but I especially took on board Annareeves post saying was I playing at being leader. Honestly - yes I was. I was going through the motions, not increasing my levels of pressure and hoping that everything was going to be OK. Earlier that week I had ordered Clinton Anderson's fundamentals pack at a huge cost and it arrived that Friday. Instructor was due on that Sunday and all weekend I watched Clinton wall to wall - house a mess, nothing else achieved!!

Lesson that Sunday was good - I got on him and practiced hindquarter disengagement. Instructor got on first and for the first time in ages, I really wanted to be up on him.

We have practiced every day since doing exercises - today instructor came again. Toby was sloppy and fairly disrespectful with me initially and she asked me whether I knew that he was not an easy horse and had I taken him out hacking. I said that although he is much better, I haven't seen that light bulb moment that says he respects me 100% and I don't think it is very wise to climb on board if we haven't sorted all our issues out. She said she was concerned that I might give up on him and I said that just won't happen. We will get there and if I don't ride for six months, in his lifetime that isn't very long.

I then did a couple of hindquarter yields with him and then onto circling. Was so happy that she said she just didn't believe it was the same horse. No mucking about, soft on the line, respectful in his yields .........

So here's hoping ............ will keep you updated if you haven't died of boredom in the interim.

The best thing for me is that I am no longer so fearful of him on the ground. I am now fine if he plays up and I have to get tougher. And I am really starting to enjoy the groundwork. Whether this is because I know whilst I am doing groundwork I don't have to get on him I don't know.
 
So here's hoping ............ will keep you updated if you haven't died of boredom in the interim.

The best thing for me is that I am no longer so fearful of him on the ground. I am now fine if he plays up and I have to get tougher. And I am really starting to enjoy the groundwork. Whether this is because I know whilst I am doing groundwork I don't have to get on him I don't know.

Not bored, enjoying this, will be cheering you on. Good luck mrs and agree we need to see the boy himself, he sounds like quite a fella!:wink:
 
This diary is a great idea. Keep at the Clinton. I have complete faith in the DUH method and completely agree that you should stick to the groundwork until you feel ready to get on.
People underestimate how important it is to have complete control on the ground first. It sounds like he just needs starting again which is exactly what you are doing. I had a very similar horse a while ago. I bought him as un-rideable for £300 and 1 year later sold him for £4000. And I credit it all to the DUH method.
Keep us updated and stay safe. xx
 
Found a pic of him lying down - seems keen on snoozing at present and refusing to get up. And one of he and I together - Toby lying down again - (far more flattering of Toby than me!) And another of him doing his favourite pastime - eating!! Shall take some this evening
 

Attachments

  • 10-04-10_0858.jpg
    10-04-10_0858.jpg
    34.9 KB · Views: 63
  • P1010201.jpg
    P1010201.jpg
    47.3 KB · Views: 60
  • 10-04-10_0859.jpg
    10-04-10_0859.jpg
    34.2 KB · Views: 64
Instructor came last Tuesday and I was stuck on forequarter yield. Can now get him to move over, but not the snappy move that Clinton does. Clinton really amps up the pressure. Instructor says the problem is that Toby is always on his forehand and needs to lift up and back.

Had a long practice tonight. Long suffering friend videoed us because I am sure I am not doing what Clinton is doing. Unfortunately video camera ran out of battery!

Bit of a messy day today. Friend was going to load her bomb proof cob up and take her for a ride with a friend of hers. Both of whom have no problem at all with their horses - not feeling hard done by!! Have tried to rise above it and try to remember what a lovely bond Toby and I will have when we have cracked this. On the upside, Toby was caught this morning, but friend's cob wouldn't be. Told instructor about friends problem with catching her bombproof cob last time she was here, and instructor very dismissively said 'horses vote with their feet' so felt a bit encouraged that even though Toby is extremely naughty whilst out riding, at least he must like me enough to be caught!

Friend set off leading her horse from field - too tricky a turn to load in the field - Toby very good, only whinnied once and then I went into the trailer body to get hay. Toby followed me - rather be with me than alone - and was helpful whilst I tried to split the bale - had lost my knife so had to yank the string off. Me sat on bale, Tobes with head in trailer body picking hay up. 5 minute later friend came back. She had met a marshall as there was a fun ride coming right past our small paddock. She was concerned about Tobes which actually was really really kind. Had thought she was being slightly selfish as we were having to do groundwork whilst she swanned off, but I suppose really it isn't her problem. Toby has a real issue with horses going past him - whilst he is in the field or ridden - any hints for coping with this gratefully received.
 
Friend decided not to go on fun ride, which was kind. We got them in this afternoon and I did Toby's exercises. Am hugely pleased with him tonight - he was compliant, and did all I asked - except the forequarter yield - having a real issue with that. Will keep trying - any tips gratefully received!!
 
Very interesting - not boring at all. The photo of him lying down - looks like butter wouldn't melt! Will follow your diary with interest.
 
Have just done bits of groundwork since last weekend - light not good but floodlight now fitted, so fingers crossed. Today however, I had a day off. Raining here this morning - friend and I had moved them into stable field last night as I was off today - starvation paddock according to horses!

Decided to do groundwork this afternoon before friend arrived. Started with de-sensitizing, Tobes very desensitized, trying to bite stick! Moved onto three methods of backing up. Tobes sighing greatly, but put a bit more effort in when asked. I then decided I wanted to practice my sending - this is where we are up to in dvd. Tobes has done sending but is not keen on it. Decided he couldn't possibly tonight, did it and then spun off backwards down the field. Managed to be calm and sent again - he did it again the otherway. Decided to do lungeing for respect instead and he took off like a bullet. However, happily, he decided there really wasn't much mileage in putting in huge amounts of effort for catapaulting around as he was going to have to do it anyway and then did a couple of nice circuits either side. We then went back to sending in a different position - oddly between the line of the stables and the uprights which is much narrower, and he was really good. What I am pleased about is that it is making him think and he is less reactive. Last time he didn't want to do it he got into a real state with rearing and kicking out at me. This time, he must have thought about it and reacted far less violently. Did some lovely neck yields after that as well. So all in all, feel quite upbeat about it.

I suppose this is flushing out all the things he really doesn't like or doesn't want to do. When I was riding him, I just got around what he didn't want to do, but this is making us both face it and work it out. So all in all, a good session.
 
And some pics -= clearly his diary not that busy as had spent most of it rolling!!
 

Attachments

  • P1010873.jpg
    P1010873.jpg
    46.2 KB · Views: 43
  • P1010875.jpg
    P1010875.jpg
    40.6 KB · Views: 40
  • P1010876.jpg
    P1010876.jpg
    33.2 KB · Views: 41
  • P1010878.jpg
    P1010878.jpg
    45.7 KB · Views: 43
Have never really been one of those people in life who is especially committed to anything really. I usually take the path of least resistance and the easiest way out, but strangely seem to be making a real effort to get Tobes and I back on track.

Today I had to take my son up to Surrey and come back again. About 3.5 hours each way - depending on M25!

So .. I organised friend and I to bring the horses from the big field across the village to the little stable field last night, got up early this morning, got them in, unrugged (aren't we just all so lucky not having to stable at night yet?) and proceeded with more groundwork - not huge amounts admittedly, but sending and desensitising. Toby is sighing a great deal at the moment - I think I am going to have to up my game and find more interesting obstacles to do these things with. The problem is, Toby reacts quite violently to peculiar (to me) things and as I am learning how to do it and trying to teach him, putting different obstacles in makes me worry it will be overload. Still, he was good, did it - not very snappily, but did it, and then was hugely helpful whilst I washed out breakfast bowls, came around to the trailer body to collect hay, and then watched me go standing up against the electric fence, which I thought was very sweet as his friend was off in the middle of the field grazing. Spec he was just checking I really was going and thought if I help her with the bowls, she will clear off quicker!!

Got back from Surrey and friend and I met to feed, rug and put in the big field. Toby looked bay from a distance as he had rolled so much - friend kindly informed me he was clean when she left to go for a ride on her horse this afternoon, but was filthy when she got back - grr!! As he was wet and muddy, I decided to towel him off before rugging him. He was sweet on one side and then on the other side decided to kick out at me and then proceeded to turn his backside to me. Now, I have no doubt if he had wanted to kick me he would have connected. It was that sort of slow lazy cow kick that says 'back off'. So I left the stable, put his rope headcollar and rope on, led him outside, tipped his head slightly toward me, and dried and dried and dried him on his bad side. Little monkey stood like butter wouldn't melt!!

So, lesson for me today is:
1) They never stop testing you
2) Be more organised and put halter and rope on first
3) Must grow an imagination

On the upside of everything, am back feeling best friends again with BF who has bomb proof cob. Feel a bit bad really that I thought she was being selfish. It really isn't her fault that Tobes has been a pickle, and she is entitled to enjoy herself and go off riding really. And kindly she is going to video me so I can see where I am going wrong (and email to Twobob so she can tell me better!). So I suppose fourth lesson for me today is not to be so selfish!!
 
Well, the last week or so has been a mixture of ups and downs. Saturday was and OK groundwork day, had a strop, tried to barge me and I stopped him. Did lovely circling at 4ft distance, bril hindquarter disengagement, circled well and spent over half an hour trying to get forequarter yield. Much better than previous week which were none existent.

Sunday (which rained) we cracked the forequarter yield. Was on cloud 9, happy and planning on doing next few exercises in the dvd and then onto ridden.

Instructor came yesterday (Tuesday). Absolutely gale force winds and lashing down with rain. I had wanted her to help us with the last exercise on the groundwork dvd, but she declined, and said it was an advanced movement and could injure him. Am thinking this is now going to be a problem. I cannot just do one lesson with her every three weeks, and remember all she has said and the exercises she has shown us. I need a structure and the Clinton Anderson Fundamentals is structured. I can watch and re-watch.

Toby was not good at all, well, thats probably not fair. He was good on the side of the paddock we always work on, and then instructor asked us to move to the other side. He was convinced that there were several horse eating monsters in the hedge, not least of which was a plastic bag (oops - bad horse owners!). I suggested I show him the bag - this is what I usually do with horses - show them and then they see there is nothing to fuss about. Instructor disagreed and said no, that was not the way forward. He was to work near the hedge. Well, he zoomed around on the rope, kicked, bucked, pulled and was generally a real nuisance. Ripped rope out of my hand and careered up the field. Instructor took over but I am not convinced I saw a huge swing in his attitude even with her on the line. And that was that lesson. So last night I felt very much at sixes and sevens. NH I had thought was NH, but clearly not and everyone has differing opinions. I actually feel that I have gone backwards and not forwards, whereas Sunday, I felt positive.

So I am going to have to work him in lots of different places in the field as the one side is clearly his comfort zone. Thought I might go for a little ride over the weekend - just up pheasant lane and back again with friend to see what (if anything) has changed. If he is awful I can always get off.
 
Well haven't updated for ages. So here goes ..... Didn't have instructor back again, am sure she is fantastic but didn't like the way our last session went. She maintained he was really scared of the fence and bag and frankly whacking him past it, just doesn't do it for me.

We carried on with groundwork, but varied it - I think it was Mark Rashid that said that constantly doing the same thing is rather like digging a ditch and filling it in, digging a ditch and filling it in. He knows how to do all these things so I just use them in the stable, backing up for gates when coming in.

November/December was pretty much out for everything. We had so much ice we had to leave them out because it was dangerous getting them across the village. Toby had a heavyweight rug with neck topped with a middleweight and they seemed quite happy. Disaster then struck when one evening (with headlamps on) we went to feed and Toby didn't come (never happens). I found him in the middle of the field on three legs. Ground was like rock and roads still sheet ice. Had the vet out, who wasn't sure what it was, friends OH who is a farrier had his shoe off in the van headlights to make sure it wasn't an abcess, but we were still none the wiser.

Two days later friends OH and I managed to get them across the village - quite hair raising but we did it. Had a proper equine vet out who nerve blocked him and it was between the fetlock joint and hoof. This makes it all sound quite smooth - needless to say it wasn't!! I led Toby out of the field to trot him up which he was quite happy about. Friends cob however wasn't and lacking Toby began galloping around the field. Toby then grew to about 18hh, nearly trod all over me and wouldn't co-operate at all. Gave Toby to long suffering vet and collected Amber who for once couldn't wait to be caught. Took Amber onto lane and handed her to vet who seemed relieved to hand Toby over. We then had to nerve block him. Toby took exception to the vet sticking needles in and promptly kicked him :banghead: Vet (who had been in Australia for some months) took it all in good part and asked whether I had ever considered using a chifney on him as he slammed forward into the door!!! Back onto the lane with both horses and me trotting Toby up and down. Vet considered that leaving him for a month was the best option as Toby not the best patient and the solution to most problems was leaving them for a month. This advice suited us both perfectly and Toby was in at night and out during the day.
 
Toby recuperated during most of January becoming sounder and sounder. My confidence on the ground with him increased, and I did lots of spook busting. Sprays have always been a no no for Toby, but an hour after we started, he was happily accepting water being sprayed on his legs, neck and even face. I bought a tarpaulin, which I thought would really freak him out, but because we had done so much spook busting with a plastic bag, he happily wore it around his neck and then stomped all over it without thinking twice - £8 wasted!!. I decided to start walking him out in hand in February. I ordered a new bit for him - a Rockin S raised snaffle after long emails to Tom Widdicombe, who is just so helpful and has such a brilliant mindset towards horses. This bit was created by a chap called Mark Sulan in conjunction with Mark Rashid who is my new hero. Have purchased nearly all of Mark Rashid's books now, and read them twice, cover to cover, he just seems to make so much sense, and his way of being with horses sits with me much better than some other trainers. Friend rode and Toby and I walked. Every time he trotted off, I just circled him round me and he realised it was easier to just walk. The second time we did out four mile walk I hopped on him bareback for the last mile home. The next time we went out and I rode all four miles bareback with not a spook from him - just as well really as he is fairly slippery!!

Well, last weekend and this weekend we have ridden Saturday and Sunday both weekends. I was extremely nervous about doing this and the first Saturday we encountered a large field full of horses. This is our bete noir and it was a bridge too far so I wussed out and we turned around and rode the other way. This entailed going down through the woods which wasn't something I wanted to do as Toby has a huge bruise on his foot which farrier and I think could have been the cause of his lameness. I walked with him over the stony bits and rode the rest. Going downhill for us is also not good. Toby is on his forehand and as he has hated every bit I have tried on him, encouraging him to do half halts to get him to engage his hindquarters has never worked. I guess I must have held him up too tight because he bucked which is fair enough really. So the next day we practiced half halts down hills and stopping really. As he is pretty happy in the new bit he took to this well and we have progressed to small steps of backing. Am using the Mark Rashid principle and it is going well.

This Saturday we chose to do the main road block. Firstly because I hate main roads and secondly because there are some horses in a field on the main road, but only a small section of the field goes onto it. And thirdly because on the back lane going home, Toby gets very excited and bucks and therefore I have never liked this route. The horses didn't move so Toby didn't fuss, I used my lowest energy to match his 8 and the main road was fine. He got excited on the back lane but I breathed and didn't hang onto him and he didn't buck and calmed down. Sunday we went a small way up the main road down Perry Lane which is FULL of horses and which I was dreading. As luck would have it the horses in the high field didn't move, but a yearling in the road field went belting around. Toby grew to 18hh again and snorted like a stallion and pranced along. Breathe shouted my friend which I tried to do, didn't cling onto his mouth and we got past. Managed to get past the last field of horses without them moving and onto the main road. Didn't feel strong enough to do the return journey past them so suggested going along the main road through the town and down that way. Friend agreed as this would mean I had do do main road (which I hate), through the town (which I don't like) and then up the Toby bucking road!! Well, what a saint, past the tip with the Viridor large lorry who was putting down a skip, and didn't even charge up his bucking road, let alone buck. Fell a bit of a wimp really that I didn't want to go back past the horses, but am hoping doing it all slowly will work for him and me.

So am doing the best with my nerves that I can and am just hoping it will get easier!!
 
Hi SJP. For some reason have only just found this but am very pleased to be cited as saying the right thing at the right time. I feel positively famous :wink: Sometimes someone random just says one thing and it just hits the nail right on the head. I have several of those one liners odd people have said to me stored up for when I need them.

Its really interesting to read your journey. You are doing a really great job of persevering - thats the toughest bit sometimes :biggrin:

Also interesting the thing I picked up most, especially from your latest posts is all the things YOU are scared of! And it seems when you take the lesser of your two evils it seems to work out ok. Hmmmmm. Its funny because I could have written those posts myself not that long ago. Rosie takes 99% of her confidence from me - if Im not feeling it, she's all over the place.

Somewhere along the way since then Ive become concious of a total mind switch - instead of avoiding things that I am afraid of or find myself procrastinating about or making up 'what ifs' about (im very good at avoiding things without conciously recognising thats what Im doing - Ill suddenly be running late and not have time, or find that I NEED to do something else instead) so I try to go seek them out instead. i found I had been avoiding going to our local common on my own as Rosie tends to rush round and be a bit silly - so now I make myself go once a week and she's fine. Either that or if she is rushing I oblige and help her along with some much longer than she wants to do canters :) It sounds a bit twee but Im working really hard to no longer see things as a problem or obstacle but as an opportunity to learn some new and despook her to another thing. Looking fron another perspective means I can laugh at her being an idiot and I can just stand and let her get on with it, without feeling pressure to get past or solve 'the problem'. Works for us most of the time anyway! Im waffling now but look forward to hearing how you get on :)
 
Didn't ride at all last weekend as was in Surrey.

Rode this morning. I decided we should ride past horses in fields but without too large an expanse of field onto the road if you know what I mean, so if he gets over excited, we haven't got that far to go before we are past them. How wimpy am I?

So I picked a route that had a short stretch with two horses in a field and that looped around to a piece with two horses in a yard right onto the road. Friend who is really supportive agreed that is what we should do. Bringing the horses in from the field across the village two riders met us head on. Toby was fantastic, didn't perform and walked straight past them which was a huge relief. Once tacked up and on we set off down the back road and onto the main road. Two weeks ago when I rode Toby down the main road he was not at all fussed. This morning he decided the traffic (of which there was a lot) was uber scarey - now this is odd. Two weeks ago I was very scared of the traffic (on his behalf) and he was bomb proof, and today I was not at all scared of the traffic (on his behalf) because he hadn't been two weeks ago and he was?

Nevertheless, we managed and got onto another back road. Happily for me the two horses in the field only wandered up to the hedge and after we had passed them we turned around so he had a proper look. Back onto a main road and I had completely forgotten that there are five horses in a big field which slopes down to the main road in full view of the road we were on. God must have been with me as happily they all stayed at the top and we got back onto the back road and passed the two horses in a yard who also barely moved without a problem. Home on the main road and Tobes tired by now so not fussed about traffic.

I am thinking tomorrow we really should ride the Perry Farm route which has horses on either side all the way down the road which is a good mile long. Am not really sure if this is a brilliant idea, as my confidence is fairly shaky and I could do without it being knocked any further, but, if I could do it and he was fine then it might increase it ...... can't quite decide.

On the up side, I have realised that bringing him back and forwards through the village is now easy. We very rarely have any incidents or crashing sideways into me, so I guess that is a huge step forward.

Also on the plus side, because I encourage him when leading to look and investigate anything that he is worried about, he is also doing this when I am riding him. Not quite so confidently because Mum isn't in front of him, but walking up to anything that he isn't sure of.

So thats us up to date. Am going to try riding Tues Weds and Thurs next week now the clocks have changed. Am hoping the more miles we get under our belt, the better all wll be.
 
I hear you, the more miles we all do, the more bombproof they get!! Well done with what you've managed so far, you're definitely striding out of your comfort zone - and good luck with the gauntlet (sorry for calling it that) but a mile lined either side with horses? Woah!!!
 
newrider.com